**** (four of five stars)
Summary
Gabe tells his mother about the events of last issue, explaining how the Public Eye officers beat him while Kasey was taken from the scene. He begs Conchata not to take him to the doctor and she agrees. Gabe muses what his life would be like without Alchemax, where he and Kasey could be alone, and Conchata tells him to get some rest. She tells herself that it's on her to make things right while, elsewhere, Miguel fights Venture. Venture notes how much more aggressive Spidey is since he was when last they met and Miguel keeps him seriously on the ropes for most of their fight. Venture tells him that he's making a mistake but Spidey responds that his only mistake was going easy on him the first time they fought. He tells Venture that he and the "corps" have been harrassing him since he first got his powers, but they'll have to think again about their assumption that he was weak. Proving his point, he maneauvers Venture onto a mag-lev track; Venture's metallic body is stuck to the track and he's hit by a mag-lev train. Miguel expresses shock that he just did what he did, but even more shock when Venture crawls from the track, virtually unscathed. He attacks, but Miguel uses Venture's own staff to overload his system. He thinks the fight is over, but Venture ejects his hands from his body and uses them to pin Miguel to the ground. Meanwhile, at Miguel's apartment, Xina has Lyla running again, but she's a little surprised when Dana appears.
Standing over Miguel, Venture explains that he had no intention of fighting Miguel, since he was "obliged" to him for defeating Risque. But, he explains that they're now enemies since Miguel came out swinging, telling Miguel, "You still got a lot to learn about power, son. When to use it...and when not to." Miguel leaves to the sounds of Venture using his staff to beat his still-paralyzed sister. Miguel heads to Alchemax where he hitches a ride on Tyler Stone's car, committed to ending Tyler's threat to his family once and for all. He reasons that Tyler is beyond feeling emotions except for fear, the same fear that Kasey felt when she was arrested, or Gabe felt when he was beaten, or Miguel himself felt when he was hooked on rapture. Miguel decides to attack Tyler in his house, where he'll feel as safe as possible, so that he'll know that he'll never be fully safe.
Prepared to kill him, Miguel begins to inflitrate the house, using his accelerated vision to get past the security systems, while, in the foyer, Tyler is greeted by Conchata. Tyler offers her a drink and they retire to the living room. Conchata tells Tyler that his "goons" beat up Gabriel, but Tyler counters that Gabe threatened them with a gun. Conchata retorts that he was trying to keep the Public Eye from taking Kasey and demands that she be released with a clean record and that they be left alone. She also informs him that she knows that he addicted Miguel to rapture, asking how much Tyler hates her for continually going after her family. Tyler stresses that it's business, with Conchata remarking that makes it even worse. She threatens to bring down Tyler if he doesn't do what she wants, saying that she'll let his ex-father-in-law know that he was involved in the death of his late wife. Tyler retorts that she has no proof, but Conchata insists that she does, though wonders if Tyelr wants to call her on the bluff that he's accusing her of making. Miguel arrives in time to see Tyler kiss Conchata, informing her that she was the only woman who was ever a match for him. Tyelr commits to release Kasey and informs her that he didn't really get Miguel addicted to rapture, expositing that it was a simulation; it was meant to last only three days, which is why he never asked how Miguel was dealing with his "addiction." Miguel reels from the revelation that he could've had a normal life and Tyler tells Conchata that she doesn't want to admit that he might have genuine affection for Miguel. Conchata tells Tyler that Miguel thinks that she hates him because she reminds him of her husband, but that the truth is that she only see Miguel's father, Tyler, when she looks at him. She then threatens to kill Tyler if he tells Miguel.
In the back-up story, the Net Prophet enters cyberspace (as a real person, not a computer archetype) and notices a woman to whom he's drawn. Before he can do anything, the woman's ex-boyfriend appears, trying to take her with him. The systems operator tries to stop him, but he attacks, revealing that he's made modifications that make him untouchable in cyberspace. The Net Prophet engages him and vaguely recognizes the sword and the shield that he's using. On the ropes, the ex-boyfriend threatens the woman with a program that would fry her brain in real life, but the Net Prophet cuts off his limbs with eyebeams, convincing him that he's also doing so in real life. In reality, he's put the ex-boyfriend in a "recursive loop" to keep him busy and kisses the woman. The kiss awakens memories in him, but they fade before he can identify them. The woman also disappears and the Net Prophet becomes convinced that she's the key to his past.
The Review
I actually knew the outcome of this issue, since this issue is the last one that I read the first time that I read this series. (The revelation that Tyler is Miguel's father is pretty memorable, even 19 years later.) So, everything after this point is new ground for me.
This issue somewhat clears the decks of the plots that have been the focus of this series over the last few issues or, at least, moves them to the back burner. David has recently spent time developing the world around Miguel, using him as our guide to the realities of the 2099 world. But, we now return to a more personal focus, with Miguel taking center stage again. You can tell that this issue is really going to define the next few issues (if not the rest of the series).
Along those lines, I think the key development here, besides the obvious, is actually the undercurrent of Miguel's fury running through this issue. Between his attempt to kill Venture and his inclination to kill Tyler, David is making it clear that Miguel has had enough. The revelation that Tyler is Miguel's father could either send him over the edge or somehow force him to come to some sort of peace with Alchemax's presence in his life. I'm guessing that it's going to be the former rather than the latter, but we'll see!
The Good
1) Once again, David shows enormous respect for his readers by addressing a past loose-end, namely Tyler never noticing that Miguel wasn't actually addicted to rapture anymore. Sure, he probably wondered why Miguel didn't berate him after realizing that he wasn't actually addicted to it, but, if Miguel didn't mention it, it makes sense that Tyler wouldn't broach the subject either. Plus, the psychological harm that this revelation is going to inflict on Miguel is obvious, given that he never had to become Spider-Man in the first place.
2) The idea that Tyler could have affection for anyone, particularly Miguel, is interesting, particularly given Miguel's seemingly accurate assessment that Tyler has shut off real human emotions in the interest of climbing the corporate ladder. We've seen hints of Tyler's secret compassion (such as his private moment of pain after he flushed his son's ashes down the toilet in issue #10), though whether it would really make any difference in the way he treats people (including Miguel) remains to be seen.
3) Speaking of affection, we really see Miguel as a caring older brother here. He's usually so tightly controlled with his emotions, but David makes it clear that a large part of his fury has to do with the Public Eye goons beating up Gabe and taking in Kasey. If Tyler Stone gets to have emotions, I'm glad that Miguel does as well.
The Unknown
1) The revelation that Conchata and Tyler had a relationship (and seemed to have been in love) raises the question about how a Downtown girl like Conchata got involved with an uptown guy like Tyler. I'm sure David is going to tell us this story and I can't wait to see it.
2) Along those lines, I wonder what "business" Tyler has in persecuting the O'Haras. Is it just that the boys keep running against Alchemax, forcing Tyler's hands, or does he mean something more specific? How would persecuting the O'Hara boys specifically help him? Is it related to whether or not he knows that Miguel is Spider-Man?
3) I wonder who Tyler's ex-father-in-law is? Is it Avatarr? It seems to be someone sufficiently powerful to be a threat to Tyler and not many people are on that list. If it is Avatarr, it begs the question if Tyler is where he is because of nepotism? It could explain why he's so ruthless, since he knows he doesn't deserve to be where he is.
4) Seriously, what the Hell happened between Risque and Venture that they hate one another so much? I wonder if David ever gets a chance to tell that story.
I cover a lot of different titles, with some particular attention to the previous runs of "Spider-Man 2099" and "Nova." Welcome back, Richard! Until next time, Miguel.
Wednesday, May 15, 2013
Ghost Rider 2099 #7: "Been Caught Stealing"
(I'm using my regular-review format for these one-off side issues since they're not really all that likely to play a role in Miguel's overall continuity, making the "Summary" section more or less unnecessary.)
First, I'm both impressed and surprised by the number of direct references and obvious allusions to William Gibson's Sprawl trilogy: Zero, ono-sendai, ice. It's almost like Marvel acquired the rights to Gibson's books and incorporated them into the 2099 world. It's also why I mentioned that I'm surprised, though, since it's such an appropriation of Gibson's work that I'm surprised that he didn't sue!
This issue is significantly better than Miguel's guest "appearance" in "Ravage 2099" #5, since Miguel is actually in it for more than two panels! Kaminski does a good job making the story accessible to someone who hasn't been reading "Ghost Rider." Ghost Rider, or Zero, is looking for a chemical that will help someone named Kylie. Although we're not necessarily told who she is, it's clear that she's important to him, motivating him to break into Alchemax to get the chemical. Of course, it just happens to be in Miguel's lab.
I thought Kaminski did a good job making this entire conflict between Zero and Miguel feel organic. Miguel goes after Zero not because he's trying to get back Alchemax's property (which would be weird), but because the chemical that Zero stole is highly toxic. Miguel worries that Zero will accidentally release it and, since Alchemax won't do anything to help people Downtown, realizes that he's the only one who can prevent that from happening. Plus, I liked how the story didn't end with the two heroes realizing that they're both fighting the same fight, shaking hands, and then teaming up together to take on Alchemax. Instead, Ghost Rider really doesn't care about Spider-Man or, really, the resident of Downtown; he just wants the chemicals. Miguel has to stop fighting him to save a bunch of squatters from a collapsing building caused by their fight and Ghost Rider is able to escape with the chemical. It was an end that I didn't see coming and thought really fit the story well.
Finally, I also enjoyed seeing New York through Zero's eyes. Complaining about everything being too neat and orderly makes me wonder what Transverse City is like!
I'm definitely intrigued by Zero and part of me wonders whether I should pick up this series now. But, I'm thinking that the Gibson homage might become a little more Gibson theft and get old quickly. As such, I'll just stay focused on the regularly scheduled Spider-Man 2099 project. But, I'd definitely recommend this issue to anyone wanting to read about Spider-Man 2099, since, unlike previous guest-appearances, he plays a really integral role to the story here.
First, I'm both impressed and surprised by the number of direct references and obvious allusions to William Gibson's Sprawl trilogy: Zero, ono-sendai, ice. It's almost like Marvel acquired the rights to Gibson's books and incorporated them into the 2099 world. It's also why I mentioned that I'm surprised, though, since it's such an appropriation of Gibson's work that I'm surprised that he didn't sue!
This issue is significantly better than Miguel's guest "appearance" in "Ravage 2099" #5, since Miguel is actually in it for more than two panels! Kaminski does a good job making the story accessible to someone who hasn't been reading "Ghost Rider." Ghost Rider, or Zero, is looking for a chemical that will help someone named Kylie. Although we're not necessarily told who she is, it's clear that she's important to him, motivating him to break into Alchemax to get the chemical. Of course, it just happens to be in Miguel's lab.
I thought Kaminski did a good job making this entire conflict between Zero and Miguel feel organic. Miguel goes after Zero not because he's trying to get back Alchemax's property (which would be weird), but because the chemical that Zero stole is highly toxic. Miguel worries that Zero will accidentally release it and, since Alchemax won't do anything to help people Downtown, realizes that he's the only one who can prevent that from happening. Plus, I liked how the story didn't end with the two heroes realizing that they're both fighting the same fight, shaking hands, and then teaming up together to take on Alchemax. Instead, Ghost Rider really doesn't care about Spider-Man or, really, the resident of Downtown; he just wants the chemicals. Miguel has to stop fighting him to save a bunch of squatters from a collapsing building caused by their fight and Ghost Rider is able to escape with the chemical. It was an end that I didn't see coming and thought really fit the story well.
Finally, I also enjoyed seeing New York through Zero's eyes. Complaining about everything being too neat and orderly makes me wonder what Transverse City is like!
I'm definitely intrigued by Zero and part of me wonders whether I should pick up this series now. But, I'm thinking that the Gibson homage might become a little more Gibson theft and get old quickly. As such, I'll just stay focused on the regularly scheduled Spider-Man 2099 project. But, I'd definitely recommend this issue to anyone wanting to read about Spider-Man 2099, since, unlike previous guest-appearances, he plays a really integral role to the story here.
Friday, May 10, 2013
Secret Avengers #4 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This series just keeps getting better and better. Spencer tells a pretty complex and brilliantly executed story here, full of double- and triple-crosses. I love that he brings it to the place where S.H.I.E.L.D. needed it to be, but from the completely opposite side of the actual events. (Instead of S.H.I.E.L.D. using the Hulk to eliminate the mind-controlled Iron Patriots before they bombed Tehran, as actually happened, they tell everyone they used the Iron Patriots to stop the mind-controlled Hulk from destroying Tehran. Different story, same result.) The way that the story unfolded felt totally organic and I legitimately had no idea (in a good way) where we were going to end. Great stuff.
Thursday, May 9, 2013
Avenging Spider-Man #20 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is awesome! Seriously! Awesome! It's possibly even better than the "Avengers" movie in terms of feeling like an action movie!
First, Yost continues to portray Otto (much more interestingly) as a guy with a significantly weaker commitment to being a hero than Slott portrays him. Otto manipulates his way onto the S.H.I.E.L.D. helicarrier for the express purpose of breaking out the Chameleon, part of his ongoing (yet still unclear) plan of assembling the Sinister Six in his secret base. However, a group of Russian terrorists attack the helicarrier at the same time as Otto puts his plan into action, seeking to take out the Chameleon before he can spill Russia's secrets. Otto does show some signs of being a hero here, since he feels guilt for the people that the Chameleon killed in his escape. (Yost at some point should probably make clear if it was just "Parker luck" that resulted in the Russians appearing at the same time as Otto shutting down S.H.I.E.L.D.'s systems or if they knew somehow that it was going to happen.) But, in typical Otto fashion, he decides that it was the Russians' fault that everything went haywire and engages them in combat.
