New(-ish) Comics! (HERE BE SPOILERS!)

Batman #11:  Not surprisingly, I have a lot to say about this issue.  Overall, I'll comment that I'm emotionally, if not, narratively, satisfied with where we find ourselves at the end of this arc.  I'm surprised that I'm not emotionally satisfied for the reason that I thought I would be, but, in the end, it's good enough for me.  Let's start with the reasons why I liked this issue and then get to the reasons why I didn't.

First, the good.  Snyder goes the way I expected here, establish two equally compelling scenarios that explain that Lincoln isn't, or is, Bruce's brother.  We learn that Thomas Wayne, Jr. was born and lived a single night, explaining why Alfred and Bruce would've been aware of him but didn't, in fact, abandon him.  We also learn that, a week after Thomas' death, a John Doe was admitted to the hospital.  It's clear that Lincoln could really have been a simple stranger admitted as John Doe (in the "Lincoln isn't Bruce's brother" version), just as it's clear that the Waynes could've, theoretically, admitted Thomas as that John Doe (in the "Lincoln is Bruce's brother" version).  Lincoln describes a childhood with Martha Wayne visiting him and the Court members encouraging him to see his connection to the Waynes as his key to the city.  However, Bruce makes it clear that Martha visited all her charities and it's pretty obvious that the Court could simply have been telling Lincoln lies about his past in the hope of using him to take over Gotham.  (Lincoln himself mentions this plan when he tells Bruce that he and the Court were ready to launch it when Bruce disappeared on his adolescent sojourn to train to become Batman.)  I have to applaud Snyder for the conversation that Bruce and Dick have laying out this information, because he makes it clear that neither one of them really knows what the answer is.  It's a singular moment, really, watching the world's greatest detective and his equally capable apprentice realize that they are more or less stumped.  Bruce decides that his parents would have told him had his brother survived, leaving us with the sense that it's the correct version of events.  However, we do come to the issue with the bias of seeing it through Bruce's eyes.  We also learn that he's still committed to eventually getting a DnA sample from Lincoln to make sure, a determination that Snyder uses to remind us that even Bruce still can't be 100 percent sure that Lincoln isn't Bruce's brother.

In the end, though, it's Alfred's comment to Bruce at the end of the secondary story that resolves this issue for me.  I had thought, as JT and I discussed on x-man75's blog, that this secondary story could reveal the truth about Thomas' fate, allowing the reader to know whether or not Lincoln was Bruce's brother (and not get frustrated by the ambiguity in future stories as Bruce tries to solve the mystery).  In this scenario, Bruce would be left in the dark, providing the impetus for said stories.  Snyder went the opposite way.  We, the reader, are left with the ambiguity, but, as Alfred makes clear, it doesn't matter.  Bruce Wayne lost his brother that night, regardless of whether Lincoln is or is not biologically connected to him.  Lincoln isn't suddenly going to become sane, emotionally embrace Bruce as he realizes the errors of his way, and become the family that Bruce never had.  One way or another, Thomas Wayne, Jr. died that night, at the hands of the Court of the Owls.

I mentioned above that the emotionally satisfying ending wasn't something that I expected.  After all, the loss of Bruce's family is so central to his identity that the revelation that a family member might have been out there all along seems like the worst possible thing that could happen to him.  I wondered if we might be seeing Bruce on a downward spiral, leaving him in a position like he was at the start of "Batman:  A Lonely Place of Dying," where he was struggling to get over Jason's death.  But, instead, Snyder leaves Bruce realizing that he's always had a family and treats us to the warmest scene between Bruce and Dick that I think I've ever seen.  Bruce tells Dick not to think about Bruce saving him from the fate of being a Talon, but instead think about him saving Bruce from his own dark fate.  It's a lovely moment, and Snyder futhers the characterization even more by using Dick's joke about not being able to pay back the punch that Bruce delivered to him in issue #7 to accentuate the moment.  He reminds us that Bruce is thanking Dick for exactly that trait, his ability to keep everything light while still feel emotions.  Sure, Bruce sounds wistful when he notes that, for one night, we did have a brother on this Earth.  But, Snyder makes it clear that having a son like Dick mattered more.  It is, when you really think about it, the only possible ending to this saga that would leave you feeling like the emotional journey was complete.  Bruce might have an insane brother out there, but, it doesn't matter, because he's built all the family that he needs.

