Well, OK, I definitely didn't see that coming.
Johns does much better crafting a believable story in this issue than he did in "Justice League" #16. First, Arthur and Bruce have a normal conversation where they bury the proverbial hatchet, though I still don't think that Arthur needed to apologize for trying to reason with his brother. But, this conversation at least puts aside the "house divided against itself" storyline and allows the pair to focus on trying to locate Superman and Wonder Woman. In so doing, they discover that the King of Atlantis' scepter controls the weird zombie Atlanteans that we've seen lurking on the edges of this conflict since the start. But, most importantly, they also learn that Orm doesn't have it, as the zombies attack the Atlanteans; Vulko does. It's a great reveal, one that makes sense in terms of the story but one that I didn't really see coming. I thought Johns made a wise decision in throwing us off the scent by having Aquaman suggest somewhere in the middle of the issue that Orm might've been behind the attack as a justification to attack the surface world; it really amplified the impact of the surprise that Vulko was behind it. Vulko's motives seem pretty clear (revenge for his exile and Arthur's treatment), though I think Johns at some point needs to show why Vulko chose now to act. Moreover, Johns still has some work to do in explaining Dr. Shin, whose role in this conflict is still unclear. But, at least we get a good sense of why the attack is happening in the first place..
The other main event in this issue is the debut of the Justice League of America and Johns shows enough disfunction there that I think that I can say that I'm actually excited about this one.
All in all, Johns saves the concept here and I'm legitimately intrigued to see how he wraps up this arc.
I cover a lot of different titles, with some particular attention to the previous runs of "Spider-Man 2099" and "Nova." Welcome back, Richard! Until next time, Miguel.
Sunday, February 24, 2013
Justice League #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
First, Orm is hilarious. I totally imagine him having a British accent like some villain from a PBS show. "Mother would be disappointed. I know I am." Burn!
Unfortunately, Orm's wit is about the only thing I liked about the main event in this issue. I still don't understand why Johns portrays the Justice League as so blinded by a need for, well, justice that they're willing to make matters worse. Arthur lays out a pretty reasonable scenario for defusing the conflict and instead they just rush into it. What about the millions of Atlantean soldiers waiting under the tide was unclear? Does Johns want us to believe that they're just this cocky? The good news is that Orm makes pretty quick work of them. The bad news is that I'm pretty sure Johns doesn't want me rooting for Orm. But, I am. Team Atlantis. Take down the surface-dwellers.
However, the big reveal here is that "Throne of Atlantis" appears to be the impetus for the formation of the Justice League of America, as Cyborg activates a list of unvetted reserve members. It's a moment that feels organic, since Cyborg is essentially the only member left standing by this point and he's preparing to be in surgery for the next several hours to get a mechanical lung. We'll see how they do against Orm.
In the back-up story, Johns does a great job of showing how out of his league Billy is here. Black Adam makes quick work of him and Billy retreats, ending the issue crying next to a dumpster. Johns has been so careful in showing us Billy as an isolated, lonely kid that I'm really anticipating his hero's moment, where he gets to save the day and inherit a family. But, we've clearly got several issues before that happens.
Unfortunately, Orm's wit is about the only thing I liked about the main event in this issue. I still don't understand why Johns portrays the Justice League as so blinded by a need for, well, justice that they're willing to make matters worse. Arthur lays out a pretty reasonable scenario for defusing the conflict and instead they just rush into it. What about the millions of Atlantean soldiers waiting under the tide was unclear? Does Johns want us to believe that they're just this cocky? The good news is that Orm makes pretty quick work of them. The bad news is that I'm pretty sure Johns doesn't want me rooting for Orm. But, I am. Team Atlantis. Take down the surface-dwellers.
However, the big reveal here is that "Throne of Atlantis" appears to be the impetus for the formation of the Justice League of America, as Cyborg activates a list of unvetted reserve members. It's a moment that feels organic, since Cyborg is essentially the only member left standing by this point and he's preparing to be in surgery for the next several hours to get a mechanical lung. We'll see how they do against Orm.
In the back-up story, Johns does a great job of showing how out of his league Billy is here. Black Adam makes quick work of him and Billy retreats, ending the issue crying next to a dumpster. Johns has been so careful in showing us Billy as an isolated, lonely kid that I'm really anticipating his hero's moment, where he gets to save the day and inherit a family. But, we've clearly got several issues before that happens.
Saturday, February 23, 2013
Young Avengers #1 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I read this book standing up.
I picked up this issue off my bookshelf and, despite my anal-retentive need to get through my back issues in chronological order, I unwisely made the decision to just peek at the first page. And I love Kate Bishop so I was excited to see her. And I turned the page. And I didn't expect her to be on a spaceship and then I definitely didn't expect that spaceship to be attacked by Skrulls. And then, suddenly, Hulking was giving a terribly moving speech about how Billy has everything he ever wanted and yet Teddy is the one who watched his only parent burn to death in front of him. And then we had Loki. And some girl I didn't recognize. And then Loki seemed to know something about Billy that we don't know. And then Teddy's mom was alive. And then she maybe killed Billy's parents.
And I am totally and completely effing thrilled that these characters are in my life again.
I picked up this issue off my bookshelf and, despite my anal-retentive need to get through my back issues in chronological order, I unwisely made the decision to just peek at the first page. And I love Kate Bishop so I was excited to see her. And I turned the page. And I didn't expect her to be on a spaceship and then I definitely didn't expect that spaceship to be attacked by Skrulls. And then, suddenly, Hulking was giving a terribly moving speech about how Billy has everything he ever wanted and yet Teddy is the one who watched his only parent burn to death in front of him. And then we had Loki. And some girl I didn't recognize. And then Loki seemed to know something about Billy that we don't know. And then Teddy's mom was alive. And then she maybe killed Billy's parents.
And I am totally and completely effing thrilled that these characters are in my life again.
Uncanny Avengers #3 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Remender crafts a beautiful story here, truly embracing the "Uncanny" and "Avengers" sides of this story.
First, I have to say how impressed I was with how well Remender uses the 80's-style omniscient narrator here to amplify the drama and tension of the story. The 00's and 10's have been all about a "Batman"-esque first-person narrator, one that may drive a story but does little to create a mood. But, here, Remender details the terror that the victims of the Red Skull's mob feel, shows the struggle that Captain America experiences in fighting the Red Skull's telepathy, and generally conveys the sense of hysteria that we see seize Manhattan, all through his carefully worded narration boxes. Moreover, John Cassady perfectly matches these narrative cues with great facial expressions, keeping us focused on the people amidst the chaos that could have easily deadened the emotional impact of the story.
Remender also really gets his characters here. For example, he perfectly describes a Logan so enraged by the Red Skull's use of Professor X's brain that he gives himself totally to the animal in him. I also loved his work with Havok and Captain America, showing Havok as completely in charge and unbowed by a mid-controlled Steve's attempts to undermine him. It's such a nice change from how we usually see Alex portrayed.
But, it's the Red Skull who really takes the cake here. Remender has created a Red Skull freed from years of stories and baggage, allowing him to retain the brutal focus that he had during the war. He's totally in command of the situation and the issue. By having people actually die, Remender makes you wonder where we're going next, showing a Red Skull who has broken free of the usual rules and, as such, is more unpredictable now than ever.
Given how incomprehensible "Avengers" and "New Avengers" are, this issue serve as a stark contrast, a classic story done extremely well.
First, I have to say how impressed I was with how well Remender uses the 80's-style omniscient narrator here to amplify the drama and tension of the story. The 00's and 10's have been all about a "Batman"-esque first-person narrator, one that may drive a story but does little to create a mood. But, here, Remender details the terror that the victims of the Red Skull's mob feel, shows the struggle that Captain America experiences in fighting the Red Skull's telepathy, and generally conveys the sense of hysteria that we see seize Manhattan, all through his carefully worded narration boxes. Moreover, John Cassady perfectly matches these narrative cues with great facial expressions, keeping us focused on the people amidst the chaos that could have easily deadened the emotional impact of the story.
Remender also really gets his characters here. For example, he perfectly describes a Logan so enraged by the Red Skull's use of Professor X's brain that he gives himself totally to the animal in him. I also loved his work with Havok and Captain America, showing Havok as completely in charge and unbowed by a mid-controlled Steve's attempts to undermine him. It's such a nice change from how we usually see Alex portrayed.
But, it's the Red Skull who really takes the cake here. Remender has created a Red Skull freed from years of stories and baggage, allowing him to retain the brutal focus that he had during the war. He's totally in command of the situation and the issue. By having people actually die, Remender makes you wonder where we're going next, showing a Red Skull who has broken free of the usual rules and, as such, is more unpredictable now than ever.
Given how incomprehensible "Avengers" and "New Avengers" are, this issue serve as a stark contrast, a classic story done extremely well.
Avengers #3 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue may be the single worst comic book that I have ever read. I have no effing idea what happened here. I can think of no issue that better encapsulates the practice of an author conflating intentional confusion with interesting narrative. As I think I've previously mentioned, I feel like Hickman writes a perfectly normal script and then goes and deletes 30 percent of the words just to make it interesting. It doesn't. It just makes it incomprehinsble.
Moreover, even if you just try to get past the awful dialogue and focus on the main events of this issue, Hickman seems to undermine the whole point of this new series: instead of some expanded Avengers roster rising to an incredible challenge and preventing an alien race from destroying Earth, Captain Universe simply dismisses the alien race with a few words. It's incredibly anti-climatic and seems to disprove Tony's theory that the Avengers need to get bigger; all they really needed was to add Captain Universe. I'm giving this series maybe two more issues, tops, before I'm done.
Moreover, even if you just try to get past the awful dialogue and focus on the main events of this issue, Hickman seems to undermine the whole point of this new series: instead of some expanded Avengers roster rising to an incredible challenge and preventing an alien race from destroying Earth, Captain Universe simply dismisses the alien race with a few words. It's incredibly anti-climatic and seems to disprove Tony's theory that the Avengers need to get bigger; all they really needed was to add Captain Universe. I'm giving this series maybe two more issues, tops, before I'm done.
Friday, February 22, 2013
X-Factor #250 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
In typical Peter David fashion, we get no fewer than four previous plot lines converging in this issue as Darwin, Guido, and Jezebel all return in order to to kill Rahne's son Tier and avert a Hell War. It appears that the beings that emerged from the volano in the Botanical Gardens last issue were Helllords and one of them has to kill Tier to win the aforementioned war, something that Darwin and Jezebel are trying to avoid completely by preemptively killing him. David still has a few questions to answer related to this plot, namely:
1) Why would killing Tier "win" the war for a Helllord? In "X-Factor" #214, a hallucinating Darwin faces down an adult Tier in the Wild West. In that dream (if it was a dream), Tier reveals that he's the Beast who will bring about the Apocalypse. I get that part. But, wouldn't the Helllords sort of want the Apocalypse to happen? Or, will it upset their power, making them want to avert it entirely?
2) Is Jezebel acting independently of her pact with the Isolationist? I'm still really confused about her. We first saw her creating said pact to destroy all mutants, but we've also seen her helping Theresa against the Morrigan and she clearly seems to be trying to do good (at least by her definition of "good") here. I don't need my characters to be black-and-white good guy or bad guy, but I'm really unclear on her motives. Sure, preventing a Hell War doesn't necessarily mean that you don't want to kill all mutants any longer, but she's starting to feel a little deus ex machina-y, the character that David uses when he needs to advance the plot a little more quickly than he would be able to do without her.
But, David doesn't make this issue all about asking and answering questions. He brilliantly uses Tier as our insight into the struggles that we see here, portraying him as a pretty typical 12-year-old boy who's really just looking for stability (as seen by his embrace of Madrox) and who's confused by the adult world around him. I mean, navigating the New York City subway by yourself as a pre-teen without money is just as scary as facing down six Helllords!
I'm excited to see where David goes with this one. Given that it's been building for at least 36 issues, I can only imagine what we're going to see here.
1) Why would killing Tier "win" the war for a Helllord? In "X-Factor" #214, a hallucinating Darwin faces down an adult Tier in the Wild West. In that dream (if it was a dream), Tier reveals that he's the Beast who will bring about the Apocalypse. I get that part. But, wouldn't the Helllords sort of want the Apocalypse to happen? Or, will it upset their power, making them want to avert it entirely?
2) Is Jezebel acting independently of her pact with the Isolationist? I'm still really confused about her. We first saw her creating said pact to destroy all mutants, but we've also seen her helping Theresa against the Morrigan and she clearly seems to be trying to do good (at least by her definition of "good") here. I don't need my characters to be black-and-white good guy or bad guy, but I'm really unclear on her motives. Sure, preventing a Hell War doesn't necessarily mean that you don't want to kill all mutants any longer, but she's starting to feel a little deus ex machina-y, the character that David uses when he needs to advance the plot a little more quickly than he would be able to do without her.
But, David doesn't make this issue all about asking and answering questions. He brilliantly uses Tier as our insight into the struggles that we see here, portraying him as a pretty typical 12-year-old boy who's really just looking for stability (as seen by his embrace of Madrox) and who's confused by the adult world around him. I mean, navigating the New York City subway by yourself as a pre-teen without money is just as scary as facing down six Helllords!
I'm excited to see where David goes with this one. Given that it's been building for at least 36 issues, I can only imagine what we're going to see here.
Venom #30 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Bunn does a good job of showing how crowded things are in Flash right now, given that he's fighting for control with a demon and symbiote. I rolled my eyes at first at the idea that the demon had taken over Flash, but Bunn really has it serve a purpose here, giving it the role of Emma Frost showing Iceman that he could do more than he thought that he could. I mean, controlling lackeys via the symbiote's tentacles? Pretty cool. Bunn also shows Flash's profound loneliness, evident in the fact that he's taken to talking to symbiote-created dummies of Katy and Valkyrie (who act and appear disturbingly similar). Flash specifically makes the point that neither woman stayed much longer than it took to clean up the mess that the U-Foes left, but, at some point, Bunn is going to have to create a stable supporting cast for Flash. Books like "Captain Marvel" and "Hawkeye" excel in no small part because DeConnick and Fraction have done a great job building up the support network around each hero, making you feel a stronger connection to them (and proving the impetus to interesting stories). I get that Flash is a loner, but he's going to need a Frenchie or a Microchip: someone who helps him tactically and, to a lesser extent, emotionally. But, I'm still pretty happy with this series' new direction and can't wait to meet the new Toxin!