Not only is it a pretty great plot, but Yost really builds the tension well, in part due to excellent characterization and great dialogue. It feels like a horror movie, where you watch the cast blunder into an unexpected trap. We begin with Otto crowing over his cleverness, as he sends out his spider-bots unnoticed to take over the helicarrier. Otto's interactions with the other characters are amazing, in part because Yost has such a clear sense of them. They're not just background pieces moved around a board, but equal participants reflecting back Otto's actions. Hawkeye's suspicious, Widow's concerned, Fury's confused, Coulson's annoyed: it all helps to show the sense of disequilibrium that Otto has injected into the system with his unexpected presence.
But, things get really fun when everything goes to Hell. Otto is totally rattled and it shows us why he's so bad at these plans, since he doesn't know what to do when something doesn't go exactly how he thought it was going to go. After all, did he really not plan for the fact that he might not be standing right in front of the Chameleon's cell when the energy field dissipated? Did he really not expect the Chameleon to kill someone, take their identity, and try to escape? The beauty is that these failings aren't Yost's; their Otto's, because you absolutely believe that Otto is in fact that arrogant not to anticipate those things. You can only imagine his shock when he's not only fighting the Russians but the Hulk suddenly appears at the end.
Seriously, this issue was a tone-perfect romp, from the excellent characterization of all the characters to the steady way that Yost built the tension. It's also a great issue to get if you know nothing about Spider-Man, but just want to enjoy a good time. In other words, it's highly recommended to everyone.
First, Yost continues to portray Otto (much more interestingly) as a guy with a significantly weaker commitment to being a hero than Slott portrays him. Otto manipulates his way onto the S.H.I.E.L.D. helicarrier for the express purpose of breaking out the Chameleon, part of his ongoing (yet still unclear) plan of assembling the Sinister Six in his secret base. However, a group of Russian terrorists attack the helicarrier at the same time as Otto puts his plan into action, seeking to take out the Chameleon before he can spill Russia's secrets. Otto does show some signs of being a hero here, since he feels guilt for the people that the Chameleon killed in his escape. (Yost at some point should probably make clear if it was just "Parker luck" that resulted in the Russians appearing at the same time as Otto shutting down S.H.I.E.L.D.'s systems or if they knew somehow that it was going to happen.) But, in typical Otto fashion, he decides that it was the Russians' fault that everything went haywire and engages them in combat.
Not only is it a pretty great plot, but Yost really builds the tension well, in part due to excellent characterization and great dialogue. It feels like a horror movie, where you watch the cast blunder into an unexpected trap. We begin with Otto crowing over his cleverness, as he sends out his spider-bots unnoticed to take over the helicarrier. Otto's interactions with the other characters are amazing, in part because Yost has such a clear sense of them. They're not just background pieces moved around a board, but equal participants reflecting back Otto's actions. Hawkeye's suspicious, Widow's concerned, Fury's confused, Coulson's annoyed: it all helps to show the sense of disequilibrium that Otto has injected into the system with his unexpected presence.
But, things get really fun when everything goes to Hell. Otto is totally rattled and it shows us why he's so bad at these plans, since he doesn't know what to do when something doesn't go exactly how he thought it was going to go. After all, did he really not plan for the fact that he might not be standing right in front of the Chameleon's cell when the energy field dissipated? Did he really not expect the Chameleon to kill someone, take their identity, and try to escape? The beauty is that these failings aren't Yost's; their Otto's, because you absolutely believe that Otto is in fact that arrogant not to anticipate those things. You can only imagine his shock when he's not only fighting the Russians but the Hulk suddenly appears at the end.
Seriously, this issue was a tone-perfect romp, from the excellent characterization of all the characters to the steady way that Yost built the tension. It's also a great issue to get if you know nothing about Spider-Man, but just want to enjoy a good time. In other words, it's highly recommended to everyone.
Wednesday, May 8, 2013
Avengers Assemble #15.AU (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is...odd.
First, it's slow. I mean, really slow. I was halfway through the issue and I felt like I should already be done with the story. I actually can't put my finger on why I felt that way, since Ewing actually does a decent job of working the exposition into the story as seamlessly as possible. But, it just felt like it was taking forever to get to the point.
Moreover, the point itself is also confusing. Carol rescues a guy who just sort of stands there when he's confronted by some Ultrons. We learn that he conveniently happens to be Computer Graham, a former child superhero who used to enter video games to prevent their villains from entering our world. He hasn't used his power since video games got too complex, but Captains Britain and Marvel recognize a chance when they see one. So, they go on a suicide mission, with Computer Graham managing to free part of London from Ultron's control. As Excalibur exposits at the end, it means that they should be able to call for help from Otherworld, since Brian deputized her Captain Britain before he left on the mission.
Did I mention that they were accompanied by a girl whose super-power is to kick goals? They were.
Anyway, something about this issue didn't click with me. Between Carol conveniently finding Graham and Ewing breezing past the fact that Ultron seems to be able to be stopped by magic, I felt like it was a little too manufactured to get to the end result. But, I do wonder at the larger impact that end result will have. It seems to be the first issue in this entire event where the good guys get something like a win. But, to make matters odder, I'm not really sure how it connects to the main title, since, in theory, the Ultron invasion didn't happen, since Wolverine killed Hank Pym before he could invent Ultron. It's just plain bizarre that it comes after "Age of Ultron" #6 and #7 and "Wolverine and the X-Men" #27 AU, where all these events transpire. I'm not sure if it's hinting at something or if it's just sloppy continuity. (With Marvel, you never know.)
Anyway, we have six issues left in this event and I feel like it's about five issues too many. This issue didn't really help matters much. It wasn't awful, but between its slow pacing and the fact that it seems months behind the events of the main title, it didn't do much to improve my impression of this event at this point.
First, it's slow. I mean, really slow. I was halfway through the issue and I felt like I should already be done with the story. I actually can't put my finger on why I felt that way, since Ewing actually does a decent job of working the exposition into the story as seamlessly as possible. But, it just felt like it was taking forever to get to the point.
Moreover, the point itself is also confusing. Carol rescues a guy who just sort of stands there when he's confronted by some Ultrons. We learn that he conveniently happens to be Computer Graham, a former child superhero who used to enter video games to prevent their villains from entering our world. He hasn't used his power since video games got too complex, but Captains Britain and Marvel recognize a chance when they see one. So, they go on a suicide mission, with Computer Graham managing to free part of London from Ultron's control. As Excalibur exposits at the end, it means that they should be able to call for help from Otherworld, since Brian deputized her Captain Britain before he left on the mission.
Did I mention that they were accompanied by a girl whose super-power is to kick goals? They were.
Anyway, something about this issue didn't click with me. Between Carol conveniently finding Graham and Ewing breezing past the fact that Ultron seems to be able to be stopped by magic, I felt like it was a little too manufactured to get to the end result. But, I do wonder at the larger impact that end result will have. It seems to be the first issue in this entire event where the good guys get something like a win. But, to make matters odder, I'm not really sure how it connects to the main title, since, in theory, the Ultron invasion didn't happen, since Wolverine killed Hank Pym before he could invent Ultron. It's just plain bizarre that it comes after "Age of Ultron" #6 and #7 and "Wolverine and the X-Men" #27 AU, where all these events transpire. I'm not sure if it's hinting at something or if it's just sloppy continuity. (With Marvel, you never know.)
Anyway, we have six issues left in this event and I feel like it's about five issues too many. This issue didn't really help matters much. It wasn't awful, but between its slow pacing and the fact that it seems months behind the events of the main title, it didn't do much to improve my impression of this event at this point.
Batman and Red Hood #20 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Oh, Jesus fucking Chris, can't Jason ever get a win?
This issue is perfect. It's a brilliant tour of Bruce and Jason's emotions, a portrait of Bruce's grief and Jason's suffering. Bruce is so insane right now that he's blind to the emotional impact that taking Jason to the spot where he died would have, hoping that the location will spark some memory of how Jason returned to life. Meanwhile, Jason is incredulous that he put himself in a situation to trust Bruce again only to have Bruce betray him in the worst possible way, conforming for him that he's never been the son that the other Robins have been for Bruce. It's horribly well done and it's so completely why Tomas is one of the best writers of emotion that I've ever read.
But...
...we were almost there. We were almost at the moment that Jason was going to be part of the Bat-family again and Bruce threw it into the gutter. My one consolation is that Jason is in good company, with the rest of the Bat-family not speaking to Bruce either. Plus, even if they start speaking to Bruce again, it's not like they're going to take Bruce's side on this one. I don't see Dick dismissing his actions here as justified given the harm that they do to Jason. So, maybe a better way of phrasing it would be to say that Jason's part of the Bat-family, but it doesn't matter because Bruce isn't. I'd actually love for Jason to appear in "Batgirl" or "Nightwing" and show us that the rest of the Bat-family cares about him. (In fact, Barbara would have to get off her high horse and admit that she's no less a killer now than Jason is, something that would be great to see.)
In other news, Carrie Kelly returns in a great sequence and Tomasi is making it clear that JT might be right: we might soon have enough Batgirls to have "Batgirl, Inc." At the very least, I'm glad that someone'll be keeping Titus company.
So, all in all, this issue is brilliant, truly brilliant. But, I'm extremely disappointed in Bruce as a result. I absolutely believe that he's so mad with grief that he'd do what he does here, but it doesn't mean I have to like it.
This issue is perfect. It's a brilliant tour of Bruce and Jason's emotions, a portrait of Bruce's grief and Jason's suffering. Bruce is so insane right now that he's blind to the emotional impact that taking Jason to the spot where he died would have, hoping that the location will spark some memory of how Jason returned to life. Meanwhile, Jason is incredulous that he put himself in a situation to trust Bruce again only to have Bruce betray him in the worst possible way, conforming for him that he's never been the son that the other Robins have been for Bruce. It's horribly well done and it's so completely why Tomas is one of the best writers of emotion that I've ever read.
But...
...we were almost there. We were almost at the moment that Jason was going to be part of the Bat-family again and Bruce threw it into the gutter. My one consolation is that Jason is in good company, with the rest of the Bat-family not speaking to Bruce either. Plus, even if they start speaking to Bruce again, it's not like they're going to take Bruce's side on this one. I don't see Dick dismissing his actions here as justified given the harm that they do to Jason. So, maybe a better way of phrasing it would be to say that Jason's part of the Bat-family, but it doesn't matter because Bruce isn't. I'd actually love for Jason to appear in "Batgirl" or "Nightwing" and show us that the rest of the Bat-family cares about him. (In fact, Barbara would have to get off her high horse and admit that she's no less a killer now than Jason is, something that would be great to see.)
In other news, Carrie Kelly returns in a great sequence and Tomasi is making it clear that JT might be right: we might soon have enough Batgirls to have "Batgirl, Inc." At the very least, I'm glad that someone'll be keeping Titus company.
So, all in all, this issue is brilliant, truly brilliant. But, I'm extremely disappointed in Bruce as a result. I absolutely believe that he's so mad with grief that he'd do what he does here, but it doesn't mean I have to like it.
Spider-Man 2099 #24: "Assault and Batteries"
**** (four of five stars)
Favorite Quote: "Ohhh yeah. The one who couldn't keep his gilfriend happy so she went and swiped my boyfrined. Not that I'm bitter, you understand." "Nice try, Xina. But you're not gonna get a rise out of me." "Your girlfriend have the same problem?" -- Xina and Gabe, going PG-13 in a pretty hilarious way that also reminds us how much Gabe has at stake in Kasey not falling in love with Miguel
Summary
Kasey, now outfitted and "cybernetically merged" with a suit of armor, tries out her new abilities. Deeming them "beautiful," she beelines for Alchemax for some "payback." In New York, Xina is working on repairing Lyla and expresses annoyance when Gabriel bursts into the apartment, telling Miguel that he has a problem. At Alchemax, Winston has returned to duty just in time for a Public Eye officer to inform Tyler Stone that Kasey is en route, something that he apparently anticipated. Outside Xina's apartment, Gabriel brings Miguel to speed, but Miguel isn't sure that he can help Kasey. Miguel tells Gabe not to underestimate Kasey's "personal resourcefulness"...when Kasey flies by them. Miguel recognizes her and Gabriel tells him to go after her, since she's in love with Spider-Man and will listen to him. Telling Miguel that she's trying to impress him (Spider-Man), Gabriel asks Miguel to stop her so that he doesn't lose a second girl to Miguel.
At Alchemax, Kasey makes pretty short work of the building's defenses and the Public Eye. However, when she uses towlines to yank out the officers' flybikes from underneath them, she suddenly finds herself unable to maintain her lift. Spider-Man arrives in time to help, cutting loose the towlines (since Kasey herself couldn't release them since they were too embedded in the bikes). Miguel has her take them to safety and he tells her that she's being idiotic when she tells him that she's taking the fight to Alchemax. (When she notes that he does it, he comments, "Yes, but I'm an idiot.") Spidey uses her name, which surprises her; he covers by saying that he heard someone use it. He tells her to stop with the "Payback" business, but she tells him that great power brings great responsibility. When he comments, "Oh, not that again," Kasey realizes that she knows Spider-Man. He tries to stall, but she places his voice, asking him if he's Gabriel (not Miguel). She's not entirely sure, believing that she's seen them together, but only in chaos.
Before they can address the issue, Risque appears, using her finger cannons to take out Kasey. Spidey manages to stop Kasey's fall, but Risque blasts the Web-Line and Kasey crashes to the ground. Gabe rushes to Kasey, but she's surrounded by Public Eye officers telling him to give them space. He pulls a gun on them only to have Tyler Stone appear and tell him to drop it if he doesn't want to get arrested. Gabe drops the gun and the Public Eye deliver him a sound beating. Meanwhile, Risque exposits that Stark-Fujikawa used Kasey to draw out Spider-Man. Miguel manages to pull off her cloak, revealing that she's a cyborg. Using Venture's staff, she chokes him and then tries to unmask him. He prevents her, but she kisses his exposed mouth, giving him the opportunity to use his fangs to poison her. While she's paralyzed, Miguel knocks her unconscious, only for Venture to appear behind him.
