As I was writing my reviews of "Avengers" and "New Avengers" #34, I decided that I couldn't let the end of Bendis' run on those series pass without commenting on it.
I've made it pretty obvious over the years that I haven't been a fan of Bendis's run on the Avengers titles. I actually loved "Siege," the first work of Bendis' that I ever read. But, his tenure on the Avengers titles focused too much on the grand battles that made "Siege" work and and too little on the character development and team dynamics that make "Avengers" work. Bendis frequently played fast and loose with continuities, changing characters' histories and personalities to make them match whatever story he was telling at the time. Partly as such, it seems unlikely that any he told in his run is going to have a lasting impact. Wonder Man suddenly hated the Avengers, the Scarlet Witch suddenly went crazy (again), Iron Man believed in big government. All of a sudden it seemed possible that Cap would start praising the virtue of the Nazis or Namor would start waxing poetic about humans.
Of course, the impact of these fluctuations in characterization was at least muted by the fact that Bendis was often juggling at least a dozen characters in each issue, so you didn't have time to linger over your confusion. "Why is Hawkeye encouraging everyone to file their taxes on tim...wait, is Spider-Man killing someone?" In fact, Bendis cycled so many characters through "Avengers" and "New Avengers," with so much overlap, that I'm actually hard pressed to tell you the actual roster of each team.
In his farewell letter, Bendis admits that his goal was to basically tell slug-fest stories. He tells us that he just wanted to tell the stories that he wanted to read. Basically, he admits that it was all about him. He was less concerned about telling a story that developed the characters and more concerned about seeing how many superheroes he could cram onto a page at a time. I get fun. I do. But, I feel bad for Bendis that he thinks the Avengers are just a pale imitation of the Justice League.
One of the Avengers runs that I remember most is Bob Harras' in the mid-300s. It involved the Black Knight/Crystal/Sersi love triangle and the mysterious Proctor and the Gatherers. I actually remember feeling frustrated with it at the time, in part because I was an impatient teenager who didn't understand why Harras couldn't just tell us Proctor's identity. But, after all these years, I remember those comics so vividly because Harras didn't rush those stories. He let them develop at a natural pace. He'd go and tell other stories, and other authors would come and tell other stories, and then he'd return to the story to thicken the plot.
It wasn't really an A-list roster. Sure, you had Cap, but everyone else was pretty B-list: Black Knight, Black Widow, Crystal, Giant Man, Hercules, Sersi, and Vision. But, Harras did a great job of playing up the affections and tensions between them. I remember feeling devastated for Crystal when Dane took Sersi's hand and stepped through that portal. We had gone through so much by that point that it seemed cruel that they didn't get a chance to have their happy ending. But, the fact that I felt that way showed how much I cared. It reminds me now of the great scene at the end of "Avengers" #230 when Hank finally leaves and Captain Marvel and She-Hulk comfort a crying Jan. The Avengers have never been the Justice League. They've always been a family.
Bendis never got that. He never got that I think most of us rarely remember battle sequences from comics. But, I do remember Cap holding up the Cosmic Cube and telling Bucky to remember who he is and I remember Beast making a witty remark while grabbing Jean right before Cyclops obliterated Mr. Sinister. I remember Jean using her telekinesis to dance with Professor X at her wedding and I remember the pancake breakfast the X-Men had after defeating Onslaught. I remember a woman giving Spidey a box of macaroons after he stopped a thief from stealing her purse right before Christmas and I remember Spidey crying next to Harry Osborn's body. I remember Jason Todd dying and I remember Tim Drake reminding Batman why he needs a Robin. I remember realizing what a man Nova had become and Mary Jane reminding Peter that he'll always find a way to save the day. I remember those moments because I care about those characters and the authors knew that.
I can't recall a single moment from Bendis' run that rises to that level. I've read his run on Avengers for three years and nothing comes to mind. The only moment that comes close is Tony Stark telling Steve Rogers that he's not nearly as good at doing something as he is when he's doing it with Steve from "Avengers Prime" #5. But, Bendis decided that story couldn't get told in the main series. He made it pretty clear that character development had no business in "Avengers."
Bendis is writing the X-Men now. He's writing about a team with even deeper emotional connections to each other. I hope he remembers that. I hope he takes the time to really ponder what Scott's fall means for Beast or Iceman or Storm. I mean, don't get me wrong: I really would love to see Bobby kick Scott's ass. But, maybe he could actually reflect on it afterwards.
So, ciao, Bendis. I wish I had something better to say. I probably would've avoiding saying anything at all, but I couldn't just let you claim that the Avengers are a pale imitation of the Justice League and not defend them. At least now I can read the Avengers without feeling bad about myself for paying money to do so.
I cover a lot of different titles, with some particular attention to the previous runs of "Spider-Man 2099" and "Nova." Welcome back, Richard! Until next time, Miguel.
Showing posts with label Avengers (2010). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Avengers (2010). Show all posts
Thursday, November 29, 2012
Avengers #34 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
And so it ends. The Bendis era is over.
Unlike the story that he's telling in "New Avengers," Bendis tells a real, honest-to-goodness Avengers story in his last arc. It's not an over-the-top, everyone-but-Squirrel-Girl-(oh-wait-no-it-has-Squirrel-Girl-too) story, like the Infinity Gauntlet arc or the "H.A.M.M.E.R. War." It consists of an actual team of five (and then six) heroes, with long-standing ties to the Avengers and to each other. It doesn't involve everyone on the team just randomly hitting on the villain, but shows them displaying actual teamwork that helps them win. In other words, at long last, after eight years, Bendis finally wrote an "Avengers" story.
Unlike the story that he's telling in "New Avengers," Bendis tells a real, honest-to-goodness Avengers story in his last arc. It's not an over-the-top, everyone-but-Squirrel-Girl-(oh-wait-no-it-has-Squirrel-Girl-too) story, like the Infinity Gauntlet arc or the "H.A.M.M.E.R. War." It consists of an actual team of five (and then six) heroes, with long-standing ties to the Avengers and to each other. It doesn't involve everyone on the team just randomly hitting on the villain, but shows them displaying actual teamwork that helps them win. In other words, at long last, after eight years, Bendis finally wrote an "Avengers" story.
Saturday, November 10, 2012
Avengers #33 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Bendis continues to channel George Lucas in this issue (and the fact that it's an improvement says a lot more about Bendis than it does about Lucas). Thor and Jan's conversation in their cell is reminiscent of the great scene on the skiff in "Return of the Jedi," where Han expresses dismay when Luke tells him that things are going the way that they usually go for them. In addition to being funny, it also manages to be a touching moment, with Bendis making palpable the relief that Thor feels at the discovery that he did not, in fact, kill Jan during "Secret Invasion." Bendis also manages to inject some honest-to-goodness drama into this issue, with the Avengers getting their asses handed to them due mostly to the unpredictable nature of the Microverse's effect on them. (I'll note that I don't remember the Microverse having a negative effect on the FF and Spidey during their journey there in "Amazing Spider-Man" #590-1 and it doesn't seem to be having one on Kaine and Venom, who are there right now as part of "Minimum Carnage." But, I'm actually enjoying this arc, so I'm going to try really hard not to focus too much on details like that one.) The guys will eventually find a way to adapt and hand Lord Centaur a rousing defeat. But, in the meantime, it's a nice change of pace to watch them face some actual opposition and not waltz their way through a fight. In the end, we'll be reminded of why they got together in the first place, why they're more than the sum of their parts, and it's definitely a nice touch on Bendis' part to draw those parallels as he wraps up his run.
Sunday, October 28, 2012
Avengers #32 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
To be honest? I love this issue. LOVE IT. I know I've been hating on Bendis lately and it doesn't change the fact that I really think that it's time for him to go, but, honest to God, I enjoyed this issue from start to finish.
First, he manages to bring back Janet in a way that makes total sense, at least in the context of comic-book resurrections. I'll buy the fact that she wound up shrunk into the Microverse when she exploded; after all, it's the opposite of what was happening to her when she "died," namely that she was growing at too fast of a rate. (I wasn't reading "Avengers" then, so, thank you, Wikipedia, for that synopsis.) Bendis also builds to the moment well. Although it's pretty clear after a page or so that we're dealing with Janet (and not Rita DeMara, as I originally thought), I still found myself holding my breath as the Avengers gathered on the spot in Central Park where she "died." When it was the original Avengers -- Ant-Man, Captain America, Iron Man, and Thor -- who walked through that portal I knew that it was go time.
But, the really exciting part is that Bendis manages to remind us why she's been so missed in the first place. In fact, Bendis' type of corny humor seems perfectly suited for Jan, who's always been prone to delivering a good soliloquy about the amazing wonderfulness of chocolate shakes. Whereas he often seems to be forcing his brand of hilarity onto certain characters, it seems to really work with Jan, energizing the whole book. It makes you wonder how much better it would've worked if she had been here all along. I loved when she exclaims how she's not good at extricating herself from jams but managed to make it happen. Most superheroes are portrayed as geniuses and wise and crafty and resourceful. However, in real life, those traits rarely go together and I love Janet knowing that she's not so great at one aspect of superheroing, namely, the resourcefulness part. It reminds us that Jan has always been a particularly human superhero, one who doesn't define herself just by her status as a superhero. I also loved the guys' deadpan reactions to her discovery. Was the mouth-on-mouth kissing a little much? Sure. Does it kind of fit with Jan, though? Yes. Yes, it does. It also fits with Jan that she's also basically running a one-woman rebellion against a dictator. So, let's kick some centaur ass and get her home.
First, he manages to bring back Janet in a way that makes total sense, at least in the context of comic-book resurrections. I'll buy the fact that she wound up shrunk into the Microverse when she exploded; after all, it's the opposite of what was happening to her when she "died," namely that she was growing at too fast of a rate. (I wasn't reading "Avengers" then, so, thank you, Wikipedia, for that synopsis.) Bendis also builds to the moment well. Although it's pretty clear after a page or so that we're dealing with Janet (and not Rita DeMara, as I originally thought), I still found myself holding my breath as the Avengers gathered on the spot in Central Park where she "died." When it was the original Avengers -- Ant-Man, Captain America, Iron Man, and Thor -- who walked through that portal I knew that it was go time.
But, the really exciting part is that Bendis manages to remind us why she's been so missed in the first place. In fact, Bendis' type of corny humor seems perfectly suited for Jan, who's always been prone to delivering a good soliloquy about the amazing wonderfulness of chocolate shakes. Whereas he often seems to be forcing his brand of hilarity onto certain characters, it seems to really work with Jan, energizing the whole book. It makes you wonder how much better it would've worked if she had been here all along. I loved when she exclaims how she's not good at extricating herself from jams but managed to make it happen. Most superheroes are portrayed as geniuses and wise and crafty and resourceful. However, in real life, those traits rarely go together and I love Janet knowing that she's not so great at one aspect of superheroing, namely, the resourcefulness part. It reminds us that Jan has always been a particularly human superhero, one who doesn't define herself just by her status as a superhero. I also loved the guys' deadpan reactions to her discovery. Was the mouth-on-mouth kissing a little much? Sure. Does it kind of fit with Jan, though? Yes. Yes, it does. It also fits with Jan that she's also basically running a one-woman rebellion against a dictator. So, let's kick some centaur ass and get her home.
Wednesday, October 17, 2012
Avengers #31 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I can't tell if my disappointment with this issue has to do with the plot or if I'm just so damned tired with the way that Bendis sets up stories that I just can't do it anymore.