Thursday, February 21, 2013
New Avengers #2 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I am really, really trying to give Hickman the benefit of the doubt, but, man, he does not make it easy.
OK, I'll start with the good. He does at least explain the events that occurred last issue and are driving this first arc. The mysterious woman who seemed to destroy a planet actually destroyed it because it was occupying the same time-space as our Earth. She reveals to Reed that Earth is the focal point of a series of ongoing collisions between universes. The premature destruction of one universe has resulted in a chain reaction, pushing one universe after another into one another. In each collision, if one Earth isn't destroyed, both universes die, exacerbating the ongoing chain reactions and shortening the life of the multiverse all the more. I actually sort of get that part. I also get the question that Reed and T'Challa pose at the end, whether this process is an inevitable function of the multiverse's eventual destruction or is someone specifically trying to bring about the end of the multiverse early.
Moreover, I applaud Hickman having the Illuminati decide to use the Infinity Gauntlet. The possibility of doing so during "Avengers vs. X-Men" was mentioned, I believe, only once and it seems absurd to believe that the Illuminati would allow Scott to destroy the world rather than using all the power that they had at their disposal to stop him. Here, Hickman is at least intellectually honest about the Infinity Gauntlet and actually has Cap make the case that they need to use it to avoid having to choose between destroying their Earth or another one. Although it's a little surprising that it's Cap arguing for it (since he was against the Illuminati in the first place), his argument that these sorts of decisions always leave the decision-makers more compromised that they expect to be.
But, I do have problems with this series so far and they are two-fold. The first problem is fairly mundane. Although we learn all about the upcoming "incursion" and how we'll occupy the same space as other Earth for eight hours, Hickman never actually describes how we'll both actually occupy the same space. Why can the two planets be in the same space for either hours without combusting? Why the window? Wouldn't they just immediately combust? If not, wouldn't our universe merge with their universe to create some sort of third universe? But, that didn't happen last issue, when we did actually go through an incursion with another universe.
But, more importantly, I feel like this whole story has a certain eye-roll factor. I mean, it's not even that the possibility that the Illuminati could fail and the multiverse winds up destroyed could be on the table. (Of course, that, in and of itself, would have a high eye-roll factor.) It's more that I'm not sure if we're going to get an interesting story from it. As it stands now, we've just gotten a lot of male posturing and it seems like we're just going to continue to get male posturing. I anticipate a lot of 'But, Steve!" and "But, Tony!" arguments while they race to save the multiverse that we all now that they're going to save. These stories only work if the threat that everyone knows isn't going to be realized at least inspires some interesting moments among the characters, moments that you probably wouldn't see if the heroes weren't facing such a tremendous threat (Although I disapproved of it greatly, I am thinking of Fraction having Spider-Man leave the battle in "Fear Itself" to go find Aunt May.) Here, when you're dealing with such morally compromised characters from the start, characters that pride themselves on making the hard decisions, then it's unclear what new ground you're going to be able to cover. Do we really think Namor is going to lament destroying some other Earth to save our Earth? It seems unlikely.
In other words, I'm bored. I used a lot of words here, but I'm bored. I'm at least not confused, as I am in "Avengers," but it's not exactly an improvement to applaud.
OK, I'll start with the good. He does at least explain the events that occurred last issue and are driving this first arc. The mysterious woman who seemed to destroy a planet actually destroyed it because it was occupying the same time-space as our Earth. She reveals to Reed that Earth is the focal point of a series of ongoing collisions between universes. The premature destruction of one universe has resulted in a chain reaction, pushing one universe after another into one another. In each collision, if one Earth isn't destroyed, both universes die, exacerbating the ongoing chain reactions and shortening the life of the multiverse all the more. I actually sort of get that part. I also get the question that Reed and T'Challa pose at the end, whether this process is an inevitable function of the multiverse's eventual destruction or is someone specifically trying to bring about the end of the multiverse early.
Moreover, I applaud Hickman having the Illuminati decide to use the Infinity Gauntlet. The possibility of doing so during "Avengers vs. X-Men" was mentioned, I believe, only once and it seems absurd to believe that the Illuminati would allow Scott to destroy the world rather than using all the power that they had at their disposal to stop him. Here, Hickman is at least intellectually honest about the Infinity Gauntlet and actually has Cap make the case that they need to use it to avoid having to choose between destroying their Earth or another one. Although it's a little surprising that it's Cap arguing for it (since he was against the Illuminati in the first place), his argument that these sorts of decisions always leave the decision-makers more compromised that they expect to be.
But, I do have problems with this series so far and they are two-fold. The first problem is fairly mundane. Although we learn all about the upcoming "incursion" and how we'll occupy the same space as other Earth for eight hours, Hickman never actually describes how we'll both actually occupy the same space. Why can the two planets be in the same space for either hours without combusting? Why the window? Wouldn't they just immediately combust? If not, wouldn't our universe merge with their universe to create some sort of third universe? But, that didn't happen last issue, when we did actually go through an incursion with another universe.
But, more importantly, I feel like this whole story has a certain eye-roll factor. I mean, it's not even that the possibility that the Illuminati could fail and the multiverse winds up destroyed could be on the table. (Of course, that, in and of itself, would have a high eye-roll factor.) It's more that I'm not sure if we're going to get an interesting story from it. As it stands now, we've just gotten a lot of male posturing and it seems like we're just going to continue to get male posturing. I anticipate a lot of 'But, Steve!" and "But, Tony!" arguments while they race to save the multiverse that we all now that they're going to save. These stories only work if the threat that everyone knows isn't going to be realized at least inspires some interesting moments among the characters, moments that you probably wouldn't see if the heroes weren't facing such a tremendous threat (Although I disapproved of it greatly, I am thinking of Fraction having Spider-Man leave the battle in "Fear Itself" to go find Aunt May.) Here, when you're dealing with such morally compromised characters from the start, characters that pride themselves on making the hard decisions, then it's unclear what new ground you're going to be able to cover. Do we really think Namor is going to lament destroying some other Earth to save our Earth? It seems unlikely.
In other words, I'm bored. I used a lot of words here, but I'm bored. I'm at least not confused, as I am in "Avengers," but it's not exactly an improvement to applaud.
Captain Marvel #9 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is just simply excellent. I could go into all the ways that it's excellent, but somehow doing so would cheapen the excellence. Overall, I will just say that the excellence comes from the fact that DeConnick really gets the concept of a "day in the life" story, using it not only to show Carol's connections to her supporting cast (and deepen the connections that she has with them and that they also have with each other) but also to show how disruptive the challenges of being Captain Marvel are to the goal of being Carol Danvers. Even if you've never read "Captain Marvel," you end this issue with an excellent idea of who she is and who she aspires to be. Excellent. Just excellent. (DId I mention that it was excellent?)
Captain America #3 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Remender does a lot of stuff here. If this issue were part of a movie and not a comic-book arc, I feel like it would've been a really rushed second act.
Cap breaks free of his bonds in time to save himself and Ian from execution and activates his universal translator in time to understand one of the aliens, Ksul, explaining that he, too, is an enemy of Zola. The revelation stays their execution and Steve and Ian recuperate with Ksul and his wife. The problem is that Remender rushes these scenes. We're supposed to believe that Steve has formed a deep bond with Ksul, one that helps him convince Ksul to rebel against Zofjor, the head of the tribe (and the guy who was trying to execute Steve and Ian in the first place). Zofjor kills Ksul for his insolence, pitting a heartbroken Steve against him. But, it all happens so quickly -- over the course of three pages -- that it doesn't really have the emotional impact that it's supposed to have. It's supposed to show that Steve is falling apart quickly in the face of the challenges of Dimension Z, particularly when it's revealed that Zola has implanted a screen in Steve's chest. But, instead, it's just a jumble of action that feels like it's simply moving us to where we need to be, not where the story takes us.
Remender does better in the flashbacks of Steve's youth, showing that his determination to defend his friend is the same determination that led him to try to convince Ksul to rebel. The problem is that JR JR is at his worse here, depicting a young Steve as almost a bobble-head, distracting me for the entire sequence.
Needless to say, I was a little disappointed, particularly after the amazing last issue. But, the twist at the end definitely holds a lot of promise, even though I'm curious why it was only when Zofjor cut Steve that he was able to see the screen. Anyway, hopefully this issue was just a bump in the road.
Cap breaks free of his bonds in time to save himself and Ian from execution and activates his universal translator in time to understand one of the aliens, Ksul, explaining that he, too, is an enemy of Zola. The revelation stays their execution and Steve and Ian recuperate with Ksul and his wife. The problem is that Remender rushes these scenes. We're supposed to believe that Steve has formed a deep bond with Ksul, one that helps him convince Ksul to rebel against Zofjor, the head of the tribe (and the guy who was trying to execute Steve and Ian in the first place). Zofjor kills Ksul for his insolence, pitting a heartbroken Steve against him. But, it all happens so quickly -- over the course of three pages -- that it doesn't really have the emotional impact that it's supposed to have. It's supposed to show that Steve is falling apart quickly in the face of the challenges of Dimension Z, particularly when it's revealed that Zola has implanted a screen in Steve's chest. But, instead, it's just a jumble of action that feels like it's simply moving us to where we need to be, not where the story takes us.
Remender does better in the flashbacks of Steve's youth, showing that his determination to defend his friend is the same determination that led him to try to convince Ksul to rebel. The problem is that JR JR is at his worse here, depicting a young Steve as almost a bobble-head, distracting me for the entire sequence.
Needless to say, I was a little disappointed, particularly after the amazing last issue. But, the twist at the end definitely holds a lot of promise, even though I'm curious why it was only when Zofjor cut Steve that he was able to see the screen. Anyway, hopefully this issue was just a bump in the road.
Avenging Spider-Man #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Chris Yost continues to do the best job, to my mind, of giving us a realistic (relatively) portrayal of Dr. Octopus as Spider-Man. Whereas "Amazing Spider-Man" #700 gave us an unbelievably heroic Doc Ock and "Superior Spider-Man" #1 gave us a troublingly villainous one, Yost strikes more of a balance here. He gives us a Dr. Octopus committed to being a better Spider-Man than Peter was, but one who still expresses frustration with the indignities that he cannot believe that Peter endured. One of those indignities that Otto refuses to accept comes when he decks Wolverine for presuming to touch him, a hit that I really relished watching due to my general dislike of Wolverine, particularly given recent attempts by Marvel to elevate him to the same leadership status as Captain America. Here, we see exactly why he's not Captain America. But, possibly more importantly, Yost uses this moment to have Logan do the math that Mary Jane apparently is incapable of doing and presents the first instance of someone wondering if Peter is who he says that he is. In so doing, he also introduces the obvious conundrum (for Otto) of telepathy, something that Ock immediately recognizes as a threat and cleverly avoids by using the Parker charm. Finally, the revelation that the spider girl was created by the Jackal raises a question that hadn't previously dawned on me, namely whether it'll be a villain who figures out Doc Ock is Spider-Man, not a hero. The Jackal is a pretty savvy guy and if he manages to realize that he's not dealing with Peter as easily as Logan was, it could be all sorts of bad. All these twists and turns so far are much more interesting (and less gimmicky) than anything happening in the main title, so I have to thank Yost for saving the concept to the extent that anyone could for me.
All-New X-Men #6 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This is the true story of five X-Men picked to come to the present and have their lives scripted to find out what happens when people stop being polite and start getting real. The Real World...Xavier's Mansion!
The opening narration of the "Real World" came to me while reading this issue because we see exactly what it describes here: people stop being polite and start getting real. Everyone is trying to treat the original five X-Men with kid gloves, but it's clear that they're going to be able to do so for only so long. Jean wrecks Kitty's room (where she's staying) with her telekinesis during a violent dream and is then overwhelmed when her telepathy gives her an inside look into the thoughts of everyone in the Mansion. Kitty teaches Jean to block out the voices, something that she ironically learned to do from older Jean. In doing so, the two bond and Jean begins to ask tentative questions about her relationship with other X-Men. But, even this effort is complicated since, when Kitty says that she admired older Jean, original Jean's telepathy allows her to discover that Kitty wasn't quite as admiring of Jean as she claimed. (On this score, I have to give Bendis huge ups for actually treating older Jean as a real person and not as a martyred saint. She could be difficult! Who knew?)
Moreover, Scott steals Logan's motorcycle and heads to town, causing him to discover the joys of cellular phones and bottled water. I thought Bendis did a good job with their conversation outside the convenience store, with Logan showing some capacity to understand that Scott is going through a difficult time. However, I particularly loved Scott's reaction, knocking back Wolverine with his optic blast and then leaving again. I honestly didn't see that coming and I think that it's the moment where I realized that the X-Men have already started to lose their control over the kids and, as we see with Mystique observing the image of a teenage Scott, the world has started to notice. Moreover, we don't really know what Scott wants. It seems like he may be going to see his older self, his desire for answers driver by his fury over waking up one day in the present and finding himself isolated from his friends for a crime that he didn't commit. But, who better to sway original Scott to the dark side than present Scott? Again, Bendis is making it clear that the kids' learning period has come to a close and their actions are going to begin to have pretty serious consequences.
Along those lines, Bendis also shows that the status quo that existed in the original X-Men's team dynamics are in flux. Jean has emerged, somewhat to her own surprise, as the leader of the team, as Bendis hinted would happen last issue. Warren feels increasingly isolated from his friends over his anger at having been overruled, a sense of betrayal that probably isn't going to be helped when he discovers what happens to him in the future. Moreover, I was reminded during this issue the rude awakening these kids are going to have. Beyond Warren's obviously traumatic future, I realized that Jean is going to discover at some point that her entire family has been murdered. I mean, it's probably going to be weird for original Bobby to have Kitty as his headmistress now that he knows that he's going to be dating her in the future. It's a lot to process and it seems clear this issue that they're not all going to do so well at it.
