Showing posts with label Batgirl (2016). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Batgirl (2016). Show all posts

Wednesday, June 21, 2017

Not-Very-Deep Thoughts: The May 24 Edition (HERE BE SPOILERS!)

Batgirl #11:  Unfortunately, I'm officially done with this title now.  I love Babs, but she's had a rough run lately in terms of creators.  This tale eventually just spun completely beyond Larson's control, as she makes no attempt to explain how Ethan's data mining led to him being able to control people's thoughts over WiFi via something he calls "murmurations."  Instead, she explains how "murmurations" are also what you call flocks of starlings and the Danish word for starling is "black sun."  Coincidence!  Except it's...not.  It's fiction so I'm not really sure why Larson wants us to be impressed by these connections.  I'd rather she explain how exactly Ethan's power works. But, things go from bad to worse as Babs lectures Ethan rather than helping him as his suit overloads.  Larson can't pretend Babs doesn't realize it's happening, as she herself says she's not going to let him "fry."  But, she does exactly that, and he suffers burns over 90 percent of his body.  Barbara Gordon as the Punisher isn't really my bag of tea.  I'm outtie.

Ben Reilly:  Scarlet Spider #2:  Given how proud Ben is that he doesn't rip off Cassandra Mercury's arm when she opens fire on him, David seems to be implying the main struggle of these first few issues is going to be Ben learning how to overcome his baser instincts.  It's still unclear why Ben has said instincts, though I'm guessing we're going to blame all of his questionable behavior on the torture he suffered at the Jackal's hands and leave it at that.  In the meantime, the parameters of this series are starting to take shape.  When Mercury's daughter miraculously awakens after Ben touches her, Mercury is convinced he cured her and agrees to bankroll his research into her daughter's disease.  Ben knows he didn't do anything, but he's happy to take the cash.  With Kaine hot on Ben's trail, David seems to be taking inspiration from the '70s "Incredible Hulk" TV show:  Ben is going to solve someone's problems, probably for money, as Kaine tries to bring him to justice.  If that is David's plan, I'm down with it.  The only real question from this issue is how Ben managed to crush Mercury's gun without touching it.  He lies to her at one point in this issue, telling her he used telepathy to awaken her daughter.  But, maybe he at least has some form of telekinesis now?  (It was my first thought when he crushed the gun and thus I was surprised when he denied he had telepathy.)  I guess we'll see.

Captain America:  Steve Rogers #17:  This issue has some bright moments even though it largely covers ground we're already trod.  Spencer uses a journalist interviewing Steve on live TV to review the realities of HYDRA's America, from the concentration camps for Inhumans to the mutant nation on its border.  The only new information we get in this issue is insight into Steve's secret deal with the mutants.  As expected, he offered Magneto his own nation to get the mutants off the map, since he couldn't handle taking over America and fighting the mutants.  (Publicly, as agreed with Magneto, Steve claims the mutants illegally seized the land.)  We're not clear on why Steve insisted on making Xi'an the head of the country, but I'm pretty sure "Secret Empire:  United" will fill in those details.  Otherwise, the issue mostly involves Steve justifying his action by delivering far-right talking points about bringing economic and physical security to people who craved it.  He's admirably good at delivering said points.  The only problem is when the journalist mentions Las Vegas, something Dr. Faustus explicitly forbade her to do.  The TV feed is cut, and she's thrown into a prison cell for "endangering national security;" you get the sense she's lucky to be a prisoner and not dead.  Overall, Spencer uses this issue to remind us that a certain percentage of Americans -- a parallel to Donald Trump's oft-mentioned 38 percent -- will find a way to dismiss the destruction of Las Vegas as either a conspiracy theory or a justifiable act.  The closer these justifications come to real-life ones, the more depressing it gets.

Also Read:  Deathstroke #19; Detective Comics #957; Pathfinder:  Runescars #1; Rebels:  These Free and Independent States #3; X-Men:  Blue #4

Monday, May 8, 2017

Not-Very-Deep Thoughts: The April 26 DC Edition (HERE BE SPOILERS!)

