All-New X-Men #7: Hopeless legitimately makes you wonder if he's going to kill Scott here, as he has to collapse a tunnel on himself to escape Toad. It's a remarkable feat, given how cynical of a comic-book reader I am, so I felt that it merited mentioning.
Detective Comics #51: You have to wonder if Tomasi knew the DCnU was ending or if he's going to have to wrap up this story more quickly than he expected. After all, this story feels like the start of an ambitious arc, as Jim Gordon travels to Afghanistan to discover who (or what) is killing his former unit mates. It's a gripping story, with Tomasi doing an amazing job of really immersing you into the lives of the people fighting our foreign wars. I do have two nitpicks, though. First, Jim doesn't seem to think through the implications of him appearing as Jim Gordon on the base and then as Batman to shake down the crooked Colonel. Rookie mistake, Jimbo. (That said, I don't think that the Colonel is going to survive long enough to put two and two together.) Second, I'm still not sure how old we're supposed to believe Jim is. We invaded Afghanistan in 2001. Even if Jim was in the Marines at the start of the war -- in that first wave -- it means that he's only been a cop for 15 years. But, he does have a daughter old enough to be in a Ph.D. program. Even if he had her at 18 years old and Barbara herself is 24 years old, he's got to be at least 42 years old. Did he become a cop at 27 years old? Was he in the Marines until then? That said, Barbara has always remembered him as a cop, not a soldier, so it actually implies that he left the Corps before she could remember. Did he leave almost immediately after she was born, say, when he was 20 years old. If so, what did he do between 20 and 27? Was he a cop in Chicago during that time? Oh, well. We're going to reboot the whole universe in an issue anyway, so I guess that it doesn't matter.
Spider-Man 2099 #9: My problem with this issue is that I still really have no idea who David wants us to believe that Tempest -- or, for that matter, her mother, Cecilia -- is. In fact, Tempest seems to be a totally different character now -- with an entirely different history -- than she originally was. When we first met Tempest, she was the foul-tempered super at the crappy apartment building where Miguel rented a place. She had cancer, her mother "never gave a damn about [her] growing up" (series 2, issue #11), and her father wanted a boy so took her to "every game he could afford" (series 2, issue #2). However, David has been straying from this script significantly. First, we don't really have any idea what Tempest is doing now that she and Miguel are together, though it seems like she's no longer a super. Then, we learn that her mother is a mutant (or, knowing Marvel, an Inhuman), that she kept Tempest isolated for fear that she had inherited her powers, and that she murdered her Mob-connected second husband when she discovered that he used to take hidden-camera photos of Tempest. I'm assuming that it's not the same father that took her to the ball games, particularly since her mom mentions that Tempest never liked him. (No wonder.) The problem with that theory is that Tempest's mom also says in this issue that Tempest's birth father abandoned them when she was four years old. It's hard to believe that she'd remember games she attended as a three-year-old. So, which is it? Moreover, is Cecilia just a caring mother that scared away Miguel for his own good, as she claims here? Hiring Man Mountain Marko seems to be taking that approach to an extreme. Or, is it more sinister, like she whacked her husband and took over his criminal empire ? Do we just blame it on "Secret Wars?" It's all unclear.
Uncanny Avengers #8: I don't think that I've commented on "Avengers Standoff," mainly, I think, because I'm actually enjoying it. It's a little decentralized, but that format actually helps highlight the confusion that the characters themselves feel. The problem that I had in this issue has nothing to do with "Standoff," though. Duggan has Deadpool claim that Steve put him on the team to remind the other members that everyone wasn't gods. It's a fair point...but one undermined by the fact that he's not in his costume when he delivers it. As a result, we see his cancer-ridden body, and we're reminded how extraordinary his healing factor is. Black Widow and Hawkeye are powerless humans that remind us that all the Avengers aren't gods: Deadpool doesn't really fit in that category.
Also Read: Amazing Spider-Man #1.4; Batgirl #50; Batman and Robin Eternal #26; Black Panther #1; Captain America: Sam Wilson #7; Justice League of America #8; Justice League: Darkseid War - Special #1; Midnighter #11; New Avengers #9; Poe Dameron #1; Spider-Man #3
I cover a lot of different titles, with some particular attention to the previous runs of "Spider-Man 2099" and "Nova." Welcome back, Richard! Until next time, Miguel.
Showing posts with label Detective Comics (2011). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Detective Comics (2011). Show all posts
Tuesday, June 14, 2016
Tuesday, March 22, 2016
Detective Comics #48 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Tomasi's gift has always been his great sense of characterization and his uncanny ability to convey that characterization through dialogue. He's perfectly matched on this issue with Pasarin, Ryan, and Sotomayor; they do an excellent job getting across specific moods that highlight why the characters do what they do. In other words, it's a solid team effort from start to finish.
The story is fairly simple. We begin with Jim standing on a rooftop and (somewhat creepily, to be honest) watching Gothamites going about their lives in their apartments. It's a good reminder that the Joker isn't murdering everyone in Gotham at all times. Jim watches a father tuck in his daughter, and he calls Babs. She's taking down some purse-snatchers as Batgirl, and then he follows the sound of a gunshot as Batman, and it results in a legitimately funny conversation where she pretends to be at the movies and he pretends to be grabbing some pizza. It's a nice way to start the issue. Unfortunately for Jim, it doesn't stay nice.
At the source of the gunshot, he stumbles upon the body of what appears to be a Revolutionary War re-enactor, and it's here where the artists really shine. One of the hardest things to convey in comics is sound. To do so, the artists use words straight from the 1960s Batman TV show extremely effectively here: we hear the gunshot that hits Jim in the back of the head as he's examining the body, we hear him crash into a bunch of garbage cans, we hear him panting as he calls the Bat-blimp for support. All the while, we also get the sense of claustrophobia that comes with the fact that it all happens in an alley in the pouring rain. It just really pulls you into the story, one of those moments where you feel like you're there.
Later, Jim meets Harvey in the morgue, and we learn that the victim was a decorated fireman. Jim catches the fact that his thigh bone has been surgically removed, but, other than that, they've got no leads. (Harvey comments that the medical examiner would've missed that, so they should probably think about getting a new one.) Meanwhile, the perpetrator returns to his base of operations in an abandoned cemetery. He strips off the Revolutionary War outfit that he'd been wearing, and he hangs the mask on a peg next to dozens of other masks. He then approaches a guy that he has chained to a chair and proceeds to shave off his beard while muttering what sounds like quotes from the Federalist Papers. Later, we discover his next victim (presumably the bearded man) dressed as an astronaut attached to the spire on top of Wayne Tower.
Tomasi and the artists make you feel like he's an extreme version of Calendar Man, except one obsessed with American iconography not dates. A crazed history teacher? I guess we'll see. In the meantime, it's the type of story that I love seeing in "Detective Comics," a mystery that passes for typical in Gotham. With the excellent characterization and palpable mood, the creators really catch your attention from the first page and never let it go. It's a good reminder that you don't need the "Darkseid War" or "Secret Wars" to tell a good superhero story.
*** (three of five stars)
Wednesday, March 2, 2016
Detective Comics #47 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
(I accidentally read this issue before I read "Grayson" #15, so you can imagine my surprise when Damian, Jason, Tim, and the Robins are all in prison.)
In this issue, we finally start getting more details on the war on the Robins. We learn that Dick believes that the confrontation at the liquor store was a set-up. To his mind, it's too convenient that the cop entered the store just as the untrained Robin was apprehending the suspect. After the obligatory hero/hero confrontation, Dick shares this theory with Jim. (Said fight happens when Jim catches Dick riffling through someone's apartment, though it's unclear to me whose apartment it is and why they're both there.) Jim initially rejects Dick's theory, but, during their conversation, admits that his gut has been telling him that something similar. Together, they go to find out more information on Councilwoman Noctua.
Meanwhile, in prison, a member of the Court of Owls emerges from the shadows with a squad of Talons to "handle" the Robins before they can jeopardize the Court's plans for Gotham and the "Gray Son." In terms of the larger plot, we still don't know what the Court wants, other than Dick. (Heh.) At this stage, it's not clear to me what the Robins were preventing the Court from doing when it comes to their "plans" for Gotham and Dick. It seems like it has to be more than just using them to attract Dick to Gotham.
Meanwhile, in prison, a member of the Court of Owls emerges from the shadows with a squad of Talons to "handle" the Robins before they can jeopardize the Court's plans for Gotham and the "Gray Son." In terms of the larger plot, we still don't know what the Court wants, other than Dick. (Heh.) At this stage, it's not clear to me what the Robins were preventing the Court from doing when it comes to their "plans" for Gotham and Dick. It seems like it has to be more than just using them to attract Dick to Gotham.