This series continues to keep building and building steam. My only negative this issue was actually Marquez. In two separate instances, he splashed the panels across two pages in a way that wasn't entirely obvious that he had done so, resulting in me reading them page-by-page, realizing I read them in the the wrong order, and then having to re-read them left to right. I like interesting panel designs, but they shouldn't get in the way of the story, as they do here. Overall, though, it's a pretty minor complaint. I'm still a really happy camper with this series.
The opening narration of the "Real World" came to me while reading this issue because we see exactly what it describes here: people stop being polite and start getting real. Everyone is trying to treat the original five X-Men with kid gloves, but it's clear that they're going to be able to do so for only so long. Jean wrecks Kitty's room (where she's staying) with her telekinesis during a violent dream and is then overwhelmed when her telepathy gives her an inside look into the thoughts of everyone in the Mansion. Kitty teaches Jean to block out the voices, something that she ironically learned to do from older Jean. In doing so, the two bond and Jean begins to ask tentative questions about her relationship with other X-Men. But, even this effort is complicated since, when Kitty says that she admired older Jean, original Jean's telepathy allows her to discover that Kitty wasn't quite as admiring of Jean as she claimed. (On this score, I have to give Bendis huge ups for actually treating older Jean as a real person and not as a martyred saint. She could be difficult! Who knew?)
Moreover, Scott steals Logan's motorcycle and heads to town, causing him to discover the joys of cellular phones and bottled water. I thought Bendis did a good job with their conversation outside the convenience store, with Logan showing some capacity to understand that Scott is going through a difficult time. However, I particularly loved Scott's reaction, knocking back Wolverine with his optic blast and then leaving again. I honestly didn't see that coming and I think that it's the moment where I realized that the X-Men have already started to lose their control over the kids and, as we see with Mystique observing the image of a teenage Scott, the world has started to notice. Moreover, we don't really know what Scott wants. It seems like he may be going to see his older self, his desire for answers driver by his fury over waking up one day in the present and finding himself isolated from his friends for a crime that he didn't commit. But, who better to sway original Scott to the dark side than present Scott? Again, Bendis is making it clear that the kids' learning period has come to a close and their actions are going to begin to have pretty serious consequences.
Along those lines, Bendis also shows that the status quo that existed in the original X-Men's team dynamics are in flux. Jean has emerged, somewhat to her own surprise, as the leader of the team, as Bendis hinted would happen last issue. Warren feels increasingly isolated from his friends over his anger at having been overruled, a sense of betrayal that probably isn't going to be helped when he discovers what happens to him in the future. Moreover, I was reminded during this issue the rude awakening these kids are going to have. Beyond Warren's obviously traumatic future, I realized that Jean is going to discover at some point that her entire family has been murdered. I mean, it's probably going to be weird for original Bobby to have Kitty as his headmistress now that he knows that he's going to be dating her in the future. It's a lot to process and it seems clear this issue that they're not all going to do so well at it.
This series continues to keep building and building steam. My only negative this issue was actually Marquez. In two separate instances, he splashed the panels across two pages in a way that wasn't entirely obvious that he had done so, resulting in me reading them page-by-page, realizing I read them in the the wrong order, and then having to re-read them left to right. I like interesting panel designs, but they shouldn't get in the way of the story, as they do here. Overall, though, it's a pretty minor complaint. I'm still a really happy camper with this series.
Tuesday, February 19, 2013
Earth 2 #8 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is a little more clunky of one than we normally see from Robinson, a result of his attempt to cram a lot of exposition into the story. It actually reminds me of the challenge that he had in the first issue, where he similarly had to get a lot of facts on the table. But, since I know that the awkward moments of the first issue had nothing to do with his ability to write dialogue but more a need to get the ball rolling, I'm confident that he'll return to form next issue.
Dialogue aside, Robinson sets up an interesting struggle between Steppenwolf and Marov, the king of Dherain who we learn aided and abetted Steppenwolf during the war and now provides him sanctuary. You pretty much knew from the start where this "friendship" was going to go since, in human history, these sorts of alliances between conquering villains don't usually last all too long. We learn that Marov is only after Steppenwolf's advanced technology and the World Army bounty whereas Steppenwolf is looking for a country from where he can launch his campaign for world conquest. Both motives were pretty predictable. However, the surprising twist was the revelation that Steppenwolf was going to be aided in his attempt to take over Dherain by Fury, the daughter of Wonder Woman. Robinson has Marov ask the obvious question, why Wonder Woman's daughter would throw in her lot with an alien conqueror who killed her mother. We don't get an answer here, but I'm sure that answer is going to drive not a few plots over the coming issues.
The main drawback to the issue is surprisingly the dialogue, something at which Robinson usually excels. The exchange between the two Dherainian soldiers was seriously awkward, since I'm pretty sure that two soldiers chatting wouldn't feel the need to identify the name of their elite unit or to describe Steppenwolf as "powerhouse of energy, grand commander of the armies of Apokolips" given that everyone knows who he is. Moreover, Steppenwolf and Marov's exchanges also felt forced, particularly when Steppenwolf suddenly denounced Marov despite having had a friendly discussion with him a few pages earlier. I get that Steppenwolf knew that Marov was planning to move against him and had to announce his counter-attack at some point, but we're not really given any hint of it coming. One minute they're sipping champagne, the next minute Steppenwolf is announcing that Marov's men are as good as dead. I get that Robinson was trying to fill in some blanks, so I'll go easy on him, but this issue could've been truly spectacular had he found away to make the dialogue more fluid.
Still, with Steppenwolf and Fury now (somewhat awkwardly) introduced, it feels like all the pieces of the puzzle have fallen into place in terms of building our basic understanding of Earth 2. Steppenwolf makes it clear that he's been abandoned by his lieutenants (except for Fury) and I like the Napoleonesque vibe of the would-be conqueror plotting his return from isolation. I get the sense that now the fun begins!
Dialogue aside, Robinson sets up an interesting struggle between Steppenwolf and Marov, the king of Dherain who we learn aided and abetted Steppenwolf during the war and now provides him sanctuary. You pretty much knew from the start where this "friendship" was going to go since, in human history, these sorts of alliances between conquering villains don't usually last all too long. We learn that Marov is only after Steppenwolf's advanced technology and the World Army bounty whereas Steppenwolf is looking for a country from where he can launch his campaign for world conquest. Both motives were pretty predictable. However, the surprising twist was the revelation that Steppenwolf was going to be aided in his attempt to take over Dherain by Fury, the daughter of Wonder Woman. Robinson has Marov ask the obvious question, why Wonder Woman's daughter would throw in her lot with an alien conqueror who killed her mother. We don't get an answer here, but I'm sure that answer is going to drive not a few plots over the coming issues.
The main drawback to the issue is surprisingly the dialogue, something at which Robinson usually excels. The exchange between the two Dherainian soldiers was seriously awkward, since I'm pretty sure that two soldiers chatting wouldn't feel the need to identify the name of their elite unit or to describe Steppenwolf as "powerhouse of energy, grand commander of the armies of Apokolips" given that everyone knows who he is. Moreover, Steppenwolf and Marov's exchanges also felt forced, particularly when Steppenwolf suddenly denounced Marov despite having had a friendly discussion with him a few pages earlier. I get that Steppenwolf knew that Marov was planning to move against him and had to announce his counter-attack at some point, but we're not really given any hint of it coming. One minute they're sipping champagne, the next minute Steppenwolf is announcing that Marov's men are as good as dead. I get that Robinson was trying to fill in some blanks, so I'll go easy on him, but this issue could've been truly spectacular had he found away to make the dialogue more fluid.
Still, with Steppenwolf and Fury now (somewhat awkwardly) introduced, it feels like all the pieces of the puzzle have fallen into place in terms of building our basic understanding of Earth 2. Steppenwolf makes it clear that he's been abandoned by his lieutenants (except for Fury) and I like the Napoleonesque vibe of the would-be conqueror plotting his return from isolation. I get the sense that now the fun begins!
Wolverine and the X-Men #23 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Fine, I enjoyed this issue. Aaron actually does something with a member of the Hellfire Club here, giving us some insight into the demons that drive Maximilian, the newly christened Dr. Frankenstein. He also continues Idie's descent into darkness, showing her willingly trying to kill Calcabrina. (When Quentin Quire is worried about you, you know it's bad.) But, it's really Bradshaw who steals the show in showing the ridiculousness of the X-Men fighting a circus of zombie clowns. From Goop's brass knuckles to Kitty taking down a clown with the Strong Man's hammer, he plays up the laughs inherent in this story to great effect.
I will say that I wonder how much longer I'm going to get this title now that Bendis is consistently showing us the same team in action on "All-New X-Men." The only real difference between these two books is that this one in theory focuses on the students as well. However, although Aaron did some interesting stuff with the students in the first few issues, I feel like they've been mostly afterthoughts for the last few issues. I mean, sure, we learned that Eye-Boy can see magic in this arc, but I can't really say that we're getting the sort of focus on them that we did in "New Mutants" or "New X-Men." Given their absence and the fact that I really, really hate the Kiddie Hellfire Club, I may be calling it a day on this title soon.
I will say that I wonder how much longer I'm going to get this title now that Bendis is consistently showing us the same team in action on "All-New X-Men." The only real difference between these two books is that this one in theory focuses on the students as well. However, although Aaron did some interesting stuff with the students in the first few issues, I feel like they've been mostly afterthoughts for the last few issues. I mean, sure, we learned that Eye-Boy can see magic in this arc, but I can't really say that we're getting the sort of focus on them that we did in "New Mutants" or "New X-Men." Given their absence and the fact that I really, really hate the Kiddie Hellfire Club, I may be calling it a day on this title soon.
Monday, February 18, 2013
Superior Spider-Man #1 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
By buying this issue, I was essentially making a pact with Dan Slott, agreeing to accept this story on its own terms and not constantly rail against the decision to put Otto Octavius in charge of Peter Parker. I'm not saying that I'm going to give him a free pass, but I'm at least committed to allowing the story unfold and see where we go.
Slott does a decent job, but, in the end, he seems to back off the two main concepts that define this story, that Otto will improve on Peter's tenure as Spider-Man and that he is Peter Parker for all intents and purposes. By hedging his bets, I feel like Slott winds up losing the hand.
First, Otto has pledged to be a better Spider-Man than Peter was. In this issue, we see his initial attempt at doing so as he brings a number of new innovations to his fight with the new Sinister Six. He's developed some sort of remote-control device embedded in the spider emblem on his costume that allows him to activate devices via voice command, such as rendering Speed Demon's speed inoperable thanks to a frictionless surface he pre-arranged at Horizon Labs. (I'm not entirely sure how you "activate" a frictionless surface, but I'm trying not to quibble.) He also uses razor-sharp claws to embed nano-tracers into Boomerang, allowing him not only to track the Sinister Six but to hear their conversations. They're both cool innovations, to be sure. But, the problem is that it seems somewhat redundant. Maybe if "Big Time" hadn't happened, it would've been cool, similar to the time that Emma Frost took over Iceman's body and revealed to him everything that he was capable of doing but wasn't. But, "Big Time" was so successful thanks to Slott allowing Peter to evolve. The devices that we see here are cool, but, honestly, they just seem like devices that Peter himself may have eventually created given the time. After all, the spider-emblem device is reminiscent of Peter's voice-activated Web-Shooters. Slott set the bar so high when it comes to Peter's inventions during "Big Time" that nothing seems new here.
Moreover, we discover that Otto isn't as in control as he thinks he is. He finds himself surprised when he abandons his attempt to flee the Sinister Six to save a cop from one of Boomerang's errant boomerangs and when he suddenly decides to stop pummeling Boomerang despite his obvious intention to beat him into a coma (or worse). The surprise reveal is that Peter is still in there somewhere, although Otto can't "hear" him. In terms of a narrative device, it's a clever move, because it's going to keep Otto from really sullying Spider-Man's name, as we all feared that he'd do. I'm guessing that it's going to be what manages to keep Otto from successfully getting Mary Jane into bed or Spider-Man from killing someone. The problem, though, is that once again it raises the question of how significant of an impact this storyline is going to wind up having. I mean, we all knew that Peter was going to return. But, if he hadn't been able to control Otto's impulses, as we learned now that he can do, then he would've likely returned with a very different reputation. Maybe Otto would've killed someone. Maybe MJ would never be able to get over the violation she would've felt if she slept with Otto. It would've been interesting to see how Peter handled that. But, if Peter is able to stop Otto from committing the gravest transgressions to his good name, then the only real impact of this period is going to be that Peter was something of a dick to Grady.
In other words, I'm disappointed. In a way, I really wanted Slott to go all in. Have Otto beat Boomerang into a coma. Have Spider-Man reveal razored Web-Lines. Instead, we get something in the middle that just makes you feel like this whole storyline has a clock ticking over its head like that terrible Nickleback video, counting down the moments until it's all forgotten.
Slott does a decent job, but, in the end, he seems to back off the two main concepts that define this story, that Otto will improve on Peter's tenure as Spider-Man and that he is Peter Parker for all intents and purposes. By hedging his bets, I feel like Slott winds up losing the hand.
First, Otto has pledged to be a better Spider-Man than Peter was. In this issue, we see his initial attempt at doing so as he brings a number of new innovations to his fight with the new Sinister Six. He's developed some sort of remote-control device embedded in the spider emblem on his costume that allows him to activate devices via voice command, such as rendering Speed Demon's speed inoperable thanks to a frictionless surface he pre-arranged at Horizon Labs. (I'm not entirely sure how you "activate" a frictionless surface, but I'm trying not to quibble.) He also uses razor-sharp claws to embed nano-tracers into Boomerang, allowing him not only to track the Sinister Six but to hear their conversations. They're both cool innovations, to be sure. But, the problem is that it seems somewhat redundant. Maybe if "Big Time" hadn't happened, it would've been cool, similar to the time that Emma Frost took over Iceman's body and revealed to him everything that he was capable of doing but wasn't. But, "Big Time" was so successful thanks to Slott allowing Peter to evolve. The devices that we see here are cool, but, honestly, they just seem like devices that Peter himself may have eventually created given the time. After all, the spider-emblem device is reminiscent of Peter's voice-activated Web-Shooters. Slott set the bar so high when it comes to Peter's inventions during "Big Time" that nothing seems new here.