The Review
The last few issues, to be honest, have been a little slow. We've had the intrigue with Stark-Fujikawa and Kasey, the drama with Lyla, and the exploration of Miguel's past with Xina. They've been fine issues and David has done a great job of keeping all these plots interesting, but they haven't exactly been all that exciting. In fact, I can't remember the last time Miguel was actually Spider-Man. All that changes in this issue. While the Lyla and Xina sub-plots fade into the background, the Kasey one explodes to the foreground.
The Good
1) The action sequence is great here and, truthfully, sorely needed. Moreover, it was a pretty damn good fight. Risque proves more than a match for Kasey and she keeps Miguel on his toes. The revelation that she's a cyborg was well timed and, honestly, made her sexual advances to Miguel all the creepier. That said, I love how he poisoned her. David's always been great about Miguel using all the tools in his toolkit, particularly the ones that he doesn't have in common with Peter Parker. It was a great way for him to get the win. Now, Venture!
2) I loved Kasey figuring out Gabriel is Spider-Man by his voice! I mean, she's wrong (and I wonder if Gabe is going to take advantage of that fact to keep her), but it's still a great moment. As I've mentioned in many of the reviews that I've written for David-scribed comics, he really respects the reader enough to entertain the possibility that someone maybe, just maybe, would hear someone they know speak and recognize his voice. Honestly, he's probably the only writer in comics that would allow for such a thing, but it's what makes him the best there is at what he does.
The Unknown
It's still unclear (to me, at least) why Alchemax and Stark-Fujikawa are colluding on this one. When Stark-Fujikawa first appeared, Tyler Stone actually used the Specialist as similar bait for Spider-Man, expecting that his defeat at Miguel's hands would lead to Stark-Fujikawa getting drawn into a battle with Spider-Man to avenge the Specialist's honor (see issue #6, specifically). It was eventually revealed (in issue #7) that Alchemax was forced to go to Stark Fujikawa for the Specialist since Venture had been taken off-line. But, why did Stark-Fujikawa have to go to Alchemax? Did they similarly need Risque because they had no home-grown options? Moreover, doesn't Tyler want a piece of Spider-Man? Is he going to surrender him to Stark-Fujikawa so easily? I trust David to answer these questions, so I'm just putting them out there now.
The Bad
I liked the idea of Stark-Fujikawa manipulating Kasey to draw out Spider-Man. In fact, I originally put this comment in the "Good" category. But, at the end of the day, a lot doesn't make sense here. First, do they really need to draw out Spider-Man? It's not like they probably needed to wait all that long for him to appear to right some sort of wrong, given how many wrongs there are in 2099 New York to right. Second, why give Kasey so much power just to draw out Spider-Man? OK, sure, you want to draw out Spider-Man, but why equip a woman who's dedicated the better part of her life fighting you with an amazing suit of armor? Why not just have Risque kill a few people?
Favorite Quote: "Ohhh yeah. The one who couldn't keep his gilfriend happy so she went and swiped my boyfrined. Not that I'm bitter, you understand." "Nice try, Xina. But you're not gonna get a rise out of me." "Your girlfriend have the same problem?" -- Xina and Gabe, going PG-13 in a pretty hilarious way that also reminds us how much Gabe has at stake in Kasey not falling in love with Miguel
Summary
Kasey, now outfitted and "cybernetically merged" with a suit of armor, tries out her new abilities. Deeming them "beautiful," she beelines for Alchemax for some "payback." In New York, Xina is working on repairing Lyla and expresses annoyance when Gabriel bursts into the apartment, telling Miguel that he has a problem. At Alchemax, Winston has returned to duty just in time for a Public Eye officer to inform Tyler Stone that Kasey is en route, something that he apparently anticipated. Outside Xina's apartment, Gabriel brings Miguel to speed, but Miguel isn't sure that he can help Kasey. Miguel tells Gabe not to underestimate Kasey's "personal resourcefulness"...when Kasey flies by them. Miguel recognizes her and Gabriel tells him to go after her, since she's in love with Spider-Man and will listen to him. Telling Miguel that she's trying to impress him (Spider-Man), Gabriel asks Miguel to stop her so that he doesn't lose a second girl to Miguel.
At Alchemax, Kasey makes pretty short work of the building's defenses and the Public Eye. However, when she uses towlines to yank out the officers' flybikes from underneath them, she suddenly finds herself unable to maintain her lift. Spider-Man arrives in time to help, cutting loose the towlines (since Kasey herself couldn't release them since they were too embedded in the bikes). Miguel has her take them to safety and he tells her that she's being idiotic when she tells him that she's taking the fight to Alchemax. (When she notes that he does it, he comments, "Yes, but I'm an idiot.") Spidey uses her name, which surprises her; he covers by saying that he heard someone use it. He tells her to stop with the "Payback" business, but she tells him that great power brings great responsibility. When he comments, "Oh, not that again," Kasey realizes that she knows Spider-Man. He tries to stall, but she places his voice, asking him if he's Gabriel (not Miguel). She's not entirely sure, believing that she's seen them together, but only in chaos.
Before they can address the issue, Risque appears, using her finger cannons to take out Kasey. Spidey manages to stop Kasey's fall, but Risque blasts the Web-Line and Kasey crashes to the ground. Gabe rushes to Kasey, but she's surrounded by Public Eye officers telling him to give them space. He pulls a gun on them only to have Tyler Stone appear and tell him to drop it if he doesn't want to get arrested. Gabe drops the gun and the Public Eye deliver him a sound beating. Meanwhile, Risque exposits that Stark-Fujikawa used Kasey to draw out Spider-Man. Miguel manages to pull off her cloak, revealing that she's a cyborg. Using Venture's staff, she chokes him and then tries to unmask him. He prevents her, but she kisses his exposed mouth, giving him the opportunity to use his fangs to poison her. While she's paralyzed, Miguel knocks her unconscious, only for Venture to appear behind him.
The Review
The last few issues, to be honest, have been a little slow. We've had the intrigue with Stark-Fujikawa and Kasey, the drama with Lyla, and the exploration of Miguel's past with Xina. They've been fine issues and David has done a great job of keeping all these plots interesting, but they haven't exactly been all that exciting. In fact, I can't remember the last time Miguel was actually Spider-Man. All that changes in this issue. While the Lyla and Xina sub-plots fade into the background, the Kasey one explodes to the foreground.
The Good
1) The action sequence is great here and, truthfully, sorely needed. Moreover, it was a pretty damn good fight. Risque proves more than a match for Kasey and she keeps Miguel on his toes. The revelation that she's a cyborg was well timed and, honestly, made her sexual advances to Miguel all the creepier. That said, I love how he poisoned her. David's always been great about Miguel using all the tools in his toolkit, particularly the ones that he doesn't have in common with Peter Parker. It was a great way for him to get the win. Now, Venture!
2) I loved Kasey figuring out Gabriel is Spider-Man by his voice! I mean, she's wrong (and I wonder if Gabe is going to take advantage of that fact to keep her), but it's still a great moment. As I've mentioned in many of the reviews that I've written for David-scribed comics, he really respects the reader enough to entertain the possibility that someone maybe, just maybe, would hear someone they know speak and recognize his voice. Honestly, he's probably the only writer in comics that would allow for such a thing, but it's what makes him the best there is at what he does.
The Unknown
It's still unclear (to me, at least) why Alchemax and Stark-Fujikawa are colluding on this one. When Stark-Fujikawa first appeared, Tyler Stone actually used the Specialist as similar bait for Spider-Man, expecting that his defeat at Miguel's hands would lead to Stark-Fujikawa getting drawn into a battle with Spider-Man to avenge the Specialist's honor (see issue #6, specifically). It was eventually revealed (in issue #7) that Alchemax was forced to go to Stark Fujikawa for the Specialist since Venture had been taken off-line. But, why did Stark-Fujikawa have to go to Alchemax? Did they similarly need Risque because they had no home-grown options? Moreover, doesn't Tyler want a piece of Spider-Man? Is he going to surrender him to Stark-Fujikawa so easily? I trust David to answer these questions, so I'm just putting them out there now.
The Bad
I liked the idea of Stark-Fujikawa manipulating Kasey to draw out Spider-Man. In fact, I originally put this comment in the "Good" category. But, at the end of the day, a lot doesn't make sense here. First, do they really need to draw out Spider-Man? It's not like they probably needed to wait all that long for him to appear to right some sort of wrong, given how many wrongs there are in 2099 New York to right. Second, why give Kasey so much power just to draw out Spider-Man? OK, sure, you want to draw out Spider-Man, but why equip a woman who's dedicated the better part of her life fighting you with an amazing suit of armor? Why not just have Risque kill a few people?
Tuesday, May 7, 2013
Hawkeye #10 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Huh. If Grills was going to die, I wanted it to be for a better reason than a crazy assassin confusing Clint's comments about loving Spider-Woman to be about Kate.
I'm not really sure where Fraction is going to go here. We're at the very least going to get Clint spiraling even further into depression over the guilt he feels about Grills. We're also probably going to get some guilt on Kate's part for leading the assassin inadvertently to Clint's place. It's also possible that it had less to do with the clown's association with Kate and more with him working for the bro-Mafia guys. I guess we'll see. Needless to say, it wasn't my favorite issue, but I'm willing to be patient.
I'm not really sure where Fraction is going to go here. We're at the very least going to get Clint spiraling even further into depression over the guilt he feels about Grills. We're also probably going to get some guilt on Kate's part for leading the assassin inadvertently to Clint's place. It's also possible that it had less to do with the clown's association with Kate and more with him working for the bro-Mafia guys. I guess we'll see. Needless to say, it wasn't my favorite issue, but I'm willing to be patient.
All-New X-Men #11 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
About half way through this issue, I realized that I needed to breathe more.
If Bendis does one thing well, it's confusing, complicated fight scenes involving a lot of people. The near-riot that erupts in this issue when Warren announces that he's defecting to Cyclops' side is great, in part because it goes exactly how I'd imagine it would go. Jean tries to force Warren to stay with her telepathy, the Cuckoos stop her, Logan rushes to her defense, Magneto attacks Logan, and Storm tries to keep everyone calm. Seriously, it's exactly how it would go. But, beyond that, Bendis really builds an unbelievable amount of tension (hence why I forgot to breathe) as these events progress. They hit their apex when Logan threatens Emma, she refuses to yield so that Jean can learn a lesson, and older Scott is forced to get her to stop. Tense, man. Tense.
But, Bendis just doesn't let it rest there. I loved the banter between Hank, Kitty, Logan, and Storm after the fight, in part because they're really gelling (or, well, re-gelling) as a team. We really are getting back an old-school team of X-Men. I can't remember the last time someone really captured that sense of intimacy, given the casts of thousands that the X-books have had since everyone moved to San Francisco. But, I don't think that it's any accident that Storm has returned to the mohawk. Bendis is sending a clear signal that this book is about the X-Men as they used to be and will be and all I can say is that it's about time.
Also, Bendis surprisingly writes a believable 16-year-old girl. I thought that he did a spectacular job with Kitty's conversation with Jean, showing how scared (and young) Jean is and how worried (and strong) Kitty is. You can really feel the betrayal Jean feels at Warren leaving, given she really thought that they would all stay together based on her view of older Hank's memories. You can also feel the emotional importance of them staying together to her, since they're really the only people in the entire world that she knows and understands her.
Moreover, Bendis does a great job of having Kitty be a teacher. I loved Kitty quoting Spider-Man to get Jean to understand her responsibility to use her powers wisely and Wolverine to help her to find a way to channel her anger productively. The end result makes sense, with Jean focusing on the one threat that she's aware is out there: Mystique. But, they have to go through the Uncanny Avengers first. I wonder how Havok is going to react to seeing his younger older brother?
I can't believe that Bendis has kept this roll going this long, but I'm thrilled to be here!
If Bendis does one thing well, it's confusing, complicated fight scenes involving a lot of people. The near-riot that erupts in this issue when Warren announces that he's defecting to Cyclops' side is great, in part because it goes exactly how I'd imagine it would go. Jean tries to force Warren to stay with her telepathy, the Cuckoos stop her, Logan rushes to her defense, Magneto attacks Logan, and Storm tries to keep everyone calm. Seriously, it's exactly how it would go. But, beyond that, Bendis really builds an unbelievable amount of tension (hence why I forgot to breathe) as these events progress. They hit their apex when Logan threatens Emma, she refuses to yield so that Jean can learn a lesson, and older Scott is forced to get her to stop. Tense, man. Tense.
But, Bendis just doesn't let it rest there. I loved the banter between Hank, Kitty, Logan, and Storm after the fight, in part because they're really gelling (or, well, re-gelling) as a team. We really are getting back an old-school team of X-Men. I can't remember the last time someone really captured that sense of intimacy, given the casts of thousands that the X-books have had since everyone moved to San Francisco. But, I don't think that it's any accident that Storm has returned to the mohawk. Bendis is sending a clear signal that this book is about the X-Men as they used to be and will be and all I can say is that it's about time.
Also, Bendis surprisingly writes a believable 16-year-old girl. I thought that he did a spectacular job with Kitty's conversation with Jean, showing how scared (and young) Jean is and how worried (and strong) Kitty is. You can really feel the betrayal Jean feels at Warren leaving, given she really thought that they would all stay together based on her view of older Hank's memories. You can also feel the emotional importance of them staying together to her, since they're really the only people in the entire world that she knows and understands her.
Moreover, Bendis does a great job of having Kitty be a teacher. I loved Kitty quoting Spider-Man to get Jean to understand her responsibility to use her powers wisely and Wolverine to help her to find a way to channel her anger productively. The end result makes sense, with Jean focusing on the one threat that she's aware is out there: Mystique. But, they have to go through the Uncanny Avengers first. I wonder how Havok is going to react to seeing his younger older brother?
I can't believe that Bendis has kept this roll going this long, but I'm thrilled to be here!