My main problem with this issue, though, is the characterization. In fact, one of the problems of this entire cross-over event is that it functionally ignores the events of "Batman and Robin Eternal." Here, Jason and Tim are easily pushed to fighting with each other, even though they're partners in the other series. In fact, throughout the New 52!, they've always been portrayed as close. "Batman and Robin Eternal" reflects that relationship, as Jason repeatedly pressed Tim to trust him, telling him how important it was for them to be on each other's side. Instead, in this series, Fawkes makes it seem that the two of them are rivals that can barely stand each other, a characterization that we've never seen in the New 52! For most of the issue, I actually thought that they were just acting, part of some unspoken plan between them and Damian. But, it doesn't seem to be the case, unfortunately, so I'm just going to have to be disappointed. Hopefully subsequent authors will use the more standard portrayal of their relationship.
** (two of five stars)
Friday, January 1, 2016
Detective Comics #46 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
The only thing I really have to say about this issue is that it's the most touching story about a dying creature and his parents that you'll read all year.
Now, look, it's not perfect. I totally rolled my eyes when Jim miraculously put together the story of the parents sacrificing themselves for food for the baby and the baby subsequently refusing to leave his mother's skeleton. I continued to roll my eyes at the idea that the Justice League needed Jim to piece it together, given that Flash is a forensic scientist and Cyborg is...well, Cyborg. In fact, I was rolling my eyes so much by the end that they hurt. We're really supposed to believe that the Justice League had nothing better to do than track down "missing hikers?" The landscape looked like it was Antarctica, so it's hard to believe that the place had a veritable parade of hikers streaming through it. (In case you're wondering, after it ate its mother, the baby survived on the liquid found in human eyeballs. As such, it had to kill the aforementioned hikers. However, we also learn that this liquid only sustained it; Earth's atmosphere has been slowly killing it the entire time.)
All that said, I still go choked up a bit at the end, as Jim sings the dying baby a lullaby as it cradles its mother. (Cyborg had brought the mother "alive" by super-imposing a hologram on her skeleton. When the baby saw it, he let the Justice League go.) It's probably the most off-beat issue of the year, but Tomasi really sells it at the end. It's not going to be everyone's cup of tea, but it reminds me how Tomasi is one of the best scripter of emotions out there.
*** (three of five stars)
Now, look, it's not perfect. I totally rolled my eyes when Jim miraculously put together the story of the parents sacrificing themselves for food for the baby and the baby subsequently refusing to leave his mother's skeleton. I continued to roll my eyes at the idea that the Justice League needed Jim to piece it together, given that Flash is a forensic scientist and Cyborg is...well, Cyborg. In fact, I was rolling my eyes so much by the end that they hurt. We're really supposed to believe that the Justice League had nothing better to do than track down "missing hikers?" The landscape looked like it was Antarctica, so it's hard to believe that the place had a veritable parade of hikers streaming through it. (In case you're wondering, after it ate its mother, the baby survived on the liquid found in human eyeballs. As such, it had to kill the aforementioned hikers. However, we also learn that this liquid only sustained it; Earth's atmosphere has been slowly killing it the entire time.)
All that said, I still go choked up a bit at the end, as Jim sings the dying baby a lullaby as it cradles its mother. (Cyborg had brought the mother "alive" by super-imposing a hologram on her skeleton. When the baby saw it, he let the Justice League go.) It's probably the most off-beat issue of the year, but Tomasi really sells it at the end. It's not going to be everyone's cup of tea, but it reminds me how Tomasi is one of the best scripter of emotions out there.
*** (three of five stars)
Sunday, November 8, 2015
Detective Comics #45 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This issue is really solid, from start to finish.
After reading "Batman and Robin Eternal" #1, I realized that we never really saw the Bat-family members mourn in the period of time when they would've thought that both Bruce and Dick were dead. I imagine that they would've been devastated by the loss of both their guiding lights. But, we never really saw a story focus on that loss. It might've happened in "Red Hood/Arsenal" or "Teen Titans," but it didn't in "Batgirl," "Batman," or this title. On some level, it's a reflection of how Bruce- and Dick-centric the Bat-family is: DC can't keep them on the sidelines in the main titles long enough to focus on the other family members. It's a shame, because the brilliance of Snyder's "Black Mirror" arc in this series was that he fully explored Dick's keen sense of Bruce's absence. Instead, Snyder rushed introducing the amnesiac Bruce Wayne into "Batman." To be clear, I'm really enjoying the story, so I'm not complaining. But, I'm left feeling that we're missing an important piece of the puzzle.
That said, all the Bat-family authors have done an excellent job in dealing with the amnesiac Bruce (now that we have him). They've shown the fine line that everyone has to walk around him. In this issue, the Justice League arrives to recruit Bruce (and his detective skills) to solve a particularly pressing mystery. Alfred is the ever-vigilant gatekeeper here, but Bruce overhears the conversation and allows Diana to use her Lasso of Truth to see if any semblance of the old Bruce remains. It doesn't, and Takara makes Diana's conflicted emotions over that revelation obvious. We're also treated to a poignant scene of Superman clasping Bruce's hands in his own hands and thanking him for his previous assistance to the League. Both Tomasi and Takara make it clear that the League feels Bruce's loss keenly.
Instead, as Jim himself later says, the League is forced to go to Plan B: namely, Jim. They find him fighting off a group of F-15s whose pilots fell under the control of the Mad Hatter. This fight scene is awesome, like "Top Gun" meets "The Dark Knight." Takara can stay as long as he wants. In fact, Takara really shows his range in the scenes preceding the fight sequence, where Jim is taking in a Little League game and realizing why he does what he does. Jim looks relaxed for the first time (possibly ever), and it really matches the emotion that Tomasi wants us to feel, of a proud if weary warrior. He also shows Jim's anxiety when the League asks them to solve the mystery that brought them to Wayne Manor. After all, it's not every day he gets teleported to the frozen tundra to examine a giant skeleton. But, it's also a reminder that Jim is a detective in his own right, and Diana essentially tells him that they'll focus on the super-heroics if he focuses on the mystery.
In other words, it's an emotional journey that captures this feeling of loss that I realized had been missing. With the loss identified, everyone is now patting each other's backs and trying to find a way forward. We'll all see where we go.
*** (three of five stars)
After reading "Batman and Robin Eternal" #1, I realized that we never really saw the Bat-family members mourn in the period of time when they would've thought that both Bruce and Dick were dead. I imagine that they would've been devastated by the loss of both their guiding lights. But, we never really saw a story focus on that loss. It might've happened in "Red Hood/Arsenal" or "Teen Titans," but it didn't in "Batgirl," "Batman," or this title. On some level, it's a reflection of how Bruce- and Dick-centric the Bat-family is: DC can't keep them on the sidelines in the main titles long enough to focus on the other family members. It's a shame, because the brilliance of Snyder's "Black Mirror" arc in this series was that he fully explored Dick's keen sense of Bruce's absence. Instead, Snyder rushed introducing the amnesiac Bruce Wayne into "Batman." To be clear, I'm really enjoying the story, so I'm not complaining. But, I'm left feeling that we're missing an important piece of the puzzle.
That said, all the Bat-family authors have done an excellent job in dealing with the amnesiac Bruce (now that we have him). They've shown the fine line that everyone has to walk around him. In this issue, the Justice League arrives to recruit Bruce (and his detective skills) to solve a particularly pressing mystery. Alfred is the ever-vigilant gatekeeper here, but Bruce overhears the conversation and allows Diana to use her Lasso of Truth to see if any semblance of the old Bruce remains. It doesn't, and Takara makes Diana's conflicted emotions over that revelation obvious. We're also treated to a poignant scene of Superman clasping Bruce's hands in his own hands and thanking him for his previous assistance to the League. Both Tomasi and Takara make it clear that the League feels Bruce's loss keenly.
Instead, as Jim himself later says, the League is forced to go to Plan B: namely, Jim. They find him fighting off a group of F-15s whose pilots fell under the control of the Mad Hatter. This fight scene is awesome, like "Top Gun" meets "The Dark Knight." Takara can stay as long as he wants. In fact, Takara really shows his range in the scenes preceding the fight sequence, where Jim is taking in a Little League game and realizing why he does what he does. Jim looks relaxed for the first time (possibly ever), and it really matches the emotion that Tomasi wants us to feel, of a proud if weary warrior. He also shows Jim's anxiety when the League asks them to solve the mystery that brought them to Wayne Manor. After all, it's not every day he gets teleported to the frozen tundra to examine a giant skeleton. But, it's also a reminder that Jim is a detective in his own right, and Diana essentially tells him that they'll focus on the super-heroics if he focuses on the mystery.
In other words, it's an emotional journey that captures this feeling of loss that I realized had been missing. With the loss identified, everyone is now patting each other's backs and trying to find a way forward. We'll all see where we go.