Moreover, we discover that Otto isn't as in control as he thinks he is. He finds himself surprised when he abandons his attempt to flee the Sinister Six to save a cop from one of Boomerang's errant boomerangs and when he suddenly decides to stop pummeling Boomerang despite his obvious intention to beat him into a coma (or worse). The surprise reveal is that Peter is still in there somewhere, although Otto can't "hear" him. In terms of a narrative device, it's a clever move, because it's going to keep Otto from really sullying Spider-Man's name, as we all feared that he'd do. I'm guessing that it's going to be what manages to keep Otto from successfully getting Mary Jane into bed or Spider-Man from killing someone. The problem, though, is that once again it raises the question of how significant of an impact this storyline is going to wind up having. I mean, we all knew that Peter was going to return. But, if he hadn't been able to control Otto's impulses, as we learned now that he can do, then he would've likely returned with a very different reputation. Maybe Otto would've killed someone. Maybe MJ would never be able to get over the violation she would've felt if she slept with Otto. It would've been interesting to see how Peter handled that. But, if Peter is able to stop Otto from committing the gravest transgressions to his good name, then the only real impact of this period is going to be that Peter was something of a dick to Grady.
In other words, I'm disappointed. In a way, I really wanted Slott to go all in. Have Otto beat Boomerang into a coma. Have Spider-Man reveal razored Web-Lines. Instead, we get something in the middle that just makes you feel like this whole storyline has a clock ticking over its head like that terrible Nickleback video, counting down the moments until it's all forgotten.
Secret Avengers #36 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Wow.
OK, I was distracted for the first few pages because I wasn't quite sure how we got where we were at that point. I re-read the Earth-666 parts of "Secret Avengers" #35 and, to be honest, I'm still not entirely sure why Beast, Captain Britain, and Hawkeye had to return to the Hall of the Avengers of the Undead to activate the portal to our world. But, I have some vague recollection that the portal only ever appeared there, so I guess that makes sense. It might've been a little better if Remender had reminded us of that fact, though, since it interrupted the flow of the story for me when I had to stop reading and flip through "Secret Avengers' #35 to try to find out how we got there. (Though, the resolution was pretty damn hilarious and I just want to put down a marker right now that I would welcome a Beast, Captain Britain, and Hawkeye buddy mini-series at any time.)
But, I'm also still a little unclear on how the Secret Avengers learned that Brian's father was involved in the creation of the Descendants. In issue #35, Brian mentions that the Human Torch had discovered that fact, so I'm assuming it happened during the team's original skirmish with the Descendants. But, I wasn't going to read yet another comic just to get through the first few pages of this issue, so I decided just to take this one on fact. I guess it's the problem of telling this sort of epic story, particularly one that builds off issues from much earlier in the run.
Once I got past this somewhat confusing start, though, I was totally floored by where Remender went. I loved that Beast, Captain Britain, and Hawkeye wind up appearing in a New York under siege from the Descendants, with Sentinels running wild and Spidey the only hero left standing. Scalera does a great job of telegraphing their confusion, particularly since they had just moments ago been thrilled that they managed to escape the Avengers of the Undead. But, Remender takes us somewhere else that I didn't see coming, namely leaving the heroes at a loss for how to solve the problem of the Descendants. It's a brilliant (and totally logical, in the context of the story) dilemma: if they activate the Orb of Necromancy, they kill all the Descendants, but if they wait too long to do so, the virus will have turned all of humanity into Descendants, meaning that they'll wipe humanity (albeit an altered one) off the face of the Earth.
Remender doesn't just set up some sort of cool action plot here; he really pays attention to the emotional aspects of this dilemma, making it a much stronger story. First, he has Henry kill a Doombot in defending Hawkeye and it's the Doombot's all-too-human death that really fuels their dilemma, since they now know beyond a shadow of a doubt that the Descendants have feelings. As Hawkeye had said in issue #35, they're dealing with human beings, at least emotionally, not robots. Second, by having the trio encounter Spider-Man and later Giant Man, Remender has some of the best minds in the Marvel Universe staring down the problem. It will probably result in the solution in the end, but, right now, he does a great job of using it to convey the sense of helplessness that they all feel, that these four geniuses can't find a way to outmaneuver the Father without leaving all of humanity (or, at the minimum, a large chunk of it) dead. It's these two twists that give this story its emotional impact and moves it beyond just the usual slugfest. Add to that the Human Torch's fight with Captain Britain, Black Ant's fight with Venom, and Hank Pym's continued Deathlokification and you've got yourself a really emotionally charged book. (By the way, just in case you were wondering, "Deathlokification" is not in the Spell Check dictionary.)
All in all, even with the somewhat confusing beginning, this issue was just really classic. As I said in my review for last issue, Remender is telling his own epic here, the sort of story that Kurt Busiek told in his Kang War. Without tie-in issues and the like to dilute the story, Remender just makes each issue all the more powerful than the next. Plus, Scalera is quickly becoming one of my favorite artists. The splash page of Giant Man punching the Sentinel was totally unexpected and awesome. I'm going to be sad to this series end, because I feel like it's really just hitting its stride. But, at least it's been a truly stellar end.
OK, I was distracted for the first few pages because I wasn't quite sure how we got where we were at that point. I re-read the Earth-666 parts of "Secret Avengers" #35 and, to be honest, I'm still not entirely sure why Beast, Captain Britain, and Hawkeye had to return to the Hall of the Avengers of the Undead to activate the portal to our world. But, I have some vague recollection that the portal only ever appeared there, so I guess that makes sense. It might've been a little better if Remender had reminded us of that fact, though, since it interrupted the flow of the story for me when I had to stop reading and flip through "Secret Avengers' #35 to try to find out how we got there. (Though, the resolution was pretty damn hilarious and I just want to put down a marker right now that I would welcome a Beast, Captain Britain, and Hawkeye buddy mini-series at any time.)
But, I'm also still a little unclear on how the Secret Avengers learned that Brian's father was involved in the creation of the Descendants. In issue #35, Brian mentions that the Human Torch had discovered that fact, so I'm assuming it happened during the team's original skirmish with the Descendants. But, I wasn't going to read yet another comic just to get through the first few pages of this issue, so I decided just to take this one on fact. I guess it's the problem of telling this sort of epic story, particularly one that builds off issues from much earlier in the run.
Once I got past this somewhat confusing start, though, I was totally floored by where Remender went. I loved that Beast, Captain Britain, and Hawkeye wind up appearing in a New York under siege from the Descendants, with Sentinels running wild and Spidey the only hero left standing. Scalera does a great job of telegraphing their confusion, particularly since they had just moments ago been thrilled that they managed to escape the Avengers of the Undead. But, Remender takes us somewhere else that I didn't see coming, namely leaving the heroes at a loss for how to solve the problem of the Descendants. It's a brilliant (and totally logical, in the context of the story) dilemma: if they activate the Orb of Necromancy, they kill all the Descendants, but if they wait too long to do so, the virus will have turned all of humanity into Descendants, meaning that they'll wipe humanity (albeit an altered one) off the face of the Earth.
Remender doesn't just set up some sort of cool action plot here; he really pays attention to the emotional aspects of this dilemma, making it a much stronger story. First, he has Henry kill a Doombot in defending Hawkeye and it's the Doombot's all-too-human death that really fuels their dilemma, since they now know beyond a shadow of a doubt that the Descendants have feelings. As Hawkeye had said in issue #35, they're dealing with human beings, at least emotionally, not robots. Second, by having the trio encounter Spider-Man and later Giant Man, Remender has some of the best minds in the Marvel Universe staring down the problem. It will probably result in the solution in the end, but, right now, he does a great job of using it to convey the sense of helplessness that they all feel, that these four geniuses can't find a way to outmaneuver the Father without leaving all of humanity (or, at the minimum, a large chunk of it) dead. It's these two twists that give this story its emotional impact and moves it beyond just the usual slugfest. Add to that the Human Torch's fight with Captain Britain, Black Ant's fight with Venom, and Hank Pym's continued Deathlokification and you've got yourself a really emotionally charged book. (By the way, just in case you were wondering, "Deathlokification" is not in the Spell Check dictionary.)
All in all, even with the somewhat confusing beginning, this issue was just really classic. As I said in my review for last issue, Remender is telling his own epic here, the sort of story that Kurt Busiek told in his Kang War. Without tie-in issues and the like to dilute the story, Remender just makes each issue all the more powerful than the next. Plus, Scalera is quickly becoming one of my favorite artists. The splash page of Giant Man punching the Sentinel was totally unexpected and awesome. I'm going to be sad to this series end, because I feel like it's really just hitting its stride. But, at least it's been a truly stellar end.
Venom #29 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
At the end of last issue, we were left with the U-Foes revealing that they had acquired some sort of machine that they were using on kidnapped victims to figure out its purpose. I actually kind of like that twist, since Bunn pretty much nails the U-Foes perfectly. They're not really Doc Ocks or Dr. Dooms who would be able to figure out the machine on their own; they're just a bunch of thugs hoping it'll help them get more power. I still wonder where they got it and how it's connected to Project Rainbow, the alleged fringe-science government program, but, I figure we'll probably learn more next issue.
But, aside from the mystery over machine's origins, Bunn uses the reveal that it's actually a memory machine to great effect, since, in one panel, Katy Kiernan gets a lot more interesting. Why is she shaking hands with the Kingpin? Is her husband the person by whose grave we see her standing? Speaking of supporting characters, I'm also really digging the Valkyrie/Venom dynamic. On a personal level, it's fun to watch Flash get all discombobulated around her. Plus, on a fighting level, they work well as a team, with Valkyrie evening out Flash's impulsiveness.
We also discover what Flash had come to suspect is true, that the symbiote is alive and well. It was a little odd to see it talking as if it had a personality, which makes me wonder whether it has developed a higher level of awareness than we've previously seen it have or if Flash has simply created a separate personality for it within his mind. Either way, it probably doesn't bode well for Flash.
All in all, I'm pretty glad that I accidentally wound up getting these issues in my pull-list stack. I'd be pretty happy reading a comic with Flash and Katy on the trail of some sort of secret-government conspiracy, almost inverting the original premise of this series. Fingers crossed that we don't regress to demons and devils.
But, aside from the mystery over machine's origins, Bunn uses the reveal that it's actually a memory machine to great effect, since, in one panel, Katy Kiernan gets a lot more interesting. Why is she shaking hands with the Kingpin? Is her husband the person by whose grave we see her standing? Speaking of supporting characters, I'm also really digging the Valkyrie/Venom dynamic. On a personal level, it's fun to watch Flash get all discombobulated around her. Plus, on a fighting level, they work well as a team, with Valkyrie evening out Flash's impulsiveness.
We also discover what Flash had come to suspect is true, that the symbiote is alive and well. It was a little odd to see it talking as if it had a personality, which makes me wonder whether it has developed a higher level of awareness than we've previously seen it have or if Flash has simply created a separate personality for it within his mind. Either way, it probably doesn't bode well for Flash.
All in all, I'm pretty glad that I accidentally wound up getting these issues in my pull-list stack. I'd be pretty happy reading a comic with Flash and Katy on the trail of some sort of secret-government conspiracy, almost inverting the original premise of this series. Fingers crossed that we don't regress to demons and devils.
Saturday, February 16, 2013
Venom #28 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
So, I had actually dropped "Venom," but, for some reason, my LCS accidentally put a copy of issue #31 in my stack and I didn't discover it until I got home. Figuring that it was some sort of sign (because I read too many comic books not to see it as a sign), I picked up issues #28-#30 just to see how this transition to Philadelphia went. I'll say that I'm happily surprised.
First, we finally ditch the demons and the symbiotes. When Katy first appeared on the scene, I thought that she had the potential to inspire some cool stories, tipping off Flash to any number of weird occurrences that he could help her investigate. But, we never really got to see that potential fulfilled, since we wound up getting distracted by "Minimum Carnage" and the Hellstrom business. But, Bunn uses her to great effect here. She's definitely on the border of q distressed damsel, though Bunn wisely at least gives her Lois Lane's spunky attitude to make sure that we don't slip too far into '80s gender roles.
(Speaking of '80 gender roles, I've been re-reading some old "Avengers West Coast" issues and just ran across the statement from Mockingbird, about Hawkeye, in issue #24: "I was a pretty 80's lady before we met, but I'm a real, old-fashioned wife when it comes to loving my man." I know. Words fail me, too.)
Meanwhile, Bunn brings back the U-Foes, who I love for reasons that I can't fully explain. One of the things that I like about "Scarlet Spider" and "Venom" is that bad guys actually kill people and we see the U-Foes pretty gruesomely take out a number of people here. Flash is going to have some trouble dealing with this failure, just as Kaine struggled after "Minimum Carnage." But, it's a much more realistic story than we see in other series, such as Spider-Man insisting that no one would die under his watch.
So, I'm back. I'm not guaranteeing that I'll be here for long, but so long as Bunn gives us more stories about Katy and Flash investigating weird conspiracies and fewer about Flash and his demons (literal and mental), I'll be here. Plus, I wonder what the U-Foes did with Flash in the end...
First, we finally ditch the demons and the symbiotes. When Katy first appeared on the scene, I thought that she had the potential to inspire some cool stories, tipping off Flash to any number of weird occurrences that he could help her investigate. But, we never really got to see that potential fulfilled, since we wound up getting distracted by "Minimum Carnage" and the Hellstrom business. But, Bunn uses her to great effect here. She's definitely on the border of q distressed damsel, though Bunn wisely at least gives her Lois Lane's spunky attitude to make sure that we don't slip too far into '80s gender roles.
(Speaking of '80 gender roles, I've been re-reading some old "Avengers West Coast" issues and just ran across the statement from Mockingbird, about Hawkeye, in issue #24: "I was a pretty 80's lady before we met, but I'm a real, old-fashioned wife when it comes to loving my man." I know. Words fail me, too.)
Meanwhile, Bunn brings back the U-Foes, who I love for reasons that I can't fully explain. One of the things that I like about "Scarlet Spider" and "Venom" is that bad guys actually kill people and we see the U-Foes pretty gruesomely take out a number of people here. Flash is going to have some trouble dealing with this failure, just as Kaine struggled after "Minimum Carnage." But, it's a much more realistic story than we see in other series, such as Spider-Man insisting that no one would die under his watch.