Batgirl #10:  [Sigh.]  We can never seem to get past issue #10 in a "Batgirl" series before the wheels come off the bus.  I feel like Larson just invents whatever event or tool she needs to get Babs from Point A to Point B.  For example, I've been a fan of Babs' new "hyperfocus" ability, where she essentially turns her eidetic memory into a computer.  But, Larson pushes us past the already fast-approaching point of believability here, as Babs is now suddenly able to see inside a woman's car before her auto-drive system crashes it.  Is the car recording her?  How is that even possible?  Similarly, Babs is in this situation because someone randomly took a photo of her and Dick together that made Ethan jealous.  Why did that guy take the photo?  No idea.  They're just a guy and a girl standing by a motorcycle at a gas station.  How did Ethan know the photo was taken?  Also no idea.  Moreover, Ethan becomes a full-on super-villain here.  He not only reveals his new costumed identity as the oddly named Blacksun, but he broke off his relationship with Babs by sending an intern to do the dirty work.  It makes even less sense when you consider he got jealous over Babs talking to Dick after he ended it.  I just don't know how much longer I can hang in here.

Detective Comics #955:  This issue is weirdly bad.  Tynion usually produces top-notch products, but this issue is well off the mark.  He employs a tedious and unnecessary narrator to move us through the issue.  To make it worse, the narrator is reading a children's story that mirrors every aspect of Cassandra's pretty unique life.  It inspires her to take on the League of Shadows by herself, and she miraculously manages to defeat all of them.  Yup.  It's important because her allies are indisposed:  Jean-Paul, Kate, and Luke are naked and chained in the same room as the nuclear bomb meant to detonate the fault line under Gotham City; Bruce is soon to join them, and Clayface's body is distributed over a dozen canisters.  But, suddenly, they're all free and in costumes in time to face Shiva with Cass.  Moreover, Tynion wastes a few pages on Ulysses' narrating to Jake his creation of new smart chemical weapons he wants to use on the League.  In other words, we just lurch from one poorly explained plot point to another.  As I said, it's a rare miss for Tynion, but a miss it is.

The Flash #21:  We have a number of interesting developments here right at the start.  First, the Justice Society is somehow tied to this story; a 90-year-old Johnny Thunder appears at the start of the issue, and Flash talks about seeing Jay Garrick's Mercury Helmet in a vision.  Second, Barry discovers his own energy signature on Thawne's body, leading him to wonder if he kills Thawne.  He notably withholds this information from Bruce (who's now conscious).  Third, the Button is missing.  The plot gets rolling as Barry and Bruce use the Cosmic Treadmill to travel through time to identify Thawne's killer, using the radiation Barry found on the Button to calibrate their search.  Along the way, they see what they initially believe to be alternate universes showing the formation of various Justice Leagues, but then wonder if they're actually showing the period of time Dr. Manhattan stole.  But something goes wrong: they're struck by a bolt of lightning and find themselves in the "Flashpoint" Batcave, face-to-face with Thomas Wayne.  Williamson does a solid job of moving us through these numerous development without ignoring characterization.  Barry is struggling to come to grips with his emotions (or lack of them) as he realizes his mother's killer has come to justice, and Bruce obviously has all the feels when confronted with his father.  Maybe he'll even cry next issue!

Friday, February 24, 2017

Not-Very-Deep Thoughts: The January 25 Non-Marvel Edition (HERE BE SPOILERS!)

Batgirl #7:  This issue is uneven, with Larson making Barbara almost insufferable as a "social justice warrior to the maximum!" while at the same time injecting some excitement into the series with the introduction of Penguin's son, Ethan.  The conflict in the issue revolves around the homeless in Burnside.  Gordon Clean Energy has apparently turned Burnside into San Francisco, forcing out everyone in the 99 percent.  Barbara feels guilty (since it's her fault) and launches into a tirade when she overhears two hipsters at a party complaining about the homeless.  She attracts the attention of Ethan, whose company has developed an app to help move the homeless to "safer" locations.  But, no one is vetting the volunteers, and a villain named Fright uses the app to procure homeless people as research subjects.  (We're supposed to recognize Fright, because Barbara does, but I don't.)  Barbara makes quick work of Fright and uses her date with Ethan to gather more information about his plans.  The problem is Barbara doesn't do the thing she really should do to help, namely make Gordon Clean Energy a more responsible neighbor.  If its location in Burnside is driving up rents, she should move the company somewhere else in Gotham or do something to address the problem, like making sure the company is investing in affordable housing.  Even if she's not going to take over the company to do it herself, she should talk to Alyssia about it.  (Is Alyssia still running it?  Maybe it's time to rethink that?)  She's behaving as if she sold the company to a private-equity firm and can't control its behavior.  But, instead of doing something about the problem, she's actually washed her hands of technology entirely and enrolled in a library-science program.  I'm fine with her doing that (it's a nice nod to her past), but it's hard to reconcile that with her outrage over a situation she caused.  (Also, how fucking long was she in Asia.  It seemed like two weeks, tops.  How did Burnside gentrify so quickly?