Bendis drops us in medias res as some woman on a speeder bike in a "Dune" setting escapes some dudes on speeder bikes. One of the dudes manages to destroy her bike and attacks her, but she defeats him, making her way on foot to her destination, a city in the distance. Meanwhile, at Avengers Towers, the Avenger are enjoying a break after the events of "Avengers vs. X-Men" when Cap is surprised by a visit from Simon Williams. Simon apologizes to Cap for the Revengers, telling him that he feels like he's in the middle of a nervous breakdown. Cap offers to help him, but, before Simon can accept the offer, the Rulk attacks. Simon makes quick work of him, announcing to no one in particular that he knew it wouldn't be easy and pledging to make amends. He then disappears. In "Dune" land, the woman has arrived in the city and convinces someone to transmit a signal using an Avengers membership card, a signal that eventually wakes up Tony from his nap. Tony assembles the Avengers to inform them that the signal came from inner space and the scene ends before we learn who transmitted it.
As usual with Bendis, this issue shows the hint of promise for the rest of the arc, but I'm not convinced that it's going to fulfill that promise. The best parts of this issue involve the mysterious woman. I'm guessing that she might by Yellowjacket, a.k.a. Rita DeMara, since she was resurrected after "Chaos War" and it would make sense that she would somehow find herself stranded in inner space. The worst parts of this issue involved Wonder Man. I never bought the Revengers storyline, and I don't know why Bendis insists on returning to this subject. Throughout his run, Bendis just seems to have these moments where he refuses to let a plot die, no matter how much it should die. I mean, why bring in Wonder Man now to apologize? Didn't Cyclops just prove him correct? Couldn't you argue that the Avengers and the X-Men did make matters worse, just by their mere presence? I'm not saying I personally would argue that, but I think someone like Simon could make a pretty compelling argument to that effect. Why have him apologize now then?
Looking at the issue on the whole, the inner-space sub-plot doesn't seem to have anything to do with the Simon Williams sub-plot. How Bendis marries these two sub-plots is obviously going to determine how this arc goes. I'm trying to optimistic. I am. Really.
Bendis drops us in medias res as some woman on a speeder bike in a "Dune" setting escapes some dudes on speeder bikes. One of the dudes manages to destroy her bike and attacks her, but she defeats him, making her way on foot to her destination, a city in the distance. Meanwhile, at Avengers Towers, the Avenger are enjoying a break after the events of "Avengers vs. X-Men" when Cap is surprised by a visit from Simon Williams. Simon apologizes to Cap for the Revengers, telling him that he feels like he's in the middle of a nervous breakdown. Cap offers to help him, but, before Simon can accept the offer, the Rulk attacks. Simon makes quick work of him, announcing to no one in particular that he knew it wouldn't be easy and pledging to make amends. He then disappears. In "Dune" land, the woman has arrived in the city and convinces someone to transmit a signal using an Avengers membership card, a signal that eventually wakes up Tony from his nap. Tony assembles the Avengers to inform them that the signal came from inner space and the scene ends before we learn who transmitted it.
As usual with Bendis, this issue shows the hint of promise for the rest of the arc, but I'm not convinced that it's going to fulfill that promise. The best parts of this issue involve the mysterious woman. I'm guessing that she might by Yellowjacket, a.k.a. Rita DeMara, since she was resurrected after "Chaos War" and it would make sense that she would somehow find herself stranded in inner space. The worst parts of this issue involved Wonder Man. I never bought the Revengers storyline, and I don't know why Bendis insists on returning to this subject. Throughout his run, Bendis just seems to have these moments where he refuses to let a plot die, no matter how much it should die. I mean, why bring in Wonder Man now to apologize? Didn't Cyclops just prove him correct? Couldn't you argue that the Avengers and the X-Men did make matters worse, just by their mere presence? I'm not saying I personally would argue that, but I think someone like Simon could make a pretty compelling argument to that effect. Why have him apologize now then?
Looking at the issue on the whole, the inner-space sub-plot doesn't seem to have anything to do with the Simon Williams sub-plot. How Bendis marries these two sub-plots is obviously going to determine how this arc goes. I'm trying to optimistic. I am. Really.
Wednesday, September 19, 2012
New Comics: "Avengers vs. X-Men" Edition #15
Avengers #30: OMG, this issue is awful. I never wanted to hear Spider-Woman talk about her period. Bendis somehow manages to...I mean, he...you know, I can't even do it. Given the fact that Hawkeye and Spider-Woman are involved in the attack on Cyclops and Emma Frost depicted on the first two pages of this issue, I'm going to pretend that it was just a hypothetical exploration of the possibility that Hawkeye and Spider-Women weren't part of the events of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #11 and instead tried to keep order while everyone was distracted. I'm not even going to mention the fat that we also have pet peeve #2 here, since we at no point see the duo leading some sort of rag-tag team of survivors of an apocalypse, as seemingly depicted on the cover. La la la. None of it ever happened.
Thursday, August 23, 2012
New Comics!: The "Avengers vs. X-Men" Edition #12 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Avengers vs X-Men #10: Until now, Cyclops has seemed to be managing the Phoenix Force pretty well compared to his fellow members of the Phoenix Five. Whereas everyone else has had the darkest parts of their soul amplified by Phoenix, Scott has held a pretty firm line on the fact that the Phoenix Five were trying to help the world. He refused the entreaties of other members of the Phoenix Five to take a more aggressive approach with the Avengers, insisting that getting aggressive would only serve to help the Avengers paint them as the bad guys. That plan goes out the window in this issue when he decides to stop being Mr. Nice Guy to get his hands on Hope.
At this stage, I have two major questions that I would like to see answered before this series ends. First, why does Cyclops care about Hope? In the beginning, before he even conceived of himself as playing host to Phoenix, he needed Hope since she was the obvious avatar of the Phoenix Force and, therefore, the person who could use Phoenix's power to bring about the rebirth of the mutant race. But, he now possesses 1/2 of the Phoenix Force's power and, based on the cover image of issue #11, might soon possess all of it. As such, why does he still need Hope? Does he plan on surrendering his power to her? It doesn't seem like it, particularly given comments that he previously made to her (I think in issue #6) about Phoenix not wanting her anymore after Hope rejected it. Does he want her simply so that the Avengers can't use her against him? I think that's the real reason, but he doesn't seem to think about it that way. I think that it would be helpful to see him explain why he wants Hope.
Second, what's Cyclops' plan, exactly? In the beginning, he wanted Hope to use the Phoenix Force to restart the mutant race. But, we haven't seen any indication, since coming into possession of Phoenix's power himself, that he or any other member of the Phoenix Five have done anything to make that happen. Is his plan simply to rule? Is that, again, why he wants Hope? Does he want her not so that she can become the avatar of Phoenix, but so that she doesn't become a rival to him? Again, I think that the last two issues probably need to address his plan at some point, particularly if he does defeat Emma and becomes the sole Phoenix.
Looking beyond the larger plot, this issue is tense. It didn't surprise me when I looked, after I read it, and saw that Brubaker wrote it. Brubaker has excelled in telling these sort of tightly scripted thrillers in "Captain America" and "Winter Soldier," and this issue is no different. He initially portrays Scott as a benevolent dictator whose patience with his wayward subjects finally comes to an end. Slowly but surely, however, as Scott makes his way through K'un Lun, Brubaker makes it clear that Scott is just as despotic as Emma, who we see here subjugating the rest of the X-Men on Utopia. Brubaker scripts this issue like a horror movie, giving us a disturbing Cyclops roaming around an empty K'un Lun calling out Hope's name. "Come out, Hope. I'm not here to hurt you." Sure, you're not, Summers. Sure, you're not. Brubaker uses small moments to show how far gone Scott is, like the petulant comment that he makes after taking down Hawkeye, Thing, and Thor: "How's that for clobbering time?" But, Brubaker also excels when focusing on the other side, showing us a terrified Hope fleeing from Cyclops. Brubaker implies no shame in her fear, since, after all, it's pretty understandable that anyone, let alone a teenaged girl, would be pretty damned frightened if a demi-god was coming after her. Hope runs into the arms of the Thunderer and the Scarlet Witch and Brubaker uses the moment to show the adults doing their best to do right by her.
In the end, though, it's Hope's show. Brubaker's contribution to this series is to draw back the story, which has wandered over the course of Act Two, to the core conceit, namely Hope's relationship with Phoenix. As I hoped last issue, we see her kick Scott's ass here. It's a satisfying moment, but the decision (seemingly) to activate Hope's Iron Fist powers raised some questions in my mind. One of the authors' odder decisions has been tying the powers of the Phoenix Force to those of the Iron Fist and Scarlet Witch. Tony Stark has spent almost the entire mini-series trying to find the connection between the three entities, and I've been trying to be patient (even though it's pretty hard to imagine the Iron Fist connection being in play had Bendis not resurrected him from obscurity in his run on Avengers). After ten issues, though, I'm still not entirely sure why we needed to involve the Iron Fist AND Scarlet Witch in this endeavor, particularly when, as we see here, Hope's connection to the Phoenix Force continues to be the most interesting.
With the return to focus on Hope's relationship with Phoenix, I'm hoping we make some quick progress in the next issue. We seem to be missing quite a few potential players on the board (Cable, Jean Grey, Professor X, Scarlet Witch beyond her random whack-a-mole-esque appearances over the last few issues). Although the authors have done a great job of adding plot twists without making them seem just like diversions and misdirections, it's time to address the issues that I raised above, namely, what's Hope's future and how does it impact the mutant race. I'm worried, though, we're going to focus next issue on the manufactured connection to the Iron Fist energy and the Scarlet Witch's powers and the last issue is going to be a mad rush to the finish. We shall see, I guess.
Avengers #29: OK, if you're read my last few posts, you'll know that "Wolverine and the X-Men" #12 has been the biggest thorn in my side when it comes to this event, given that it didn't seem to fit in continuity. After all, I wasn't sure how Hope could be in K'un Lun in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #7 and "New Avengers" #27 while also being in Indonesia in "Wolverine and the X-Men" #12, essentially at the same time. Here, we learn that it's because she wasn't. "Hope" in "Wolverine and the X-Men" #12 was Professor X.
First, can I just say, because I rarely get to say it, OMG, thank you, Marvel, for resolving a continuity question! OK, sure, we still have the problem that Giant Man was allegedly captured in "Wolverine and the X-Men" #12, but never actually appeared in captivity after that. Fine, whatever. I can live with that. Sure, Quicksilver forgot that he was captured in that issue for two issues of "Avengers vs. X-Men," but he eventually remembered, so, you know, no harm, no foul. But, it made no sense that Hope was in Indonesia. I mean, none. Why would the Avengers risk her being in Indonesia, where the X-Men could find her, and not in K'un Lun, where she was safe? They wouldn't, which is why it didn't make sense.
Wednesday, August 15, 2012
New Comics!: The "Avengers vs. X-Men" Edition #10 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Avengers vs. X-Men #8: So far, I've been pretty impressed with how well the various authors have done in keeping all their details straight, particularly in terms of coordinating the main mini-series with the tie-in issues and other co-authors' issues. The wheels, unfortunately, come off the bus in this issue, weighing down the entire story for me as I tried to reconcile some fairly major inconsistencies.
First, we have the location problem. Whereas Hope has been in K'un Lun since "New Avengers" #27 (an issue associated more or less with "Avengers vs. X-Men" #6), she just arrives there in this issue of the main title. Presumably, Spider-Man's tutelage of her doesn't begin until after this issue (since he also just arrives in K'un Lun in this issue), making it a little odd that the events of two full issues of the main title (#7 and #8) pass before the events of "New Avengers" #27 could even remotely happen.