So, I'm back. I'm not guaranteeing that I'll be here for long, but so long as Bunn gives us more stories about Katy and Flash investigating weird conspiracies and fewer about Flash and his demons (literal and mental), I'll be here. Plus, I wonder what the U-Foes did with Flash in the end...
Friday, February 15, 2013
Scarlet Spider #13 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Holy crap, true believers, this issue rocked!
I complained in my review for last issue that "Scarlet Spider" seemed to have started to loose its way a little. I wasn't really a fan of "Minimum Carnage" and the last two issues have been excessively talky, showing Kaine cursing himself for his past over and over again. But, with this issue, Yost returns to where he was before "Minimum Carnage" and this series kicks into high gear again.
First and foremost, I like that Yost has Kaine deal with the darkness that he encounters here with a little more focus than he has lately. He knows that he's not really getting anywhere in moving against the human traffickers, because he's never going to be able to dismantle their networks. It's an interesting commentary, actually, because it raises the issue that rears its head in superhero comics every once in a while, namely why superheroes spend so much time battling super-villains and not everyday villains. Why does Spider-Man spend so much time trying to take down Doc Ock (OK, bad example right now) when he could be taking down the corner pusher? Here, Yost reminds us that Spidey's chance of success in doing some good is actually higher with Doc Ock. He can put him in prison for a few months, preventing him from doing any harm. But, the corner pusher? He'll be replaced the next day by a new guy. It's not a satisfying answer, but it's a realistic one, and I like that Yost has Kaine come to that conclusion so quickly in his superhero career. Plus, I also like that it doesn't stop Kaine from trying. It's here where Yost moves Kaine past wondering why he keeps trying to help and just has him help. It's a welcome move and a sign that Kaine (and this series) is starting to mature.
But, Yost also has Kaine handle not just the world around him in a more straight-forward way, but he also approaches his murderous past a little less hysterically in this issue than he has in previous ones. Here, Kaine's impulse to kill, and the concomitant decision not to do so, is presented more as a tactical problem than anything else. He's now committed not to be a monster and he has to find a way to do that, particularly when confronting monsters. It's this dilemma that I find interesting, not him constantly wringing his hands over his past. I mean, yes, definitely, a little introspection is good every once in a while. But, it's a better comic when Kaine is actively trying to rise to the challenge of finding a new way to fight and, thus, a way to become a better person than it is when he's moping around a hotel room. I loved Dan Slott having Spidey learn "Spider-Fun" and I feel like Yost is mining a similar vein here.
Moreover, Yost has us finally get into the mystery of Aracely. The wolf siblings are pretty freaking bad-ass, I have to say. I mean, how many times have you read a comic that ends with the superhero getting eaten by the super-villains? Plus, Yost does a good job with the mythology here. It's inaccessible at the moment, but it's also inaccessible to the characters. Unlike Hickman in "Avengers," who just seems to be obtuse for obtuseness' sake, Yost is being vague because Aracely can't remember what she needs to remember. She recognizes the threat abstractly, though, at some point, she's going to remember and we're going to get a lot more information. Right now, though, this ignorance feels totally organic and gives the issue the tension that it needs. Plus, with Kaine's review of all the wolf-related events that we've seen over the course of this series, Yost also makes it clear that it's all been brewing since the first issue.
If you can't tell, I loved this issue. I'm excited to get our surly and not mopey Kaine back and I'm really excited that Khoi Pham has returned. I had started to lose faith there, but I'm happy to say that my faith is restored.
I complained in my review for last issue that "Scarlet Spider" seemed to have started to loose its way a little. I wasn't really a fan of "Minimum Carnage" and the last two issues have been excessively talky, showing Kaine cursing himself for his past over and over again. But, with this issue, Yost returns to where he was before "Minimum Carnage" and this series kicks into high gear again.
First and foremost, I like that Yost has Kaine deal with the darkness that he encounters here with a little more focus than he has lately. He knows that he's not really getting anywhere in moving against the human traffickers, because he's never going to be able to dismantle their networks. It's an interesting commentary, actually, because it raises the issue that rears its head in superhero comics every once in a while, namely why superheroes spend so much time battling super-villains and not everyday villains. Why does Spider-Man spend so much time trying to take down Doc Ock (OK, bad example right now) when he could be taking down the corner pusher? Here, Yost reminds us that Spidey's chance of success in doing some good is actually higher with Doc Ock. He can put him in prison for a few months, preventing him from doing any harm. But, the corner pusher? He'll be replaced the next day by a new guy. It's not a satisfying answer, but it's a realistic one, and I like that Yost has Kaine come to that conclusion so quickly in his superhero career. Plus, I also like that it doesn't stop Kaine from trying. It's here where Yost moves Kaine past wondering why he keeps trying to help and just has him help. It's a welcome move and a sign that Kaine (and this series) is starting to mature.
But, Yost also has Kaine handle not just the world around him in a more straight-forward way, but he also approaches his murderous past a little less hysterically in this issue than he has in previous ones. Here, Kaine's impulse to kill, and the concomitant decision not to do so, is presented more as a tactical problem than anything else. He's now committed not to be a monster and he has to find a way to do that, particularly when confronting monsters. It's this dilemma that I find interesting, not him constantly wringing his hands over his past. I mean, yes, definitely, a little introspection is good every once in a while. But, it's a better comic when Kaine is actively trying to rise to the challenge of finding a new way to fight and, thus, a way to become a better person than it is when he's moping around a hotel room. I loved Dan Slott having Spidey learn "Spider-Fun" and I feel like Yost is mining a similar vein here.
Moreover, Yost has us finally get into the mystery of Aracely. The wolf siblings are pretty freaking bad-ass, I have to say. I mean, how many times have you read a comic that ends with the superhero getting eaten by the super-villains? Plus, Yost does a good job with the mythology here. It's inaccessible at the moment, but it's also inaccessible to the characters. Unlike Hickman in "Avengers," who just seems to be obtuse for obtuseness' sake, Yost is being vague because Aracely can't remember what she needs to remember. She recognizes the threat abstractly, though, at some point, she's going to remember and we're going to get a lot more information. Right now, though, this ignorance feels totally organic and gives the issue the tension that it needs. Plus, with Kaine's review of all the wolf-related events that we've seen over the course of this series, Yost also makes it clear that it's all been brewing since the first issue.
If you can't tell, I loved this issue. I'm excited to get our surly and not mopey Kaine back and I'm really excited that Khoi Pham has returned. I had started to lose faith there, but I'm happy to say that my faith is restored.
Cable and X-Force #3 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
OK, I'm game. I'm intrigued by the idea that Cable gets these visions of apocalyptic futures and X-Force does what it can do to stop them. It's a premise that seems to open doors to all sorts of possible stories and unintended consequences without getting quickly tired (like "Project: Rebirth" in "Venom").
Hopeless starts with an intriguing scenario here, using the brouhaha over Chik-Fil-A's support of anti-gay organizations as inspiration. I thought that Hopeless did a good job here of not reducing everyone to absurd caricatures. He has the owner of the fast-food restaurant reveal that her anti-mutant drive comes understandably from the fact that Magneto killed her daughter when he took over Manhattan, a rare acknowledgment of a past event actually having repercussions on a present story. Moreover, although Cable originally believes that she might be behind the virus that he predicts will result in anti-mutant hysteria if X-Force doesn't prevent it from getting released, Hopeless makes it clear that she's unaware of it. This revelations hints that someone else is pulling the strings here and nothing fuels a comic better than a conspiracy!
Given how unhappy I am with the Avengers line under Hickman, I'm more than happy to keep giving this title a shot, since at least it seems to know what story it's telling and where it's going.
Hopeless starts with an intriguing scenario here, using the brouhaha over Chik-Fil-A's support of anti-gay organizations as inspiration. I thought that Hopeless did a good job here of not reducing everyone to absurd caricatures. He has the owner of the fast-food restaurant reveal that her anti-mutant drive comes understandably from the fact that Magneto killed her daughter when he took over Manhattan, a rare acknowledgment of a past event actually having repercussions on a present story. Moreover, although Cable originally believes that she might be behind the virus that he predicts will result in anti-mutant hysteria if X-Force doesn't prevent it from getting released, Hopeless makes it clear that she's unaware of it. This revelations hints that someone else is pulling the strings here and nothing fuels a comic better than a conspiracy!
Given how unhappy I am with the Avengers line under Hickman, I'm more than happy to keep giving this title a shot, since at least it seems to know what story it's telling and where it's going.
Thursday, February 14, 2013
X-Factor #249 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
First, "But, we can't turn into a Lifetime movie when right now it's Showtime!" made me LOL. Oh, Peter David. God, I hope you're OK.
I think the most notable part of this issue is how well the newly pruned team is gelling. In Madro'x absence, Lorna steps into the leadership role here and it fits her quite well. Rather than setting up the sort of testosterone-driven conflict over leadership that we saw with Alex and Madrox, the emergence of Lorna as a team leader could work quite well, with Lorna leading the team in the field and Madrox handling them in the investigations. Madrox himself notes how well the team does in tackling the horde of demons, managing to be everywhere at once. It's another sign that we're in a new status quo.
We don't really get any answers about why the demons have targeted X-Factor for destruction, but David makes it pretty clear that we're going to get them. In the meantime, we get some pretty great action sequences, particularly those involving a furious Monet looking for revenge not only on Pip, for taking over her body, but her team members, who laughed when Pip revealed what he had done. (I loved that she didn't kilL Rictor simply as a sign of thanks to Shatterstar, who didn't laugh.) Anyway, it's all very Monet. I mean, sure, I tend to agree that she has a right to be angry, but the fact that she can't get over herself enough to realize that she should probably be more concerned with averting the end of the world (or, at least, the Bronx) than exacting her revenge in that moment just really sums up Monet. It also conveniently allows for hilarity like the above quote, so it's a win/win in terms of characterization and comedy.
We've been a little hit or miss in "X-Factor" lately as David wraps up some dangling threads and moves us into this new status quo. But, I feel like we've emerged from the transition period with this issue and are ready to dive into a pretty stellar arc. Good times, as always.
I think the most notable part of this issue is how well the newly pruned team is gelling. In Madro'x absence, Lorna steps into the leadership role here and it fits her quite well. Rather than setting up the sort of testosterone-driven conflict over leadership that we saw with Alex and Madrox, the emergence of Lorna as a team leader could work quite well, with Lorna leading the team in the field and Madrox handling them in the investigations. Madrox himself notes how well the team does in tackling the horde of demons, managing to be everywhere at once. It's another sign that we're in a new status quo.
We don't really get any answers about why the demons have targeted X-Factor for destruction, but David makes it pretty clear that we're going to get them. In the meantime, we get some pretty great action sequences, particularly those involving a furious Monet looking for revenge not only on Pip, for taking over her body, but her team members, who laughed when Pip revealed what he had done. (I loved that she didn't kilL Rictor simply as a sign of thanks to Shatterstar, who didn't laugh.) Anyway, it's all very Monet. I mean, sure, I tend to agree that she has a right to be angry, but the fact that she can't get over herself enough to realize that she should probably be more concerned with averting the end of the world (or, at least, the Bronx) than exacting her revenge in that moment just really sums up Monet. It also conveniently allows for hilarity like the above quote, so it's a win/win in terms of characterization and comedy.
We've been a little hit or miss in "X-Factor" lately as David wraps up some dangling threads and moves us into this new status quo. But, I feel like we've emerged from the transition period with this issue and are ready to dive into a pretty stellar arc. Good times, as always.
New Avengers #1 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I...am not optimistic about this title. Maybe I'm rushing to judgment, but after two somewhat nonsensical issues of "Avengers" and then this issue, I'm beginning to think that Jonathan Hickman writes a full script and then cuts 30 percent of the words to try to make it interesting.
This issue starts with some Wakandan kids apparently winning some sort of contest and getting congratulated for it by the Black Panther, but then suddenly shifts...somewhere. I'm not sure if Blank Panther and the kids get warped to another world or if the villains get warped to our world, but some bad-ass villain appears sounding a lot like one of Galactus' heralds, except she's not working for Galactus. I don't know. It's pretty confusing. All I know is that it apparently necessitates the calling of the Illuminati. I had really wished that the Illuminati would've gone with Bendis, but here we are. Hence, not optimistic.
This issue starts with some Wakandan kids apparently winning some sort of contest and getting congratulated for it by the Black Panther, but then suddenly shifts...somewhere. I'm not sure if Blank Panther and the kids get warped to another world or if the villains get warped to our world, but some bad-ass villain appears sounding a lot like one of Galactus' heralds, except she's not working for Galactus. I don't know. It's pretty confusing. All I know is that it apparently necessitates the calling of the Illuminati. I had really wished that the Illuminati would've gone with Bendis, but here we are. Hence, not optimistic.
All-New X-Men #5 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Amazing. Really. Just amazing.
The thing that impresses me the most about this issue is that Bendis really builds off the previous issues in a way that shows the care that he's put into crafting this narrative. When Jean discovered her telepathy in issue #2, I didn't really think all that much of it. OK, Bendis decided that he wanted Jean to have her telepathy earlier than she had it. Cool, whatever. It made sense within the story that the shock of coming to the future would've undone the mental blocks that Professor X had previously installed around her telepathy and it also made sense for the story since it would allow Jean to verify that Beast was telling them the truth. But, Bendis takes that ball and runs with it here. First, the use of her telepathy to create a virtual conference between present Beast and young Beast was brilliant, if not for the inventiveness, than for the snarkiness. But, perhaps even better, Bendis uses it to present Jean with a download of her own personal history, a revelation so disturbing that it prompts her to demand the the original X-Men stay in the present to right the wrongs that they have committed (and that have been committed against them). The believability of this series has always been attached to the reason why the original X-Men came to the future and the reason why they would stay in it. Bendis did a great job answering the first question in the first two issues and he does an equally good job of answering the second one here. No matter how fantastic it all sounds, I actually believe that the original X-Men have come to the future from the past and are here to stay. I really, really didn't expect for Bendis to be able to sell me on that as well as he has. I don't even mean that as a slight on Bendis; I have trouble believing that any author would've been able to sell me on it. But, here I am, totally buying it. Well effing done, BMB.