Young Avengers #4 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
OMG, how could this comic be even more awesome than it was last issue? "Come with me if you want to be awesome," indeed.
The problem with reviewing this series is that the best aspect of it -- the witty banter -- is almost impossible to describe. First, Gillen delivers it in a way that makes it feel totally organic. We're just watching a bunch of young friends having the time of their lives on a road trip. I mean, sure, they're on the road trip because they're actually escaping an interdimensional parasite and their car is a Kree spaceship. But, it's a road trip all the same. But, beyond just being organic, the banter is so amazing because it's based on the complicated interplay of the characters' personalities, both individually and collectively. You've got to understand Teddy, Kate, and Noh Varr to understand why their conversation -- "Your boyfriend is so cute!"/"He's totally faking it."/"My faking it is total." -- is hilarious. To try to dissect it seems to dishonor it, so I'm going to avoid doing it. Just trust me. The banter it is witty.
But, this issue is more than just witty banter. Loki is at his level best here, pointing out something that never dawned on me but completely devastated me: Billy, the gay human mutant, just happened to go the same school as Teddy, the gay Skrull prince. What are the chances? Pretty good, as Loki notes, when one of the people involved is a reality warper. Gillen suddenly throws BIlly and Teddy's relationship into question not in a soap-opera way, but in a way that totally gets to the core of this series. Maybe BIlly did summon up his "improbably dashing prince" because he doesn't have full control over his powers. Gillen isn't driving a wedge between them simply to add in some dramatic tension; he's really digging to the core of the characters. As scared as I am that something's going to happen to Billy and Teddy, Gillen handles this twist so brilliantly that I trust him completely, regardless of the outcome.
But, lest we think it's all teenage angst and drama, we also get some serious ass-kicking. The music-video battle scene this issue is spectacular and made me sad. Why did it make me sad? It made me sad because one day Gillen and McKelvie won't be working on this series together and just the thought of it is enough to make me want to eat Ben & Jerry's on the couch while listening to the Ronettes. The drums, the drums.
Next month is too far away.
The problem with reviewing this series is that the best aspect of it -- the witty banter -- is almost impossible to describe. First, Gillen delivers it in a way that makes it feel totally organic. We're just watching a bunch of young friends having the time of their lives on a road trip. I mean, sure, they're on the road trip because they're actually escaping an interdimensional parasite and their car is a Kree spaceship. But, it's a road trip all the same. But, beyond just being organic, the banter is so amazing because it's based on the complicated interplay of the characters' personalities, both individually and collectively. You've got to understand Teddy, Kate, and Noh Varr to understand why their conversation -- "Your boyfriend is so cute!"/"He's totally faking it."/"My faking it is total." -- is hilarious. To try to dissect it seems to dishonor it, so I'm going to avoid doing it. Just trust me. The banter it is witty.
But, this issue is more than just witty banter. Loki is at his level best here, pointing out something that never dawned on me but completely devastated me: Billy, the gay human mutant, just happened to go the same school as Teddy, the gay Skrull prince. What are the chances? Pretty good, as Loki notes, when one of the people involved is a reality warper. Gillen suddenly throws BIlly and Teddy's relationship into question not in a soap-opera way, but in a way that totally gets to the core of this series. Maybe BIlly did summon up his "improbably dashing prince" because he doesn't have full control over his powers. Gillen isn't driving a wedge between them simply to add in some dramatic tension; he's really digging to the core of the characters. As scared as I am that something's going to happen to Billy and Teddy, Gillen handles this twist so brilliantly that I trust him completely, regardless of the outcome.
But, lest we think it's all teenage angst and drama, we also get some serious ass-kicking. The music-video battle scene this issue is spectacular and made me sad. Why did it make me sad? It made me sad because one day Gillen and McKelvie won't be working on this series together and just the thought of it is enough to make me want to eat Ben & Jerry's on the couch while listening to the Ronettes. The drums, the drums.
Next month is too far away.
Monday, May 6, 2013
Earth 2 #12 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
First, I was reminded about how excited I am generally about this series when I saw the ad for the upcoming annual and squealed. The new Batman! Cool!
Although it's not perfect, this issue is a return to the form. After the seemingly endless exposition of the last two issues, we finally get some action, with Dr. Fate bringing the fight to Wotan. We also get Flash and Green Lantern running interference, something that seemingly inspires Alan to start seeing them as a team, given his comments at the end of the issue. I thought the revelation that the "green energy" can compel Alan to do something against his will was interesting, though I wonder why it took Dr. Fate's vision to alert them to the presence of Steppenwolf in Dherain and not the green energy. Robinson is going to have to be careful, because I feel like it's the sort of plot device that can get maddening when used intermittently.
Speaking of "maddening," I will say that Robinson still has some moments of wooden dialogue here, such as Alan declaring, "It's maddening!" to Kendra as he's compelled to depart or Kendra basically exulting in Alan's lover's death because she loves a mystery. I think Robinson is generally focused on the world-building that he continues to do here in spectacular fashion, but a little more attention to making the dialogue seem more natural would be a great evolution.
But, overall, I really enjoyed this issue, particularly since it moves us closer and closer to the formation of the Justice Society. After the Tower of Fate interlude, it's nice to be returning to stories that continue to develop the characters and their relationships to one another.
Although it's not perfect, this issue is a return to the form. After the seemingly endless exposition of the last two issues, we finally get some action, with Dr. Fate bringing the fight to Wotan. We also get Flash and Green Lantern running interference, something that seemingly inspires Alan to start seeing them as a team, given his comments at the end of the issue. I thought the revelation that the "green energy" can compel Alan to do something against his will was interesting, though I wonder why it took Dr. Fate's vision to alert them to the presence of Steppenwolf in Dherain and not the green energy. Robinson is going to have to be careful, because I feel like it's the sort of plot device that can get maddening when used intermittently.
Speaking of "maddening," I will say that Robinson still has some moments of wooden dialogue here, such as Alan declaring, "It's maddening!" to Kendra as he's compelled to depart or Kendra basically exulting in Alan's lover's death because she loves a mystery. I think Robinson is generally focused on the world-building that he continues to do here in spectacular fashion, but a little more attention to making the dialogue seem more natural would be a great evolution.
But, overall, I really enjoyed this issue, particularly since it moves us closer and closer to the formation of the Justice Society. After the Tower of Fate interlude, it's nice to be returning to stories that continue to develop the characters and their relationships to one another.
Detective Comics #20 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is exactly what I wanted it to be.
First, Layman firmly establishes Emperor Penguin as a permanent member of Batman's rogues' gallery, capping off an amazing origin arc. Oglivy proves that he's prepared for every eventuality, including (actually, particularly) his climatic fight with Batman. In fact, we learn that the whole point of his rise to power was specifically to fight Batman, to prove that he wasn't a nobody. As such, he has brought the full brunt of his attention to the task, using the Man-Bat serum to make him agile, Venom drug to make him strong, and Poison Ivy's chemicals to make him invulnerable. It all leads to Batman being genuinely surprised, something that we don't often see happen but feels totally organic. It's just so well executed, both in terms of the plan and the writing, that you believe that it's legitimately something Batman didn't predict. Both Layman and Oglivy really took their time getting us here and it shows.
Why Oglivy developed the plan in the first place is a brilliant touch of characterization on Layman's part, presenting him as Bruce Wayne through the glass, darkly. His father labored in obscurity as a low-level thug until he wound up getting killed (along with Oglivy's mother) as players higher up the food chain moved pieces around the board. Oglivy's father told him not to rock the boat after he erroneously got blamed (and lost two fingers) for betraying the boss, but Oglivy, in his own words, decided not only to rock the boat, but to own it. Now, he finds himself the "boss" in Blackgate Prison and you wonder if he hadn't been planning on exactly that all along.
Interesting enough, Penguin himself is essentially reduced to collateral damage. Although he plays an important role in springing Batman, he's pretty much a background figure for most of this issue, regaining control of his kingdom essentially because Oglivy didn't want it anymore (having already proved his point). But, Layman's decision to have the Penguin fade into the background was brilliant. He's playing off someone else's script here, having inherited an assertively public Penguin from Daniel, but he makes you feel like he had been planning this resolution since the first issue of the re-boot. After the events of the last few issues, it makes sense that Penguin decided that, in fact, he shouldn't rock the boat and instead return to the shadows.
All in all, it's a really masterful conclusion to this part of Emperor Penguin's story and, to my mind, establishes this series as the pre-eminent Batman comic of the moment.
First, Layman firmly establishes Emperor Penguin as a permanent member of Batman's rogues' gallery, capping off an amazing origin arc. Oglivy proves that he's prepared for every eventuality, including (actually, particularly) his climatic fight with Batman. In fact, we learn that the whole point of his rise to power was specifically to fight Batman, to prove that he wasn't a nobody. As such, he has brought the full brunt of his attention to the task, using the Man-Bat serum to make him agile, Venom drug to make him strong, and Poison Ivy's chemicals to make him invulnerable. It all leads to Batman being genuinely surprised, something that we don't often see happen but feels totally organic. It's just so well executed, both in terms of the plan and the writing, that you believe that it's legitimately something Batman didn't predict. Both Layman and Oglivy really took their time getting us here and it shows.
Why Oglivy developed the plan in the first place is a brilliant touch of characterization on Layman's part, presenting him as Bruce Wayne through the glass, darkly. His father labored in obscurity as a low-level thug until he wound up getting killed (along with Oglivy's mother) as players higher up the food chain moved pieces around the board. Oglivy's father told him not to rock the boat after he erroneously got blamed (and lost two fingers) for betraying the boss, but Oglivy, in his own words, decided not only to rock the boat, but to own it. Now, he finds himself the "boss" in Blackgate Prison and you wonder if he hadn't been planning on exactly that all along.
Interesting enough, Penguin himself is essentially reduced to collateral damage. Although he plays an important role in springing Batman, he's pretty much a background figure for most of this issue, regaining control of his kingdom essentially because Oglivy didn't want it anymore (having already proved his point). But, Layman's decision to have the Penguin fade into the background was brilliant. He's playing off someone else's script here, having inherited an assertively public Penguin from Daniel, but he makes you feel like he had been planning this resolution since the first issue of the re-boot. After the events of the last few issues, it makes sense that Penguin decided that, in fact, he shouldn't rock the boat and instead return to the shadows.
All in all, it's a really masterful conclusion to this part of Emperor Penguin's story and, to my mind, establishes this series as the pre-eminent Batman comic of the moment.
X-Factor #255 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I haven't been a real fan of this arc, but David at least sort of pulls it together here, setting up next issue's conclusion. I still have lots of questions, like what's Jezebel's real allegiance and what's Monet's mysterious illness. But, David gives us a more linear narrative than we've had over the last few issues, with Tier realizing that he has little choice but to kill Mephisto after Mephisto manages to defeat the other Hell Lords and take over the Earth. I guess we'll see how that goes next issue.
Winter Soldier #18 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
In all honesty, I have trouble pinpointing what Latour does to make these issues nearly unreadable. But, unreadable they are, unfortunately.
Latour actually skirts around something interesting here, showing Tesla as a child prodigy who eventually becomes too talented for her Soviet handlers to control. But, it's still difficult to piece together her story. I'm still not really clear what we're supposed to believe about Van Owen in terms of his relationship with Father Hammer or why Tesla was chosen to work with Van Owen in the first place (particularly after she appeared to slaughter her classmates at that reception). It seems weird that Father Hammer engaged in decades of effort to get Tesla where he wants her, only for him to use her as a trainer for psychopathic children and not as the theoretical physicist that he appeared to be training her to be.
You'll notice I haven't mentioned Bucky yet. That's the other problem with this issue. After you realize that you're not entirely sure that you understand Tesla, you realize that it's even less clear how Tesla fits into the story that Latour has been telling since he took over this series. How does she fit into the story about the grey-haired guy? Was the whole point of this mission to find her or is she just an unexpected surprise? I really have no clue. Moreover, Tesla seems to get basic things wrong about Bucky, such as believing that his bionic arm is somehow a tribute to the Black Widow. I'm not sure if Latour is intentionally writing it so that Tesla is wrong or if he was actually trying to say something else here. But, the fact that I don't know shows how difficult this series is to read.
The point of this tour of the illogical moments of this issue is to show that I'm really trying here. But, Latour is giving me little. It's like a one-sided relationship where you just keep pouring in effort and the other person barely returns your texts. So, I think it's time for me to break off this relationship, unfortunately. Once Latour is off this title, I'll return, but, until then, Bucky is going to have to go back into suspended animation for me.
(Update: I just read a review that said Marvel has canceled "Winter Soldier" starting next issue. So, I guess I'll get that one and see how Latour wraps up Tesla's story. But, truthfully, I'm glad to hear it, since it hopefully means that he's going to appear somewhere like "Secret Avengers" and I won't be denied reading about him because I was going to skip this title.)
Latour actually skirts around something interesting here, showing Tesla as a child prodigy who eventually becomes too talented for her Soviet handlers to control. But, it's still difficult to piece together her story. I'm still not really clear what we're supposed to believe about Van Owen in terms of his relationship with Father Hammer or why Tesla was chosen to work with Van Owen in the first place (particularly after she appeared to slaughter her classmates at that reception). It seems weird that Father Hammer engaged in decades of effort to get Tesla where he wants her, only for him to use her as a trainer for psychopathic children and not as the theoretical physicist that he appeared to be training her to be.
You'll notice I haven't mentioned Bucky yet. That's the other problem with this issue. After you realize that you're not entirely sure that you understand Tesla, you realize that it's even less clear how Tesla fits into the story that Latour has been telling since he took over this series. How does she fit into the story about the grey-haired guy? Was the whole point of this mission to find her or is she just an unexpected surprise? I really have no clue. Moreover, Tesla seems to get basic things wrong about Bucky, such as believing that his bionic arm is somehow a tribute to the Black Widow. I'm not sure if Latour is intentionally writing it so that Tesla is wrong or if he was actually trying to say something else here. But, the fact that I don't know shows how difficult this series is to read.