Bloodshot U.S.A. #2-#4:  I know it won't last, but let me just say how happy I am Lemire lets Bloodshot and Magic have their happy ending.  Lemire wraps up pretty much every loose end since "The Valiant," from Kay emerging in control of Deathmate to the CEO of P.R.S. getting his comeuppance to the Bloodshot Squad getting to make their own futures.  Lemire (or whoever picks up this series) could go a lot of different directions from here, and I'll admit I'm not sure if I'm going to follow.  We so rarely get these sorts of wins in comics, and I may actually just let the win stay a win.  If so, fare ye well, at least for now, Ray Garrison.

Detective Comics #949:  It seems as if we've seen the end of Bruce's team of misfits here, as Batwoman decides to go to war with the organizations trying to obtain the monster venom.  Combined with Red Robin's "death" during "Rise of the Batman" arc and Spoiler's defection during the "Victim Syndicate" arc, we really only Clayface and Orphan left.  I'm disappointed, because I really loved this premise and would've been thrilled to see it last longer than nine months.  But, I also have to admit Tynion and Bennett wrap up the story nicely, if we are indeed seeing the end of this group.  Everyone is where they are at the end of this issue for specific reasons that evolved over the course of the last 16 issues.  We don't often get that in comics, so I have to tip my hat to the authors, even if I'm disappointed with the outcome.  Onwards and upwards.

Pathfinder:  Worldscape #4:  In the past, "Pathfinder" series have been pretty straight-forward romps.  The plot usually hasn't been too complicated, generally a step above a smash-and-grab adventure.  But, Mona really ups the ante here.  In this issue, we learn Kulan Gath pulled Merisiel through the gates 20 years ago.  His magic identified her as the "master thief" he and Camilla needed to unify the Scepter and the Crown.  We learn Tarzan was one of the few people ever to come into possession of both items, but he thought it too dangerous to keep them together.  He went into seclusion with the Crown and gave the Scepter to his ally, the warrior Queen Pha.  Over a period of six weeks, Meris helps Camilla and her team recover the Scepter from Pha, conquering the city of Shareen in the process.  Interestingly, this Camilla claims she wants to unify the two items to empty the Worldscape, allowing everyone to return to their homeworlds.  It's unclear how she becomes the despot we saw at the start of this series.  But, we'll surely learn.  At any rate, upon arriving, Meris caught a glimpse of the jungle goddess, Fantomah.  After a failed love affair, a distraught Meris begs for her help, and she appears, sending Meris home with no memory of her time in the Worldscape.  Enigmatically, Fantomah says they can help each other before dispatching Meris, so it's clear Fantomah has plans for Meris this time.  When Meris arrives again in the Worldscape, she remembers everything...including Kulan Gath, present at her arrival and announcing she'll work for him again.  For how complicated it all sounds, Mona does an amazing job of presenting it coherently, and I'm really, really excited about where we're going from here.

Also Read:  Reborn #4

Monday, February 13, 2017

Not-Very-Deep Thoughts: The December 28 DC Edition (HERE BE SPOILERS!)