Moreover, Bendis is doing great stuff here with the characterizations, of the present and original X-Men alike. Finally, someone has Logan be an asshole again! Logan is an asshole. Logan is exactly the type of guy that would threaten to kill at teenage boy for the adult man that he will become. Given how neutered Logan has become, it was a real thrill to see a flash of his old self here.
Plus, I like this assertive Jean. Unlike a lot of female characters created in the '60s and '70s, Jean was never actually too much of a victim. After all, she accepted the Phoenix Force as a conscious decision to save the lives of her friends; it wasn't like Captain Marvel, where she essentially became a hero because of an accident that occurred with a man was defending her. But, that said, Jean was never really a leader either, like Storm or Rogue have been. Here, she clearly emerges as just that, the leader of the original X-Men. Her view of their future has erased any passivity that she may have had in her, inspiring her to do everything in her power to avoid the dark futures awaiting her and her friends. After all, it's the differences between the original X-Men and their present counterparts that are going to make this series interesting. Is something going to happen to Bobby to make him more serious? Is something going to happen to Scott to make him less serious? Are they going to wind up dating any of the other students? It would be pretty weird for present Bobby to be dating Kitty and original Bobby to be dating Idie. But, it's that weirdness and those differences that's going make this series interesting. It could definitely go the wrong way at some point, but, right now, Bendis' adroit handling of a changed Jean here certainly shows promise for the whole concept.
All in all, Bendis is five for five and I found myself, once again, anxiously awaiting the next issue.
The thing that impresses me the most about this issue is that Bendis really builds off the previous issues in a way that shows the care that he's put into crafting this narrative. When Jean discovered her telepathy in issue #2, I didn't really think all that much of it. OK, Bendis decided that he wanted Jean to have her telepathy earlier than she had it. Cool, whatever. It made sense within the story that the shock of coming to the future would've undone the mental blocks that Professor X had previously installed around her telepathy and it also made sense for the story since it would allow Jean to verify that Beast was telling them the truth. But, Bendis takes that ball and runs with it here. First, the use of her telepathy to create a virtual conference between present Beast and young Beast was brilliant, if not for the inventiveness, than for the snarkiness. But, perhaps even better, Bendis uses it to present Jean with a download of her own personal history, a revelation so disturbing that it prompts her to demand the the original X-Men stay in the present to right the wrongs that they have committed (and that have been committed against them). The believability of this series has always been attached to the reason why the original X-Men came to the future and the reason why they would stay in it. Bendis did a great job answering the first question in the first two issues and he does an equally good job of answering the second one here. No matter how fantastic it all sounds, I actually believe that the original X-Men have come to the future from the past and are here to stay. I really, really didn't expect for Bendis to be able to sell me on that as well as he has. I don't even mean that as a slight on Bendis; I have trouble believing that any author would've been able to sell me on it. But, here I am, totally buying it. Well effing done, BMB.
Moreover, Bendis is doing great stuff here with the characterizations, of the present and original X-Men alike. Finally, someone has Logan be an asshole again! Logan is an asshole. Logan is exactly the type of guy that would threaten to kill at teenage boy for the adult man that he will become. Given how neutered Logan has become, it was a real thrill to see a flash of his old self here.
Plus, I like this assertive Jean. Unlike a lot of female characters created in the '60s and '70s, Jean was never actually too much of a victim. After all, she accepted the Phoenix Force as a conscious decision to save the lives of her friends; it wasn't like Captain Marvel, where she essentially became a hero because of an accident that occurred with a man was defending her. But, that said, Jean was never really a leader either, like Storm or Rogue have been. Here, she clearly emerges as just that, the leader of the original X-Men. Her view of their future has erased any passivity that she may have had in her, inspiring her to do everything in her power to avoid the dark futures awaiting her and her friends. After all, it's the differences between the original X-Men and their present counterparts that are going to make this series interesting. Is something going to happen to Bobby to make him more serious? Is something going to happen to Scott to make him less serious? Are they going to wind up dating any of the other students? It would be pretty weird for present Bobby to be dating Kitty and original Bobby to be dating Idie. But, it's that weirdness and those differences that's going make this series interesting. It could definitely go the wrong way at some point, but, right now, Bendis' adroit handling of a changed Jean here certainly shows promise for the whole concept.
All in all, Bendis is five for five and I found myself, once again, anxiously awaiting the next issue.
Wolverine and the X-Men #22 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
La la la, Kiddie Hellfire Club, la la la, don't really care, la la la.
Scarlet Spider #12.1 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Since I've got a backlog of something like 48 comics, I'm going to have to forgo the longer style review that I usually do for "Amazing Spider-Man" and "Scarlet Spider," at least until I manage to get current.
I enjoyed this issue, though I think Yost has to start moving past the somewhat overwrought narration that we've been getting lately with Kaine. I don't mind the narration itself, since I think Yost has such a great sense of Kaine's voice. I just mean that he can't always be thinking about what a monster he used to be. I know that it's a Point One issue, so Yost is under the gun to use this issue to introduce Kaine to a wider audience. But, we just had a similar story last issue, where Kaine actually received some form of absolution for his brutal past from Donald. I'm not saying that Kaine should totally forget about it or that Donald suddenly wiped away all his guilt. But, I think that it's time for him to stop focusing on it as much, particularly since, as the Arranger said, he has enough on his plate right now.
Moving to the issue itself, though, I totally loved the story here. Kaine taking on human traffickers is right up the alley of this series, given its embrace of the darker corners of the superhero world. I loved the sudden shift at the end, with the Arranger killing the human trafficker and declaring that the Kingpin (and, thus, the Hand) would have a more active presence in Houston. Siqueira and Edwards do a great job showing Kaine battle the Hand here and I think that they're a good choice as a new ongoing adversary for Kaine. (Maybe Peter could teach him Spider-Fu!) Moreover, I'm excited that we seem to be getting somewhere next issue on the Aracely mystery.
All in all, I continue to love this title. It's just a reliable good read every month and, given the state of some other comics that I read, I can't really think of higher praise than that.
I enjoyed this issue, though I think Yost has to start moving past the somewhat overwrought narration that we've been getting lately with Kaine. I don't mind the narration itself, since I think Yost has such a great sense of Kaine's voice. I just mean that he can't always be thinking about what a monster he used to be. I know that it's a Point One issue, so Yost is under the gun to use this issue to introduce Kaine to a wider audience. But, we just had a similar story last issue, where Kaine actually received some form of absolution for his brutal past from Donald. I'm not saying that Kaine should totally forget about it or that Donald suddenly wiped away all his guilt. But, I think that it's time for him to stop focusing on it as much, particularly since, as the Arranger said, he has enough on his plate right now.
Moving to the issue itself, though, I totally loved the story here. Kaine taking on human traffickers is right up the alley of this series, given its embrace of the darker corners of the superhero world. I loved the sudden shift at the end, with the Arranger killing the human trafficker and declaring that the Kingpin (and, thus, the Hand) would have a more active presence in Houston. Siqueira and Edwards do a great job showing Kaine battle the Hand here and I think that they're a good choice as a new ongoing adversary for Kaine. (Maybe Peter could teach him Spider-Fu!) Moreover, I'm excited that we seem to be getting somewhere next issue on the Aracely mystery.
All in all, I continue to love this title. It's just a reliable good read every month and, given the state of some other comics that I read, I can't really think of higher praise than that.
Secret Avengers #35 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Honestly, this issue seems to prove the point that many of us have been making about "Death of the Family," that it would've somehow been more epic if it had been contained to "Batman." Remender is telling a story here that seems ready-made for some sort of huge summer cross-over event, particularly as it spreads to the larger Marvel Universe in this issue. I mean, Sleeper synthezoids transforming all humans into synthezoids? Talk about epic!
But, rather than have the story diluted by a never-ending series of poorly coordinated tie-in issues, Remender got to maintain tight control over this story, building it slowly but surely until it explodes in this issue. I liked the point that he makes here that the Descendants had been a Secret Avengers problem but it has now spilled into a "real" Avengers problem. It actually really underlines the importance of a team like the Secret Avengers, trying to eliminate threats before they get too huge. It's just that sometimes they fail!
I really didn't like the Descendants when they first appeared, because their origin and purpose was somewhat muddled back then. In fact, I feel like Remender may have originally been going somewhere else with them before he decided on this story. But, whatever the case may be, Remender has really sold this story to me over these last few issues. I'm continually surprised every issue, whether it's by Deathlok Jan turning Giant-Man into a fellow Deathlok or the Father declaring Bagalia as his own state, if only because he knew that the United Nations will refuse his request and justify his attack. Each surprise moves us to the next phase in an organic way; no plot point has feel extraneous or forced.
But, Remender doesn't just have mastery over the storytelling; he also has such a great ear for dialogue. I loved the banter between Captain Britain, Hank, and Hawkeye, but, even more, I loved the conversation between Natasha and Venom. Her mentoring clearly impacts Flash and I'm intrigued to see where Remender goes with him here. Moreover, it's nice to see Natasha portrayed as a real person and not just an emotionless super-spy, as she often is. Finally, Scalera is on fire in this issue. I loved that opening shot of the Human Torch rallying the troops, but the scenes of the Sentinel attack on Avengers Tower are even better. The Sentinel staring in the window at the Avengers? Amazing.
This issue has to be one of my favorites of the year, if only because it does the standard comic-book story to perfection.
But, rather than have the story diluted by a never-ending series of poorly coordinated tie-in issues, Remender got to maintain tight control over this story, building it slowly but surely until it explodes in this issue. I liked the point that he makes here that the Descendants had been a Secret Avengers problem but it has now spilled into a "real" Avengers problem. It actually really underlines the importance of a team like the Secret Avengers, trying to eliminate threats before they get too huge. It's just that sometimes they fail!
I really didn't like the Descendants when they first appeared, because their origin and purpose was somewhat muddled back then. In fact, I feel like Remender may have originally been going somewhere else with them before he decided on this story. But, whatever the case may be, Remender has really sold this story to me over these last few issues. I'm continually surprised every issue, whether it's by Deathlok Jan turning Giant-Man into a fellow Deathlok or the Father declaring Bagalia as his own state, if only because he knew that the United Nations will refuse his request and justify his attack. Each surprise moves us to the next phase in an organic way; no plot point has feel extraneous or forced.
But, Remender doesn't just have mastery over the storytelling; he also has such a great ear for dialogue. I loved the banter between Captain Britain, Hank, and Hawkeye, but, even more, I loved the conversation between Natasha and Venom. Her mentoring clearly impacts Flash and I'm intrigued to see where Remender goes with him here. Moreover, it's nice to see Natasha portrayed as a real person and not just an emotionless super-spy, as she often is. Finally, Scalera is on fire in this issue. I loved that opening shot of the Human Torch rallying the troops, but the scenes of the Sentinel attack on Avengers Tower are even better. The Sentinel staring in the window at the Avengers? Amazing.
This issue has to be one of my favorites of the year, if only because it does the standard comic-book story to perfection.
Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Batman #17 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
All right, before I say anything else, I will say that this issue is beautifully crafted. Snyder's script is flawless. Joker sounds like Joker and Bruce sounds like Bruce. Moreover, his pacing is perfect. I was stunned by the reveal that the platters contained the faces of the Bat-family and I felt an overwhelming sense of panic over the next few panels, even as my mind knew realistically that I had also picked up an issue of "Batgirl" today with Barbara's face clearly in tact on the cover. But, when it was revealed to be, as Damian put it, a joke, this sense of logic didn't undermine the relief I felt, a relief that Bruce also clearly demonstrated when he hugged Damian. Moreover, I loved Snyder flipping the issue of identities at the end, revealing that Joker doesn't know who Batman is but Batman knows who he is. In the art department, Capullo is also firing on all cylinders here, whether it's tight reaction shots, like Bruce realizing that Alfred wasn't dead, or grand underground vistas, like where Joker and Batman have their climactic battle. It's all just beautifully, beautifully crafted.
But...
At the end of the day, I just have to call bullshit on Joker not knowing. I mean, Snyder does his best here. I thought the revelation that Bruce essentially told Joker his secret identity years earlier, after he found the card in the Batcave, was a brilliant effort to show just how intimate the relationship between the two of them is. It shows how unbalanced Joker makes Bruce, how he is willing to take risks when it came to Joker. I'm not entirely sure that I buy that Bruce would actually take that risk, but I get where Snyder was going with it. It shows that the issue of Bruce's identity and Joker's identity is less important than the roles that they play for one another. Moreover, this scene shows us why Bruce therefore was so convinced that Joker didn't know the Bat-family's identities, since he knew in that moment what many of us have long theorized, that Joker doesn't really care. It's why he left on everyone's masks when he "cut off" their faces. He's confirming that he really doesn't want to know, because it would undermine the fun. It would be like reading the last chapter of a book, but then trying to muster the energy to read it now that you knew how it ended. He's in it for the thrill, not the resolution.
However, Snyder and his fellow authors have told a story over this arc that makes it completely implausible to believe that Joker doesn't know. Joker just happened to kidnap Batgirl's mother? He just happened to destroy Haly's Circus? He just happened to know that Jason's father was a deadbeat dad? It's incredibly difficult to believe that. (I mean, it's just unbelievable to believe that he managed to do all those things in the time frame allotted, but I'm just going to concede that issue.) Moreover, even if you're willing to accept alternative possibilities to these attacks, like Barbara Gordon, Sr. being kidnapped because of her ex-husband and not her daughter, you have to consider everything that Lobdell gave us when it comes to Joker "creating" Jason. He couldn't not know. It would literally be impossible. You can't have an alternate explanation for that.