I mention these problems not only because they annoy me, but because they compound the problem that you already have under the best of circumstances with these sorts of events, trying to fit the stories happening in the main mini-series into some sort of continuum with the tie-in issues. Beyond the "prisoner problem," I've got a slew of questions about when the events in some of the tie-in issues happen. For example, when do the Phoenix Five fit in going after Mr. Sinister, particularly if they're the Phoenix Four by the end of this issue? When you start getting the authors directly contradicting each other, then it starts becoming really problematic, because it's hard to stay in the story.
Putting aside my anal-retentiveness, the other problem with this issue is that it really just seems like a stalling device. I mean, sure, Namor loses the power of the Phoenix and the Avengers have a pity party over the fact that it took everything that they had just to knock out a member of the Phoenix Five. But, nothing really substantially changed from the end of last issue. I mean, it takes Hope and Wolverine half an issue just to step through a portal! Instead, we get Professor X appearing suddenly furious at the end. I don't really understand why he was mad at Scott, since it's not like Scott destroyed Wakanda. I mean, I'm not really a fan of Scott's at this point, but it's pretty hard to blame Namor's rogue actions on him. But, Professor X just seems totally enraged, despite the fact that, the last time that we saw him, in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #6, he was just concerned. I'm getting almost all the tie-in issues (except, I think, "Avengers Academy") so I'm 95 percent certain that we haven't seen the reason why he went from concerned to furious in those issues. As such, it just feels like an arbitrary plot device to move us to the next mini-plot of the series.
I'm not really sure where it's all leading. We still don't have a clear sense of Phoenix's motives; at this point, it seems to be allowing the Phoenix Five to do what they want, but it's pretty clear that approach is going to change. I'm also confused why the X-Men are more focused on changing the world than changing mutantkind. Shouldn't they be using their power to restart the mutant race? Offering to return powers to mutants de-powered on M-Day? Phoenix's (purported) power to restart mutantkind is, after all, the whole reason the two sides are fighting this battle, since Cyclops believes it outweighs all the potential danger. Why isn't he using it to do that then? It's unclear to me whether it's part of Phoenix's plan (so it's manipulating Cyclops to feel less urgent in his need to address the issue) or if the authors' have just gotten distracted by other parts of the event.
Either way, the lack of attention paid to the issue is just one of the reasons why this issue felt like a massive attempt to stall. I mean, don't get me wrong. The battle with Namor was epic and the Avengers have a point that they don't have a whole lot of hope if it took all of them just to take down 1/5 of the Phoenix Five. But, in the end, this issue and issue #7 probably could've been collapsed into one and we wouldn't have been worse for it.
Avengers #28: I complain throughout this review about the fact that the coordination of tie-in issues with the main mini-series has taken a hit lately, but Bendis is the exception to the rule here. He does a really great job inserting this story between panels of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #7. He also wins applause for telling a story that makes sense, because I totally believe that General Ross would take it upon himself to try to assassinate Cyclops. The story flows smoothly and Ross' narration works well, getting us inside his head and showing us the sacrifices that he's willing to make to advance the cause. (I thought his most interesting comment was about Wolverine not being able to bring himself to assassinate Cyclops. I've always appreciated the fact that Bendis has often given Logan credit for a greater level of humanity than other authors have.) All in all, it's a pretty solid showing that does exactly what a tie-in issue should do, developing a plot that the main story doesn't have time to explore. It reminded me of Hope and Wolverine's adventure in "Wolverine and the X-Men" #11, another example of a tie-in issue filling in the blanks between panels. It's also the type of story that I expected to see from "Avengers" during this event, so it's a welcome relief from the recent Space Team plot, which seemed totally unnecessary given the competing story being told in "Secret Avengers." My only real complaint is the fact that Cyclops decided not to lock up Rulk. Personally, I'd prefer to have a guy who Emma Frost herself notes went toe-to-toe with the Silver Surfer locked far, far underground. Why bother locking up Luke Cage, Giant Man, Hawkeye, Quicksilver, and Spider-Woman if you're going to let Rulk go? But, I understand that Bendis is working under editorial constraints, so it's not really his fault. Overall, it's worth a read if you're looking for a story that makes a lot more sense than Thor swinging a hammer at a cosmic entity in space.
Uncanny X-Men #16: The main problem with this issue is the fact that it's hard to be too worried about the outcome given that we know that the events depicted in it happen before the events of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #8, since Namor is still a member of the Phoenix Five in this issue. So, whatever Sinister is planning to do to the Phoenix Five, he clearly doesn't succeed, because they're all intact by the start of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #8. This issue is a great example of how that increasing lack of coordination negatively impacts the story that Gillen is trying to tell here. Is it still fun to watch Sinister to score some points against the Phoenix Five? Sure. But, in addition to knowing that they all eventually regain their powers in time for Namor to attack Wakanda, Gillen doesn't really explain how the Madelynes manage to siphon off their powers in the first place. They just sort of...do. You'd think Phoenix, who chose the Five, after all, would have some sort of say. All in all, it's not a terrible issue, but the lack of suspense and clarity drags it down a lot, a disappointment in light of how strong issues #14 and #15 were.
Wolverine and the X-Men #14: OK, Jason Aaron wins the prize for author of a tie-in issue who most successfully uses the main event to advance his series' ongoing storylines. In the love-triangle department, we've got Kitty firmly rejecting Peter and essentially instructing Bobby to ask her on a date. We've got the revelation that Toad is (creepily) collecting Husk's discarded skins and using them (creepily) to create life-sized models of her so that he can (creepily) serve them tea. (I told you it was creepy.) We've even got hints of Paige's ongoing problems with her powers, since I don't remember her leaving behind full-sized skins in the past. Seriously, I've enjoyed "Avengers vs. X-Men" so far, but this issue was the first one that made me wish it would come to an end soon so we could resume exploring the interesting storylines that Aaron reminds us are brewing in this title.
In terms of "Avengers vs. X-Men," Aaron furthers the plot significantly. Colossus is arguably the first member of the Phoenix Five that we see totally crack under the pressure. I mean, sure, Namor attacked Wakanda, but, frankly, it's pretty much within Namor's personality to go off half-cocked and attack a country. It is not, however, in Peter's nature to threaten Kitty or destroy schools. At several points during this issue, Aaron has us fear that Colossus is going to hurt Kitty, an idea so ridiculous that Aaron successfully uses it show you how far gone Peter is. (You know that it's going to go down hill quickly when he tells her early in the issue, during their dinner between the sea, that he has everything but her.) Molina and Lee do a great job of showing Peter vacillating between sanity and rage. One moment, his eyes are laughing at the thought that he might be under the possession of Phoenix; the next, they're burning with the idea that he could destroy existence as we know it. They really manage to accentuate the message that Aaron is trying to convey, making it all the more powerful for it. By the end of the issue, when Colossus tells Kitty that he could kill her and resurrect her, you realize just how quickly everything is deteriorating. But, before Colossus can do anything that he'd later regret, Aaron makes Colossus realize how far gone he is as well, as he's standing in the ruins of the statue of Jean Grey. It's a poignant moment, all the more so for reminding us of Jean's notable absence throughout this event. (I also thought that Kitty made a great point telling Colossus that she's treating him differently than Jean because Jean didn't round up people who disagreed with her. Given that the X-Men essentially viewed Jean, before the Phoenix Five got their powers, as weak for failing to control Phoenix and implied that a teenage girl could do it better, I'm glad that someone is giving her props.)
Also importantly, we see Bobby finally have enough when he's forced to "arrest" Thing. He and Rachel return, a defection (or refection) that seems to portend the start of Act Three, particularly because I'm assuming Rogue will come to a similar conclusion in the upcoming issue of "X-Men Legacy." It's also unclear what Colossus is going to do, as we seem him end this issue contemplating his actions as he walks across the Moon.
I've often felt frustrated with this series because Aaron has by and large ignored Kitty. But, we see a lot of the old Kitty here. For example, her response to Bobby and Rachel's return is a great moment. She's been trying to hold the School together for weeks, and it's pretty clear that the less she knew about the events happening outside the School, the better. As such, she refuses to engage Bobby on the subject, instead instructing him and Rachel to start teaching classes and serving lunches. ("Rogue's gym class and Beast's advanced biology are still open. I taught both of them at the same time yesterday.") Combined with the fact that she easily defended the School against Colossus, it shows the grit and determination that we used to see from Kitty. I hope that we see more of it in the future.
This issue only had two small downsides for me. First, in terms of the ongoing coordination problems, it seems odd that Ben was suddenly in New York when, last I checked, he had been spirited to K'un Lun with the rest of the Avengers in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #8. Moreover, I wish we would've seen more about Rachel's decision to return to the X-Men. I get why Bobby defected, but I feel like we needed some sort of explanation behind why Rachel did. She was a lot more committed to the cause than Bobby was, believing that it was her way to help prevent her future from becoming a reality, not to mention her desire to support her father. Although we saw hints of her disquiet in "Wolverine and the X-Men" #12, I didn't really think that she was on the verge of defecting. It would've been nice to see what got her there.
But, all in all, for the advancement of several "Wolverine and the X-Men" and "Avengers vs. X-Men" storylines as well as the great moments of characterization for Kitty, this issue is one of the best of the bunch. To mention one last moment, one that really defined the issue for me, I thought Aaron got across his message loud and clear with the "X-Men" who confronted Colossus. Kitty, Deathlok, Doop, Husk, Toad, and Warbird. A-Team, it was not. But, there they were, drawing a line in the sand in front of the School, even when faced with a Phoenix-powered Colossonaut. It was perhaps one of the few moments when the X-Men felt like the X-Men of my youth, a misfit band of mutants trying to do the right thing, no matter how overpowering the opposition. Thanks, Jason Aaron, for giving me that.
X-Men Legacy #270: As expected, Rogue pulls up stakes here, realizing that the Phoenix Five have gone around the bend when she sees Magik's demonic prison. The rest of the story is a well-written standard prison-break tale, with some nice moments between Carol and Rogue that pretty definitively move them from the "adversary" to "friend" category. For those scenes alone, it's worth the read. Like Rulk in "Avengers" #28, the final disposition of Rogue seems a little difficult to believe, since, personally, if I were the Phoenix Five, I'd be a lot happier with Rogue and Rulk in Magik's prison. But, given that other authors are guilty of the same trick, I'm not going to blame Gage for it here. Overall, it's a strong issue and a good sequel to the previous one, bringing Carol and Rogue's story full-circle.
Thursday, August 9, 2012
New(-ish) Comics: The "Avengers vs. X-Men" Edition #7 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Avengers vs. X-Men #5: I saw an advertisement that billed this issue as the end of Act One, and it's a pretty apt description. The storyline so far has revolved around Cap and Cyclops' dueling views of Hope, with Cap maybe taking overly aggressive steps to address the danger that he felt that a Phoenix-empowered Hope posed to the world and Cyclops pretty much proving that he had lost his mind by constantly asserting that a so-empowered Hope would save the mutant race. A reckoning between these two visions has been coming, and we get one (to an extent) in this issue.
Last issue, we saw that Hope herself didn't really necessarily believe that Cap or Cyke had any idea what they were doing, a pretty reasonable conclusion given that, as I mentioned in my last review, Cap had no real plan to protect her from Phoenix and Cyclops didn't seem to have any idea how she would control it. She convinced Logan to let her try to control Phoenix, but got him to agree to kill her if it looked like she couldn't. They then went to the Moon to greet Phoenix. (It was like Burning Man, but with less acid.)
We start this issue with the Avengers having located Hope, thanks to a tip from Logan, and the X-Men arriving right on their heels, as a result of Emma successfully plucking her location from someone's mind. The Phoenix Force has also arrived and Hope quickly realizes that she can't control it while the Avengers and the X-Men resume pounding on one another. I thought Fraction did a great job of using Hope's narration to explain that the war between the two sides had gone beyond the rational and, in fact, seemed no longer to have anything to do with her. Even with this pretty reasonable explanation why years of emotions meant that neither side seemed capable of putting together a workable plan, it was getting hard to believe that the two sides would just continue to wail on each other for the next seven issues given that it really wasn't doing anything to resolve the issue of Hope.