The point of this tour of the illogical moments of this issue is to show that I'm really trying here. But, Latour is giving me little. It's like a one-sided relationship where you just keep pouring in effort and the other person barely returns your texts. So, I think it's time for me to break off this relationship, unfortunately. Once Latour is off this title, I'll return, but, until then, Bucky is going to have to go back into suspended animation for me.
(Update: I just read a review that said Marvel has canceled "Winter Soldier" starting next issue. So, I guess I'll get that one and see how Latour wraps up Tesla's story. But, truthfully, I'm glad to hear it, since it hopefully means that he's going to appear somewhere like "Secret Avengers" and I won't be denied reading about him because I was going to skip this title.)
Sunday, May 5, 2013
Thanos Rising #2 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Damn if Aaron isn't making Thanos into a sympathetic character.
In the first issue, Aaron downplayed the isolation that Thanos felt as a result of his mutation. I didn't quite catch the import of that decision at first, but, in this issue, it sets the stage for Thanos' murder spree, since it establishes that Titan is the type of place where everyone accepts everyone for who he is. Thus, in this sort of Utopia, someone like Thanos can be accepted for who he appears to be and, conversely, not really be suspected of who he actually is.
But, who is he? Aaron is leaving it to us to guess if Thanos' murder spree is a reflection of nature or nurture. Thanos seems to suspect that it's his nature, given that his obsession with vivisection comes from his desire to discover why he feels the way that he does when he murders someone. Is it an integral part of him or is it something born of his peculiar circumstances? He also hypothesizes that it's the lack of love in his life, a pretty plausible conclusion given that his mother immediately tried to kill him and his "girlfriend" rebuffs him constantly. But, his mother tried to kill him because she sensed evil in him and it's pretty clear that the "girlfriend's" obsession with him comes from a similar sense of something innately part of him. As such, we still lack a clear answer to whether it's nature or nurture.
But, Aaron also shows that it's increasingly mattering less and less. As Thanos comes to enjoy murder, you can see the point is coming when he's going to stop worrying about it. I'm still intrigued by the series of events that'll lead to Thanos becoming the psychopath that he'll eventually become, but we've definitely seen the roots of that psychosis laid here. All in all, this mini-series really does surprise by providing new insights into Thanos while not really undermining his established history. It's an impressive feat, needless to say.
In the first issue, Aaron downplayed the isolation that Thanos felt as a result of his mutation. I didn't quite catch the import of that decision at first, but, in this issue, it sets the stage for Thanos' murder spree, since it establishes that Titan is the type of place where everyone accepts everyone for who he is. Thus, in this sort of Utopia, someone like Thanos can be accepted for who he appears to be and, conversely, not really be suspected of who he actually is.
But, who is he? Aaron is leaving it to us to guess if Thanos' murder spree is a reflection of nature or nurture. Thanos seems to suspect that it's his nature, given that his obsession with vivisection comes from his desire to discover why he feels the way that he does when he murders someone. Is it an integral part of him or is it something born of his peculiar circumstances? He also hypothesizes that it's the lack of love in his life, a pretty plausible conclusion given that his mother immediately tried to kill him and his "girlfriend" rebuffs him constantly. But, his mother tried to kill him because she sensed evil in him and it's pretty clear that the "girlfriend's" obsession with him comes from a similar sense of something innately part of him. As such, we still lack a clear answer to whether it's nature or nurture.
But, Aaron also shows that it's increasingly mattering less and less. As Thanos comes to enjoy murder, you can see the point is coming when he's going to stop worrying about it. I'm still intrigued by the series of events that'll lead to Thanos becoming the psychopath that he'll eventually become, but we've definitely seen the roots of that psychosis laid here. All in all, this mini-series really does surprise by providing new insights into Thanos while not really undermining his established history. It's an impressive feat, needless to say.
Age of Ultron #7 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
So, we traded Ultron for Tony. I have the sinking suspicion that this revelation is supposed to be more shocking than it actually is and Bendis doesn't really have anything else up his sleeve. If I had to guess, Logan and Sue are going to escape from the Defenders next issue, then rally them to their side in issue #9, and set back everything the way it was before Ultron invaded in issue #10. I'm actually so sure that something along these lines is going to happen that I'm wondering if it's even worth spending the $11.97 on these issues.
Saturday, May 4, 2013
Wolverine and the X-Men #28 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I think I'm done. It was one thing when this series was essentially the only game in town, the primary series dealing with Wolverine and his side after "X-Men: Schism." But, with "All-New X-Men" and "Uncanny X-Men" taking their place at the center of the X-verse, it's hard to justify getting a series whose stories are told this inartfully. I like Jason Aaron normally, but something about this series has reduced him to overwrought narrations and unrealistic characterizations. Plus, I'll be thrilled never to have to see the Kiddie Hellfire Club again. So, I'm done.
Guardians of the Galaxy #2 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Ooo, I enjoyed this issue thoroughly.
First, I love how Bendis keeps J'Son's motivations really unclear here. After all, he lays out the threat that Earth has posed to the galactic leaders that he's assembled -- the Asgardians, the Badoon, the Brood, the Kree, and the Shi'Aar -- but fails to mention that Earth has never really attacked Spartax. Sure, he makes the argument that once Earth develops space travel all bets are off the table, but you still have to wonder why he's so concerned about that threat now. It obviously leads you to wonder if it's all an attempt to manipulate Peter into returning to Spartax. If so, the plan worked pretty well. He gets Freya to put Earth under her protection, declares that it's off-limits to the assembled potentates, drops a hint to Peter that it's a sitting duck, gets Peter to go save it from the inevitable Badoon invasion, and, BAM, finds that Peter is dragged to Spartax in chains for violating the quarantine. Pretty clever.
But, as is required if this series is going to work, this issue isn't just about the possible manipulations of Peter's father. The Guardians themselves give us a rollicking good time and Bendis gives us a lot to love here. I loved Rocket declaring, "BLAM, murdered you" every time that he shot someone. I loved Peter and Tony's banter (and Tony dissing Captain Britain). I loved Drax and Gamora being Drax and Gamora. I loved that we have to wait for Groot to regrow himself. Along the way, Bendis peppers their conversation with enough nonsense words -- "What am I, a Figalleon farmer?" -- to keep up the campy space-opera theme that this series also needs to have to work. For good measure, Bendis also throws in enough Easter eggs -- from science-fiction references like Rigel-Seven to comic-book jokes like "Power Pack?" -- to make you wonder if Bendis has finally found the book where his corny sense of humor actually works.
First, I love how Bendis keeps J'Son's motivations really unclear here. After all, he lays out the threat that Earth has posed to the galactic leaders that he's assembled -- the Asgardians, the Badoon, the Brood, the Kree, and the Shi'Aar -- but fails to mention that Earth has never really attacked Spartax. Sure, he makes the argument that once Earth develops space travel all bets are off the table, but you still have to wonder why he's so concerned about that threat now. It obviously leads you to wonder if it's all an attempt to manipulate Peter into returning to Spartax. If so, the plan worked pretty well. He gets Freya to put Earth under her protection, declares that it's off-limits to the assembled potentates, drops a hint to Peter that it's a sitting duck, gets Peter to go save it from the inevitable Badoon invasion, and, BAM, finds that Peter is dragged to Spartax in chains for violating the quarantine. Pretty clever.
But, as is required if this series is going to work, this issue isn't just about the possible manipulations of Peter's father. The Guardians themselves give us a rollicking good time and Bendis gives us a lot to love here. I loved Rocket declaring, "BLAM, murdered you" every time that he shot someone. I loved Peter and Tony's banter (and Tony dissing Captain Britain). I loved Drax and Gamora being Drax and Gamora. I loved that we have to wait for Groot to regrow himself. Along the way, Bendis peppers their conversation with enough nonsense words -- "What am I, a Figalleon farmer?" -- to keep up the campy space-opera theme that this series also needs to have to work. For good measure, Bendis also throws in enough Easter eggs -- from science-fiction references like Rigel-Seven to comic-book jokes like "Power Pack?" -- to make you wonder if Bendis has finally found the book where his corny sense of humor actually works.
Uncanny X-Men #5 (HERE BE SPOILERS)
Honestly, I didn't really think that Bendis was capable of writing something as emotionally complex as this issue. But, much to my pleasant surprise, he recalls an Illyana that we haven't seen in a long, long time.
It's been pretty clear since this series started that Illyana's sudden strength was going to be revealed to be part of the same post-Phoenix phenomenon that broke Cyclops, Emma, and Magneto's powers. Bendis confirms that here, revealing that Illyana now exerts less control over Limbo than she previously did. Although Bendis doesn't give us the specifics, his reasoning for not doing so is sound: Illyana herself doesn't know. I thought this part of Bendis' exploration of Illyana was the most fascinating thing that Bendis has done in this series, revealing that she doesn't understand Limbo as well as she could and that this lack of knowledge makes her susceptible to the attack from Dormammu that we see here. It fits with the way that her character has been portrayed over the years, since you're left wondering why she's only now willing to approach Dr. Strange and learn more about her powers. The fact that her weakness now threatens the entire Brotherhood makes you wonder how many of the new recruits are going to be keen on the New Xavier School after they spend some time in Hell itself.
All in all, it's yet another solid issue. On some level, it makes me realize how desperate Scott is, since he's been forced to rely on Magik these last few weeks and now has to start paying the consequences of that here. I'm really intrigued by what Bendis is going to make those consequences be.
It's been pretty clear since this series started that Illyana's sudden strength was going to be revealed to be part of the same post-Phoenix phenomenon that broke Cyclops, Emma, and Magneto's powers. Bendis confirms that here, revealing that Illyana now exerts less control over Limbo than she previously did. Although Bendis doesn't give us the specifics, his reasoning for not doing so is sound: Illyana herself doesn't know. I thought this part of Bendis' exploration of Illyana was the most fascinating thing that Bendis has done in this series, revealing that she doesn't understand Limbo as well as she could and that this lack of knowledge makes her susceptible to the attack from Dormammu that we see here. It fits with the way that her character has been portrayed over the years, since you're left wondering why she's only now willing to approach Dr. Strange and learn more about her powers. The fact that her weakness now threatens the entire Brotherhood makes you wonder how many of the new recruits are going to be keen on the New Xavier School after they spend some time in Hell itself.
All in all, it's yet another solid issue. On some level, it makes me realize how desperate Scott is, since he's been forced to rely on Magik these last few weeks and now has to start paying the consequences of that here. I'm really intrigued by what Bendis is going to make those consequences be.
Uncanny Avengers #7 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Although I was initially a little surprised by the high level of vitriol that we see here amongst the Avengers, I have to say that I eventually came to realize that Remender is actually presenting a pretty damn realistic portrayal of how this group would interact with one another after the events of "Avengers vs. X-Men." Remender has made it clear that Rogue will no way forgive Wanda for her role in M-Day and I can totally buy that. Moreover, Wanda is trying to stay civil (even though she finally gives up doing so here when she refers to Rogue as a "floozy"), but you can just tell that she believes that she made amends (since she did help Hope restart the mutant race, after all). In other words, it all fits. Similarly, I totally buy that Jan would make comments about the X-Men not being "real Avengers" and then proceed to hit on Havok. (She does have a thing for blondes.) Even Logan defending Rogue fits with the idea that we're still Avengers and X-Men on this team, name to the contrary. I think the adjustment to this sort of profound in-fighting comes from the fact that Bendis made the Avengers into a shiny, happy family who never fought. But, constant bickering is a long cherished Avengers tradition and I'm actually enjoying watching Remender resurrect it.
Remender really does an amazing job of keeping all the balls in the air here and making you wonder where we're going next. Although the main focus of this issue is the arrival of the Apocalypse Twins, Remender reminds us that the Red Skull is still out there fomenting anti-mutant hysteria. He also sets up a future story with Havok dispatch Rogue after Magneto. Turning to the matter at hand, we learn that Kang didn't need Jarnbjorn to pierce Apocalypse's armor, as appeared to be the case last issue, but a Celestial's (assuming that Uriel killing him was actually part of Kang's plan). I would still love to know how it wound up falling into Baron Mordo's hands (as seen in the end of issue #6) or why Logan would know about Jarnbjorn (since it was his ancestor who was on hand for Thor's fight with Apocalypse). But, I feel like Remender will get us there, given how carefully he's handled such dangling plot threads so far.
Obviously, the big question now is why Uriel and Eimin have returned at this exact moment. Is it all part of Kang's plan or are they acting on their own? It seems like a good time for Kang to send them to the present, if the goal was to stop Genocide from gaining Apocalypse's powers. But, where do we go from here? I can't wait to get that answer!
Remender really does an amazing job of keeping all the balls in the air here and making you wonder where we're going next. Although the main focus of this issue is the arrival of the Apocalypse Twins, Remender reminds us that the Red Skull is still out there fomenting anti-mutant hysteria. He also sets up a future story with Havok dispatch Rogue after Magneto. Turning to the matter at hand, we learn that Kang didn't need Jarnbjorn to pierce Apocalypse's armor, as appeared to be the case last issue, but a Celestial's (assuming that Uriel killing him was actually part of Kang's plan). I would still love to know how it wound up falling into Baron Mordo's hands (as seen in the end of issue #6) or why Logan would know about Jarnbjorn (since it was his ancestor who was on hand for Thor's fight with Apocalypse). But, I feel like Remender will get us there, given how carefully he's handled such dangling plot threads so far.
Obviously, the big question now is why Uriel and Eimin have returned at this exact moment. Is it all part of Kang's plan or are they acting on their own? It seems like a good time for Kang to send them to the present, if the goal was to stop Genocide from gaining Apocalypse's powers. But, where do we go from here? I can't wait to get that answer!
Scarlet Spider #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Yay, we're finally back!