All Star Batman #5:  Snyder not only takes the easy road here, but has the chutzpah to try to convince us it was the difficult one.  By claiming Harvey's brain chemistry can never be altered, he shows the hubris of every author who thinks he can quickly but permanently change a character's status quo.  It's only the slow changes that stick, like Cyclops' evolution into a villain over the course of years of storylines.  For every "you're Two-Face forever now!" moment, I can point to dozens of similar ones:  Otto Octavius as Spider-Man forever!, every permanent! Jean Gray death, Colossus as Juggernaut/Phoenix/Horseman of Apocalypse, etc.  Snyder doesn't even really properly end the issue.  We're never shown Harvey calling off the attacks on Batman.  Batman believes the crowd won't attack him now that he's defeated Two-Face, but they don't really know that he has:  they're just there for the money.  The larger struggle is irrelevant to them.  But, Bruce and Duke just waltz through the crowd, and we're done.  I think I'm done with this series, too.

Batgirl #6: Son of the Penguin?  Color me excited!

Detective Comics #947:  Batman doesn't lose often, but Tynion lets him lose here.  More importantly, he has him learn from that loss.  Spoiler leaves the team, believing the team members' lives would be better if they left behind their costumes and Gotham's citizens' lives would be better if the police were the ones to protect them.  Tynion clearly doesn't feel that way.  He uses Luke to give the dissenting opinion:  the heroes aren't perfect but they hold a line the police can't hold.  But, Tynion also acknowledges Spoiler may have a point:  Steph disables the Batsignal, and Bruce is shaken when he realizes no one got hurt in a gun fight between two gangs that the team missed as a result.  It'll be interesting to see the role Spoiler will play in the next few months.  After all, it'll be hard for her to "spoil" the team's activities without actually helping criminals.  Does she help the cops instead?  I guess we'll see.  But, it's a reminder of how nuanced of a story Tynion is telling.  It's no longer just black hats versus white hats.  Stephanie has identified a gray area, and we'll see how she operates in it.

Also Read:  Titans #6

Monday, December 26, 2016

Not-Very-Deep Thoughts: The August 24 Edition (HERE BE SPOILERS!)

Batgirl #2:  OK, I admit, it's exciting to see Babs on the road.  Larson has thrown the deck of cards into the air and we'll see where they land.  Babs is in a sort of controlled free-fall; she's never been an erratic "On the Road" type, but here she is.  She leaves Kai in this issue less because she's worried he's trouble (and he clearly is), but more because she doesn't want to be tied down.  Meanwhile, she's trying to improve her skills as a fighter, but she's still Barbara.  Her eidetic memory provides her clues about the identity of the villain who attacked Kai last issue, whether she likes it or not.  It's tweaking the Batgirl formula, where Barbara is recognizable if different.  I'm hoping Larson can keep us in this place as long as possible, after Fletcher and Stewart struggled to do so in the previous iteration of this series.

Captain America:  Steve Rogers #4:  This issue is not a smooth read.  I'm OK with Spencer entertaining the idea of Steve as a sleeper agent for HYDRA, since it's pretty clear it's going to end with him being returned to normal.  After all, Spencer isn't going all Slott and claiming he's going to remain a HYDRA agent forever.  But, the hook isn't enough to keep us going here.  Steve sounds hypnotized as Spencer is forced to drag out his dialogue to get it to work as a framing device.  But, he stretches it too far.  He uses it to cover everything, from Maria's fight with the S.H.I.E.L.D. governors to Sharon's presentation to Congress to Kobik's interactions with the Thunderbolts.  Throw in there flashbacks to Steve's new childhood and Rick Jones joining Free Spirit at a bedside vigil over Jack Flag and it's just too much.  We also have an example of pet peeve #2, since Steve isn't even in the same room as Carol and Tony, let alone putting himself in the middle of one of their arguments (as shown on the cover).  In other words, it's not Cap as a HYDRA agent that's a problem -- it's Cap as a boring expository device that's the problem.

Star Wars #22:  This issue really fulfills the promise of this series, as Han, Leia, and Luke steal an imperial Star Destroyer.  It's the sort of amazing untold story you expected to be out there, and it's one only a comic book could tell.