But, perhaps even worse than not buying that Joker doesn't know their identities, I also don't buy that Joker successfully destroyed the bonds that the Bat-family has to Bruce. This criticism is particularly damning, since it's the whole damn point of this arc. Going beyond just "revealing" that he had been in the Batcave, we're supposed to believe that Joker undermines this trust by apparently telling the Bat-family what Bruce "really thinks" of them. Snyder leaves it a mystery what Joker told them but, honestly, I don't find it all that interesting of a mystery. Joker didn't get into the cave and his book was empty; anything he would've told them would be a mere fabrication. He's not reading some sort of mystery file that Bruce prepared marked, "Deepest, Darkest Thoughts: Bruce's Eyes Only!" Moreover, Bruce was right that Joker didn't know their identities. Sure, he should have told them about the Batcave incident, but, at the end of the day, it's really Bruce's only transgression. Snyder, though, seems to want us to believe that Joker said things to the Bat-family that forever changed their opinion of Bruce, building on their anger that he hadn't told them that Joker might know their identities. Truthfully, I just don't see that happening. They know that it's Joker. I mean, sure, maybe they're shaken, but, as X predicted, it's hard to argue that we're going to see the ramifications of this event past next issue. Someone at some point will tell Bruce what Joker said, he'll deny it, it'll be awkward for a while, and then they'll return to where they were. After all, they're all estranged anyway in the DCnU. How much worse could it get?
In the end, despite how brilliantly crafted this issue was, I just feel like this story was a disappointment. Snyder makes it difficult to believe that Joker doesn't know their identities and that the Bat-family would abandon Bruce, even though we're supposed to draw exactly those conclusions. To be honest, after the Court of Owls and "Death of the Family," I'm really excited to get a few stand-alone issues on this title for the first time since it launched. I need to be reminded of why I collect this title, since this arc made me continue to wonder.
But...
At the end of the day, I just have to call bullshit on Joker not knowing. I mean, Snyder does his best here. I thought the revelation that Bruce essentially told Joker his secret identity years earlier, after he found the card in the Batcave, was a brilliant effort to show just how intimate the relationship between the two of them is. It shows how unbalanced Joker makes Bruce, how he is willing to take risks when it came to Joker. I'm not entirely sure that I buy that Bruce would actually take that risk, but I get where Snyder was going with it. It shows that the issue of Bruce's identity and Joker's identity is less important than the roles that they play for one another. Moreover, this scene shows us why Bruce therefore was so convinced that Joker didn't know the Bat-family's identities, since he knew in that moment what many of us have long theorized, that Joker doesn't really care. It's why he left on everyone's masks when he "cut off" their faces. He's confirming that he really doesn't want to know, because it would undermine the fun. It would be like reading the last chapter of a book, but then trying to muster the energy to read it now that you knew how it ended. He's in it for the thrill, not the resolution.
However, Snyder and his fellow authors have told a story over this arc that makes it completely implausible to believe that Joker doesn't know. Joker just happened to kidnap Batgirl's mother? He just happened to destroy Haly's Circus? He just happened to know that Jason's father was a deadbeat dad? It's incredibly difficult to believe that. (I mean, it's just unbelievable to believe that he managed to do all those things in the time frame allotted, but I'm just going to concede that issue.) Moreover, even if you're willing to accept alternative possibilities to these attacks, like Barbara Gordon, Sr. being kidnapped because of her ex-husband and not her daughter, you have to consider everything that Lobdell gave us when it comes to Joker "creating" Jason. He couldn't not know. It would literally be impossible. You can't have an alternate explanation for that.
But, perhaps even worse than not buying that Joker doesn't know their identities, I also don't buy that Joker successfully destroyed the bonds that the Bat-family has to Bruce. This criticism is particularly damning, since it's the whole damn point of this arc. Going beyond just "revealing" that he had been in the Batcave, we're supposed to believe that Joker undermines this trust by apparently telling the Bat-family what Bruce "really thinks" of them. Snyder leaves it a mystery what Joker told them but, honestly, I don't find it all that interesting of a mystery. Joker didn't get into the cave and his book was empty; anything he would've told them would be a mere fabrication. He's not reading some sort of mystery file that Bruce prepared marked, "Deepest, Darkest Thoughts: Bruce's Eyes Only!" Moreover, Bruce was right that Joker didn't know their identities. Sure, he should have told them about the Batcave incident, but, at the end of the day, it's really Bruce's only transgression. Snyder, though, seems to want us to believe that Joker said things to the Bat-family that forever changed their opinion of Bruce, building on their anger that he hadn't told them that Joker might know their identities. Truthfully, I just don't see that happening. They know that it's Joker. I mean, sure, maybe they're shaken, but, as X predicted, it's hard to argue that we're going to see the ramifications of this event past next issue. Someone at some point will tell Bruce what Joker said, he'll deny it, it'll be awkward for a while, and then they'll return to where they were. After all, they're all estranged anyway in the DCnU. How much worse could it get?
In the end, despite how brilliantly crafted this issue was, I just feel like this story was a disappointment. Snyder makes it difficult to believe that Joker doesn't know their identities and that the Bat-family would abandon Bruce, even though we're supposed to draw exactly those conclusions. To be honest, after the Court of Owls and "Death of the Family," I'm really excited to get a few stand-alone issues on this title for the first time since it launched. I need to be reminded of why I collect this title, since this arc made me continue to wonder.
Teen Titans #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Lobdell tries to do some interesting stuff here, but it just winds up being a mess. I mean, sure, for a moment, I thought that we had confirmation that Joker knew the guys' identities, since he claimed to have their fathers captive. But, I didn't believe that Jason would try to kill Tim for the sake of saving his allegedly alive dead-beat father. But, if you don't believe that, you really don't believe everything that follows. Moreover, I really don't believe that Tim, for how smart he allegedly is, would believe that Jason had killed Joker without verifying it. I mean, how many times has Joker evaded death? Jason shoots him full of holes and they just sit there and shoot the shit? "Hey, man, that Starfire girl is h-o-t. Well done!" "Thanks. It's been a crazy...holy crap, Joker is alive!" Really? Seriously, it's just time for this whole event to end. When it does, I need to make some decisions about whether DC is getting as much money as I've been giving it.
Red Hood and the Outlaws #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is a hot mess. No, really. I'm actually OK, in theory, with it not being about Jason and showing us the Outlaws and the Titans addressing a secondary problem related to Joker; "Detective Comics" #16 did essentially the same thing to great effect. I also don't mind Lobdell using it as a way to get Arsenal to realize that he has something to offer beyond just his bow. In fact, Lobdell almost seems to be setting up Arsenal and Starfire absconding to the Titans, a move that would make sense given their histories and really free up this series to focus on Jason, who's always been the main event. But, he handles the characters here so inartfully that it's hard to believe he writes both series. Arsenal's soliloquies about science make him sound more like Batman and his narration is almost devoid of personality, written solely to move us through recollections and bridge action sequences. Moreover, Wonder Girl is almost unrecognizable and Bunker is portrayed as much more full of doubt than he usually is. I could continue, but, seriously, you just need to know that it was a hot mess and be thankful if you skipped it.
Tuesday, February 12, 2013
Nightwing #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I have to say, I'm pretty damn surprised that Higgins has Joker destroy Haly's Circus here. Plus, when I say destroy, I mean, destroy. From the bodies of deceased members to the lives of current members to the structure of the circus, Joker destroys all of it. Has Higgins been planning on that? Have the last 16 issues of "Nightwing" been setting up this moment, giving Dick a raison d'être in his personal life only to have it ripped from him by Joker? Even for Joker, it's a pretty brutal attack; after all, it stands to reason that Dick's parents' bodies were in there somewhere when Joker brought down the circus.
But, it makes me wonder if Joker has been misrepresenting himself, or, at least, if we've been misinterpreting him. Maybe he doesn't really want to "murder" the Bat-family. It'd be too easy. Maybe the "death" in "Death of the Family" is a metaphorical one. When the dust settles and Barbara contemplates the fact that she was almost driven to murder Joker and Dick realizes that everything that he ever had has been stripped from him (plus whatever Jason and Tim experience at Joker's hands), it stands to reason that they're going to blame Bruce. He knew that Joker knew their identities and he didn't tell them. Sure, Bruce can pretend that he didn't think that Joker really knew. But, he was pretty clearly wrong. So, by not allowing the Bat-family to draw its own conclusions from the evidence, Bruce has made himself solely responsible for this mess. He's the reason that Barbara's mother lost a finger, why Dick lost Haly's Circus totally and completely, and whatever happened to Alfred happened. It's all on him. When they all leave him, furious at him for failing them so greatly, it stands to reason that he'll focus his anger fully on Joker...giving him exactly what he wants.
If Snyder plays it this way, then I buy it. I totally buy it. I buy the estrangement that we're probably going to see in the next few months of Bat-books and the anger that Bruce will likely feel. At this stage, it's the only conclusion that I could see coming from this event that would make me buy it and, increasingly, I think that it's where Snyder et al. are going. Fingers crossed.
But, it makes me wonder if Joker has been misrepresenting himself, or, at least, if we've been misinterpreting him. Maybe he doesn't really want to "murder" the Bat-family. It'd be too easy. Maybe the "death" in "Death of the Family" is a metaphorical one. When the dust settles and Barbara contemplates the fact that she was almost driven to murder Joker and Dick realizes that everything that he ever had has been stripped from him (plus whatever Jason and Tim experience at Joker's hands), it stands to reason that they're going to blame Bruce. He knew that Joker knew their identities and he didn't tell them. Sure, Bruce can pretend that he didn't think that Joker really knew. But, he was pretty clearly wrong. So, by not allowing the Bat-family to draw its own conclusions from the evidence, Bruce has made himself solely responsible for this mess. He's the reason that Barbara's mother lost a finger, why Dick lost Haly's Circus totally and completely, and whatever happened to Alfred happened. It's all on him. When they all leave him, furious at him for failing them so greatly, it stands to reason that he'll focus his anger fully on Joker...giving him exactly what he wants.
If Snyder plays it this way, then I buy it. I totally buy it. I buy the estrangement that we're probably going to see in the next few months of Bat-books and the anger that Bruce will likely feel. At this stage, it's the only conclusion that I could see coming from this event that would make me buy it and, increasingly, I think that it's where Snyder et al. are going. Fingers crossed.
Batgirl #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is odd, mainly because I'm not really sure where we end it.
This issue begins more or less how'd you expect it, with Barbara struggling to keep herself from killing Joker since he has her mother hostage. But, then, James appears and a few things happen that bring us in a different direction than we seemed to have been going. First, James tells Barbara that their mother is safe, which allows her to go wild on Joker. Interestingly, Simone doesn't let us learn if Barbara would've killed Joker, since James chloroforms her before she can do so. We then learn that James made a deal with Joker to give her to Joker in exchange for his mother. I'm all good until this point. In fact, I thought James was a great addition to this issue, really ramping up the tension (as he's wont to do). I particularly loved the part where James impresses Joker. Snyder made it very clear that his James was the once and future Joker in his DCU "Detective Comics" run and Joker himself seems to realize that in this moment. I loved that.
But, I don't get where we are at the end. Joker was going to cut off Batgirl's arms and legs as a "wedding present," so it's possible that it's her limbs under the domed plate. It's possible, but, unlikely. Since Penguin and Two-Face recognized whatever is under the dome in "Batman" #16, it seems pretty obvious that it's a head of someone familiar. Maybe it's Barbara's face, but I sort of doubt that they'd recognize that. So, if Joker didn't do anything to Barbara, it raises the question why he didn't. James clearly interrupted whatever Joker was planning for Barbara and maybe Joker was just bluffing about cutting off her arms and legs; if you're working under the theory that he knows that she's Barbara Gordon, then it makes sense, in a Joker way, to threaten to do to her something that she couldn't undo, like she "undid" her paralysis. But, he's been talking about the "role" that she has to play in his final fight with Batman. Why would James' interruption change his plans for Barbara? I guess we still have time for Snyder to reveal that plan, but I felt like this issue, and Barbara's own arc with Joker, ended fairly abruptly, jettisoning a lot of the story that we've seen to this point in the rush to set up "Batman" #17.
This issue begins more or less how'd you expect it, with Barbara struggling to keep herself from killing Joker since he has her mother hostage. But, then, James appears and a few things happen that bring us in a different direction than we seemed to have been going. First, James tells Barbara that their mother is safe, which allows her to go wild on Joker. Interestingly, Simone doesn't let us learn if Barbara would've killed Joker, since James chloroforms her before she can do so. We then learn that James made a deal with Joker to give her to Joker in exchange for his mother. I'm all good until this point. In fact, I thought James was a great addition to this issue, really ramping up the tension (as he's wont to do). I particularly loved the part where James impresses Joker. Snyder made it very clear that his James was the once and future Joker in his DCU "Detective Comics" run and Joker himself seems to realize that in this moment. I loved that.
But, I don't get where we are at the end. Joker was going to cut off Batgirl's arms and legs as a "wedding present," so it's possible that it's her limbs under the domed plate. It's possible, but, unlikely. Since Penguin and Two-Face recognized whatever is under the dome in "Batman" #16, it seems pretty obvious that it's a head of someone familiar. Maybe it's Barbara's face, but I sort of doubt that they'd recognize that. So, if Joker didn't do anything to Barbara, it raises the question why he didn't. James clearly interrupted whatever Joker was planning for Barbara and maybe Joker was just bluffing about cutting off her arms and legs; if you're working under the theory that he knows that she's Barbara Gordon, then it makes sense, in a Joker way, to threaten to do to her something that she couldn't undo, like she "undid" her paralysis. But, he's been talking about the "role" that she has to play in his final fight with Batman. Why would James' interruption change his plans for Barbara? I guess we still have time for Snyder to reveal that plan, but I felt like this issue, and Barbara's own arc with Joker, ended fairly abruptly, jettisoning a lot of the story that we've seen to this point in the rush to set up "Batman" #17.
Detective Comics #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue has almost nothing to do with "Death of the Family." In fact, if I had to place it in continuity, I'd have to put it somewhere before issue #14, before Bruce actually confronts Joker. But, it is, nonetheless, a Joker story, with Layman showing us the effect that Joker has on Gotham. It's often been said that Batman actually causes Gotham's problems with crime because he inspires a certain level of craziness in the super-villains that he winds up having to confront. Here, Layman posits that the super-villains themselves serve as a multiplying force for that effect, inspiring their own legion of villains and copy-cats. My favorite Batman stories are the ones where we get to interact with Gotham in a way that shows how people live day-to-day, answering the age-old question, "Why do people still live there?" It's why I liked the early few issues of "Batwoman," which did a great job showing Kate Kane living her life in Gotham. Here, Layman gives us exactly this sort of story, showing us the effect that Joker is having on regular people. It's not a necessary read, but it definitely tells a story that I think is worth considering.