After the Other business, this issue is a comparatively light-hearted romp that accentuates what makes this series so great (when it is great), namely the characters. Yost displays such a strong command over their individual voices, like Kaine's impressive commitment to being a grumpy old man or Aracely's excited narrative of everything around her. But, he also really excels at portraying their relationships with each other, like Donald telling Kaine that he can resume being moody tomorrow or Wally asking Aracely how she can eat so much.
More than anything, though, I loved Yost's ham-fisted use of a drunk and heart-broken Armadillo as the vehicle for Kaine realizing that monsters can have happy endings, too. I mean, is it going to be a happy ending? No, of course not (particularly given the last page). But, it does help Kaine experience life more fully than he has so far, making it one more step in him becoming a real boy, if you will. This series is at its best when it plays to Kaine's inner hope that he can live a normal life (instead of wallowing in his nagging fear that he can't). This issue is a great example of that and I'm excited to see where Kaine's relationship with Annabelle brings us on that journey. I just hope that we keep on getting more like it.
But, of course, Yost doesn't let everything be all happy. When are the Kravens going to attack? Who's this "she" whose return Madame Web warns Kaine in a letter will result in everyone dying? Did Annabelle burn said letter because she wanted Kaine to stay or for more nefarious reasons? I mean, I want Kaine to be happy; I don't want him to be too happy.
(Whew.) Seriously, I was worried about this series there for a few issues, but I'm glad we found our footing again. Great stuff.
After the Other business, this issue is a comparatively light-hearted romp that accentuates what makes this series so great (when it is great), namely the characters. Yost displays such a strong command over their individual voices, like Kaine's impressive commitment to being a grumpy old man or Aracely's excited narrative of everything around her. But, he also really excels at portraying their relationships with each other, like Donald telling Kaine that he can resume being moody tomorrow or Wally asking Aracely how she can eat so much.
More than anything, though, I loved Yost's ham-fisted use of a drunk and heart-broken Armadillo as the vehicle for Kaine realizing that monsters can have happy endings, too. I mean, is it going to be a happy ending? No, of course not (particularly given the last page). But, it does help Kaine experience life more fully than he has so far, making it one more step in him becoming a real boy, if you will. This series is at its best when it plays to Kaine's inner hope that he can live a normal life (instead of wallowing in his nagging fear that he can't). This issue is a great example of that and I'm excited to see where Kaine's relationship with Annabelle brings us on that journey. I just hope that we keep on getting more like it.
But, of course, Yost doesn't let everything be all happy. When are the Kravens going to attack? Who's this "she" whose return Madame Web warns Kaine in a letter will result in everyone dying? Did Annabelle burn said letter because she wanted Kaine to stay or for more nefarious reasons? I mean, I want Kaine to be happy; I don't want him to be too happy.
(Whew.) Seriously, I was worried about this series there for a few issues, but I'm glad we found our footing again. Great stuff.
Thursday, May 2, 2013
Superior Spider-Man #9 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Overall, I liked this issue. No, really. Stegman takes the ball that Slott hands him and really runs with it, reminding of me of the beautiful artwork that Marcos Martin delivered for our last tour of Peter's subconscious, in "Amazing Spider-Man" #655. I thought Stegman did an amazing job with the sequence that begins the tour, with Peter standing on a deserted street, misspelled landmarks of his life collapsing around him. It really sets the stage for where the rest of the issue goes.
Moreover, the fight between Peter and Otto is a real tour de force, with Slott really exploring how both characters see themselves and Spider-Man. Pete calls upon his family and friends as his representatives of his strength to fight back Otto, but Otto brilliantly hurls Peter's enemies at him as representatives of his failures. (That scene with snippets of Peter's enemies appearing in boxes was unbelievably cool.) But, it's the moment where they both peel back their "masks," revealing their costumes under their faces, that everything is suddenly on the line. Slott really conveys the sense that it's no longer a game, the two of them moving around chess pieces on a psychological board. It's the final moment.
However, I'm not really thrilled with how that moment happens.
Ultimately, my problem with that moment is that Slott again does two things that annoyed me about "Amazing Spider-Man" #700 in the first place. First, he sullies Peter by having him do something that he views as irreparably breaking his own moral code. In "Amazing Spider-Man" #700, Slott has Peter decide to kill Dr. Octopus, declaring that he would never again be able to be Spider-Man (even if he somehow survived) because he had crossed that line. Here, Slott has Peter admit that he was trying to prevent Otto from operating on the girl so that he wouldn't get his hands on the neurolitic scanner and discover Peter's presence. To be honest, in both situations, Peter faced a real existential threat and I think his actions can be morally justified by arguing that they were for the greater good. Killing a guy who just tried to destroy the world (and could use the good offices of Spider-Man to engage in even more outrageous acts of mass destruction) and delaying surgery for a girl in order to regain control over his own body are both steps that can make sense when you view how dangerous the alternative outcomes would be. Slott argues that Peter doesn't view them as justifiable and I get that. But, similar to a problem I actually had with issue #655, I think Spidey's authors often view him as way too adolescent in his moral approach. After having spent years of his life as Spider-Man, Peter knows that these sorts of decisions aren't as black-and-white as his authors occasionally portray him as seeing it. I'm not saying that Peter should go all Punisher and view the ends as always justifying the means, but I think Peter is capable of occasionally seeing the ends justifying the means in certain situations. By denying him that moral complexity, his authors often make him a much more one-dimensional character than he needs to be.
Second, this moral failing leaves Peter once again "dying" broken and alone. In fact, issue #700 at least had him die somewhat less depressingly, with Otto pledging to uphold Peter's memories by becoming a hero. But, with Peter entirely wiped from Otto's mind, it stands to reason that this pledge could be in jeopardy, something that Peter would know as he faded into oblivion. Moreover, Slott implies that Otto is actually right (and not delusional) that Peter no longer deserves to be Spider-Man, that somehow his attempt to prevent Otto from operating on the girl invalidated his previous lifetime of doing good. We're left with Peter questioning whether he's worthy as his life ends and, if we are really to believe that Peter is gone, it's an awful way for his story to end.
But, of course, he's not. The real question, now that this transition phase has come to an end, is where do we go from here. To be honest, Slott now confronts the same problem that the editors of the Clone Saga faced, namely Otto now has to operate as Peter without knowing anything about Peter. It's ultimately what kept the editors of the Clone Sage from allowing Ben Reilly to become Spider-Man (or, more to the point, Peter Parker), since it would be difficult to explain why he didn't have information about his "missing years." But, it also opens the back door, namely Carlie. On the face of it, it feels like Peter is now lost to us, but Slott wouldn't have introduced the Carlie sub-plot if that were true. With Otto more likely to act like Otto and less like Peter now that he's wiped Peter's memory, it stands to reason that Carlie is going to have an easier time convincing people that he's not really Peter.
At this stage, we've set the stage for the story I wanted from the start, Otto unrestricted. Although I'm not thrilled how we got here, I'm a lot more interested in where we go from here.
Moreover, the fight between Peter and Otto is a real tour de force, with Slott really exploring how both characters see themselves and Spider-Man. Pete calls upon his family and friends as his representatives of his strength to fight back Otto, but Otto brilliantly hurls Peter's enemies at him as representatives of his failures. (That scene with snippets of Peter's enemies appearing in boxes was unbelievably cool.) But, it's the moment where they both peel back their "masks," revealing their costumes under their faces, that everything is suddenly on the line. Slott really conveys the sense that it's no longer a game, the two of them moving around chess pieces on a psychological board. It's the final moment.
However, I'm not really thrilled with how that moment happens.
Ultimately, my problem with that moment is that Slott again does two things that annoyed me about "Amazing Spider-Man" #700 in the first place. First, he sullies Peter by having him do something that he views as irreparably breaking his own moral code. In "Amazing Spider-Man" #700, Slott has Peter decide to kill Dr. Octopus, declaring that he would never again be able to be Spider-Man (even if he somehow survived) because he had crossed that line. Here, Slott has Peter admit that he was trying to prevent Otto from operating on the girl so that he wouldn't get his hands on the neurolitic scanner and discover Peter's presence. To be honest, in both situations, Peter faced a real existential threat and I think his actions can be morally justified by arguing that they were for the greater good. Killing a guy who just tried to destroy the world (and could use the good offices of Spider-Man to engage in even more outrageous acts of mass destruction) and delaying surgery for a girl in order to regain control over his own body are both steps that can make sense when you view how dangerous the alternative outcomes would be. Slott argues that Peter doesn't view them as justifiable and I get that. But, similar to a problem I actually had with issue #655, I think Spidey's authors often view him as way too adolescent in his moral approach. After having spent years of his life as Spider-Man, Peter knows that these sorts of decisions aren't as black-and-white as his authors occasionally portray him as seeing it. I'm not saying that Peter should go all Punisher and view the ends as always justifying the means, but I think Peter is capable of occasionally seeing the ends justifying the means in certain situations. By denying him that moral complexity, his authors often make him a much more one-dimensional character than he needs to be.
Second, this moral failing leaves Peter once again "dying" broken and alone. In fact, issue #700 at least had him die somewhat less depressingly, with Otto pledging to uphold Peter's memories by becoming a hero. But, with Peter entirely wiped from Otto's mind, it stands to reason that this pledge could be in jeopardy, something that Peter would know as he faded into oblivion. Moreover, Slott implies that Otto is actually right (and not delusional) that Peter no longer deserves to be Spider-Man, that somehow his attempt to prevent Otto from operating on the girl invalidated his previous lifetime of doing good. We're left with Peter questioning whether he's worthy as his life ends and, if we are really to believe that Peter is gone, it's an awful way for his story to end.
But, of course, he's not. The real question, now that this transition phase has come to an end, is where do we go from here. To be honest, Slott now confronts the same problem that the editors of the Clone Saga faced, namely Otto now has to operate as Peter without knowing anything about Peter. It's ultimately what kept the editors of the Clone Sage from allowing Ben Reilly to become Spider-Man (or, more to the point, Peter Parker), since it would be difficult to explain why he didn't have information about his "missing years." But, it also opens the back door, namely Carlie. On the face of it, it feels like Peter is now lost to us, but Slott wouldn't have introduced the Carlie sub-plot if that were true. With Otto more likely to act like Otto and less like Peter now that he's wiped Peter's memory, it stands to reason that Carlie is going to have an easier time convincing people that he's not really Peter.
At this stage, we've set the stage for the story I wanted from the start, Otto unrestricted. Although I'm not thrilled how we got here, I'm a lot more interested in where we go from here.
New Avengers #5 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Honestly, I think I'm done here. Hickman tries to advance the story, but I'm still not really sure what he wants me to think. Some god was born and, as such, the multiverse started to die? Something like that? I honestly can't say I care all that much, so this one is gone, unfortunately.
Tuesday, April 30, 2013
Red Hood and the Outlaws #19 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Honestly, I'm not sure what I think about this issue. Something clearly happens in "Batman and Red Hood" #20 to make Jason lament his dark past, implying that it serves as some sort of stumbling block to his reconciliation with Bruce (if not for Bruce, then for Jason). As such, he asks S'Aru to take away every memory that the darkness touches and, not surprisingly, given that it's Jason, S'Aru is forced to take all his memories. If Tynion is using this story as a way for Jason to truly come to grips with his dark past so that he can become a hero again, then I'm all for it. (Also, when I say "hero," I still want him to be Jason. I still want him to essentially have a "no questions asked" approach with Bruce. I don't suddenly want him to become Dick.) But, if it's just another way of delaying his return to the Bat-family by having him wallow in his troubled history, then I really just want it done.
Nightwing #19 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Honestly? This issue was difficult to take seriously, since it felt like the hundredth time that this series has changed its M.O. It's hard to even remember how many different approaches that we've had over the last 20 issues: first, we had Dick setting down roots in Gotham after leaving Bludhaven, then we had him traveling around the United States with Haly's Circus, then we had him installing Haly's Circus as a permanent fixture on Amusement Mile. Now, we've moved to Chicago, at least for a few weeks. I'll make sure not to get attached to Mike.
Trying to move past my annoyance over the constant upheaval (heh) of this series, Higgins does an OK job establishing our new reality in this issue. At the very least, Dick has a clear sense of purpose: he wants to find Tony Zucco and he wants to find him bad. My main criticism here is that Higgins throws a lot of characters at us at once. I want to say that he makes tracking down Zucco a little too easy with the introduction of the "Dealer" character, but, given how many other series rely on a similar character to provide the hero with information, I can't fault him for it too much. Plus, he actually makes the Dealer into something of a character, with the whole card shtick. I was less impressed with the crazy woman in the bar, simply because she seemed to be a completely unnecessary distraction. I think we would've been better served by him spending more time on the Dealer or on Dick adjusting to Chicago. But, I'll also say that I find the Prankster intriguing; I love how s/he has the child trafficker burn his money to stay alive. Higgins uses that moment to seemingly install the Prankster as an anti-hero, though it's still unclear why s/he would tip off the cops that Nightwing was in town.
Speaking of the Chicago authorities, Higgins introduces two mysteries related to them here. The first is the fact that something clearly happened in Chicago to turn the city against masked vigilantes. The second is the fact that Tony Zucco happens to be the Mayor's driver. I'm guessing that we're going to revisit both mysteries soon.
So, overall, it was a decent opening to Dick's time in Chicago, even if it was a bit of a mixed bag. I'd like to think that it was a permanent shift and allow myself to get accustomed to the setting, but, again, given this series, I assume that he'll be rooming with Flash Thompson in Philly by the end of the year. But, if Higgins actually manages to stay with this approach for, like, six whole issues, I could see myself really enjoying it.