*** (three of five stars)
Tuesday, October 13, 2015
Detective Comics #44 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Buccellato really wraps up this arc nicely. In fact, each arc just keeps getting tighter and tighter. It already makes me excited about the next one.
In the end, this arc was really about re-establishing the Bullock/Montoya partnership. Renée tells Harvey that she had to leave Gother (and him) to learn what she did in Blüdhaven, and he gets over his anger at her for leaving. But, he can't have two partners, and it means that Yip has to go. In truth, Buccellato gives her a better send-off than she deserved. He had me going for a few pages that Harvey really did kill her, but eventually I figured that he simply rescued her from the burning car and let her slink into the night. Instead, we learn that she went into the witness-protection program, turning on Stefano Falcone. He had hired her to provide the seating chart for the circus not because he wanted to kill the VIPs (as everyone thought), but because he wanted to kill the cops attending the rehearsal that had refused to work with him. It's a solid motive, one made all the clearer when he lets Yip live after he gives her the money, since he wants people that do work with him to know that they'll be rewarded.
I don't really have a problem with his motivation, but I still don't understand Yip's. She tells Stefano that she worked with him since she realized that all the other cops in Gotham were in his pocket, so she might as well be. I totally get that, but we don't learn why she immediately called Harvey after she takes the money. I would buy her feeling enough guilt after a period of time to call, hurriedly confessing to the crime in time for Harvey to save everyone. Instead, Buccellato essentially lets her have her cake and eat it, too: she gets the blood money and a clean conscience. But, if she had qualms about helping Stefano kill a bunch of cops, then why take the money in the first place? Conversely, if her motivation came from the fact that she didn't care about the GCPD given how corrupt it was, then why feel guilt over a getting a bunch of cops killed? Buccellato has her on a fine line here, as if she essentially only felt bad that clean cops would get killed so she makes the play to make everyone happy. I'd rather the type of clear (and dark) motivation that we saw from Captain Watanabe in "Amazing Spider-Man: Spiral."
Motivations aside, her departure clears the deck for Bullock and Montoya to reunite, so good riddance to bad rubbish, I say. Along the way, Jim is forced to take down Joker's Daughter's Jokerbot, a reminder that sometimes Batman has a lot of competing priorities that we has to tackle. Jim ends the issue sharing a beer with Harvey on the rooftop, so all's well that ends well. Just like Layman's run on this title giving us a better set of Batman-focused stories than the main title did, I feel like Buccellato is following the same path, stripping away the mythos that often plagues "Batman" and just telling a good story. Hopefully he keeps up the good work.
*** (three of five stars)
Sunday, September 20, 2015
Detective Comics #43 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
The plot definitely thickens in this issue, in part because Buccellato adds a number of new layers.
We learn that the three "brothers" that comprise La Morte are a team of operatives that only take on big jobs. They're in Gotham to fulfill contracts for two clients. The first is to steal the power core from the Batsuit and deliver it to Joker's Daughter. The second is to assassinate someone at the circus event (presumably) for the Falcone family. Harvey and Montoya have a hunch that someone may be pulling the strings despite the fact that the two contracts seem unrelated.
As usual, when we get more answers, we also get more questions. It's not clear to me how Joker's Daughter learned about the power core in the Batsuit. It seems like she'd have to have someone pretty deep in the system to get that information. It could be Yip, but it seems more like she's working for the Falcones, since Monotoya's investigation of her call history reveals that she sent someone the seating chart for the circus event. So, we still need to learn how Joker's Daughter discovered the secret, if you will, of the Batsuit's power. We also learn that La Morte goaded Gordon into leaving the suit at the end of the issue specifically to steal the core. The bad news for them is that Gordon managed to take down two of them, leaving only one operational. He negotiates with Joker's Daughter to help, and it seems like she debuts the Jokerbot that we see at the end of this issue (presumably using the stolen core) to distract Gordon. I'm not entirely sure why she's acting now, though, since I feel like the circus event is still a few days in the future. I guess we'll see.
We also still don't know Yip's motivations. Harvey approaches her here, but she merely tells him that she's already dead, something he'll understand when he sees who the target of the assassination is. Although Buccellato tries to make it seem like Harvey is trying to convince Jim to help him kill Yip, it seems pretty clear that he wants to fake her death so she can escape. Again, it reminds to be seen how it's going to go.
Buccellato is on his own this issue, in the writing department, and it may be why we get such a direct line from Point A to Point B. Regardless, the team continues to do a better job in advancing these mysteries issue by issue, and I'm intrigued to see where we go from here.
*** (three of five stars)
We learn that the three "brothers" that comprise La Morte are a team of operatives that only take on big jobs. They're in Gotham to fulfill contracts for two clients. The first is to steal the power core from the Batsuit and deliver it to Joker's Daughter. The second is to assassinate someone at the circus event (presumably) for the Falcone family. Harvey and Montoya have a hunch that someone may be pulling the strings despite the fact that the two contracts seem unrelated.
As usual, when we get more answers, we also get more questions. It's not clear to me how Joker's Daughter learned about the power core in the Batsuit. It seems like she'd have to have someone pretty deep in the system to get that information. It could be Yip, but it seems more like she's working for the Falcones, since Monotoya's investigation of her call history reveals that she sent someone the seating chart for the circus event. So, we still need to learn how Joker's Daughter discovered the secret, if you will, of the Batsuit's power. We also learn that La Morte goaded Gordon into leaving the suit at the end of the issue specifically to steal the core. The bad news for them is that Gordon managed to take down two of them, leaving only one operational. He negotiates with Joker's Daughter to help, and it seems like she debuts the Jokerbot that we see at the end of this issue (presumably using the stolen core) to distract Gordon. I'm not entirely sure why she's acting now, though, since I feel like the circus event is still a few days in the future. I guess we'll see.
We also still don't know Yip's motivations. Harvey approaches her here, but she merely tells him that she's already dead, something he'll understand when he sees who the target of the assassination is. Although Buccellato tries to make it seem like Harvey is trying to convince Jim to help him kill Yip, it seems pretty clear that he wants to fake her death so she can escape. Again, it reminds to be seen how it's going to go.
Buccellato is on his own this issue, in the writing department, and it may be why we get such a direct line from Point A to Point B. Regardless, the team continues to do a better job in advancing these mysteries issue by issue, and I'm intrigued to see where we go from here.
*** (three of five stars)
Sunday, August 2, 2015
Detective Comics #42 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
The authors continue to do a good job immersing us in the increasingly complicated world of Harvey Bullock, but I feel like we're starting to see stretching at the seams as the story expands.
First, we've got Montoya's awkward conversation with Harvey after he prematurely leaves a meeting at GCPD HQ. Following her lead, Harvey says that the tension in the room came from the age-old divide within the GCPD between crooked and straight cops. But, I didn't really see anything of the sort in that meeting. Harvey left because some of the other cops were making fun of Batman, since they had to save him in his battle with La Morte earlier in the evening (more on that in a minute). Nothing about that conversation really seemed like it had anything to do with crooked or straight cops. It just seemed like Harvey was pissed at them for (unknowingly) dissing his friend Jim.
Second, Harvey inexplicably becomes suspicious of Yip, despite the fact that we don't see any reason why he would be here. We get a scene where he and Yip walk into his apartment and he asks her to give him a minute, but I didn't see anything in the apartment that would arouse his suspicions. But, when he sees that she missed 11 calls while they were sleeping, he writes down the number and gives it to Montoya. OK, sure, he didn't tell Montoya that it was a number connected to Yip. But, at some point the authors have to make some sort of effort to explain why Harvey suddenly got suspicious of Yip. It can't just be that he realized that Montoya was Internal Affairs and immediately suspected that she was talking to him because she wanted to get to Yip. It's not like GCPD doesn't have plenty of other dirty cops that Montoya might be tracking or that Montoya wouldn't talk to Harvey anyway given their relationship. Right now, it feels like he's suspicious simply because the authors need him to be to move along the story.
Moreover, we still don't have any information on La Morte. They make some reference to designing weapons for someone named "J.D.," but it's about the only clue that we get. It seems like the team may be connected to the disappearance of an "egghead" working for Geri Powers. At first, I thought that the cop that mentioned the disappearance was referring to Daryl, Julia's partner on the blimp team, since Harvey had previously referred to him as a nerd to Jim. But, Daryl appears later in the issue, so it can't be him. I don't think that anyone mentioned a missing technician last issue, so I'm assuming that we've got a case of Chekhov's gun here and that we'll learn more at some point.
