Wednesday, March 21, 2012

New Comics! (HERE BE SPOILERS!)

Avengers:  The Children's Crusade #9:  Wow.

OK, on the face of it, Heinberg wraps up everything here almost too neatly.  Ant-Man returns, Stature's death and Vision's murder are the catalysts for Iron Lad stepping on the path to becoming Kang, Wanda is off the hook, the Young Avengers partially disband, and the remaining members are accepted into the Avengers fold.  But, it didn't feel like it was "too neatly."  It all felt real, with each event, no matter how neatly it advanced the plot, flowing logically from the emotional reactions that the heroes had to preceding events.

Let's take Iron Lad.  I ended last issue hoping against hope that Heinberg would find a way to keep him on the team.  But, instead, within the first five pages, Heinberg makes him into the villain we all feared he'd one day become, and that transition feels real.  Heinberg so nailed the emotions that Iron Lad would be feeling -- his rage at the Avengers and Young Avengers not letting him take Cassie into the future to heal her -- that he leaves no question that Nate has crossed the line.  By killing the Vision, he goes so beyond redemption here that you aren't left wanting him to join the Young Avengers anymore because you realize he can't.  I've rarely read a more powerful sequence in comics than this one, and if you would've told me that Heinberg would've managed it in five pages, I wouldn't have believed you.

The aspect that was the most convenient was Cyclops letting Wanda off the hook for M-Day.  But, I'm hard pressed for Cyclops to have found any other way.  I'm glad Heinberg has Cyclops acknowledge the Billy was right, in his awesome tirade from last issue, that killing the Scarlet Witch wouldn't result in any justice being had.  Moreover, lately, it's almost laughable to think of Scott as anything approaching a moral authority.  This series, I believe, happens before "X-Men:  Schism," since Iceman appears at Cyclops' side, so Scott at least had some measure more authority, in terms of speaking for mutant-kind, than he does now.  But, it's still hard to follow his logic that the Scarlet Witch should be punished, but Magneto, who's part of his "Extinction Team" shouldn't.  Heinberg successfully made that argument last issue, which is why it was fairly easy to accept the fairly manner in which the Scarlet Witch's future was resolved.

But, Heinberg goes beyond the conflict about Wanda's future and actually, for once, makes it about her.  I loved the part where Wanda rejects the offers of Cap, Simon, Magneto, and Quicksilver to take care of her, finally (FINALLY) deciding that it's time she becomes her own person.  I've always been annoyed by the way that various "Avengers" authors have treated her as a fragile tool, a history Jamie Madrox himself notes when he comments on the likelihood that the Avengers will try to find her the next time Dormammu or Mephisto attacks.  She's always just been the powerful character who quietly saved the day, but whose fragility was what made her a sympathetic character.  Wanda appears to be playing a significant part in the upcoming "Avengers vs. X-Men" event, and I'm really intrigued where Marvel is going to go with her character, one who might finally be freed from her days as nothing more than a helpless pawn.

Lest we forget whose book we're reading, Heinberg brings us home in the end.  I almost got teary during the scenes of the five remaining Young Avengers sitting on the High Line.  I thought Heinberg did an amazing job with Eli here.  We actually see a superhero take real, honest accountability for his actions.  I thought it was a great speech, having him note that he's only seventeen years old and that he didn't want his mistakes to hurt anyone else.  Kate's comments were equally moving, talking about the loss of Cassie, the death of Vision at the hands of Iron Lad, and her lack of powers as reasons for her to leave.  But, it's Billy, who's always been the emotional core of the group that delivers the coup de grace, deciding that he was the enemy all along.  No one believes that, but Billy does, as we see over the next few pages as Heinberg and Cheung give us a play-by-play view of the last few months' of events in the Marvel Universe, as seen from Billy's window, where he's been licking his wounds.

But, heroes are heroes, and Heinberg doesn't leave us there.  Teddy and Billy's conversation is lovely, and, OMG, thank God they finally get some.  But, it's Cap's call to the four of them -- Billy, Kate, Teddy, and Tommy  -- to come to the Mansion to see the statue dedicated to Stature and the Vision (and someone else, who I didn't recognize) that really got me.  Again, from a narrative perspective, it's convenient.  Heinberg has pared down their roster and brought them under the auspices of the Avengers.  I wonder if they're going to appear in "Avengers Academy" or in their own back-up stories in "Avengers."  But, the important part is, again, Heinberg makes it feel real.  It doesn't feel triumphant.  It doesn't feel the way that they probably thought it would feel.  But, it feels real, because it's sad.  As Billy said, "There are no happy endings.  But you show up anyway."  'Nuff said.

I had some qualms with this mini-series.  It went on too long, lost its way a few times, and involved too many characters.  Heinberg doesn't really clarify how Dr. Doom manipulated Wanda into causing the events of "Avengers:  Disassembled" and M-Day or how he used the portal she and Billy opened to gain more power, not less power (as originally intended).  In fact, despite being the villain of the series and possibly revealing a major ret-con, Doom is totally absent here, meriting only a brief mention as the heroes debate where or not he actaully manipulated Wanda as he claimed.  I'm also not sure why Heinberg decided to swap out Stature for Ant-Man, who, I have to say, wasn't exactly such an amazing character that the masses were clamoring for his return. 