Here, Fraction resolves that issue, in a way. We finally see the device that Tony Stark has been building over the last few issues, some sort of giant robot that reminded me of Tranzor Z from the '80s. Stark and Hank Pym fly said robot straight at the Phoenix Force, detonating some sort of energy field that disrupts her. Fraction isn't entirely clear how the robot manages to do that, but I'm willing to concede that Stark and Pym are capable of finding some way to do it without me needing to understand all the mechanics. The Phoenix Force, rejected by Hope and attacked by Stark, splits itself five ways, imbuing Colossus, Cyclops, Emma, Magic, and Namor with its power. They then inform the Avengers that they're taking Hope with them and that they plan on helping Phoenix heal so that it can remake the world.
The good news is that I don't necessarily hate this development. When I first heard about it, I rolled my eyes and figured that it would be the moment when this whole endeavor jumped the shark. I mean, it's pretty obviously a stalling tactic to help justify a 12-issue mini-series. But, it's a stalling tactic that at least works in terms of the story. It makes sense that Tony and Hank could damage, but not destroy, Phoenix, so I'm willing to concede that the actual effect of their attack was to split her power between the five X-Men. In fact, Hope herself comments that Phoenix didn't want her any more after she initially rejected it. I'm waiting to see where Fraction goes with that. After all, the obvious question is why Phoenix didn't just give Hope its powers. If it was able to empower the five X-Men mentioned above here, then it seems like that it could also have just gone ahead and empowered Hope. Fraction seems to be implying that Hope's realization that she couldn't handle the power somehow affected Phoenix's view of her, and I'm wondering if the point of imbuing the five X-men was to give them the ability to convince her to play host.
In other words, Fraction does really bring us to a solid end of Act One. It's no longer about Cap and Cyke's dueling visions about Hope's potential future. We're now waiting to see what Cyclops et al. meant about the need for Phoenix to heal itself before it can "evolve tomorrow itself." I'm glad to say that I'm excited to see what the answer to that question is.
Finally, Fraction does a good job of making Hope a little more likable here. After all, she realizes that she can't handle the Phoenix Force and asks Wolverine to kill her. As grim as that sounds, it shows that Hope is trying to do the right thing and allows us to have empathy for her, something that has always been hard to have given how obnoxious she's been. All in all, despite my doubts, it was a pretty strong issue.
AVX:VS #3: This title's previous issues have been fun, but I can honestly say this one is totally skipable. The Colossus/Thing fight is totally formulaic and the Black Widow/Magik fight is rendered almost unintelligible by Marvel's decision to put half of it in Russian, hoping we'll download its AR app. I'm specifically NOT downloading the AR app as a result. So there.
Avengers #27: OK, I've pretty well documented the fact that the "Avengers" and "Secret Avengers" coordination problem has been my least favorite thing about "Avengers vs. X-Men." The problem is, unfortunately, all the more stark after my six-week hiatus, because I spent most of this issue trying to remember what happened in the last issue versus what happened in the last issue of "Secret Avengers." If I'm not mistaken, we ended "Secret Avengers" with Ms. Marvel and the Protector supporting a reborn Captain Marvel and I had more or less ascertained that the upcoming fight was contained between panels in "Avengers" #26. I think that hunch is more or less supported by this issue, given that Marvel isn't even mentioned and Carol is clearly no longer under his sway. I don't remember the exact details of the Protector's attack on his teammates last issue, but he appears to have stolen something that will help the Supreme Intelligence gain control over the Phoenix Force.
Unfortunately, he assumed that the Supreme Intelligence would then help save Earth. He is clearly an idiot. (I mean, really? I actually liked this plot line better when he was merely traitorous, not naive.) He was wrong (obviously) and I give credit to Bendis that the sequence where he's deserted by his teammates is heartbreaking to read. Or, at least, it would be heartbreaking if I believed it. Bendis makes it seem like the Protector staked Captain America through the heart given the vitriol that the team spews at him. I mean, Hank gets so angry about singed fur that he threatens to kill the Protector? I get that they're upset, but, honestly, something about the team members' reaction just seemed totally over the top to me, given that any number of Avengers have done much, much worse but are still welcomed with open arms. I'm not saying that he didn't do a terrible thing, but I don't know if I believe that they would've reacted the way that they did. In the end, it wasn't a terrible issue. In fact, it's pretty damn good for Bendis, But, I still find myself scratching my head why we're dedicating two titles to the Space Team when one would've definitely sufficed. But, at least it seems like the dueling Space Team stories are coming to an end, so I'm happy that we'll presumably be seeing something else next issue.
Unfortunately, he assumed that the Supreme Intelligence would then help save Earth. He is clearly an idiot. (I mean, really? I actually liked this plot line better when he was merely traitorous, not naive.) He was wrong (obviously) and I give credit to Bendis that the sequence where he's deserted by his teammates is heartbreaking to read. Or, at least, it would be heartbreaking if I believed it. Bendis makes it seem like the Protector staked Captain America through the heart given the vitriol that the team spews at him. I mean, Hank gets so angry about singed fur that he threatens to kill the Protector? I get that they're upset, but, honestly, something about the team members' reaction just seemed totally over the top to me, given that any number of Avengers have done much, much worse but are still welcomed with open arms. I'm not saying that he didn't do a terrible thing, but I don't know if I believe that they would've reacted the way that they did. In the end, it wasn't a terrible issue. In fact, it's pretty damn good for Bendis, But, I still find myself scratching my head why we're dedicating two titles to the Space Team when one would've definitely sufficed. But, at least it seems like the dueling Space Team stories are coming to an end, so I'm happy that we'll presumably be seeing something else next issue.
Uncanny X-Men #13: Despite the fact that "Uncanny X-Men" is just a tie-in issue, Gillen makes two fairly major revelations here. First, he has Unit reveal that the Phoenix Force has, in fact, come to Earth specifically because it felt "pushed" by Wanda's decimation of the mutant race, implying that it's here to correct it. Second, he reveals the existence of another messiah who previously used the Phoenix Force to save her race.
Needless to say, I'm pretty surprised that we didn't see the reveal about Phoenix's intentions in the main title. After all, it pretty much proves that Scott is right (to an extent). Given how insane Scott has seemed lately, I think this revelation makes him seem significantly less crazy. I mean, he still seems somewhat crazy, since I'm pretty sure that Unit didn't tell Scott about Phoenix's intentions and he's just basing his belief in its redemptive abilities on some sort of instinct. One theory about his erratic behavior has been that Hope or Phoenix has been manipulating him, so it makes sense that, if Phoenix has been manipulating him, his connection to it would probably given him some insight into its intentions. Now, Gillen doesn't actually draw that line here, so it's entirely possible that Cyclops is really just on a limb in his belief in Phoenix as the mutants' savior. Moreover, even if he's right that it's come to Earth to recreate the mutant race, it doesn't mean that a lot of people aren't going to die in the process. (In other words, Cap isn't necessarily wrong that Hope and Phoenix are threats, even if Cyclops is right that it's here to undo Wanda's spell.) But, at the very least, it does make me feel like Scott's not as insane as I think, even if he is only basing his opinion on instinct that may or may not come from a connection to the Phoenix Force.
Morever, Gillen address one of my questions from "Avengers vs. X-Men" #5, namely, why Phoenix decided to empower the five X-Men on the Moon. Here, we learn that it parallels an event that happened a billion years ago, when a messiah was born to a race who found itself evolutionarily halted by a group of demons who had enslaved it. The messiah built up a group of five acolytes and called to Phoenix for help. Phoenix answered, and the messiah and her acolytes worked with Phoenix to undo the spell and reform their world. So, Phoenix not only has come to Earth to save the mutant race, but it's essentially done the same thing previously. Gillen draws an implicit parallel between Hope and her original Lights from "Generation Hope." We've never really gotten an explanation of how Hope exerted the influence over the Lights that she did, since it's not her mutant power to do so, but Gillen seems to be implying that it was due to her link to Phoenix, given the previous messiah's experience. In the present, with Hope discarded and her acolytes scattered, it's clear that Phoenix is willing to use a different set of acolytes to further its goals. We'll see where that goes.
Again, it seems odd to me that the editors at Marvel would shunt these revelations -- that the Phoenix Force IS here to recreate the mutant race and that Hope isn't the first messiah surrounded by five acolytes to call on the Phoenix Force to save her people -- to a tie-in issue. But, I'm certainly glad that these stories got told, regardless of where they were told, because it does help address two nagging questions I had, namely Cyclops' insistence that he was right about Hope and Hope being able to control the Lights. On the down side, the use of Unit as the source of this information remains deus ex machina-y, and I found myself rolling my eyes at his revelation that he's trying to prevent Hope from saving the mutants since he has nothing to learn from such a scenario, given that he's already witnessed a messiah achieving her goal. Plus, I might be giving Gillen a little too much credit here, given that, as I've noted, I'm connecting some dots that Gillen doesn't specifically connect himself. But, all in all, I'll take any sort of clarity that I can get.
The other focus of this issue is Magneto, Psylocke, and Storm regrouping at a pre-designated location after the battles that we've seen occur throughout Earth over the last few issues. It's a great series of scenes, because it gives the event the quiet time that it's been missing, allowing the characters to consider the events of the last few days. Again, we're moving into Act Two here, so I thought it was a nice touch for Gillen to use this issue to spend some time reflecting on the events of Act One. All in all, I probably enjoyed this issue of "Uncanny X-Men" more than any since the re-launch.
X-Men Legacy #268: OK, first, I was confused by where we start this issue, because I thought that, when we last left Rogue and her team, they were still in the middle of a fight with Falcon and his team. I guess I'll have to check. Anyway, this issue is the first one to deal directly with the aftermath of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #5, informing us that the five X-Men empowered by the Phoenix Force are remaking the world in their image. For starters, they've outlawed war and we start the issue with Cyclops disarming both sides of a conflict somewhere in Africa. Enter Frenzy, who's tasked with keeping the peace for a few hours until the Stepford Cuckoos can come and re-write everyone's memory. (They're a little busy at the moment disarming Iran's nuclear program.) I was also a little confused by this moment, since I was pretty sure that only Bobby, Rachel, and Warren defected to Cyclops' side. Have Rogue et al. followed? I guess that they have, but it would've been nice to see that. Instead, I was left feeling like I missed an issue.
I was worried from the get-go with this story, because I find that authors often fail miserably when they engage in these foreign-intervention tales. They usually greatly oversimplify the complicated dynamics that tend to create these sorts of internal conflicts and fail to write a story that provides a believable role for the costumed hero who finds herself suddenly thrust in the middle of one. As someone who works in foreign affairs, these stories generally require too significant of a willful suspension of disbelief for me, particularly when it comes to the reality that the victims will face once the heroes leave.
I will say that Gage mostly (though not totally) avoids all these traps. By using Frenzy, he gives us a protagonist who completely understands that the X-Men are not going to keep two sides who've been fighting each other for decades from attacking each other, even if they have been disarmed. Gage somewhat wisely has the conflict itself take a backstage, since the issue is really about Frenzy and the abuse that she suffered at the hands of her father, a history that inspires her to intervene when she comes across a guy abusing his child bride. My only real criticism of the issue is this moment, since Gage has the guy spout off way too many theories about international relations while telling Frenzy to take a hike. Gage also falls into the oversimplification trap as Frenzy decides that she's going to solve this girl's problems by just stopping the guy from hitting her. (Gage actually somewhat sidesteps the question entirely by killing off said husband at the end of the issue, so that we don't have to wonder what's going to happen to the girl once Frenzy leaves. I'm not entirely sure why the guy was killed, though. Did another guerrilla group stumble across the rebel camp and kill everyone there? Gage isn't really clear on that. If the husband was a member of the group at the camp, why would they kill him?) But, leaving this scene aside, the rest of the issues flows pretty smoothly (though sadly) as Frenzy tells her story to the man's wife, who's barely a teenager, as she leads Frenzy to the rebel's camp.