Trying to move past my annoyance over the constant upheaval (heh) of this series, Higgins does an OK job establishing our new reality in this issue. At the very least, Dick has a clear sense of purpose: he wants to find Tony Zucco and he wants to find him bad. My main criticism here is that Higgins throws a lot of characters at us at once. I want to say that he makes tracking down Zucco a little too easy with the introduction of the "Dealer" character, but, given how many other series rely on a similar character to provide the hero with information, I can't fault him for it too much. Plus, he actually makes the Dealer into something of a character, with the whole card shtick. I was less impressed with the crazy woman in the bar, simply because she seemed to be a completely unnecessary distraction. I think we would've been better served by him spending more time on the Dealer or on Dick adjusting to Chicago. But, I'll also say that I find the Prankster intriguing; I love how s/he has the child trafficker burn his money to stay alive. Higgins uses that moment to seemingly install the Prankster as an anti-hero, though it's still unclear why s/he would tip off the cops that Nightwing was in town.
Speaking of the Chicago authorities, Higgins introduces two mysteries related to them here. The first is the fact that something clearly happened in Chicago to turn the city against masked vigilantes. The second is the fact that Tony Zucco happens to be the Mayor's driver. I'm guessing that we're going to revisit both mysteries soon.
So, overall, it was a decent opening to Dick's time in Chicago, even if it was a bit of a mixed bag. I'd like to think that it was a permanent shift and allow myself to get accustomed to the setting, but, again, given this series, I assume that he'll be rooming with Flash Thompson in Philly by the end of the year. But, if Higgins actually manages to stay with this approach for, like, six whole issues, I could see myself really enjoying it.
Justice League #19 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
After twenty issues, I have to say that one thing that still bothers me about Johns' writing is that every issue seems to have a moment where the characters do something that doesn't really make sense. I mean, don't get me wrong, Johns is great at the small moments of characterization; Firestorm's one-sided conversation in this issue is a great testament to that. But, we always seem to have a moment where I'm left scratching my head.
In this issue, I don't understand why Superman and Wonder Woman decided to invade Kahndaq to rescue the prisoners taken by the Sons of Adam terrorist group. After all, Superman tells Wonder Woman, after they've freed the hostages, that he made the decision long ago to use his powers "to inspire, not interfere." But, he did interfere. I mean, he interfered in a way that resulted in Kahndaq threatening to attack U.S. interests. In terms of interfering, he chose a really big way to do it. But, Superman never really answers the question why here. In fact, Johns seems to be implying that Clark is only there because Diana wanted him to help her. Diana takes a stronger position on her right to interfere to make the world a better place and in so doing proving Bruce's point that people are going to be scared about what the two most powerful people on Earth could do when it's revealed that they're dating. Given how portentous this event is, you'd think Johns would've spent a little more time explaining why Clark and Diana decided to initiate it. Plus, why those hostages? Why not any number of other people who needed help elsewhere in the world?
The answer seems to be so that Johns could get them in Kahndaq, since, as we learn in the back-up story, it was the home of Black Adam in ancient times. Given that Billy's confrontation with Adam is reaching a head, it seems like we're close to the moment where these two stories are going to merge. Although that moment seems long overdue, I still expected Johns to bring it together in a more carefully constructed way, not just having Clark and Diana go rogue in a country to which Black Adam is connected. (Speaking of the back-up story, I thought Johns did a great job having Billy project his fears onto Black Adam. Billy calls Adam a kid "lashing out to hurt people" "before they can hurt [him]," who doesn't "trust anyone -- because people have always taken advantage of [him] for it," and who's angry "because [he's] trying to hid how scared [he] really is." Sound familiar?)
We also have the mysterious stranger who invaded the Batcave for kryptonite and the arrival of Despero in the mix. I'm still enjoying this series, but I just wish Johns would spend a little bit more time making the characters feel a little less like chess pieces that he's obviously moving around the board.
In this issue, I don't understand why Superman and Wonder Woman decided to invade Kahndaq to rescue the prisoners taken by the Sons of Adam terrorist group. After all, Superman tells Wonder Woman, after they've freed the hostages, that he made the decision long ago to use his powers "to inspire, not interfere." But, he did interfere. I mean, he interfered in a way that resulted in Kahndaq threatening to attack U.S. interests. In terms of interfering, he chose a really big way to do it. But, Superman never really answers the question why here. In fact, Johns seems to be implying that Clark is only there because Diana wanted him to help her. Diana takes a stronger position on her right to interfere to make the world a better place and in so doing proving Bruce's point that people are going to be scared about what the two most powerful people on Earth could do when it's revealed that they're dating. Given how portentous this event is, you'd think Johns would've spent a little more time explaining why Clark and Diana decided to initiate it. Plus, why those hostages? Why not any number of other people who needed help elsewhere in the world?
The answer seems to be so that Johns could get them in Kahndaq, since, as we learn in the back-up story, it was the home of Black Adam in ancient times. Given that Billy's confrontation with Adam is reaching a head, it seems like we're close to the moment where these two stories are going to merge. Although that moment seems long overdue, I still expected Johns to bring it together in a more carefully constructed way, not just having Clark and Diana go rogue in a country to which Black Adam is connected. (Speaking of the back-up story, I thought Johns did a great job having Billy project his fears onto Black Adam. Billy calls Adam a kid "lashing out to hurt people" "before they can hurt [him]," who doesn't "trust anyone -- because people have always taken advantage of [him] for it," and who's angry "because [he's] trying to hid how scared [he] really is." Sound familiar?)
We also have the mysterious stranger who invaded the Batcave for kryptonite and the arrival of Despero in the mix. I'm still enjoying this series, but I just wish Johns would spend a little bit more time making the characters feel a little less like chess pieces that he's obviously moving around the board.
X-Factor #254 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Although I can't say that it's my favorite issue of "X-Factor," David does a good job here in focusing more on the characters and less on the Hell on Earth War. He reminds us that Tier is just a scared kid by having him confess to Rahne that he doesn't want to be forced to kill the Hell Lords. He also reminds us that X-Factor is the good guys by having them agree to help Tier find another way to end the war. OK, Lorna isn't too thrilled with that plan, but, honesty, you can't really blame her, given that she suddenly finds herself in a leadership role that she didn't ask to have (and a war between Hell Lords that she has to stop). I still can't say that I'm really digging this arc, but at least this issue showed us some of the group dynamics (and internal fighting) that makes this series what it is.
Venom #34 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)`
OK, sure, it's not too hard to write a great symbiote-vs.-symbiote story, but I have to give credit to Bunn all the same, because I really enjoyed this issue. Bunn made it pretty damn clear that Flash was getting his ass handed to him and his "Hail Mary" play at the end showed the kind of tactical decision that a former combat veteran like Flash should make but, frankly, often hasn't. (For a moment, I was worried that he was going to play dead...again.) Bunn built the tension to that final moment really well, in no small part thanks to Shalvey, who really goes to town here in showing just how much more powerful Toxin is than Venom. Moreover, Bunn's makes it clear in this issue that Venom is still going to be spending the next few issues cleaning up the U-Foes' mess, since the Symbiote Slayers seem to be from the same batch of experiments as the Figure was. It's an approach that at least explains why this number of crazies have suddenly flooded Philly's streets. It can't last forever, but, for now, at least, it's working. Good stuff.
Monday, April 29, 2013
Superior Spider-Man #8 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
So, here we go. It looks like next issue Slott is going to lay all his cards on the table and show if he really intends to take Peter Parker from us. For once, I'm actually intrigued by the answer.
On the plus side, Slott cleverly pulls together a number of plot threads from previous issues to bring us to this moment. Last issue's conflict with Cardiac over the neurolitic scanner leads to this issue's confrontation with the Avengers, where Otto learns that he has a minor anomaly in his brain pattern. That revelation leads to this issue's confrontation with Cardiac over the scanner, where Otto discovers that Ghost-Peter is, in fact, the "minor anomaly." Moreover, Carlie Cooper comes to the conclusion that Spidey isn't Spidey, setting up a race against time for her to act on this revelation. With just one villain and a clear conflict over a specific device, Slott is able to produce a believable series of events that brings us on the cusp of resolving the Ghost-Peter issue and ending the transition phase of this experiment. Given that I honestly don't know which way that this story is going to go, I'm actually excited to see where it does go.
(On a philosophical note, I thought that it was interesting that Otto described Ghost-Peter was "all of Peter's memories[,] taking on a life of their own." Otto seems to be dismissing the idea that Ghost-Peter is actually Peter, preferring instead to think of him as a simulacrum of some sort. But, even if it is "just" Peter's memories taking on a life of their own, isn't that enough to constitute Peter? Are we more than the sum of our memories? I'll have to ask my philosophy professor!)
(On a philosophical note, I thought that it was interesting that Otto described Ghost-Peter was "all of Peter's memories[,] taking on a life of their own." Otto seems to be dismissing the idea that Ghost-Peter is actually Peter, preferring instead to think of him as a simulacrum of some sort. But, even if it is "just" Peter's memories taking on a life of their own, isn't that enough to constitute Peter? Are we more than the sum of our memories? I'll have to ask my philosophy professor!)
On the minus side, I will say that I still find it difficult to deal with Otto's mood swings. In fact, this issue provides possibly the best example of this problem, making me realize just how much it's bothered me. Here, Otto goes to pieces upon realizing that his attempt to destroy the world with his Octavian lenses left the girl at the center of this issue's conflict brain damaged. It's here where I still have issues with this series, because I still don't feel like Slott has given us a clear reason for Otto's change of heart. Is it Peter's memories that make him a better person? Is it his selfish drive to outdo Peter's heroism? Is it both? Without any real clarity on this front, I'm still left rolling my eyes at the idea that Otto suddenly cares about a girl whom he was going to happily kill only a few issues ago.
But, to end on the plus side, "Ends of the Earth" also provides a good moment here, with the Black Widow relying on the connection that she and Peter developed during that experience to encourage him to talk to her as he slides into a darker M.O. It's a great moment of character work on Slott's part and allows the reader to feel like the Avengers aren't simply washing their hands of the conundrum of a more brutal Spidey once they learned that he wasn't a Skrull.
So, in the short run, I'm excited to see where we're going, but, in the long run, if Otto is going to stay in control of Peter's body, I think Slott still has work to do in clarifying Otto's goals and motivations so that we're not constantly wondering if bad Otto or good Otto is in charge.
Nova #3 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Meh.
My first problem with this issue is that Loeb relies on a pretty formulaic approach to Sam as he adjust to his newly discovered powers. "I just went to the Moon!" "I think I'm missing a math test!" On some level, it's a necessary step, Sam adjusting to his new circumstances and wondering how they're going to complicate his daily life. But, Loeb doesn't really put too much effort into doing anything unique with this story, giving us the same "teenager gains powers" story that we've all read a hundred times since "Amazing Fantasy" #15.
I could live with that, seeing it as a temporary bump in the road as we start to gather speed, but I can't say that I'm thrilled with other parts. We still don't know how Sam's father became a member of the Nova Corps and why no one seemed to be aware that he had been one (since everyone thought that Richard Rider was the first human Nova). We also don't know why he wasn't called to help the Nova Corps when it was destroyed (the first time), though I assume we're going to discover that he was off-line or something. In fact, we still don't know what happened to him or why he was suddenly called when he was, though Rocket Raccoon acknowledging that whatever happened to him was his fault makes you think that he'd be a little less hard on the kid. Finally, we don't seem to be getting to the point where we eventually need to be, namely, "Marvel Point One" #1, when Sam warns everyone about the coming of the Phoenix Force. Instead, we spend time sending Sam against the Chitauri, which seems like an unnecessary movie distraction given that "Avengers 2" doesn't hit theaters until 2015.
Essentially, I could deal with weak characterization or a weak plot, but we seem to be getting both here. Fingers crossed that Loeb is able to move past this awkward phase and start telling some better stories.
My first problem with this issue is that Loeb relies on a pretty formulaic approach to Sam as he adjust to his newly discovered powers. "I just went to the Moon!" "I think I'm missing a math test!" On some level, it's a necessary step, Sam adjusting to his new circumstances and wondering how they're going to complicate his daily life. But, Loeb doesn't really put too much effort into doing anything unique with this story, giving us the same "teenager gains powers" story that we've all read a hundred times since "Amazing Fantasy" #15.
I could live with that, seeing it as a temporary bump in the road as we start to gather speed, but I can't say that I'm thrilled with other parts. We still don't know how Sam's father became a member of the Nova Corps and why no one seemed to be aware that he had been one (since everyone thought that Richard Rider was the first human Nova). We also don't know why he wasn't called to help the Nova Corps when it was destroyed (the first time), though I assume we're going to discover that he was off-line or something. In fact, we still don't know what happened to him or why he was suddenly called when he was, though Rocket Raccoon acknowledging that whatever happened to him was his fault makes you think that he'd be a little less hard on the kid. Finally, we don't seem to be getting to the point where we eventually need to be, namely, "Marvel Point One" #1, when Sam warns everyone about the coming of the Phoenix Force. Instead, we spend time sending Sam against the Chitauri, which seems like an unnecessary movie distraction given that "Avengers 2" doesn't hit theaters until 2015.
Essentially, I could deal with weak characterization or a weak plot, but we seem to be getting both here. Fingers crossed that Loeb is able to move past this awkward phase and start telling some better stories.
Sunday, April 28, 2013
Captain Marvel #12 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Damn, this issue was good. DeConnick and Sebela really bring everything together here, from the mysterious villain to the brain tumors to Helen Cobb. It adds to the ongoing sense that this series conveys that you're really immersed in Carol's life, something that makes you all the more nervous about where it's heading.
First, the authors did a great job of splicing the battle between Carol and Deathbird with the conversation between the two doctors. Usually, this sort of back-and-forth approach winds up stalling the momentum of the story, as the less energetic tale drags down the other one. However, here, the doctors' conversation about Carol's affliction heightens the tension of her battle with Deathbird, making it clear that the stakes are higher than Carol knows. Moreover, the battle itself is thrilling, with Cap's sky-cycle becoming almost a third character in their dance. Andrade does a great job with these scenes, keeping you guessing how each character will outmaneuver her equally skilled opponent. By the time you reach the end of the issue, you're on the edge of your seat.