Batman and Robin #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I wound up enjoying this issue more than I did last issue, if only because Tomasi gave us a pretty tightly scripted battle between Damian and "Batman" and avoided some of the "Death of the Family" baggage in the process. I actually thought that it was Batman for most of this issue, given that it made sense that Joker could've injected him with a Joker serum after the events of "Batman" #16. The revelation that it wasn't him didn't do anything to diminish the story, though, since the whole point was to show a devastated and weakened Damian played right to where Joker wanted him. Snyder et al. are certainly playing up this mysterious platter, though this issue doesn't really give us any hints whose head might be in it. Joker does mention the family skeletons being removed from the closet and uses a quote that sounds suspiciously similar to Jack Napier's, "Ever dance with the Devil in the pale moonlight?" quote from the original Batman movie. But, unless it's Jack Nicholson's head, I'm not sure what the connection will be. I guess we'll see.
Batman #16 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
When I saw that CNN was running a story on "Batman" #17, I managed not to read it. But, given that temptation is strong, I realized that I need to prioritize reading "Death of the Family" as I make my way through my back issues so that I don't wind up caving and getting the answer spoiled.
I will say that everything seems to be happening pretty fast. Compared to the year-long Court of Owls story, this story has unfolded quickly. Joker had a few opening moves: kidnapping Alfred, killing the cops at GCPD, and poisoning Commissioner Gordon, not to mention everything he's been doing in the other titles. But, the conflict with Batman has been pretty quick. He tricked him into going to Ace Chemicals, where Harley attacked him, confronted him at the reservoir, where he "revealed" that he knew his identity, and then lured him into Arkham Asylum. Maybe it's just because the beginning of the Court of Owls story was so brilliantly paced, but I do feel like Snyder is moving us through this arc a little too briskly. He seems to be relying on the tie-in issues to show the breadth of Joker's plans, leaving the story in "Batman" as a more frontal assault. It feels a little more Hush-y than it does Joker-y.
At any rate, Snyder builds the tension well here, but, essentially, nothing really happens. Batman makes his way through Arkham as Joker taunts him, eventually finding Joker in Jeremiah Arkham's private chambers, where he's assembled the "Batking's" court. The Penguin, Ridder, and Two-Face angle is funny, but I'm not entirely sure if we're supposed to recognize the four people that he has playing Aquaman, Green Lantern, Superman, and Wonder Woman. Even if we are, though, we're not given all that much time to recognize them, since this scene is really a feint, building up Bruce's confidence that he's managed to capture Joker only to reveal that Joker is holding (or has killed) the Bat-family.
It's here where Snyder takes an odd turn, having Bruce willingly sit on an electrical chair. I'm assuming that Bruce didn't think that he was going to kill himself, but Snyder doesn't make that entirely clear. Moreover, the secret identity issue rears its ugly head here again. For all the hand-wringing over whether Joker knows Batman's identity or not, Snyder makes it completely irrelevant with this scene (but not in a good way). If Joker really wanted to know, he very easily could, pulling off the unconscious Batman's mask. But, he doesn't. So, again, it either means that he knows or he doesn't care, once again showing how ridiculous it is for Snyder to put this question at the center of the story.
The real question at this point is pretty clearly whether Alfred's head is on the platter that Joker shows Penguin and Two-Face. Now, even if it is, it's pretty easy to dismiss that "revelation" as shock value. After all, the Dollmaker made Joker a living tapestry, so it seems plausible that he could gin up a reasonable facsimile of Alfred's head. The other question is how Joker defeated the various Bat-family members, a question that I assume that I'm going to get answered in the various tie-in issues that I'm going to read next.
But, I have to wonder if I care about the answer to either question. I mean, even if Joker did cut off Alfred's head, do I really think that he's going to stay dead? I mean, as we've already established, Alfred, Bruce, and Jason have all died and returned; Barbara and Bruce were both paralyzed and can walk again. At this stage, only Dick and Tim haven't gone through some sort of miraculous resurrection/healing (though, honestly, they may have and I just forgot about it). Moreover, any assurances after the fact that "Alfred is really dead" from DC would be met with as much belief as the "Peter Parker is really dead" assurances from Marvel.
Maybe at the end of the day, my problem with this arc is exactly that. It plays on two of the oldest tropes -- secret identities and dramatic deaths -- in comics that have lost their punch over the years. The Court of Owls arc, in the beginning, was interesting because it spoke to whether Bruce understood the city as well as he thought he did. This arc just brings us stuff -- including a title -- that we've seen time and time again.
I will say that everything seems to be happening pretty fast. Compared to the year-long Court of Owls story, this story has unfolded quickly. Joker had a few opening moves: kidnapping Alfred, killing the cops at GCPD, and poisoning Commissioner Gordon, not to mention everything he's been doing in the other titles. But, the conflict with Batman has been pretty quick. He tricked him into going to Ace Chemicals, where Harley attacked him, confronted him at the reservoir, where he "revealed" that he knew his identity, and then lured him into Arkham Asylum. Maybe it's just because the beginning of the Court of Owls story was so brilliantly paced, but I do feel like Snyder is moving us through this arc a little too briskly. He seems to be relying on the tie-in issues to show the breadth of Joker's plans, leaving the story in "Batman" as a more frontal assault. It feels a little more Hush-y than it does Joker-y.
At any rate, Snyder builds the tension well here, but, essentially, nothing really happens. Batman makes his way through Arkham as Joker taunts him, eventually finding Joker in Jeremiah Arkham's private chambers, where he's assembled the "Batking's" court. The Penguin, Ridder, and Two-Face angle is funny, but I'm not entirely sure if we're supposed to recognize the four people that he has playing Aquaman, Green Lantern, Superman, and Wonder Woman. Even if we are, though, we're not given all that much time to recognize them, since this scene is really a feint, building up Bruce's confidence that he's managed to capture Joker only to reveal that Joker is holding (or has killed) the Bat-family.
It's here where Snyder takes an odd turn, having Bruce willingly sit on an electrical chair. I'm assuming that Bruce didn't think that he was going to kill himself, but Snyder doesn't make that entirely clear. Moreover, the secret identity issue rears its ugly head here again. For all the hand-wringing over whether Joker knows Batman's identity or not, Snyder makes it completely irrelevant with this scene (but not in a good way). If Joker really wanted to know, he very easily could, pulling off the unconscious Batman's mask. But, he doesn't. So, again, it either means that he knows or he doesn't care, once again showing how ridiculous it is for Snyder to put this question at the center of the story.
The real question at this point is pretty clearly whether Alfred's head is on the platter that Joker shows Penguin and Two-Face. Now, even if it is, it's pretty easy to dismiss that "revelation" as shock value. After all, the Dollmaker made Joker a living tapestry, so it seems plausible that he could gin up a reasonable facsimile of Alfred's head. The other question is how Joker defeated the various Bat-family members, a question that I assume that I'm going to get answered in the various tie-in issues that I'm going to read next.
But, I have to wonder if I care about the answer to either question. I mean, even if Joker did cut off Alfred's head, do I really think that he's going to stay dead? I mean, as we've already established, Alfred, Bruce, and Jason have all died and returned; Barbara and Bruce were both paralyzed and can walk again. At this stage, only Dick and Tim haven't gone through some sort of miraculous resurrection/healing (though, honestly, they may have and I just forgot about it). Moreover, any assurances after the fact that "Alfred is really dead" from DC would be met with as much belief as the "Peter Parker is really dead" assurances from Marvel.
Maybe at the end of the day, my problem with this arc is exactly that. It plays on two of the oldest tropes -- secret identities and dramatic deaths -- in comics that have lost their punch over the years. The Court of Owls arc, in the beginning, was interesting because it spoke to whether Bruce understood the city as well as he thought he did. This arc just brings us stuff -- including a title -- that we've seen time and time again.
Captain Marvel #8 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
DeConnick manages to wrap up this story in a way that somehow combines the weakened levees, the missing boats, and the Captain Marvels. I'll admit that it felt a little forced, but the explanation that robots formerly belonging to Hogarth Hamontree were slowly recharging and rebuilding themselves with materials available to them while they lay dormant in the Gulf of Mexico is a more sensible explanation than I figured that we'd get, given how these stories often go. DeConnick doesn't make it feel like a MacGuffin, a nonsensical plot point used merely to set up the conflict. It felt like something that could happen, even if it seems pretty unlikely.
But, the main draw is her interactions with Monica, who I hope we see again soon. The action is fast paced, with Carol and Monica's powers complementing one another nicely to create some great sequences. I enjoyed their good-natured teasing and I could see it getting all the better if Monica really has seen inside Carol's brain (or, even, if she just pretends to have seen inside it). Moreover, Frank seems like a nicely evolved straight guy, so I'd be happy to see him hang around a little longer. All in all, this series continues to move along swimmingly.
But, the main draw is her interactions with Monica, who I hope we see again soon. The action is fast paced, with Carol and Monica's powers complementing one another nicely to create some great sequences. I enjoyed their good-natured teasing and I could see it getting all the better if Monica really has seen inside Carol's brain (or, even, if she just pretends to have seen inside it). Moreover, Frank seems like a nicely evolved straight guy, so I'd be happy to see him hang around a little longer. All in all, this series continues to move along swimmingly.
Monday, February 11, 2013
Captain America #2 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
When I turned to the first page, with its "One Year Later" dramatically printed on black, I admit that I gasped. I wasn't expecting it and I instantly found myself pulled into the story that Remender planned on telling. But, almost as quickly, I found myself worrying about continuity, wondering how Remender was going to get me to believe that the Captain America that I just saw in "Avengers" #2 had somehow been gone a year. After reading comics for 30 years, I immediately figured that Remender would have to go "Adventures of Cyclops and Phoenix" in the end: Steve would raise a child, but he would leave him to his world and return to his own world mere moments after he left.
But, soon, Remender made me care less about the logistics. Instead, he had me immersed in the story that he was actually telling, the story of a man protecting his son. It was a poignant moment, to say the least. After reading about Captain America for a long time, it's always been pretty clear that he never really saw himself as a father. In fact, in the first issue of this series, he wonders if he can even be a husband. Brubaker never really addressed the issue of the baby that Steve and Sharon lost as a result of the Red Skull. I'm not even sure if Steve knows that Sharon was pregnant. But, here, Steve is a father, falling into a role similar to the father in Cormac McCarthy's "The Road," guiding his charge through an inhospitable landscape, unable to surrender in the face of adversity because of the overwhelming responsibility that he has to that child. It makes the end all the more profound. Is Remender going to kill Ian? Remender seems to have put everything on the table here and I'm scared for Ian. Moreover, is Steve's parenting of Ian going to push Steve closer to Sharon or further from her when he returns? Remender is clearly building to that moment, given that he had Sharon propose in the first issue. The fact that I don't know what the answer is going to be shows just how magic what Remender is doing here.
I haven't been all that impressed with a lot of the comics that I've been reading over the last few weeks. Between Doctor Octopus becoming Spider-Man or the Joker suddenly making us all feel like idiots for ever believing that he hasn't known the identities of the Bat-family, it's all just felt...silly. It's all been recycled plots without a lot of actual heart. I'm not sure what Snyder wants me to be feeling when I read "Death of the Family," but I'm definitely not feeling it, whatever it is. I was seriously contemplating just ditching a whole lot of titles, feeling the same sort of resignation that I felt right before I quit comics the last time. But, not to overdo it, this issue actually reminded me why I like comics. I can read a story about a guy stuck in another dimension, defending a child genetically manufactured from his own DNA from alien monsters, and be moved by the humanity that the hero shows. Remender makes us care about the two people on the page here and the relationship that they have with one another and, at the end of the day, it's that dynamic that makes us all read comics. It's not really seeing if we can figure out Joker's next steps or how Spidey is going to escape this particular trap. I mean, it's part of the fun, but, if you miss that core reality -- that we're here for the relationships -- everything else feels hollow. So, thanks, Rick Remender, for remembering that.
But, soon, Remender made me care less about the logistics. Instead, he had me immersed in the story that he was actually telling, the story of a man protecting his son. It was a poignant moment, to say the least. After reading about Captain America for a long time, it's always been pretty clear that he never really saw himself as a father. In fact, in the first issue of this series, he wonders if he can even be a husband. Brubaker never really addressed the issue of the baby that Steve and Sharon lost as a result of the Red Skull. I'm not even sure if Steve knows that Sharon was pregnant. But, here, Steve is a father, falling into a role similar to the father in Cormac McCarthy's "The Road," guiding his charge through an inhospitable landscape, unable to surrender in the face of adversity because of the overwhelming responsibility that he has to that child. It makes the end all the more profound. Is Remender going to kill Ian? Remender seems to have put everything on the table here and I'm scared for Ian. Moreover, is Steve's parenting of Ian going to push Steve closer to Sharon or further from her when he returns? Remender is clearly building to that moment, given that he had Sharon propose in the first issue. The fact that I don't know what the answer is going to be shows just how magic what Remender is doing here.
I haven't been all that impressed with a lot of the comics that I've been reading over the last few weeks. Between Doctor Octopus becoming Spider-Man or the Joker suddenly making us all feel like idiots for ever believing that he hasn't known the identities of the Bat-family, it's all just felt...silly. It's all been recycled plots without a lot of actual heart. I'm not sure what Snyder wants me to be feeling when I read "Death of the Family," but I'm definitely not feeling it, whatever it is. I was seriously contemplating just ditching a whole lot of titles, feeling the same sort of resignation that I felt right before I quit comics the last time. But, not to overdo it, this issue actually reminded me why I like comics. I can read a story about a guy stuck in another dimension, defending a child genetically manufactured from his own DNA from alien monsters, and be moved by the humanity that the hero shows. Remender makes us care about the two people on the page here and the relationship that they have with one another and, at the end of the day, it's that dynamic that makes us all read comics. It's not really seeing if we can figure out Joker's next steps or how Spidey is going to escape this particular trap. I mean, it's part of the fun, but, if you miss that core reality -- that we're here for the relationships -- everything else feels hollow. So, thanks, Rick Remender, for remembering that.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)