Titans #2:  On one level, I'm glad "Titans" is the front-line series exploring the impact Dr. Manhattan had on the DCU, because I'm at least moderately interested in the answer.  On the other hand, it could get old fast.  When Kadabra isn't sending the Titans against clones of their younger selves for convoluted super-villain reasons, he's pondering how Dr. Manhattan was involved in breaking time.  This part gets confusing, as all time-travel stories -- good or bad -- do.  In Kadabra's time, Linda and Wally haven't met yet, but it's difficult to see how that would happen.  Sure, in the original DCU, Linda and Wally would've already met.  But, in the current DCnU, Wally didn't exist.  Kadabra is implying Wally existed in his time, so is Kadabra from a third U?  I guess it's also possible he's from the future, but it doesn't seem to be the case.  I guess we'll see.  I just hope it's five or six issues from now, not 50 or 60 issues.

Also Read:  Detective Comics #939; Dungeons & Dragons:  Shadows of the Vampire #4; Extraordinary X-Men #13; New Avengers #15

Monday, December 19, 2016

Not-Very-Deep Thoughts: The August 3 Edition (HERE BE SPOILERS!)

Batgirl #1:  OK, I'm in.  I initially loved Fletcher and Stewart's run on "Batgirl," with its focus on Babs putting the Bat-family behind her and instead getting her Ph.D. and becoming Burnside's defender.  But, almost immediately, they deviated from this vision.  Babs seemed to have a new supporting cast and raison d'être every four or five issues.  Over the course of 18 issues, we went from Jeremy, Nadimah, and Qadir to Liam to Dinah, Frankie, and Luke.  We went from her trying to create a program capable of predicting crime as her Ph.D. thesis to her running a large corporation based on an idea she essentially stole.  Moreover, the characters' personalities changed to fit the story the authors wanted to tell.  Jeremy went from a hapless but endearing graduate student to a sullen and depressed criminal accessory.  Alysia went from an activist bartender with aspirations of becoming a professional chef to running Babs' corporation.  I could continue, but, like Babs, it's time to focus on the future, not the past.

Larson and Albuquerque make a great team as they re-imagine Babs as a woman backpacking through Asia on a journey of self-discovery.  Albuquerque is known for his darker themes, but he adopts this comic's unique visual style, embracing a manga sensibility for the characters.  (It's fitting since Babs starts her tour of Asia in Japan.)  Larson makes it clear that she's trying to separate Babs from her immediate past as quickly as possible.  We make a quick call to Alysia for an update, she tells Babs everything is going fine, and we're done.  I'm guessing we won't hear anything more about the company or the former supporting cast for a while.  It's a brutal yet needed transition.

In Japan, Babs' goal is to track down Fruit Bat, a Japanese heroine from the 1930s.  Upon arrival in Japan, she discovers her roommate at the hostel is Kai, a handsome but troubled childhood friend who draws the attention of a super-villain.  In other words, Larson makes us quickly forget about the past and excited about the future.   Rebirth, indeed.

Batman #4:  We'd been doing really well, but I have to admit I'm confused now.

First, Batman goes to see Amanda Waller after Gotham -- under Psycho-Pirate's influence -- kills 27 of her soldiers.  He's able to find her after Duke adds up the serial numbers on the soldiers' dog tags and they sum to 24 -- the corresponding letter of the alphabet is "X," for Task Force X, i.e., Suicide Squad.  Wait, what?  Why would Waller do that?  Was it a backdoor to make sure Batman found her in case something went wrong?  If not, it's way too comic book-y of a solution.  At any rate, we learn Hugo Strange used Gotham to kill the soldiers because Waller sent them to keep on eye on Strange.

Unfortunately for Gotham, one of the soldiers apparently survived.  He took a picture of Gotham's face after he took off his mask (a rookie mistake), ran it through Task Force X's database, and then killed Gotham's parents.  I get King is making Gotham even more of an analogue of Batman, but it's a little messy.  First, it's unclear what the time frame is of these events are.  It seems like this guy went immediately from the scene of the crime to Task Force X's base, ran the photo, and then bolted to the Clover's to kill them.  Didn't he have at least some sort of debriefing?  I know Waller doesn't care about people's mental states, but even she should recognize it's probably dangerous to the sole survivor of a massacre running around town.  Of course, based on a comment she makes to Batman, maybe she wanted Gotham to go crazy.  Did she send the guard herself?  I'm not sure we're going to get that answer.  It's also weird killing Gotham's parents is his first thought.  Is that the standard DCU response to having a beef with someone?  At any rate, Gotham kills the soldier in front of Bruce and resolves -- again, under the influence of Psycho-Pirate -- to raze Gotham before it hurts someone else again.