As such, from an emotional perspective, Snyder did everything I wanted him to do here.  We're left with a Bruce Wayne reborn and refocused.  In fact, it dawned on me that Snyder gives us the same Bruce that we had after he returned from the dead in the DCU.  I mentioned somewhere in one of these reviews that my fear going into the reboot was that it was going to erase that emotional progress that Bruce made after his death in the DCU.  After his death, we saw Bruce's importance to the people around him -- Alfred, mourning the loss of his son; Dick, taking up the mantle of the Bat; Tim, keeping the faith of his survival.  We also see Bruce realize how important they were to him.  Here, Snyder leaves Bruce in the same place as he was then, realizing the importance of family that he built, not necessarily the one he was born having.  It's the best possible outcome of this story for me. 

As a result of the success of channeling the emotional impact of this story, mentioning Snyder's narrative failures at the end of this arc feels similar to having to address boring administrative measures.  It's almost like Kevin Bacon having to go arrest Jack Nicholson off-camera in "A Few Good Men," because the emotional denouement ("You're damn right I did!") had already happened.  But, I'll make a few points on those failures, because I do feel that it's what keeps this story from being the greatest Batman story ever told.

First, I'm still disappointed by the Court getting pushed to the back burner in this issue and issue #10.  Bruce makes some vague threats here about tracking down the Court and dismantling it, but I'm not sure that we're even going to see that story (unless maybe it's part of "Batman Incorporated" at some point).  As such, it's doubtful that we're going to resolve a number of loose ends:

-- We never learn why the Court, which seemingly so prized secrecy, decided to engage in the "Night of the Owls" in the first place, laying itself bare.  It's not a moot point, since its decision to do so pretty much damns the Court (thereby, you know, justifying its secrecy in the first place).

-- We never learn why the Court turned against Lincoln.  After all, he seemed poised to become Mayor, which, presumably, would've been just as good as him returning as the long-lost Wayne.  Why did they decide instead to assassinate him in issue #2 along with Bruce?  After all, it's that decision that leads Lincoln on the path to staging his own death and becoming Owlman.

-- It's a smaller point, but we never learn how exactly the Court took a kid who couldn't move his body or open his eyes and turned him into Lincoln March.  I mean, sure, they could resurrect Talons from the dead, but they only managed to do that thanks to Mr. Freeze.  They somehow took a broken kid and turned him into a guy who could be a quarterback for the Steelers?

-- As a subset to that comment, I have some serious questions about the Talons.  Snyder seemed to be going one way with them at the start of this saga and abruptly changed paths.  For example, we never really learn why the Court froze the Talons in the first place, if it seemingly didn't have a way of resurrecting them.  Did it just hope for the technology to present itself one day?  In the beginning, I thought the frozen Talons were actually prospective Talons, not former ones, particularly because of the appearance of the Talons' trainer in the first issue.  I think that he was only Dick's ancestor's trainer, but Snyder never really cleared up that point, part of the reason why I was confused by the chronology of the Talons in the first place.)

I will also add an additional lament.  It's not a loose end, exactly.  In fact, in my last review, I gave credit to Snyder for resolving it.  But, I will say, at the end, I have a general sense that, like the possible switch in the Talons' narrative from prospective agents to former ones, we were being led down a path in terms of the Waynes' involvement with the Court that ultimately proved untrue.  Why did the Court go after Bruce's ancestor all those years ago?  Why didn't they want Martha to build her school?  By pushing the Court to the background, we never really get these answers.  We were lead to believe that the Court behaved in a certain methodical way, but we never really saw what its end goal was.

In the end, Snyder did what he meant to do, giving us a tour d'horizon of Batman's world in the DCnU.  It's still a masterful arc despite its failing, and Snyder has plenty of time to address those loose ends in a way that will retroactively shore up the arc even further.  I'd be lying if I didn't say that I'm anxious to see Snyder turn his attention to the types of stories that we were seeing in "Detective Comics" before the reboot, but I can certainly take a moment to appreciate the ambition of this endeavor even if it didn't 100 percent deliver.  I'd rather someone like Snyder swinging for the fences and I can't wait to see where we go from here.