Finally, Jim is way too easily defeated here. Now, I get that it's part of the story. In fact, it seems likely that the missing "egghead" gave information about the suit to La Morte, since they were able to disable it so easily. But, again, it just feels like he's defeated that easily because he has to be for the authors to achieve their goal. It seems that they want to use it as Jim's baptism by fire, since he's forced to leave the suit and fight only in his union suit at the end of this issue. But, it raises the question of how long we can continue believing that Jim is Batman, if he and the suit are so easily defeated. Maybe the suit really is a transitional item, and, after Jim wins a few fights in his union suit, he'll discover that he's better without the larger suit. We'd see him really become Batman then. But, I'm not sure if it's where we're going. I'm worried that, instead, Jim's tenure as Batman is going to be all about his suit malfunctioning, like how the early days of Spider-Man were about him exhausting his Web-Fluid.
Again, I'm really enjoying the focus on Harvey, but the authors really need to do some work here to take the sort of care that they took in the Anarky arc to build the story slowly. Otherwise, it's going to feel like we're just bouncing from development to development without any real motivation or reason.
** (two of five stars)
First, we've got Montoya's awkward conversation with Harvey after he prematurely leaves a meeting at GCPD HQ. Following her lead, Harvey says that the tension in the room came from the age-old divide within the GCPD between crooked and straight cops. But, I didn't really see anything of the sort in that meeting. Harvey left because some of the other cops were making fun of Batman, since they had to save him in his battle with La Morte earlier in the evening (more on that in a minute). Nothing about that conversation really seemed like it had anything to do with crooked or straight cops. It just seemed like Harvey was pissed at them for (unknowingly) dissing his friend Jim.
Second, Harvey inexplicably becomes suspicious of Yip, despite the fact that we don't see any reason why he would be here. We get a scene where he and Yip walk into his apartment and he asks her to give him a minute, but I didn't see anything in the apartment that would arouse his suspicions. But, when he sees that she missed 11 calls while they were sleeping, he writes down the number and gives it to Montoya. OK, sure, he didn't tell Montoya that it was a number connected to Yip. But, at some point the authors have to make some sort of effort to explain why Harvey suddenly got suspicious of Yip. It can't just be that he realized that Montoya was Internal Affairs and immediately suspected that she was talking to him because she wanted to get to Yip. It's not like GCPD doesn't have plenty of other dirty cops that Montoya might be tracking or that Montoya wouldn't talk to Harvey anyway given their relationship. Right now, it feels like he's suspicious simply because the authors need him to be to move along the story.
Moreover, we still don't have any information on La Morte. They make some reference to designing weapons for someone named "J.D.," but it's about the only clue that we get. It seems like the team may be connected to the disappearance of an "egghead" working for Geri Powers. At first, I thought that the cop that mentioned the disappearance was referring to Daryl, Julia's partner on the blimp team, since Harvey had previously referred to him as a nerd to Jim. But, Daryl appears later in the issue, so it can't be him. I don't think that anyone mentioned a missing technician last issue, so I'm assuming that we've got a case of Chekhov's gun here and that we'll learn more at some point.
Finally, Jim is way too easily defeated here. Now, I get that it's part of the story. In fact, it seems likely that the missing "egghead" gave information about the suit to La Morte, since they were able to disable it so easily. But, again, it just feels like he's defeated that easily because he has to be for the authors to achieve their goal. It seems that they want to use it as Jim's baptism by fire, since he's forced to leave the suit and fight only in his union suit at the end of this issue. But, it raises the question of how long we can continue believing that Jim is Batman, if he and the suit are so easily defeated. Maybe the suit really is a transitional item, and, after Jim wins a few fights in his union suit, he'll discover that he's better without the larger suit. We'd see him really become Batman then. But, I'm not sure if it's where we're going. I'm worried that, instead, Jim's tenure as Batman is going to be all about his suit malfunctioning, like how the early days of Spider-Man were about him exhausting his Web-Fluid.
Again, I'm really enjoying the focus on Harvey, but the authors really need to do some work here to take the sort of care that they took in the Anarky arc to build the story slowly. Otherwise, it's going to feel like we're just bouncing from development to development without any real motivation or reason.
** (two of five stars)
Monday, July 13, 2015
Detective Comics #41 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
We have a lot of ground to cover here.
This issue follows from "Divergence FCBD Special Edition" #1 and "Batman" #41, with Jim Gordon fully ensconced as the new government-approved Batman. At first, I wondered how Manallato responded to getting a change in the identity of Batman forced on them. After all, they've only been at the helm of "Detective Comics" for a short while, and they seemed to be telling a long story, given how characters flowed from minor to major to minor from issue to issue. But, Manallato make it clear that they're not only fully on board with the change, but that it gives them a chance to explore Bullock (clearly the main character of the series at this point) in a way that they haven't before.
Manallato do a great job of using flashbacks to show Bullock coming to grips with this new Batman. First, he's the only person in Gotham that thinks that the original Batman is still alive (showing how clever he is, given the last page of "Batman" #41). However, Commissioner Sawyer refuses his request to continue investigating that possibility. The Powers That Be want him to head up the Batman Task Force, but he declines. Later, he sets off a brawl at a cop bar when a few bikers enter, ostensibly because he's offended that they're there. But, Manallato remind us how clever Bullock is, because it's clear that he did so so that Yip, now his girlfriend, can save one of the members of the review board. (She's still suspended after shooting Lonnie a few weeks earlier.) Eventually, Montoya appears, saving Bullock from getting clobbered over the head with a beer bottle. (Their conversation later, where she calls him "Glass jaw" and he calls her "Man hands" is a highlight of the issue.) We learn that she's returned to Gotham to work on the Task Force, and she lets slip to Harvey that Jim may be the Batman. This revelation brings Bullock on board, but he extracts a promise from Montoya to help him keep investigating the original Batman.
Again, Manallato give us quintessential Harvey here. They remind us that he's an excellent detective (given his hunch about Bruce) and that he's principled (since his initial reluctance to join the Task Force came from his disapproval of masked vigilantes). But, they continue to show his vulnerable side. First, they remind us that, for his gruff, macho exterior, Bullock's closest relationships are with women that he respects: Montoya, Sawyer, and Yip. But, his emotions cloud his judgment with Yip, since we learn here that she might be colluding with someone to blow up a circus performance for cops and firefighters. (Jim is earlier seen talking with Sawyer about protecting it.) I instantly felt bad for Harvey since he's not going to recover from the revelation, if it happens, that he missed the fact that Yip had turned to the dark side.
Moreover, Manallato make this book an integral part of the larger story that DC is telling about Batman. While "Batman" so far is focused on Jim and his team, "Detective Comics" looks like it's going to be the place where we get to the bottom of what happened in that cave under Gotham. Come for Batman, stay for Harvey. I can dig it.
**** (four of five stars)
This issue follows from "Divergence FCBD Special Edition" #1 and "Batman" #41, with Jim Gordon fully ensconced as the new government-approved Batman. At first, I wondered how Manallato responded to getting a change in the identity of Batman forced on them. After all, they've only been at the helm of "Detective Comics" for a short while, and they seemed to be telling a long story, given how characters flowed from minor to major to minor from issue to issue. But, Manallato make it clear that they're not only fully on board with the change, but that it gives them a chance to explore Bullock (clearly the main character of the series at this point) in a way that they haven't before.
Manallato do a great job of using flashbacks to show Bullock coming to grips with this new Batman. First, he's the only person in Gotham that thinks that the original Batman is still alive (showing how clever he is, given the last page of "Batman" #41). However, Commissioner Sawyer refuses his request to continue investigating that possibility. The Powers That Be want him to head up the Batman Task Force, but he declines. Later, he sets off a brawl at a cop bar when a few bikers enter, ostensibly because he's offended that they're there. But, Manallato remind us how clever Bullock is, because it's clear that he did so so that Yip, now his girlfriend, can save one of the members of the review board. (She's still suspended after shooting Lonnie a few weeks earlier.) Eventually, Montoya appears, saving Bullock from getting clobbered over the head with a beer bottle. (Their conversation later, where she calls him "Glass jaw" and he calls her "Man hands" is a highlight of the issue.) We learn that she's returned to Gotham to work on the Task Force, and she lets slip to Harvey that Jim may be the Batman. This revelation brings Bullock on board, but he extracts a promise from Montoya to help him keep investigating the original Batman.
Again, Manallato give us quintessential Harvey here. They remind us that he's an excellent detective (given his hunch about Bruce) and that he's principled (since his initial reluctance to join the Task Force came from his disapproval of masked vigilantes). But, they continue to show his vulnerable side. First, they remind us that, for his gruff, macho exterior, Bullock's closest relationships are with women that he respects: Montoya, Sawyer, and Yip. But, his emotions cloud his judgment with Yip, since we learn here that she might be colluding with someone to blow up a circus performance for cops and firefighters. (Jim is earlier seen talking with Sawyer about protecting it.) I instantly felt bad for Harvey since he's not going to recover from the revelation, if it happens, that he missed the fact that Yip had turned to the dark side.