The most interesting part of this issue comes at the end, with Frenzy successfully convincing the Stepford Cuckoos not to wipe the traumatic memories from the minds of the villagers, since they need those memories to protect themselves from the next warlord. If Cyclops and his crew are really having the Cuckoos rewrite the memories of everyone on Earth to conform to their vision of the world, I'm wondering what nightmare Utopia we're going to be seeing in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #6. Plus, shouldn't they be re-sparking the mutant race? I mean, why are they bothering with political conflicts when they could be going to every de-powered mutant and reviving their powers? Overall, I'm a little worried, because these sorts of stories about free will have been done many, many times before (and probably most successfully by the "Squadron Supreme" mini-series in the '80s) and I think that this entire endeavor could get really derivative really quickly. Fingers crossed that it doesn't. In the meantime, Gage gives us a decent character study here that managed to miss all the pitfalls that this sort of issue usually carries with it. Frenzy continues to grow as a character and Gage clearly enjoys writing her. You don't necessarily need to read this issue in terms of the larger event, but if you like Frenzy and you're looking for a good character study, you should think about getting it.
Friday, May 25, 2012
New Comics!: The "Avengers vs. X-Men" Edition #5 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Avengers vs. X-Men #4: OMG, I love the fact that Hope, too, decided that Logan was the only person thinking straight! I mentioned in a comment on X-Man75's blog that I thought that Logan is the only person, at this point, with a plan. Cyclops has yet to articulate a way to help Hope handle the Phoenix Force and Cap doesn't seem to have any idea how to protect her from it. I might not agree with Logan that killing Hope is the only option, but he's the only one with a plan that addresses the issue. It seems that Hope herself acknowledges that here.
At first, I was furious with the idea that Logan would just give up his position that Hope was too dangerous to live and agree to help her see if she could control the Phoenix Force. I mean, Logan knows that the minute that the Phoenix touches Hope, she's going to be WAY too powerful for him to do anything if she loses control. So, I was thrilled when Hickman reveals that Logan, in fact, contacted the Avengers. I mean, I still raised an eyebrow that he decided not to kill her immediately, because I'm pretty sure that Logan's position on the threat that she poses hasn't changed. Hickman seems to be arguing that he has just backed off his position that she has to die and instead embraced Cap's view that she might be saved. To be honest, I think it would've been helpful for Hickman to explain why he changed his mind, particularly since we see that he still strongly believes that no one can control the Phoenix Force. But, overall, I concede that it makes it a little easier that we're now only dealing with two teams and not three (even if Logan was in and of himself a team).
My only real problem with this issue is that the events involving the Space Team don't match the events of "Secret Avengers" #26. In that issue, Thor recovers in the Avengers' ship while Phoenix redirects to the Kree's homeworld. So, either we've got a major continuity problem here when we see Thor crash into the moon with Phoenix hot on his heels, or we're seeing events that have yet to transpire in "Secret Avengers." Either way, it's really an unnecessary distraction. If it's the former, it makes you lose some suspension of disbelief, since both events can't happen at once. If it's the latter, it makes you wonder why bother getting the remaining issues of "Secret Avengers" since nothing particularly ground-breaking appears to happen.
On the plus side, Hickman addresses an issue that I mentioned last time, resolving the location of some of the missing Avengers and X-Men. Quake and Venom are now the only unassigned Avengers (as far as I can tell), and we seem to have a full accounting of the X-Men. (However, some members of the New Mutants and "X-Men" roster are missing. We see Nate briefly in this issue, but, as far as I'm aware, we haven't see Cypher, Dani, or Moonstar. In terms of the "X-Men" roster, I don't think we've seen Pixie yet.)
In terms of where we are in the story, I'm surprised that the Phoenix has presented itself so early. When Iron Man mentions that it was an estimated ten hours from Earth, I figured we'd have another five or six issues before it actually arrived. With eight issues left in the main mini-series, I wonder where we're going. Cyclops himself noted that the X-Men's only goal was to keep Hope free until the Phoenix arrived, which they manage to do. So, what happens now? I'm guessing Logan doesn't kill Hope next issue, so either Hope becomes the host for the Phoenix Force or we learn that it always intended to find another host (such as the Scarlet Witch, as numerous people have surmised). Either way, we still have a lot of issues left!
AVX:VS #2: I don't really know how to recap this issue. Cap and Gambit fight. Colossus and Spidey fight. It's awesome. 'Nuff said. Again, it's your call as to whether it's worth $3.99 a month, but I can't say that it isn't fun.
Avengers #26: OK, I have to say, so far, I've been impressed with how well the various books are connecting with the main event. "AVX:VS," "Uncanny X-Men," "Wolverine and the X-Men," and "X-Men Legacy" have all managed to flesh out moments that we briefly saw in the main mini-series in a way that gives you a deeper understanding of the overall story. These stories might not have been essential to understand the main plot, but they definitely give you a better sense of the event as a whole. For example, both "Wolverine and the X-Men" and "X-Men Legacy" fleshed out Bobby and Rachel's motivations for taking Scott's side; if you were just reading the main title, you'd probably be a little surprised by their sudden defection. Moreover, "AVX:VS" and "Uncanny X-Men" have given some more "screen-time" to the fights between iconic characters, given a better sense of just how deep the divide between both sides is. In so doing, no one has tripped on continuity; they've perfectly filled in the events happening between panels, going so far as taking the dialogue verbatim and expanding on it.
Then, we have "Avengers" and "Secret Avengers."
As I mentioned above, I think the scene that we see at the end of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4 actually happens AFTER the entire "Secret Avengers" arc, a supposition that seems to be supported by the editor's note in this issue to see "Secret Avengers" #26-#28...despite the fact that we're only on #26. However, now, I'm not so sure. For example, the scenes inside the Avengers' ship seem to take place concurrent to, and shortly after, the scenes in "Secret Avengers" #26. We start "Avengers" #26 with Thor and War Machine recovering from the confrontation with the Phoenix in "Secret Avengers" #26, but end "Avengers" #26 with Thor taking on the Phoenix Force again, something that hasn't yet happened in "Secret Avengers" (but may happen in issue #27). Fine. That part could work, since it's not too much of a stretch to assume that Thor eventually heals sufficiently to take on Phoenix again. But, it's the Protector aspects of this story that make no sense. We ended "Secret Avengers" #26 with Ms. Marvel and the Protector encountering a resurrected Captain Marvel. So, unless the events of "Secret Avengers" #27 happen entirely between panels in this issue, it didn't make sense to me that the Protector appears on the ship examining Thor's hammer when, last I knew, he was sitting on a rock conspiring with Ms. Marvel. In fact, it seems like all of "Secret Avengers" #26-#28 happens within this issue, not before it.
As such, it seems bizarre that we're dedicating ANOTHER issue to the Space Team. After all, we only briefly saw the various Avengers teams confronting the various X-Men teams in the five locations where Hope might've been in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4. "AVX:VS" #2 expands on some of these fights, as I think "Uncanny X-Men" #12 will. But, I feel like we had enough story there to get the "Avengers" title involved as well, particularly since "New Avengers" is in its own little world at this moment. "Secret Avengers" seemed to be adequately dealing with the Space Team; its inclusion in this series seems to muddy the waters unnecessarily, particularly since they were already muddied in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4.
Uncanny X-Men #12: OK, right away, Gillen address one of my issues with "Avengers vs. X-Men" #3, which is that we weren't really shown how the X-Men not on the Extinction Team escaped. Here, we learn that they escaped one by one, rendezvousing with the Extinction Team at a set location. Cyclops gives a similar set of assignments as Captain America did in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4, and we fully transition to the second round of fights between the two sides. It's not seamless, however. For example, how is She-Hulk at Tabula Rasa and Wolverine's school at the same time? According to the title page of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4, only Luke and Thing should be in Tabula Rasa. Also, Boom Boom is sent to Wundagore Mountain with Magneto and Psylocke, but, in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4, we don't actually see her there, in the intro roster or the issue itself. Instead, she's replaced by Angel and Iceman, and, I have to say, I hope we don't just move right past them joining Scott's side. We had two issues dedicated to their defection ("Wolverine and the X-Men" #11 and "X-Men Legacy" #266), but we so far haven't seen them joining the X-Men side. They, and Rachel, just suddenly appear in this issue. Given the number of tie-in issues, you think someone at some point would've taken the chance to show us that moment, because I think one of Scott's oldest friends and his future daughter re-joining his side has at least some potential to be a decent story. At this point, though, "Uncanny X-Men" continues to serve the same role as "AVX:VS," giving us some more details on the fights that we briefly see in the main mini-series. Unfortunately, It lacks the fun of "AVX:VS" and some of the drama of "Wolverine and the X-Men" and "X-Men Legacy," so I can't really say it's indispensable. But, it's not as random as "New Avengers" or as confusing as "Avengers" and "Secret Avengers," so I guess that's a plus.
At first, I was furious with the idea that Logan would just give up his position that Hope was too dangerous to live and agree to help her see if she could control the Phoenix Force. I mean, Logan knows that the minute that the Phoenix touches Hope, she's going to be WAY too powerful for him to do anything if she loses control. So, I was thrilled when Hickman reveals that Logan, in fact, contacted the Avengers. I mean, I still raised an eyebrow that he decided not to kill her immediately, because I'm pretty sure that Logan's position on the threat that she poses hasn't changed. Hickman seems to be arguing that he has just backed off his position that she has to die and instead embraced Cap's view that she might be saved. To be honest, I think it would've been helpful for Hickman to explain why he changed his mind, particularly since we see that he still strongly believes that no one can control the Phoenix Force. But, overall, I concede that it makes it a little easier that we're now only dealing with two teams and not three (even if Logan was in and of himself a team).
My only real problem with this issue is that the events involving the Space Team don't match the events of "Secret Avengers" #26. In that issue, Thor recovers in the Avengers' ship while Phoenix redirects to the Kree's homeworld. So, either we've got a major continuity problem here when we see Thor crash into the moon with Phoenix hot on his heels, or we're seeing events that have yet to transpire in "Secret Avengers." Either way, it's really an unnecessary distraction. If it's the former, it makes you lose some suspension of disbelief, since both events can't happen at once. If it's the latter, it makes you wonder why bother getting the remaining issues of "Secret Avengers" since nothing particularly ground-breaking appears to happen.
On the plus side, Hickman addresses an issue that I mentioned last time, resolving the location of some of the missing Avengers and X-Men. Quake and Venom are now the only unassigned Avengers (as far as I can tell), and we seem to have a full accounting of the X-Men. (However, some members of the New Mutants and "X-Men" roster are missing. We see Nate briefly in this issue, but, as far as I'm aware, we haven't see Cypher, Dani, or Moonstar. In terms of the "X-Men" roster, I don't think we've seen Pixie yet.)
In terms of where we are in the story, I'm surprised that the Phoenix has presented itself so early. When Iron Man mentions that it was an estimated ten hours from Earth, I figured we'd have another five or six issues before it actually arrived. With eight issues left in the main mini-series, I wonder where we're going. Cyclops himself noted that the X-Men's only goal was to keep Hope free until the Phoenix arrived, which they manage to do. So, what happens now? I'm guessing Logan doesn't kill Hope next issue, so either Hope becomes the host for the Phoenix Force or we learn that it always intended to find another host (such as the Scarlet Witch, as numerous people have surmised). Either way, we still have a lot of issues left!