At this point, I'm not entirely sure how whatever Yon-Rogg did to manipulate Helen Cobb into thinking that she took a ride with a former beau would result in her smelling like old gasoline, but the authors seem to be holding out the possibility that Yon-Rogg is manipulating reality somehow. Moreover, we don't know why Yon-Rogg chose Deathbird to attack Carol, unless it was just that they were pretty evenly matched. But, the authors don't seem to be rushing the story, so I'm pretty confident that we'll get those answers. At this stage, Yon-Rogg seems to be draining Carol's powers to survive, which seems, you know, bad. The upcoming involvement of the Avengers certainly raises the stakes in this story and I'm excited to see what happens when all Hell breaks loose.
First, the authors did a great job of splicing the battle between Carol and Deathbird with the conversation between the two doctors. Usually, this sort of back-and-forth approach winds up stalling the momentum of the story, as the less energetic tale drags down the other one. However, here, the doctors' conversation about Carol's affliction heightens the tension of her battle with Deathbird, making it clear that the stakes are higher than Carol knows. Moreover, the battle itself is thrilling, with Cap's sky-cycle becoming almost a third character in their dance. Andrade does a great job with these scenes, keeping you guessing how each character will outmaneuver her equally skilled opponent. By the time you reach the end of the issue, you're on the edge of your seat.
At this point, I'm not entirely sure how whatever Yon-Rogg did to manipulate Helen Cobb into thinking that she took a ride with a former beau would result in her smelling like old gasoline, but the authors seem to be holding out the possibility that Yon-Rogg is manipulating reality somehow. Moreover, we don't know why Yon-Rogg chose Deathbird to attack Carol, unless it was just that they were pretty evenly matched. But, the authors don't seem to be rushing the story, so I'm pretty confident that we'll get those answers. At this stage, Yon-Rogg seems to be draining Carol's powers to survive, which seems, you know, bad. The upcoming involvement of the Avengers certainly raises the stakes in this story and I'm excited to see what happens when all Hell breaks loose.
Captain America #6 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Honestly, this issue was hard to read. Remender gives us a totally broken Steve Rogers here, a man willing to commit murder to save his son from a lifetime of Zola worship. The fact that he crosses that line and may have done so for nothing makes it almost too much to bear.
Before getting to the good parts, I will say that this issue isn't perfect. First, it was the second one in a row where the events of the previous issue were difficult to recall. I felt like I had missed an issue, a familiar feeling when I'm reading stories that are expressly written for the inevitable trade, as this one is starting to feel like it is. I didn't remember Zola's forces eliminating the Phrox, as they seemed to have done here (or, at least, as Ian seems to think they have done) and I was bewildered by Zola's claim that he was in love with Ian's mother, Mary. The only human woman I remember in this series other than Jet or Sharon is the woman who Zola kept in a box and tried to turn into a dog. I mean, sure, I could buy that Zola would possibly express his love that way, but I'm guessing that Remender has something else up his sleeve here. But, it would've been nice to have seen an example of Zola's devotion to "Mary" before him professing it to Ian, since it's hard to judge if Zola's just trying to pull a fast one on him or really believes it.
But, for its faults, this issue is still a decent installment in this story. As I mentioned in the first paragraph, Remender builds the tension here as we watch Steve unravel. He pulls in flashback sequences of previous issues to show us Steve's motivation, not to abandon Ian in a world surrounded by enemies as his father did to him. He also beautifully depicts Jet's crisis of faith as she finds herself confused by Steve's nobility. Speaking of beautiful, JR JR is also on fire here: I was particularly impressed by the creepily religious, Kirby-inspired Zola painting that took up a full page. It conveyed the totality of Zola's control of Dimension Z, reminding you just why Steve has been driven to the place where he now finds himself. Along those lines, the revelation that Zola has spent all this time trying to perfect a process to turn the Phrox into Steve-cloned Super-Soldiers so that he can invade Earth also upped the diabolical stakes significantly.
If we're going to stay in Dimension Z much longer, it would be nice for Steve to get a win at some point. As I said in the beginning, this issue was hard to read and, given that Steve is going to fight Ian next issue, I'm guessing that the next one isn't going to be a walk in the park. But, lest we become completely inured to Steve's misery to the point that it stops having meaning, we need something to give him hope, even if it's just going eventually to be taken from him. Without that hope, it's hard to differentiate between shades of black.
Before getting to the good parts, I will say that this issue isn't perfect. First, it was the second one in a row where the events of the previous issue were difficult to recall. I felt like I had missed an issue, a familiar feeling when I'm reading stories that are expressly written for the inevitable trade, as this one is starting to feel like it is. I didn't remember Zola's forces eliminating the Phrox, as they seemed to have done here (or, at least, as Ian seems to think they have done) and I was bewildered by Zola's claim that he was in love with Ian's mother, Mary. The only human woman I remember in this series other than Jet or Sharon is the woman who Zola kept in a box and tried to turn into a dog. I mean, sure, I could buy that Zola would possibly express his love that way, but I'm guessing that Remender has something else up his sleeve here. But, it would've been nice to have seen an example of Zola's devotion to "Mary" before him professing it to Ian, since it's hard to judge if Zola's just trying to pull a fast one on him or really believes it.
But, for its faults, this issue is still a decent installment in this story. As I mentioned in the first paragraph, Remender builds the tension here as we watch Steve unravel. He pulls in flashback sequences of previous issues to show us Steve's motivation, not to abandon Ian in a world surrounded by enemies as his father did to him. He also beautifully depicts Jet's crisis of faith as she finds herself confused by Steve's nobility. Speaking of beautiful, JR JR is also on fire here: I was particularly impressed by the creepily religious, Kirby-inspired Zola painting that took up a full page. It conveyed the totality of Zola's control of Dimension Z, reminding you just why Steve has been driven to the place where he now finds himself. Along those lines, the revelation that Zola has spent all this time trying to perfect a process to turn the Phrox into Steve-cloned Super-Soldiers so that he can invade Earth also upped the diabolical stakes significantly.
If we're going to stay in Dimension Z much longer, it would be nice for Steve to get a win at some point. As I said in the beginning, this issue was hard to read and, given that Steve is going to fight Ian next issue, I'm guessing that the next one isn't going to be a walk in the park. But, lest we become completely inured to Steve's misery to the point that it stops having meaning, we need something to give him hope, even if it's just going eventually to be taken from him. Without that hope, it's hard to differentiate between shades of black.
Cable and X-Force #7 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I'm not entirely sure why Scott appears in this issue, other than Hopeless' need to distract Cable so that he can't help Domino and Boom-Boom as the mission start to go off the rails. I also can't remember how he learned where Cable et al. were last issue, but the fact that he found them makes you wonder how good of a job Cable's doing cover their tracks. Moreover, he's apparently there to help, but doesn't really do much of anything, allowing Cable to go by himself after the insane alien who's taken Domino and Boom-Boom hostage. Again, it's an odd appearance.
Moreover, with the alien off the planet, the main drama driving this arc appears to have passed, now that the alien is off Earth. Cable just has to round up his team and they can move onto the next crisis. It's hard to be too excited about the oncoming slugfest, since we all pretty much know how it's going to go down.
The best part of the issue is Hopeless' focus on Colossus and Domino's "relationship." Hopeless appears to be using Domino as a way to redeem Pete, which could work so long as she doesn't become some love-lorn schoolgirl. It's definitely better than Nemesis' awful banter with Forge.
Moreover, with the alien off the planet, the main drama driving this arc appears to have passed, now that the alien is off Earth. Cable just has to round up his team and they can move onto the next crisis. It's hard to be too excited about the oncoming slugfest, since we all pretty much know how it's going to go down.
The best part of the issue is Hopeless' focus on Colossus and Domino's "relationship." Hopeless appears to be using Domino as a way to redeem Pete, which could work so long as she doesn't become some love-lorn schoolgirl. It's definitely better than Nemesis' awful banter with Forge.
Wolverine and the X-Men #27.AU (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue gives a little more insight into Logan and Sue's journey from Antarctica to New York to stop Hank Pym from creating Ultron, as seen in "Age of Ultron" #6. It's reminiscent of "Wolverine and the X-Men" #11, where we got similar insight into Logan and Hope's journey from Antarctica to the Moon (as depicted in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4). Unfortunately, it's not quite as good as that issue. Logan randomly gets all humanitarian, deciding to rescue a Brood hatchling but unwittingly helping the Brood adapt to his powers. Most bizarrely, Sue decides to warn Reed that S.H.I.E.L.D. is watching him, but, curiously, neglects to warn him about Ultron. After all, if she and Logan fail, wouldn't it make sense to let past Reed know what Hank's doing and why it's important to stop him? Right there, you have a great example of the problem with time-travel stories, since it's usually hard to argue that the actions that the characters take are the ones that make the most sense. Man, this event is going downhill quickly.
Age of Ultron #6 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is a complicated one. On one hand, it's seriously ballsy, but, on the other hand, it was somewhat predictable and occasionally sloppy.
Bendis takes the interesting step of refocusing the past storyline on just Wolverine and Sue Storm. (Unfortunately, he never explains where the other characters who traveled into the past with them went or why a young Nick Fury just conveniently arrived at his Savage Land base when Logan and Sue desperately needed a vehicle.) Bendis uses this narrowed focus to have Logan and Sue argue the ethical dilemma at the core of the mission, weighing the life of Hank Pym against the lives of Ultron's victims. (On a continuity point, Sue mentions that Ultron killed her children, but, per "Fantastic Four" #5 AU, I thought they were just stranded in space. Did she just forget that she left them there?) However, the predictability part comes into play with the end result; it seemed pretty unlikely that Sue would stop Logan from killing Hank with all those lives on the line. (Continuing the parenthetical notations of sloppiness, one of my problems with this issue was the fight scene itself, since Bendis has Logan announce his presence to Hank. Although I get that it sets up Sue's moral dilemma later in the issue, it seems unlikely that Logan would've taken that chance. It would've been better to have an alarm sound or something.)
With Hank now dead and the future team defeated, it appears that we're going to be entering the Marvel Universe's version of the DCnU. (That's the ballsy part.) Assuming that Marvel isn't actually taking that step, Bendis now has two actions to undo to restore the Marvel Universe we all know. First, he has to unkill Hank Pym and, second, he has to stop Ultron before he invades. My guess is that Logan and Sue will serve the same role that Bishop did in "Age of Apocalypse," the institutional memory of the previous reality. Sue seems the most likely candidate for getting the MnU's heroes to undo what's happened, but I'll admit that I'm not sure how excited I am about it. It seems increasingly unlikely that anything from this event is going to persist after it concludes, sapping some of the energy from the book. I mean, I'm not saying that should be the measure of how good the event itself is, given that I am overall enjoying it. But, I'm starting to wonder whether the ending is going to be worth the effort.
Bendis takes the interesting step of refocusing the past storyline on just Wolverine and Sue Storm. (Unfortunately, he never explains where the other characters who traveled into the past with them went or why a young Nick Fury just conveniently arrived at his Savage Land base when Logan and Sue desperately needed a vehicle.) Bendis uses this narrowed focus to have Logan and Sue argue the ethical dilemma at the core of the mission, weighing the life of Hank Pym against the lives of Ultron's victims. (On a continuity point, Sue mentions that Ultron killed her children, but, per "Fantastic Four" #5 AU, I thought they were just stranded in space. Did she just forget that she left them there?) However, the predictability part comes into play with the end result; it seemed pretty unlikely that Sue would stop Logan from killing Hank with all those lives on the line. (Continuing the parenthetical notations of sloppiness, one of my problems with this issue was the fight scene itself, since Bendis has Logan announce his presence to Hank. Although I get that it sets up Sue's moral dilemma later in the issue, it seems unlikely that Logan would've taken that chance. It would've been better to have an alarm sound or something.)
With Hank now dead and the future team defeated, it appears that we're going to be entering the Marvel Universe's version of the DCnU. (That's the ballsy part.) Assuming that Marvel isn't actually taking that step, Bendis now has two actions to undo to restore the Marvel Universe we all know. First, he has to unkill Hank Pym and, second, he has to stop Ultron before he invades. My guess is that Logan and Sue will serve the same role that Bishop did in "Age of Apocalypse," the institutional memory of the previous reality. Sue seems the most likely candidate for getting the MnU's heroes to undo what's happened, but I'll admit that I'm not sure how excited I am about it. It seems increasingly unlikely that anything from this event is going to persist after it concludes, sapping some of the energy from the book. I mean, I'm not saying that should be the measure of how good the event itself is, given that I am overall enjoying it. But, I'm starting to wonder whether the ending is going to be worth the effort.
Saturday, April 27, 2013
Uncanny X-Men #4 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Honestly, I don't have too much to say about this issue, since most of the plot was covered by "All-New X-Men" #10. The revelation that Angel was the other student to defect (besides the Cuckoos) was pretty easy to spot, so this issue didn't really do much to advance the story that Bendis is telling in these two titles. (Moreover, Emma's conversation with the Cuckoos wasn't fascinating enough to make it feel like it added a new twist on the story, particularly since the Cucooks' defection was also pretty predictable.) The best part of this issue is Bendis' work developing the personalities of the New Xavier School's students, since he makes it clear that Scott may see defections of his own soon. Overall, as I mentioned in my review of "All-New X-Men" #10, it's clear that Bendis is bringing the first phase of this brave new world to a close. With the teams now more or less set, I'm intrigued to see where we go from here.
Tuesday, April 23, 2013
Batman and Robin #19 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Frankenstein's monster? First, we're supposed to believe that Bruce has decided that he's going to resurrect Damian and then we're supposed to believe that the only way that he can think of doing so is turning him into Frankenstein's monster? Really? I know I have a love/hate relationship with Tomasi, but, man, this issue definitely falls into the latter category for me.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)