Moreover, Manallato make this book an integral part of the larger story that DC is telling about Batman. While "Batman" so far is focused on Jim and his team, "Detective Comics" looks like it's going to be the place where we get to the bottom of what happened in that cave under Gotham. Come for Batman, stay for Harvey. I can dig it.
**** (four of five stars)
Tuesday, April 14, 2015
Detective Comics #40 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
To be honest, I really enjoyed this issue, though the following review isn't going to sound like it.
On the positive side, Harvey really continues to be the star of this series. His banter with Alfred helps move us through the issue as he desperately tries to find the transmitter that Anarky is using to inspire Gotham's citizens to riot against the police. Moreover, not surprisingly, the art also continues to be spectacular; the artists could really write a textbook on how to propel the reader through a fight scene.
However, despite the revelation that Sam Young is Anarky, the authors leave us with many more questions that answers (and not in a good way). We learn that Alice was Young's sister and that the Mad Hatter tortured and killed her and other residents of the orphanage where she and Sam lived. Anarky tells Batman that Jeb Lester gave Alice to the Hatter, but, honestly, it just makes no sense. How does a guy go from running an orphanage to a Wayne Enterprises Vice President? (He's alternately been described in this series as in charge of shipments and IT. They're not exactly the background(s) of someone running an orphanage.) Similarly, what role did the Hatter play at the orphanage? We've seen him portrayed as essentially the landscape guy, but how did he go from that to a master of mind-control technology? Moreover, Young was enraged that the Gotham City Police Department didn't do anything to save the children, leading him to inspire the riots. But, how did they specifically fail? I mean, yes, I totally agree that someone should've been looking into the disappearance of a bunch of orphans, but wouldn't you first lay the blame at the feet of social services before the police?
I'd also say that Batman seems somewhat unreasonably unhinged when it comes to Young. I'm not saying that he shouldn't have stopped him, but he seems to completely discount the fact that Young seemingly suffered horrific abuse at the Hatter's hands. Bruce calls him a "liar," a "twisted killer," and "one more lunatic to add to Gotham's collection." Sure, Bruce is a pretty black-and-white kind of guy, but Manallato seem to go too far here in portraying him as lacking any sort of empathy.
Again, I enjoyed the issue as it happened, but, reflecting on it, it's got some obvious weaknesses that hopefully Manallato will manage to avoid in future stories. However, it's an improvement over "Icarus," so hopefully we'll keep on improving.
** (two of five stars)
On the positive side, Harvey really continues to be the star of this series. His banter with Alfred helps move us through the issue as he desperately tries to find the transmitter that Anarky is using to inspire Gotham's citizens to riot against the police. Moreover, not surprisingly, the art also continues to be spectacular; the artists could really write a textbook on how to propel the reader through a fight scene.
However, despite the revelation that Sam Young is Anarky, the authors leave us with many more questions that answers (and not in a good way). We learn that Alice was Young's sister and that the Mad Hatter tortured and killed her and other residents of the orphanage where she and Sam lived. Anarky tells Batman that Jeb Lester gave Alice to the Hatter, but, honestly, it just makes no sense. How does a guy go from running an orphanage to a Wayne Enterprises Vice President? (He's alternately been described in this series as in charge of shipments and IT. They're not exactly the background(s) of someone running an orphanage.) Similarly, what role did the Hatter play at the orphanage? We've seen him portrayed as essentially the landscape guy, but how did he go from that to a master of mind-control technology? Moreover, Young was enraged that the Gotham City Police Department didn't do anything to save the children, leading him to inspire the riots. But, how did they specifically fail? I mean, yes, I totally agree that someone should've been looking into the disappearance of a bunch of orphans, but wouldn't you first lay the blame at the feet of social services before the police?
I'd also say that Batman seems somewhat unreasonably unhinged when it comes to Young. I'm not saying that he shouldn't have stopped him, but he seems to completely discount the fact that Young seemingly suffered horrific abuse at the Hatter's hands. Bruce calls him a "liar," a "twisted killer," and "one more lunatic to add to Gotham's collection." Sure, Bruce is a pretty black-and-white kind of guy, but Manallato seem to go too far here in portraying him as lacking any sort of empathy.
Again, I enjoyed the issue as it happened, but, reflecting on it, it's got some obvious weaknesses that hopefully Manallato will manage to avoid in future stories. However, it's an improvement over "Icarus," so hopefully we'll keep on improving.
** (two of five stars)
Sunday, February 22, 2015
Detective Comics #39 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Curiouser and curiouser. (Sorry, I just had to start that way.) We've got two, maybe three, legs of the stool, but we don't yet have a seat. If I had to guess (though I don't necessarily think that I'm right), Anarky was raised at the same orphanage where Jervis was the groundskeeper and he had some connection to the Alice that Jervis murdered.
However, this theory has some flaws. First, I say that Jervis was the groundskeeper because he's holding a rake in the group photo. However, it doesn't make a ton of sense to me that a technology wizard like Jervis would be a simple groundskeeper at an orphanage. Second, Jervis initially calls Anarky "Alice" when he meets him; he also later comments that he's surrounded by "Alices" when Anarky and his masked cronies escort him to a vehicle to take him somewhere so that he can be made "accountable for what [he] did." The mask clearly makes Jervis think of Alice, so I'm less clear that "Alice" is a specific person. I'm pretty sure in issue #37 that Batman said that Jervis killed "Alice," leading me to believe that she was an actual person. But, it's possible that Jervis did terrible things to all the children of the orphanage (including Anarky) and he made them wear these masks while doing it. I guess we'll see.
Manallato makes it clear that they're continuing threads of the story that they first sewed into the "Icarus" arc. It requires you to be really paying attention. I had to re-read issues #33 and #38 to be reminded that Lester first fingered Young as an accomplice in issue #3 and that the photos that Harvey showed Young in issue #38 came from the suitcase that he found in Lester's office. One question I do have, though, is why would Harvey withhold the photos from the evidence box? I mean, it wound up being a correct hunch, given that the suitcase that Young gave Lester went missing from it. But, if he already had the hunch to keep the photos, then why didn't he keep the suitcase from the box as well? Also, I feel like we're dealing with different time frames of the disappearances. The bodies that Batman found in the river had decomposed to skeletons, but it feels like Bullock, at least initially, believed the kids might still be alive. At any rate, we still don't know who these kids are.
Young is also still a mystery. We've got some hints that he may be Anarky; after all, we know from issue #38 that he was raised in the foster-care system. In fact, in the first draft of this post, I said as much. But, I'm not so sure. If he were Anarky, why would he leave behind the suitcase that seemed to confirm Bullock's suspicion of him? He would've known that Lester had it, since he's the one that gave it to him. It still leaves open Young's connection to the case. The photos seem to prove a connection, to Batman's mind, that Jervis and Lester are connected, but we still don't know where Young fits into that picture.
The only weak part of this story was Batman miraculous finding "Blue House" based on its appearance in the background of photos taken of the victims. I mean, really, how did he find it? Does he have some sort of "creepy houses" database arrange by color? (He probably totally has that.)
*** (three of five stars)
Tuesday, January 27, 2015
Detective Comics #38 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Manalatto continues to blow off my socks with this one, folks. It's great stuff, from start to finish.
First, my only exposure to Anarky/Lonnie/Moneyspider came from Lonnie/Moneyspider's appearance in "Red Robin." He was paralyzed at that time (for reasons that I don't recall ever learning) and used some sort of cybernetic connection between his brain and the Internet to help Tim. I can't exactly remember the details of the case(s) where he helped Tim, but I don't think it's all that relevant, given that the DCnU obviously retconned away those stories. However, Manalatto seems to be setting up a similar dynamic here, since we end this issue with the DCnU Lonnie shot and likely dying (if not already dead). Having learned that Lonnie is the only person ever to hack into Wayne Enterprises' systems earlier in this issue, it stands to reason that we're going to see him survive, but be similarly paralyzed and connected to the Internet like the DCU's Lonnie. (The first off-note of this issue was Lonnie's weird conversation with Matches Malone, who talks to him more like a ninth-grade algebra teacher trying to inspire him than the mobster that he is.)
However, since we seem to rule out the possibility that Lonnie is Anarky, we therefore don't know who he is. Manalatto throws suspicion on Sam Young, but I'm somewhat doubtful that it's going to prove to be true. (The second off-note of this issue is that Young seems to have been demoted from a Congressman to a City Councilman. Either he's changed jobs or someone goofed, but we should probably clarify that at some point.) At this stage, we know that Young worked for Falcone and that he ordered Lester to falsify the records of containers entering the port. Harvey knows that, too (as seen in issue #33, where Lester spills the beans). However, Young doesn't necessarily know that Harvey knows. If he is Anarky, it would make sense that he'd want to tie up that loose end, though I'd like to know why he decided to do so now. Was he just waiting for the dust to settle on the Kings of the Sun debacle? As I said, I'm doubtful that Young is Anarky, not because it doesn't fit, but because it seems too obvious. However, if Young is going to continue to play a role in this series, we're also going to need to get an explanation of where his loyalties lie as a result of Falcone (his previous ally) having left town.