AVX:VS #2: I don't really know how to recap this issue. Cap and Gambit fight. Colossus and Spidey fight. It's awesome. 'Nuff said. Again, it's your call as to whether it's worth $3.99 a month, but I can't say that it isn't fun.
Avengers #26: OK, I have to say, so far, I've been impressed with how well the various books are connecting with the main event. "AVX:VS," "Uncanny X-Men," "Wolverine and the X-Men," and "X-Men Legacy" have all managed to flesh out moments that we briefly saw in the main mini-series in a way that gives you a deeper understanding of the overall story. These stories might not have been essential to understand the main plot, but they definitely give you a better sense of the event as a whole. For example, both "Wolverine and the X-Men" and "X-Men Legacy" fleshed out Bobby and Rachel's motivations for taking Scott's side; if you were just reading the main title, you'd probably be a little surprised by their sudden defection. Moreover, "AVX:VS" and "Uncanny X-Men" have given some more "screen-time" to the fights between iconic characters, given a better sense of just how deep the divide between both sides is. In so doing, no one has tripped on continuity; they've perfectly filled in the events happening between panels, going so far as taking the dialogue verbatim and expanding on it.
Then, we have "Avengers" and "Secret Avengers."
As I mentioned above, I think the scene that we see at the end of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4 actually happens AFTER the entire "Secret Avengers" arc, a supposition that seems to be supported by the editor's note in this issue to see "Secret Avengers" #26-#28...despite the fact that we're only on #26. However, now, I'm not so sure. For example, the scenes inside the Avengers' ship seem to take place concurrent to, and shortly after, the scenes in "Secret Avengers" #26. We start "Avengers" #26 with Thor and War Machine recovering from the confrontation with the Phoenix in "Secret Avengers" #26, but end "Avengers" #26 with Thor taking on the Phoenix Force again, something that hasn't yet happened in "Secret Avengers" (but may happen in issue #27). Fine. That part could work, since it's not too much of a stretch to assume that Thor eventually heals sufficiently to take on Phoenix again. But, it's the Protector aspects of this story that make no sense. We ended "Secret Avengers" #26 with Ms. Marvel and the Protector encountering a resurrected Captain Marvel. So, unless the events of "Secret Avengers" #27 happen entirely between panels in this issue, it didn't make sense to me that the Protector appears on the ship examining Thor's hammer when, last I knew, he was sitting on a rock conspiring with Ms. Marvel. In fact, it seems like all of "Secret Avengers" #26-#28 happens within this issue, not before it.
As such, it seems bizarre that we're dedicating ANOTHER issue to the Space Team. After all, we only briefly saw the various Avengers teams confronting the various X-Men teams in the five locations where Hope might've been in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4. "AVX:VS" #2 expands on some of these fights, as I think "Uncanny X-Men" #12 will. But, I feel like we had enough story there to get the "Avengers" title involved as well, particularly since "New Avengers" is in its own little world at this moment. "Secret Avengers" seemed to be adequately dealing with the Space Team; its inclusion in this series seems to muddy the waters unnecessarily, particularly since they were already muddied in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4.
Uncanny X-Men #12: OK, right away, Gillen address one of my issues with "Avengers vs. X-Men" #3, which is that we weren't really shown how the X-Men not on the Extinction Team escaped. Here, we learn that they escaped one by one, rendezvousing with the Extinction Team at a set location. Cyclops gives a similar set of assignments as Captain America did in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4, and we fully transition to the second round of fights between the two sides. It's not seamless, however. For example, how is She-Hulk at Tabula Rasa and Wolverine's school at the same time? According to the title page of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4, only Luke and Thing should be in Tabula Rasa. Also, Boom Boom is sent to Wundagore Mountain with Magneto and Psylocke, but, in "Avengers vs. X-Men" #4, we don't actually see her there, in the intro roster or the issue itself. Instead, she's replaced by Angel and Iceman, and, I have to say, I hope we don't just move right past them joining Scott's side. We had two issues dedicated to their defection ("Wolverine and the X-Men" #11 and "X-Men Legacy" #266), but we so far haven't seen them joining the X-Men side. They, and Rachel, just suddenly appear in this issue. Given the number of tie-in issues, you think someone at some point would've taken the chance to show us that moment, because I think one of Scott's oldest friends and his future daughter re-joining his side has at least some potential to be a decent story. At this point, though, "Uncanny X-Men" continues to serve the same role as "AVX:VS," giving us some more details on the fights that we briefly see in the main mini-series. Unfortunately, It lacks the fun of "AVX:VS" and some of the drama of "Wolverine and the X-Men" and "X-Men Legacy," so I can't really say it's indispensable. But, it's not as random as "New Avengers" or as confusing as "Avengers" and "Secret Avengers," so I guess that's a plus.
Tuesday, April 24, 2012
New Comics!: The "Avengers vs. X-Men" Edition #2 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Avengers vs. X-Men #2: "As soon as we get a messiah of our own, they want to swoop in and take her away." WTF? What the hell does Scott mean? "A messiah of our own?" Did the Avengers ever have a messiah? Does Scott not remember that the X-Men already had this messiah and that she ate a few planets before she had to kill herself? Does he not remember that said messiah was his wife? I don't understand how we're even remotely supposed to take the X-Men's side. I laid out most of my complaints about the lack of logic in Scott's position in my review of "Avengers vs. X-Men" #1, so I'll try not to repeat them here. Suffice it to say that the only way I can approach Scott at this point is to assume that Marvel basically wants us to believe that he has totally and completely lost his mind. I would like, at some point, for them to explain why he lost his mind, be it Hope manipulating him or him cracking under the pressure of leadership. But, if you at least approach his actions in the context of him having lost his mind, then his belief that a 16-year-old girl will be able to control a destructive universal force despite the fact that his wife was unable to do so and that said girl will use said force to resurrect the mutant race might actually make sense. Maybe.
Outside Scott, the rest of the X-Men seem to behave the way I would expect them to behave, taking their years of resentment for being treated, in Scott's words, as "ugly step-children" and venting it on the Avengers. The problem, of course, is that you figure at some point someone is going to start to question how wise it is to be fighting the Avengers on Hope's behalf, particularly, as we see this issue, when she's perfectly willing to hurt her own people to start using some of the Phoenix's power. I'd like to think that some of the X-Men, when they stop personalizing the battle and focus on actual events, may begin to realize that the Avengers might've had a point that giving a 16-year-old girl with anger issues the power of a destructive universal force might not have been the greatest idea. But, Aaron does a good job in showing that we're not quite at the "cooler heads prevailing" point of the fight and allows us to just enjoy the slugfest. And, what a slugfest it was! Colossunaut vs. Rulk, Captain America vs. Cyclops, Luke Cage vs. Namor vs. Thing, Emma Frost vs. Iron Man vs. Magneto: Aaron and Romita really deliver. I was skeptical about this event from the start, but, between Aaron selling me on the X-Men acting from years of repressed anger at being considered the ugly step-children of the superhero community (and not just blind faith in Scott) and Romita showing the awesomeness of the various battles, I'm game.
Avengers #25: Despite being branded with the "Avengers vs. X-Men banner," this issue mostly serves to wrap up Bendis' "H.A.M.M.E.R. War," with the Avengers taking down A.I.M. and recovering the genetic secrets of the superhero community. It wasn't a particularly enthralling issue, but, for Bendis, it was a pretty straight-forward "smash-and-grab" type of story, so at least I understood most of it (a definite plus when it comes to a Bendis story). Bendis also adds in a psychological element, showing that this win helps to relieve some of the pressure Captain America has been feeling to get a win after a string of losses.
The problem, of course, is that Bendis keeps telling us about these losses, but we haven't really seen them. Osborn mentions the Red Skull and the Skrulls, but Cap was, um, dead for the Red Skull saga (assuming Bendis is referring to "Captain America" #25-#42 and #49-#50 and "Captain America: Reborn" #1-#6) and Iron Man was head of national security for "Secret Invasion." In fact, since Cap took over the nation's security, the Avengers have been involved in the time-travel and Infinity Gauntlet sagas and the New Avengers faced down Agamotto and Superia. None of these stories really affected anyone outside the superhero community, particularly not to the point that people would be protesting on the Avengers' lawn about them. The only Avenger/New Avenger story that has affected people outside the superhero community is "Fear Itself," but Marvel has apparently put that story in the memory hole, given that none of the talking heads even mentioned it. (In fact, when Thor returns, even he and Cap don't discuss it, despite it, you know, being the reason why Thor was gone in the first place.) All these reasons are why the whole "Occupy Avengers Mansion" protest has seemed so utterly bizarre, because the Avengers haven't really had a loss under Steve's shepherding. They saved the future and our dimension, took down the Hood and Superia, and defeated the Serpent. I could see someone making an argument about the civilian casualties during "Fear Itself," but no one actually does. So, what, they have to go all the way to "Secret Invasion?" Again, this argument made no sense when Bendis was pushing it during the "H.A.M.M.E.R. War" and it still makes no sense now that he's trying to use it as a referendum on Cap's leadership. (Also, as I mentioned in "Fear Itself," why don't Cap and the other members of the Illuminati just pull out the Infinity Gems to defeat Phoenix? Seems to me like the potential destruction of the universe would be a good reason to do so.)
[Sigh.]
At any rate, despite this ongoing problem, it's not a terrible issue, for Bendis, and we learn, in the end, that the Protector (who tracked down A.I.M. in the first place) is really a mole for the Kree Supreme Intelligence and has directed him to trap the Phoenix, regardless of the cost. If we never have to discuss the "H.A.M.M.E.R. War" again, I'm a happy camper.
Wolverine and the X-Men #9: "Think of Utopia as a compound full of heavily armed religious fanatics. And you're the feds butting in, telling them what to believe and how to live. It won't go well." Thank you, Wolverine, for making realize that Scott Summers = David Koresh. I'm glad to at least someone acknowledge that Cyclops has lost his mind (although, as I will continue to note for as long as it bothers me, which will likely be throughout this event, I still would like someone to explain why Cyclops lost his mind and believes that a 16-year-old girl imbued with the Phoenix Force isn't going to destroy the universe). Aaron does a good job of sketching out why Logan believes that he must take the Avengers side, since he views Hope as a 16-year-old threat, not messiah. This issue has some other stuff, like Cannonball raising the issue that his sister's powers aren't on the fritz, but it's Wolverine's decision to support the Avengers that makes it notable.
Outside Scott, the rest of the X-Men seem to behave the way I would expect them to behave, taking their years of resentment for being treated, in Scott's words, as "ugly step-children" and venting it on the Avengers. The problem, of course, is that you figure at some point someone is going to start to question how wise it is to be fighting the Avengers on Hope's behalf, particularly, as we see this issue, when she's perfectly willing to hurt her own people to start using some of the Phoenix's power. I'd like to think that some of the X-Men, when they stop personalizing the battle and focus on actual events, may begin to realize that the Avengers might've had a point that giving a 16-year-old girl with anger issues the power of a destructive universal force might not have been the greatest idea. But, Aaron does a good job in showing that we're not quite at the "cooler heads prevailing" point of the fight and allows us to just enjoy the slugfest. And, what a slugfest it was! Colossunaut vs. Rulk, Captain America vs. Cyclops, Luke Cage vs. Namor vs. Thing, Emma Frost vs. Iron Man vs. Magneto: Aaron and Romita really deliver. I was skeptical about this event from the start, but, between Aaron selling me on the X-Men acting from years of repressed anger at being considered the ugly step-children of the superhero community (and not just blind faith in Scott) and Romita showing the awesomeness of the various battles, I'm game.