But, this issue was one of the best issues of any comic I've read in a long time, so we're good.  It's all good.  In the end, Heinberg used this mini-series to have our team mature and grow.  They learned some pretty hard lessons, but they also faced down the Avengers, Dr. Doom, and the X-Men, and won.  They kept the moral high road and they saved the world.  What more do you want from your heroes?

3 comments:

  1. Yay, this was the post I've been most looking forward to reading since I saw you put it up. I'd have been here sooner but you know, work and such kept me away... Blasted comic books costing me money and making me work! :P As for this issue? I pretty much agree with you all the way around. There was WAY more good than bad here(Tommy was awesome as always, Billy and Teddy FINALLY kissed on panel, the Young Avengers FINALLY gained the acceptance of the Avengers, etc), but the bad did bug me... The Doom/Wanda/Disassembled potential retcon more than anything else... I mean, yeah, I was sad to see Iron Lad go the route of becoming Kang, but that seemed to be Heinberg's intention all along, since I recall some later issue of the first series where Iron Lad is spying on the team in a rather villainous way. And swapping Cassie for her father was flat out bizarre since you'd think Cassie has WAAAAAY more upside than yet another Ant-Man running around the Marvel U. But the lack of any real mention of the Doom thing hurt this one a lot for me. Seriously, if you weren't fully paying attention to issue #8, there's a GREAT chance you'd have missed that altogether! It was just so offhanded, "Btw, I was responsible for M-Day! See ya!" and never really explored here. In a weird way, this mini almost could have used ANOTHER issue, #9 to deal with the fallout of Doom's words, while focusing on Wanda and her decision for the future, and a tenth issue, focusing on the Young Avengers and the aftermath for them. Sure, we probably would have been waiting another 5 months for that tenth issue, but still. :D With all that said? This mini-series will go down as one of my all-time favorite stories, thanks to how powerfully Heinberg wrote it and how wonderfully Cheung drew it. This is definitely an instant classic for me. Here's hoping Marvel finds something for, at the very least, Billy, Teddy and Tommy to do going forward, because they're just too good of characters to fade away.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Seriously, I went immediately to your blog after I finished writing it to read what you wrote, and was like, "Ditto."

    I'd really love to hear the behind-the-scenes scoop on why the Doom part just got totally dropped in this issue. You're totally right: as unbelievable as it is to say it, this already too long mini-series probably needed a wrap-up issue before we got to the Young Avengers wrap-up issue. The Doom thing was so huge, such an enormous ret-con, that I can't believe Heinberg didn't even remotely address it here, other than in passing during the "How Do You Solve a Problem Like Wanda?" discussion. The problem, too, is that I can't really identify an appropriate place for it to be addressed. I mean, the various Avengers and X-Men titles are going to be focused on Phoenix for the next few months, and it's not like Doom has his own series. I'm guessing it's just going to be one of those things that hangs there, unless they decide to work it into "Avengers vs. X-Men."

    But, as you said, it seems to matter less, because this issue was so great. It actually made me wish that Heinberg had gotten a chance to focus even more on the kids, rather than Wanda. We get to see them so infrequently, it would've been nice to have spent more time with them, particularly if it was the last time we see Patriot, Stature, or Vision. But, at least everyone (except Stature) gets at least an emotionally satisfying ending. I really, really hope that they do something with the three boys and put them somewhere, because, like you said, they're too good of characters to just disappear. We'll see, I guess.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Exactly! Where exactly will the Doom thing pop up? It would have made more sense if Doom was the main antagonist in AvX, but unless he suddenly shows up towards the end as some sort of mastermind behind the confrontation between the two teams(and nothing Marvel does would surprise me...), there's nowhere else that piece of info CAN come up again... It makes no sense for the FF to deal with it, since, you know, they have no dog in that fight. Maybe a Doom/Wanda mini-series down the road? Honestly, if AvX wasn't starting until, let's say May or June, Marvel could have immediately had an Avengers/X-Men mini-series(like X-Sanction)from the end of March until AvX started off. It could have been the catalyst for the Avengers and X-Men squaring off, instead of Hope, and could have examined Doom's role(if any...) with Disassembled.

    Yeah, for as much as I love Wanda, and I am a big fan of hers, I'd have preferred a full wrap-up issues dedicated to the Young Avengers, since, as you said, we see them so infrequently. It's sad really... This mini-series was SO good that it's actually going to have me missing the YA's even more. In a perfect world, maybe when Bendis leaves the Avengers books, the new writer(s) can add Hulkling and Wiccan to one of the main Avengers teams like Kurt Busiek added Firestar and Justice to the Avengers way back when. Cap already named the Young Avengers as pretty much honorary Avengers, power-wise they'd fit, I'd think personality-wise they'd be great, plus they'd give a great contrast from the confident, veteran Avengers. Ah, I can dream, right?

    ReplyDelete