Overall, again, I really adored this issue. You have to overlook certain parts, like the off-notes that I mentioned or how Anarky managed to get a mask on the doorstep of every person in Gotham in one night without anyone noticing. But, as I think I've mentioned in previous reviews, I'm happy to be forgiving of such bobbles if the story is good, and this one is. The mystery so far is easier to follow than the Icarus arc. It's a little unclear if Jervis' murder of the kids is going to tie into the larger Anarky story, but it adds to the sense that we're dealing with a lot of stuff happening in the background. So far, it's pretty easy to follow, since it involves mostly Batman just trying to ID the kids so that their families can have some peace. But, it's the identity of Anarky and the connection to Lester that'll really fuel these next few issues.
I didn't even mention the art. I'm clearly starting to take for granted how beautiful Manalatto's issues are. I'll try not to do that, because they really, really are amazing.
**** (four of five stars)
First, my only exposure to Anarky/Lonnie/Moneyspider came from Lonnie/Moneyspider's appearance in "Red Robin." He was paralyzed at that time (for reasons that I don't recall ever learning) and used some sort of cybernetic connection between his brain and the Internet to help Tim. I can't exactly remember the details of the case(s) where he helped Tim, but I don't think it's all that relevant, given that the DCnU obviously retconned away those stories. However, Manalatto seems to be setting up a similar dynamic here, since we end this issue with the DCnU Lonnie shot and likely dying (if not already dead). Having learned that Lonnie is the only person ever to hack into Wayne Enterprises' systems earlier in this issue, it stands to reason that we're going to see him survive, but be similarly paralyzed and connected to the Internet like the DCU's Lonnie. (The first off-note of this issue was Lonnie's weird conversation with Matches Malone, who talks to him more like a ninth-grade algebra teacher trying to inspire him than the mobster that he is.)
However, since we seem to rule out the possibility that Lonnie is Anarky, we therefore don't know who he is. Manalatto throws suspicion on Sam Young, but I'm somewhat doubtful that it's going to prove to be true. (The second off-note of this issue is that Young seems to have been demoted from a Congressman to a City Councilman. Either he's changed jobs or someone goofed, but we should probably clarify that at some point.) At this stage, we know that Young worked for Falcone and that he ordered Lester to falsify the records of containers entering the port. Harvey knows that, too (as seen in issue #33, where Lester spills the beans). However, Young doesn't necessarily know that Harvey knows. If he is Anarky, it would make sense that he'd want to tie up that loose end, though I'd like to know why he decided to do so now. Was he just waiting for the dust to settle on the Kings of the Sun debacle? As I said, I'm doubtful that Young is Anarky, not because it doesn't fit, but because it seems too obvious. However, if Young is going to continue to play a role in this series, we're also going to need to get an explanation of where his loyalties lie as a result of Falcone (his previous ally) having left town.
Overall, again, I really adored this issue. You have to overlook certain parts, like the off-notes that I mentioned or how Anarky managed to get a mask on the doorstep of every person in Gotham in one night without anyone noticing. But, as I think I've mentioned in previous reviews, I'm happy to be forgiving of such bobbles if the story is good, and this one is. The mystery so far is easier to follow than the Icarus arc. It's a little unclear if Jervis' murder of the kids is going to tie into the larger Anarky story, but it adds to the sense that we're dealing with a lot of stuff happening in the background. So far, it's pretty easy to follow, since it involves mostly Batman just trying to ID the kids so that their families can have some peace. But, it's the identity of Anarky and the connection to Lester that'll really fuel these next few issues.
I didn't even mention the art. I'm clearly starting to take for granted how beautiful Manalatto's issues are. I'll try not to do that, because they really, really are amazing.
**** (four of five stars)
Sunday, January 11, 2015
Detective Comics #37 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Manalatto launches its second arc in this issue by picking up a loose thread from issue #34, the apparently involvement of Anarky in the explosion of the Waterfront. The good news is that this issue gives me a lot of hope that we're going to have an easier time understanding the story that they're telling here than we did with "Icarus."
First, this issue is beautiful. Manalatto really manage to pull you into the story with the art. You feel like you're freezing standing on that hill outside Wayne Manor with the snow falling on you or treading water with the Mad Hatter off the East End Waterfront. The pièce de la résistance is the unexpected appearance of Batman in the broken window at Wayne Tower. You flip the page and, BAM, Batman in all his mysterious glory. You get a sense why Harvey is so rattled by his sudden appearance, because you're equally surprised. This whole issue is just an example of two artists at the top of their game.
The good news is that the story is just as strong. They've learned from their mistakes with "Icarus," because it seems unlikely that we're going to spend the entire arc just wondering who the players are, as we did then. We clearly know that Anarky is responsible for the attack on Wayne Enterprises that we see here, even if we don't have a motive yet. Is it just that one of its employees was involved in human trafficking? Is it the more obvious motive of wanting to take out the city's most powerful corporation? Or, is it something more complicated? Bullock seems convinced that Anarky was responsible for the Waterfront, though I'm going to have to re-read issue #34, since I was pretty sure that it was the fight with the gang smuggling Icarus that caused it to blow. But, it's a lot easier to have the mystery focused on Anarky's motives and attacks than it is a confusing web of characters whose connections, let alone motives, are unclear (as it was in Icarus). One question that I have, as usual in the DCnU, is if Anarky is a known entity. Have the GCPD and Batman encountered him previously? I guess we'll see.
The script is remarkably good. You could see it just in the excellent cold opening with the Mad Hatter. In just a few pages, Manalatto deliver a quintessential Mad Hatter story, with him insanely bouncing through a homeless camp searching for Alice. Again, the art is partly responsible for making this sequence so notable, capturing Tetch's kinetic hysteria. But, Manalatto really get down his voice; I could hear him in my head saying his dialogue. It's true of all the characters throughout this issue, a good sign that the pair is really putting in the time to get the script right.
Anyway, I have high hopes for this arc. A Christmas-time story involving a lonely Harvey Bullock, a not incompetent Batman (unlike the "Batman Eternal" one), and a mysterious new-ish villain sounds like the perfect Batman story to me.
***** (five of five stars)
First, this issue is beautiful. Manalatto really manage to pull you into the story with the art. You feel like you're freezing standing on that hill outside Wayne Manor with the snow falling on you or treading water with the Mad Hatter off the East End Waterfront. The pièce de la résistance is the unexpected appearance of Batman in the broken window at Wayne Tower. You flip the page and, BAM, Batman in all his mysterious glory. You get a sense why Harvey is so rattled by his sudden appearance, because you're equally surprised. This whole issue is just an example of two artists at the top of their game.
The good news is that the story is just as strong. They've learned from their mistakes with "Icarus," because it seems unlikely that we're going to spend the entire arc just wondering who the players are, as we did then. We clearly know that Anarky is responsible for the attack on Wayne Enterprises that we see here, even if we don't have a motive yet. Is it just that one of its employees was involved in human trafficking? Is it the more obvious motive of wanting to take out the city's most powerful corporation? Or, is it something more complicated? Bullock seems convinced that Anarky was responsible for the Waterfront, though I'm going to have to re-read issue #34, since I was pretty sure that it was the fight with the gang smuggling Icarus that caused it to blow. But, it's a lot easier to have the mystery focused on Anarky's motives and attacks than it is a confusing web of characters whose connections, let alone motives, are unclear (as it was in Icarus). One question that I have, as usual in the DCnU, is if Anarky is a known entity. Have the GCPD and Batman encountered him previously? I guess we'll see.
The script is remarkably good. You could see it just in the excellent cold opening with the Mad Hatter. In just a few pages, Manalatto deliver a quintessential Mad Hatter story, with him insanely bouncing through a homeless camp searching for Alice. Again, the art is partly responsible for making this sequence so notable, capturing Tetch's kinetic hysteria. But, Manalatto really get down his voice; I could hear him in my head saying his dialogue. It's true of all the characters throughout this issue, a good sign that the pair is really putting in the time to get the script right.
Anyway, I have high hopes for this arc. A Christmas-time story involving a lonely Harvey Bullock, a not incompetent Batman (unlike the "Batman Eternal" one), and a mysterious new-ish villain sounds like the perfect Batman story to me.
***** (five of five stars)
Monday, December 15, 2014
Detective Comics #36 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
I like what Percy tries to do here. In fact, if you've been reading this blog for a while, you know that I'm happiest with "Detective Comics" when it doesn't focus on the stories being told in the larger Bat-Universe and just tells stories about Bruce actually being a detective. Layman has been the best at that during the DCnU, even though he also really excelled at working in references to events occurring in the other Bat-books. Percy takes a page from his book, but doesn't write it as well.