Avengers #25: Despite being branded with the "Avengers vs. X-Men banner," this issue mostly serves to wrap up Bendis' "H.A.M.M.E.R. War," with the Avengers taking down A.I.M. and recovering the genetic secrets of the superhero community. It wasn't a particularly enthralling issue, but, for Bendis, it was a pretty straight-forward "smash-and-grab" type of story, so at least I understood most of it (a definite plus when it comes to a Bendis story). Bendis also adds in a psychological element, showing that this win helps to relieve some of the pressure Captain America has been feeling to get a win after a string of losses.
The problem, of course, is that Bendis keeps telling us about these losses, but we haven't really seen them. Osborn mentions the Red Skull and the Skrulls, but Cap was, um, dead for the Red Skull saga (assuming Bendis is referring to "Captain America" #25-#42 and #49-#50 and "Captain America: Reborn" #1-#6) and Iron Man was head of national security for "Secret Invasion." In fact, since Cap took over the nation's security, the Avengers have been involved in the time-travel and Infinity Gauntlet sagas and the New Avengers faced down Agamotto and Superia. None of these stories really affected anyone outside the superhero community, particularly not to the point that people would be protesting on the Avengers' lawn about them. The only Avenger/New Avenger story that has affected people outside the superhero community is "Fear Itself," but Marvel has apparently put that story in the memory hole, given that none of the talking heads even mentioned it. (In fact, when Thor returns, even he and Cap don't discuss it, despite it, you know, being the reason why Thor was gone in the first place.) All these reasons are why the whole "Occupy Avengers Mansion" protest has seemed so utterly bizarre, because the Avengers haven't really had a loss under Steve's shepherding. They saved the future and our dimension, took down the Hood and Superia, and defeated the Serpent. I could see someone making an argument about the civilian casualties during "Fear Itself," but no one actually does. So, what, they have to go all the way to "Secret Invasion?" Again, this argument made no sense when Bendis was pushing it during the "H.A.M.M.E.R. War" and it still makes no sense now that he's trying to use it as a referendum on Cap's leadership. (Also, as I mentioned in "Fear Itself," why don't Cap and the other members of the Illuminati just pull out the Infinity Gems to defeat Phoenix? Seems to me like the potential destruction of the universe would be a good reason to do so.)
[Sigh.]
At any rate, despite this ongoing problem, it's not a terrible issue, for Bendis, and we learn, in the end, that the Protector (who tracked down A.I.M. in the first place) is really a mole for the Kree Supreme Intelligence and has directed him to trap the Phoenix, regardless of the cost. If we never have to discuss the "H.A.M.M.E.R. War" again, I'm a happy camper.
Wolverine and the X-Men #9: "Think of Utopia as a compound full of heavily armed religious fanatics. And you're the feds butting in, telling them what to believe and how to live. It won't go well." Thank you, Wolverine, for making realize that Scott Summers = David Koresh. I'm glad to at least someone acknowledge that Cyclops has lost his mind (although, as I will continue to note for as long as it bothers me, which will likely be throughout this event, I still would like someone to explain why Cyclops lost his mind and believes that a 16-year-old girl imbued with the Phoenix Force isn't going to destroy the universe). Aaron does a good job of sketching out why Logan believes that he must take the Avengers side, since he views Hope as a 16-year-old threat, not messiah. This issue has some other stuff, like Cannonball raising the issue that his sister's powers aren't on the fritz, but it's Wolverine's decision to support the Avengers that makes it notable.
Wednesday, April 11, 2012
New Comics!: The Avengers Edition (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
New Avengers #23: Somewhat predictably, it feels bizarre to be reading this comic almost a full month after "Avengers" #24, given that the events of this issue precede that issue. I had already started trying to move past the H.A.M.M.E.R. war, but this issue amounts to an unfortunate relapse hindering my recovery efforts.
Amazingly, Marvel still finds a way to spoil the revelation that Skaar was working for Captain America (despite the fact that we already knew he was from "Avengers" #24) by doing it ON THE INTRO PAGE. Hi, pet peeve #1, it's been a while. Pet peeve #2 is also in effect, since the New Avengers at no point fight Skaar, despite the cover depicting them doing so. The rare bifecta! Bendis, you must be so proud. Seriously, though, WTF? Let's say you didn't read "Avengers"#24, because you had been warned by a disgruntled friend that you should read this issue first. You open up the book wondering why Skaar attacked the Dark Avengers on the last panel of issue #22, and, BAM, the intro page tells you he's working for Captain America. I don't think anyone would've necessarily guessed that Skaar was working for Captain America just because he attacks the Dark Avengers. I mean, sure, it was a possibility, but Skaar could've had any number of motivations for attacking the Dark Avengers, particularly since Bendis hadn't really done any character work with him until that point. I really would've believed almost anything. But, there you go, the intro page tells you why he attacked them. I mean, I just don't understand how Marvel can manage spoiling a surprise when said surprise isn't even a surprise anymore, but it manages to do so here.
I wish I could say that it was my only problem with this issue, but it wasn't. I mention above the fact that Bendis hadn't really done any character work with Skaar, making it hard to guess that he was working for Captain America before the intro page reveal. Well, Bendis doesn't really do any work with him after the reveal, either. I mean, Bendis spends the first few pages of this issue telling us that Skaar is working for Captain America, but never tells us why. I accept the fact that I could be missing something, since I don't read any of the Hulk series, but you'd think Bendis could throw in a comment telling us why Skaar would feel some sort of loyalty to Captain America. I mean, if Norman Osborn thought he was a good candidate for the Dark Avengers, it's clear that Skaar doesn't exactly walk on the side of angels as a default setting. Bendis needed to do some sort of explaining about why Skaar chose to be loyal to Cap. But, Bendis doesn't do that. Like Bendis always does, he just tells us Skaar is loyal to Cap and wants us to accept it just because he says so. He's done the same thing with Victoria Hand for dozens of issues, and it's no different here with Skaar.
The highlight of this issue is the fight between the remaining New Avengers and the remaining Dark Avengers, but it still feels like an afterthought. Moreover, I want to know what Bendis was thinking when he has Ms. Marvel just pound on whoever it was that was pretending to be her. She seems to be in a full-on rage, something that not only seems like a total non sequitur but also seems totally uncharacteristic of her. At any rate, the best thing I can say about this issue is that it brings us when step closer to the bright light at the end of the tunnel. Bendis' reign of holy terror over the Avengers titles will soon end. That day can't come soon enough.
Avengers #24.1: OK, I actually liked this issue. The Vision isn't my favorite character. I mean, I've read a lot (a lot) of issues where he plays a role, and I can't say I really missed him. It's hard to get attached to a guy who doesn't really have feelings. But, Bendis does a good job of exploring the range of feelings, however limited that range may be, that the Vision does have, bringing him from forgiveness to rage to sorrow. Before, I get to the Vision part, though, I want to say how thrilled I am that Bendis finally gave us a decent Hawkeye and Spider-Woman scene, making it as fun and funny as their pairing promised to be. ("You act like it's my fault we haven't had ten minutes to breathe since you and I - uh - you know." "No, please, I'd love to hear how you're going to word this.") I mean, they even get Cap's blessing! I really hope whoever takes over this title keeps up their relationship and the focus on the comedy. I mean, I love Mockingbird, but, really, it's time for them to be apart for a while, I think. Now, focusing on the Vision, I thought Bendis did the best job with the Magneto/Vision scene, if only because I totally bought his depiction of Magneto. One of the things I've hated in the X-books is how we've just wiped away Magneto's history as a homicidal maniac, forgiving all his sins. I mean, Billy had to remind the X-Men about the fact that they had welcomed this legendary murderer onto their team with open arms during "Avengers: The Children's Crusade," when they were all getting on their high horses about Wanda. I'm glad that Bendis doesn't seem to buy the new, improved Magneto either because he gives us the old, enraged Magneto. It's this Magneto -- threatening, manipulative, arrogant -- that I recognize. In fact, I hope Cyclops took a good long look at the hate with which Magneto responded to the Vision, because it might remind him of who Magneto was and who he one day may still be. Moreover, Bendis uses Magneto as an excellent foil for the Vision, provoking the Vision's rage, getting him to show some sort of emotion. His conversation with Jennifer earlier in the issue was somewhat one-sided, but it's during his fight with Magneto that we see the Vision actually start to engage. As such, it's not a surprise when we see him fall apart at the end. I'm surprised to be complimenting Bendis on bringing anyone, let alone the Vision, on an emotional journey, but there you have it. Given that the re-introduction of the Vision was done so terribly, this issue went a long way to me believing it is actually the real Vision and I can start thinking of him as such. For Bendis, that's pretty much hitting a home run.
Secret Avengers #24: OK, so it appears that this council that the Father heads is a council of synthetic -- or least artificial -- lifeforms, comprised of Doombots,"sentinaughts," adaptoids, "machine people," Reavers, etc. I was pretty sure that it was just about the adaptoids, despite the fact I seemed to know less about them than Remender thought I should. Or maybe it was just about the descendants. Honestly, I can't remember. It had something to do with the both of them. At any rate, I can honestly say I have almost no idea what story Remender is trying to tell. I think he's building a story where these artificial lifeforms are planning to rise against the "real" lifeforms. But, it's hard to focus, when Remender's got so many other irons in the fire. We've got the Pakistani boy, who may or may not be one of these descendants. We've got Ant-Man, who may or may not be dead. We've got a reanimated Janet, who I'm pretty sure isn't Janet given that she exploded, making it hard to believe that she'd have left behind enough body to be reanimated as a deathlok. It's all just a lot to try to keep straight. It seems to me like Remender is writing for a trade paperback, and I can see myself enjoying this arc more when I re-read it from start to finish after it ends. But, at this stage, I'm having a hard time staying engage when each page brings something that either confuses me or seems to contradict something that happened on another page, possibly even in a different issue. Honestly, I think I'm done with this title after "Avengers vs. X-Men," even if it is being run by Hawkeye. Sad, but true.
Amazingly, Marvel still finds a way to spoil the revelation that Skaar was working for Captain America (despite the fact that we already knew he was from "Avengers" #24) by doing it ON THE INTRO PAGE. Hi, pet peeve #1, it's been a while. Pet peeve #2 is also in effect, since the New Avengers at no point fight Skaar, despite the cover depicting them doing so. The rare bifecta! Bendis, you must be so proud. Seriously, though, WTF? Let's say you didn't read "Avengers"#24, because you had been warned by a disgruntled friend that you should read this issue first. You open up the book wondering why Skaar attacked the Dark Avengers on the last panel of issue #22, and, BAM, the intro page tells you he's working for Captain America. I don't think anyone would've necessarily guessed that Skaar was working for Captain America just because he attacks the Dark Avengers. I mean, sure, it was a possibility, but Skaar could've had any number of motivations for attacking the Dark Avengers, particularly since Bendis hadn't really done any character work with him until that point. I really would've believed almost anything. But, there you go, the intro page tells you why he attacked them. I mean, I just don't understand how Marvel can manage spoiling a surprise when said surprise isn't even a surprise anymore, but it manages to do so here.