It's unclear to me how aware of his actions Gotham is.  When Bruce confronts him over the 27 dead soldiers, he actually recognizes that the body count should've been 28.  He puts two and two together and immediately flees the scene to make sure his parents are OK.  (Again, though, it's weird it's everyone's first response.  "Someone has a beef with me; I have to check on my folks!")  However, we also see Gotham reconstructing the bridge that the mysterious agents blew up last issue, so he still believes himself to be something of a hero.  I think we're supposed to believe Strange is screwing with him, making him alternate between heroic and terrible actions to maximize the psychological damage.  From a narrative perspective, it's hard to follow and it somewhat dulls the emotional impact of the story.  You're so busy trying to figure out which Gotham is talking that you skip past the empathy we're supposed to have for him.

Moon Knight #5:  Lemire is using Marc's increasingly weak grip on reality to full effect here, as Marc is forced to cycle through his various personae -- Jake Lockley, Steve Grant, and Moon Knight himself -- as he flees the mental-institution orderlies.  He eventually encounters Seth, realizing Khonshu wasn't telling him the truth when he said Seth was responsible for his plight.  Seth encourages Marc to face his enemy, and it's revealed to be Khonshu himself.

It was all a test, because Khonshu wants Marc to take the final step:  his body is dying, and he wants Marc to surrender his body and mind to him.  Khonshu plays it as a blessing, an opportunity for Marc to be at peace from his fractured mind.  Marc seems to consider it, acknowledging his mind is indeed broken.  At the end, though, Marc rejects Khonshu, hurling himself from the pyramid where their confrontation occurred.  We see him bleeding in the sand...and then awakening as Steve Grant in New York.  He sheds a tear, happy to be there.  But, Lemire isn't revealing what we're actually seeing here.  Is Marc Spector no more?  Is Moon Knight no more?  We'll have to see.

A lot of the energy in this issue comes from the team of artists.  That phrase is usually not associated with excellence, but the editors use them brilliantly to show the different personae fighting for dominance.  I still like Smallwood's renderings the best, for they're gritty realism, but I also appreciate the use of art to drive home the different visions of the world Marc and his personalities have.  I'm definitely excited to see where we go from here.

Nightwing #2:  Although I like where Seeley is going, I can't help but feel like he's rushing to get us there.  Case in point, Raptor goes from an amoral hired gun to edgy good guy over the course of just a few panels.  Last issue, he was basically the second coming of R'as al Ghul, but in this issue he's suddenly Batman if he were a little closer to Chaotic Evil than Chaotic Good.  That said, he does seem like a fun and intriguing new character.  He shares Dick's sense of humor, even if it's a little darker; I loved his devotion to branding, marketing, and advertising as the three irresistible forces of the Universe.  He's also clearly got a back story, since he also seems to be working against the Parliament in the long run, for reasons that I assume Seeley will eventually reveal.

But, again, it feels rushed.  Seeley essentially demotes Dick to sidekick again, seemingly ignoring the fact we're talking about a guy who led the Titans, served as Batman, and was a super-spy.  It's hard to square this circle, that a previously unknown costumed hero (villain?) could so easily school Dick.  Moreover, Raptor immediately decides to trust Dick as a partner and as a confidante.  It's one thing to believe that Dick will make sure you don't get killed on a mission, but it's another thing to confide in him that you're working to take down an organization like the Parliament of Owls.  It seems ill advised moment of trust for a morally ambiguous mercenary.  It would've been better if Raptor spent a few issues taking Dick's measure and then trusting him, as a partner first and then as a confidante.

The good news, though, is I still like where we're going.  Dick never really got his hands too dirty while he was working for Spyral, but Raptor makes clear they're going to have to accept doing the Parliament's dirty work (and hurting people) in the short run to defeat them in the long run.  It'll be interesting to see where Dick draws his lines in the sand tested, particularly since, as we see when he skips a date with Babs, he'll be doing it on his own again.

Spidey #9:  Nope, I totally didn't tear up at the end.  Nope.  Not at all.

Also Read:  Justice League #2; Tokyo Ghost #9