The main problem here is that everything is way too easy. Bruce just happens to hear a news broadcast that tells him that the terrorist who released the plague in Gotham International Airport (GIA) is "believed to be in Eastern Europe." (Journalists don't need to reveal sources, but it would be nice to know who believed him to be there. The U.S. government? Interpol? Micky Mouse?) Conveniently, Dick just happens to be torturing someone in Belarus and that guy just happens to know that the terrorist used to date a woman that runs a bar in Minsk. Dick heads there and thankfully is a skilled enough kisser (that part I believe) to convince the woman to tell him where the terrorist is. Awesomely, she just happens to know that he's in GIA! Phew. Problem solved!
In other words, I like detective stories when Batman acts like a detective. Here, he just hears a news report, calls Dick, waits for an answer, and then punches someone. It's not exactly Holmesian.
In other words, I like detective stories when Batman acts like a detective. Here, he just hears a news report, calls Dick, waits for an answer, and then punches someone. It's not exactly Holmesian.
** (two of five stars)
Saturday, November 8, 2014
Detective Comics #35 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
After the convoluted journey that was "Icarus," I have to say that I enjoyed the straight-forward plot that Percy introduces in this issue. The Bat-titles lately seem to have reduced Batman to a role as a passive observer; in "Icarus," he didn't really do much more than watch as the action unfolded around him. However, Percy puts him in his comfortable role as the Detective, trying to figure out a way to save everyone (including himself) affected by an eco-terrorist's biological attack at an airport. I have no idea how Percy is going to wrap up this story in just one more issue, but hopefully it's as a solid as this issue.
*** (three of five stars)
*** (three of five stars)
Sunday, August 31, 2014
Detective Comics #34 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Man, I definitely feel like I missed an issue.
First, I still am having trouble figuring out the various gang connections. This issue makes it clear that Holter was clearly the sole supplier of Icarus (more on that revelation in a bit). If I'm putting two and two together correctly, it seems that he worked with the Falcone organization to make sure that he could smuggle the kid that generated Icarus into Gotham City (hence, the Wayne Enterprises VP fixing the books to hide the contents of the shipping containers). We knew that Jonny assassinated Elena on the orders of the Falcone organization, because Elena's plans for the Waterfront clearly threatened the Icarus operation. This revelation now seems to confirm that the Squid was merely working for Falcone, not a player in his own right. Moreover, we learn that it was actually Holter who ordered the hit on Elena; as such, it makes it clear that Falcone was clearly working with Holter, not against him. However, we never actually see Holter deal with Falcone (or the Squid deal with Falcone, if I'm not mistaken), so the reader is left to draw all these conclusions on his own, from Falcone and Holter colluding to import Icarus into Gotham to the Squid handling the distribution for both Falcone and Holter to the originator of the hit put on Elena. The conclusions make sense (more or less), but I'm still left with the nagging sense that I might have missed or misconstrued something. I don't need a lot of exposition detailing the villains' plans at the end of my stories, but it is usually helpful if we have some idea of what the actual plan was.
The oddest part of this story isn't actually the revelation that Icarus is derived from some kid with radioactive powers (though we'll get there in a minute). Instead, it's that Bruce berates himself for having missed nabbing Holter. Bruce seems to suddenly realize that Holter was behind the whole affair when he sees the Waterfront explode, but I can't for the life of me see how the explosion inspired this epiphany. Bruce even seems to know to bring the super-armor, presumably because he knew that he'd be facing the irradiated dude. But, again, we get no insight into how Bruce knew that this kid generated the Icarus. Moreover, Bruce says that he could've saved Elena if he had realized that Holter was the mastermind earlier, but I'm pretty sure that Elena was killed before Bruce even knew about the Kings. If he did know, we certainly didn't see the events that led him to that conclusion.
Finally, regarding the irradiated dude himself, that development couldn't be more from left field. I feel like we're supposed to recognize him, like he's Annie's ex-boyfriend from the annual. But, I'm pretty sure that it's not the case, since that kid clearly wasn't irradiated from the start. So, who is he? (I'm now pretty sure that he's the guy in the container in issue #31, but what happened to Sumo then?) He disappears when Bruce arrives, so we get nothing close to an answer. We also have no idea why Harvey finds an anarchy symbol in the abandoned container at the end of the issue. Are we supposed to believe that Anarky was somehow involved?
In other words, what the Hell just happened?
* (one of five stars)
First, I still am having trouble figuring out the various gang connections. This issue makes it clear that Holter was clearly the sole supplier of Icarus (more on that revelation in a bit). If I'm putting two and two together correctly, it seems that he worked with the Falcone organization to make sure that he could smuggle the kid that generated Icarus into Gotham City (hence, the Wayne Enterprises VP fixing the books to hide the contents of the shipping containers). We knew that Jonny assassinated Elena on the orders of the Falcone organization, because Elena's plans for the Waterfront clearly threatened the Icarus operation. This revelation now seems to confirm that the Squid was merely working for Falcone, not a player in his own right. Moreover, we learn that it was actually Holter who ordered the hit on Elena; as such, it makes it clear that Falcone was clearly working with Holter, not against him. However, we never actually see Holter deal with Falcone (or the Squid deal with Falcone, if I'm not mistaken), so the reader is left to draw all these conclusions on his own, from Falcone and Holter colluding to import Icarus into Gotham to the Squid handling the distribution for both Falcone and Holter to the originator of the hit put on Elena. The conclusions make sense (more or less), but I'm still left with the nagging sense that I might have missed or misconstrued something. I don't need a lot of exposition detailing the villains' plans at the end of my stories, but it is usually helpful if we have some idea of what the actual plan was.
The oddest part of this story isn't actually the revelation that Icarus is derived from some kid with radioactive powers (though we'll get there in a minute). Instead, it's that Bruce berates himself for having missed nabbing Holter. Bruce seems to suddenly realize that Holter was behind the whole affair when he sees the Waterfront explode, but I can't for the life of me see how the explosion inspired this epiphany. Bruce even seems to know to bring the super-armor, presumably because he knew that he'd be facing the irradiated dude. But, again, we get no insight into how Bruce knew that this kid generated the Icarus. Moreover, Bruce says that he could've saved Elena if he had realized that Holter was the mastermind earlier, but I'm pretty sure that Elena was killed before Bruce even knew about the Kings. If he did know, we certainly didn't see the events that led him to that conclusion.
Finally, regarding the irradiated dude himself, that development couldn't be more from left field. I feel like we're supposed to recognize him, like he's Annie's ex-boyfriend from the annual. But, I'm pretty sure that it's not the case, since that kid clearly wasn't irradiated from the start. So, who is he? (I'm now pretty sure that he's the guy in the container in issue #31, but what happened to Sumo then?) He disappears when Bruce arrives, so we get nothing close to an answer. We also have no idea why Harvey finds an anarchy symbol in the abandoned container at the end of the issue. Are we supposed to believe that Anarky was somehow involved?
In other words, what the Hell just happened?
* (one of five stars)
Thursday, August 28, 2014
Detective Comics Annual #3 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
This story isn't particularly easy to follow, but it does clarify a lot about the current "Icarus" arc. I'm writing up a summary here mostly to work out the events in my head to make sure that I got them straight. If anyone saw something else, let me know!
First, we learn that the Squid originally hired Julian Day to conduct his deal with the Kings of the Sun and ordered him to take his younger brother, Jonny, under his wing. Meanwhile, a group calling themselves the Bastards of Blackgate has managed to get its hands on a stash of the Wrath's weapons and subsequently declared the Narrows to be its territory. Batman takes down some Bastards and demands that they tell him where the weapons are. Instead, Day's son, Aden, tells him, since he's overheard their plans; he and his father live above the alley where the Bastards were discussing them. Day abuses his son, so Bruce first pays him a visit as Matches Malone; he hands him his ass and tells him to get a calendar, since he forgot that it was Aden's birthday. (Notably, Day told Jonny earlier that it was important to have a brand in Gotham.) Jonny discovers the unconscious Day, and he puts together a gang to steal the Icarus that the Kings controlled, since he no longer had to deal for it with Day. Meanwhile, Elena's daughter, Annette, is dating the guy that the Kings put in charge of guarding the Icarus while they were in meetings (presumably with Day). He's apparently a former addict and got Elena hooked. Not surprisingly, he sees Icarus as a short-cut to the courage that he needs to guard the drugs, but he instead overdoses, setting himself on fire. Jonny and his guys successfully steal the Icarus, and the Kings later threaten the Squid, since he was the only one to know the location. Jonny pretends that Day ditched him, placing the blame on him, and the Squid announces that he hired some outside muscle, namely, the Bastards, to deal with Day. They kidnap Aden and leave a ransom note for Day. Day calls to Bastard to set up a meeting, but Batman arrives instead, after finding the ransom note in Day's apartment. (He was going there to make sure that Aden was OK.) Bruce makes short work of the Bastards thanks to his super-duper armor, and he places Aden into the Aguila Family Shelter for Women and Children. Fin.