I wish I could say that it was my only problem with this issue, but it wasn't. I mention above the fact that Bendis hadn't really done any character work with Skaar, making it hard to guess that he was working for Captain America before the intro page reveal. Well, Bendis doesn't really do any work with him after the reveal, either. I mean, Bendis spends the first few pages of this issue telling us that Skaar is working for Captain America, but never tells us why. I accept the fact that I could be missing something, since I don't read any of the Hulk series, but you'd think Bendis could throw in a comment telling us why Skaar would feel some sort of loyalty to Captain America. I mean, if Norman Osborn thought he was a good candidate for the Dark Avengers, it's clear that Skaar doesn't exactly walk on the side of angels as a default setting. Bendis needed to do some sort of explaining about why Skaar chose to be loyal to Cap. But, Bendis doesn't do that. Like Bendis always does, he just tells us Skaar is loyal to Cap and wants us to accept it just because he says so. He's done the same thing with Victoria Hand for dozens of issues, and it's no different here with Skaar.
The highlight of this issue is the fight between the remaining New Avengers and the remaining Dark Avengers, but it still feels like an afterthought. Moreover, I want to know what Bendis was thinking when he has Ms. Marvel just pound on whoever it was that was pretending to be her. She seems to be in a full-on rage, something that not only seems like a total non sequitur but also seems totally uncharacteristic of her. At any rate, the best thing I can say about this issue is that it brings us when step closer to the bright light at the end of the tunnel. Bendis' reign of holy terror over the Avengers titles will soon end. That day can't come soon enough.
Avengers #24.1: OK, I actually liked this issue. The Vision isn't my favorite character. I mean, I've read a lot (a lot) of issues where he plays a role, and I can't say I really missed him. It's hard to get attached to a guy who doesn't really have feelings. But, Bendis does a good job of exploring the range of feelings, however limited that range may be, that the Vision does have, bringing him from forgiveness to rage to sorrow. Before, I get to the Vision part, though, I want to say how thrilled I am that Bendis finally gave us a decent Hawkeye and Spider-Woman scene, making it as fun and funny as their pairing promised to be. ("You act like it's my fault we haven't had ten minutes to breathe since you and I - uh - you know." "No, please, I'd love to hear how you're going to word this.") I mean, they even get Cap's blessing! I really hope whoever takes over this title keeps up their relationship and the focus on the comedy. I mean, I love Mockingbird, but, really, it's time for them to be apart for a while, I think. Now, focusing on the Vision, I thought Bendis did the best job with the Magneto/Vision scene, if only because I totally bought his depiction of Magneto. One of the things I've hated in the X-books is how we've just wiped away Magneto's history as a homicidal maniac, forgiving all his sins. I mean, Billy had to remind the X-Men about the fact that they had welcomed this legendary murderer onto their team with open arms during "Avengers: The Children's Crusade," when they were all getting on their high horses about Wanda. I'm glad that Bendis doesn't seem to buy the new, improved Magneto either because he gives us the old, enraged Magneto. It's this Magneto -- threatening, manipulative, arrogant -- that I recognize. In fact, I hope Cyclops took a good long look at the hate with which Magneto responded to the Vision, because it might remind him of who Magneto was and who he one day may still be. Moreover, Bendis uses Magneto as an excellent foil for the Vision, provoking the Vision's rage, getting him to show some sort of emotion. His conversation with Jennifer earlier in the issue was somewhat one-sided, but it's during his fight with Magneto that we see the Vision actually start to engage. As such, it's not a surprise when we see him fall apart at the end. I'm surprised to be complimenting Bendis on bringing anyone, let alone the Vision, on an emotional journey, but there you have it. Given that the re-introduction of the Vision was done so terribly, this issue went a long way to me believing it is actually the real Vision and I can start thinking of him as such. For Bendis, that's pretty much hitting a home run.
Secret Avengers #24: OK, so it appears that this council that the Father heads is a council of synthetic -- or least artificial -- lifeforms, comprised of Doombots,"sentinaughts," adaptoids, "machine people," Reavers, etc. I was pretty sure that it was just about the adaptoids, despite the fact I seemed to know less about them than Remender thought I should. Or maybe it was just about the descendants. Honestly, I can't remember. It had something to do with the both of them. At any rate, I can honestly say I have almost no idea what story Remender is trying to tell. I think he's building a story where these artificial lifeforms are planning to rise against the "real" lifeforms. But, it's hard to focus, when Remender's got so many other irons in the fire. We've got the Pakistani boy, who may or may not be one of these descendants. We've got Ant-Man, who may or may not be dead. We've got a reanimated Janet, who I'm pretty sure isn't Janet given that she exploded, making it hard to believe that she'd have left behind enough body to be reanimated as a deathlok. It's all just a lot to try to keep straight. It seems to me like Remender is writing for a trade paperback, and I can see myself enjoying this arc more when I re-read it from start to finish after it ends. But, at this stage, I'm having a hard time staying engage when each page brings something that either confuses me or seems to contradict something that happened on another page, possibly even in a different issue. Honestly, I think I'm done with this title after "Avengers vs. X-Men," even if it is being run by Hawkeye. Sad, but true.
Monday, March 19, 2012
New Comics!: The "OMG, Can Bendis Stop Writing the 'Avengers' NOW?" Edition
Avengers #24: OK, let's just get this thing done, shall we:
On some level, this issue was fine. It has an OK action sequence and, for the first time, Bendis actually uses the flashback device in a way that doesn't totally disrupt the story's flow. The Avengers themselves have some bland Bendis-esque banter and the central conflict's resolution -- the assembled Avengers discovering a way to defeat a powerful Osborn -- made sense, even if it was pretty predictable. If it were just a one-and-done issue, I'd probably give it two of five stars, maybe three of five stars if I were feeling generous.
But...
...it's not a one-and-done issue. It's the culmination of seven "Avengers" issues and eight "New Avengers" issue. It's the last arc of "Architect" Bendis's run on two titles he's controlled for years. It was supposed to be the coup de grace in which we all ask Marvel to stop publishing Avengers stories because "Architect" Bendis has written the greatest, most amazing Avengers story of all time and we should just consider the Avengers done as a franchise.
Needless to say, it wasn't any of that.
First, let's talk about Osborn. Bendis has been playing this "OMG, why does Osborn have super-powers?" game throughout the series, and it's never rung true to me, given that Osborn possessed most of the powers Bendis has had him exhibit (super strength, most notably) previously, through his exposure to the Goblin Formula. It's not like Norman Osborn has armor-based powers, like Iron Man, even if he did use the Iron Patriot armor for a while. His powers have always been tied to his exposure to the Goblin Formula and, as far as I know, he didn't lose them when the authorities sent him to the Raft after his role in "Siege." As such, the reveal that Osborn gained the powers of the Super-Adaptoid felt flat to me. Um, OK. He has some more powers. Whatever.
But, this revelation goes from bad to worse because of how obvious its resolution becomes. The minute we learn that he has Super-Adaptoid powers, we know that the Avengers are going to defeat him by overloading him. Done. Did anyone really think it was going to end any other way? That he and Captain America were going to have some sort of heroic struggle? That he and Iron Man were going to engage in a battle of the minds to save or destroy the world? That he and Spider-Man were finally going to hash out Gwen's death? No. No one did. We all knew that they were going to defeat Osborn by overloading him, since Bendis essentially has Dr. Rappaccini TELL US IT WAS GOING TO HAPPEN. Osborn tells her that he doesn't want a suit to give him power. (Let's ignore that he doesn't need to have a suit to give him power, because he already has power. Let's just ignore it. I'll concede it. Fine, he doesn't have power.) But, why wouldn't he have a suit to help him control his new power? Couldn't A.I.M. construct a suit that would address the obvious flaw in the plan, letting Osborn regulate how many powers he absorbed? If I can think of that, couldn't Bendis or, at the very least, one of his editors? Again, we're supposed to believe Osborn is SO smart, but he so easily walks into this glaring hole in his plan? Really?
Moreover, I was truly infuriated by how easily he's defeated: three panels that take up roughly a sixth of a page. In fact, the entire battle with the Avengers, the one that directly results in his defeat, takes up just three pages. Osborn's entire comment before he literally melts? "Oh, no." Genius, "Architect Bendis." Genius.
Also, before I rant more about the plot holes, I need to pick a bone with Bendis about his portrayal of Captain America. During Chuck Austen's awful "Lionheart of Avalon" arc in "Avengers" #77-#82, he had Captain America find himself emotionally incapable of comforting a little boy who lost his mother, despite the fact that Cap also lost his mother at a young age and, you know, inspired AN ENTIRE GENERATION OF ALLIED TROOPS during the Second World War. In this arc, Cap asserting that he's not good at public relations also felt ridiculous. As Obama says, the man wears a flag for his costume. He can inspire AN ENTIRE GENERATION OF ALLIED TROOPS on newsreel after newsreel, but he can't go on a Sunday morning talk show and explain, in clear and unequivocal terms, why America needs the Avengers? Bendis built this entire arc around the idea that Osborn used modern forms of communication against the Avengers, inserting doubt into the minds of the public. Although I didn't buy it for a minute, Bendis wanted us to buy it, despite never actualy selling it. As such, Cap's refusal to address the issue that Bendis wants to us to believe was the Avengers' greatest weakness makes him seem old and obsolete, like trying to get your grandfather to join Facebook so you don't have to keep sending him huge e-mails of photo files of your new puppy. I absolutely reject this idea that Captain America can't adapt to the modern era, and I'm stunned Marvel let Bendis treat one of its flagship characters this way, particularly given that it's the character who's supposed to serve as the whole moral backbone of the Marvel Universe. If Captain America can't explain to America why he and the other Avengers are needed, then who the $%^& can?
Finally, because the quicker that I can forget this arc the better, we continue to have serious coordination issues. I felt like I was missing an issue throughout this issue, that this whole arc just ended abruptly, partly because I was missing an issue. We learn here that the New Avengers took down the Dark Avengers, which I'm assuming happens in "New Avengers" #23? For the life of me, I don't understand why we couldn't get a note to that effect on the intro page. Marvel keeps using these intro pages, and they waste four paragraphs recapping a plot we already know, but not one sentence about something we don't necessarily already know. Why do they feel the need to only address these pages to people who seemingly just decided to pick up a comic for the first time? Can we not get ONE sentence noting that we should read "New Avengers" #23 first? The same thing happened with "Secret Avengers" #23, and I absolutely don't understand it. I end this entire arc not knowing fully what happened, because Marvel either couldn't get its publishing schedule in order or couldn't be bothered to care about me knowing what happened.
Final Thoughts: Honestly, I don't even know what my final thoughts are (particularly since they're not my final thoughts, because I have another issue to read). We began this arc having it be all about Osborn manipulating the Avengers via the media and end it with Osborn melting after essentially trying to defeat the Avengers in hand-to-hand combat by himself. The most glaring problem with this arc is that we never actually discovered what Osborn intended to do. It appears, in this issue, his only goal was to fight the Avengers. Bendis spent this entire arc pretending that Osborn was playing some long game...and it appears all he wanted to do was punch some people. We're left with all sorts of questions. Why exactly did Osborn try to convince the President to put him in charge of the national-security apparatus, as we saw last issue? What would he have done if the President had done so? If his plan was merely to fight the Avengers, why didn't he just attack them in the first place? Why go through the elaborate public-relations campaign? Was the goal of the public-relations campaign to weaken the President so he accepted Osborn as the head of the national-security apparatus? Why assemble his own Dark Avengers if he were so convinced that he could take on both Avengers teams by himself? I'm rattling off these questions without even reading my other posts to see if I missed anything.
I just don't know. Honestly, this entire arc has been a train wreck and I just don't know what to say, other than the fact that I can't believe I have to segue straight from the "H.A.M.M.E.R. War" to "Avengers vs. X-Men." From the future arc to the Infinity Gems to "Fear Itself" to the "H.A.M.M.E.R. War" to now "Avengers vs. X-Men:" I wonder if I'm ever going to like this series that I spend $3.99 a month to get.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)