Again, I thought that this issue cleared up a lot of background information, though I still have two groups of questions.
First, I assume that the Kings were selling the Squid the Icarus for him to distribute. If so, it raises the question why they were doing so, since they seem to be producing the product closer to Gotham now (meaning that they could presumably also distribute it a lot easier than they could when they were based in New Orleans). Were they just using the Squid as an entry point? However, we do get a better sense of why the Kings were after Jonny in the first issue of the "Icarus" arc. We're left to assume that they eventually put two and two together and realize that Day didn't steal the Icarus, though it would've been nice if Buccelatto showed us that connection.
Second, I'm not sure what we're supposed to believe about Day. We see him unconscious a little after 6:45 pm, but he allegedly calls Big Bastard somewhere after 10:11 pm to ask where Aden is. Bruce discovers the ransacked and abandoned apartment at 10:40 pm, and he notes that he doesn't think that Day took the bait. At 11:15 pm, Bruce charges the Bastards, in his armor. It seems like we're supposed to believe that it was Bruce that called Big Bastard at 10:11 pm to find where he was keeping Aden. It would make perfect sense...except for the fact that the call happens before Bruce finds the note at 10:40 pm. So, how did Bruce know where to go? Did he call Big Bastard later and just pretend that "Day" forgot where to meet? Also, if Day did call, why didn't he got meet Aden? We're supposed to believe, I think, that he bailed on town, but why call in the first place then?
Overall, it's a strong issue, and, as I said, it really helped fill in some gaps. I'll say that it feels a little weird to have the origin of Calendar Man shoehorned into this issue, particularly Day is portrayed rougher than he has previously been. But, it's helpful to confirm that Jonny did steal the Icarus from the Kings and that Elena was a drug addict, presumably part of the reason that her mother had them leave town. I'm really only wishing that I had a better sense of why the Kings were dealing with the Squid in the first place, but we may get that in the ongoing story.
*** (three of five stars)
Sunday, July 27, 2014
Detective Comics #33 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Wow. Manalatto reward our patience in this issue and put almost everything on the table. Let's walk through the shenanigans.
The Kings of the Sun are in Gotham due to the fact that the Penguin is so distracted by his ongoing war with Falcone that they can set up their own Icarus operation without retribution. Icarus is apparently mildly radioactive, so they've set up shop in a place that can mask their activity. However, we learn that Falcone is also in the Icarus business. Lester (the Wayne Enterprises VP that Bullock caught falsifying records last issue) tells Bullock that Congressman Sam Young was the one who asked him to do so, and we know that Young is definitely on Falcone's payroll. If Lester falsified records to hide the fact that Falcone was smuggling into Gotham waste containers that could contain radioactive material, then it seems clear that Falcone has his own Icarus operation. Moreover, Batman is led to an abandoned Kane Industries power plant since the Kings had some stolen equipment from there; Harvey is led there because it's a place where Falcone's men could cook up Icarus without anyone knowing. The Kings and Falcone are clearly connected by similar equipment and locations, but it's unclear what the connection is. Are they competitors or colleagues? If they were working together, they aren't any longer. We learn this issue that Holter, the head of the Kings, is Annette's father, and he's looking for revenge for Elena's death. Since Falcone put out the hit on her (through the Squid's brother), it's clear that they're no longer cooperating.
Also running through this arc, Manalatto explore Batman's relationship with Harvey. I love this version of Harvey. He's constantly crossing the line, beating Lester in an alleyway to get Young's name. In fact, Batman accuses him of murdering his partner, though it's obviously more complicated than that, based on Bullock's reaction. Snyder and Tynion have been portraying Harvey as essentially a mindless patsy in "Batman Eternal," so it's great to see him as his own man here.
The Annette/Holter and Batman/Bullock interactions in this issue really provide an emotional charge, making it a more layered story than just a simple detective story. However, it's still a helluva detective story. Manalatto aren't writing for the trade here, since I can follow the story from issue to issue without too much of a problem. But, I do look forward to re-reading the whole arc and following the story more closely. This story is exactly the story that we should be seeing in "Detective Comics." I was worried about Layman leaving, but I'm glad that he's gotten worthy successors.
**** (four of five stars)
The Kings of the Sun are in Gotham due to the fact that the Penguin is so distracted by his ongoing war with Falcone that they can set up their own Icarus operation without retribution. Icarus is apparently mildly radioactive, so they've set up shop in a place that can mask their activity. However, we learn that Falcone is also in the Icarus business. Lester (the Wayne Enterprises VP that Bullock caught falsifying records last issue) tells Bullock that Congressman Sam Young was the one who asked him to do so, and we know that Young is definitely on Falcone's payroll. If Lester falsified records to hide the fact that Falcone was smuggling into Gotham waste containers that could contain radioactive material, then it seems clear that Falcone has his own Icarus operation. Moreover, Batman is led to an abandoned Kane Industries power plant since the Kings had some stolen equipment from there; Harvey is led there because it's a place where Falcone's men could cook up Icarus without anyone knowing. The Kings and Falcone are clearly connected by similar equipment and locations, but it's unclear what the connection is. Are they competitors or colleagues? If they were working together, they aren't any longer. We learn this issue that Holter, the head of the Kings, is Annette's father, and he's looking for revenge for Elena's death. Since Falcone put out the hit on her (through the Squid's brother), it's clear that they're no longer cooperating.
Also running through this arc, Manalatto explore Batman's relationship with Harvey. I love this version of Harvey. He's constantly crossing the line, beating Lester in an alleyway to get Young's name. In fact, Batman accuses him of murdering his partner, though it's obviously more complicated than that, based on Bullock's reaction. Snyder and Tynion have been portraying Harvey as essentially a mindless patsy in "Batman Eternal," so it's great to see him as his own man here.
The Annette/Holter and Batman/Bullock interactions in this issue really provide an emotional charge, making it a more layered story than just a simple detective story. However, it's still a helluva detective story. Manalatto aren't writing for the trade here, since I can follow the story from issue to issue without too much of a problem. But, I do look forward to re-reading the whole arc and following the story more closely. This story is exactly the story that we should be seeing in "Detective Comics." I was worried about Layman leaving, but I'm glad that he's gotten worthy successors.
**** (four of five stars)
Tuesday, July 1, 2014
Detective Comics #32 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
First, under the Chekhov's gun theory, let me just say that I'm worried about the health and safety of Harvey Bullock's cats. Buccapul clearly introduced them to humanize Harvey, making it likely that they're going to meet a bad end. Nothing good happens to good people in Gotham.
Second, the scene with Batman and Elena's daughter on the pier is spectacular. Buccapul set it up so well, with the short panels giving us snippets of the action before the two-page splash page where Bruce is literally standing on the border between darkness and light. It might be a little heavy-handed in terms of imagery, but it's so beautifully crafted that I don't care.
Moving onto the plot, Buccapul up the ante here by revealing that Wayne Enterprises is connected to the human-smuggling ring (and potentially the Icarus distribution-network), since one of its VPs (Lester) signed for the containers on the dock. He clearly knew what he was doing, too, since Bullock catches him trying to destroy the paper trail. I'm not sure where Buccapul is going with this development, but I'm glad that they've at least shown why Harvey would think Wayne Enterprises was involved.
Unfortunately, we don't have such clarity when it comes to the actual Icarus distribution-network. Batman hypothesizes that Sumo was just responsible for dumping Elena's car, but why then would he leave his phone in it? It's hard to argue that he was that incompetent. (Also, isn't he a bit of a heavy just to be responsible for dumping the car? He seemed to be specifically put at the port to take on Batman.) Moreover, if it wasn't Sumo's phone, but Jonny or the Squid's instead, how did it wind up in Elena's car? Did Falcone's men plant it there to send Batman the Squid's way? We got hints that someone was purposefully directing Batman their way, but it's still unclear how or who. Also, how are the Kings of the Sun connected to Jonny? Did he steal Icarus from them?
I'm hoping we get some sort of diagram next issue making it clear how the various gangs are related to one another, lest this story become (like this review threatened to be writing it) too unwieldy. But, for now, I'm OK with a moderate level of confusion if we get some sort of clarity (that word again) next issue.
*** (three of five stars)
Second, the scene with Batman and Elena's daughter on the pier is spectacular. Buccapul set it up so well, with the short panels giving us snippets of the action before the two-page splash page where Bruce is literally standing on the border between darkness and light. It might be a little heavy-handed in terms of imagery, but it's so beautifully crafted that I don't care.
Moving onto the plot, Buccapul up the ante here by revealing that Wayne Enterprises is connected to the human-smuggling ring (and potentially the Icarus distribution-network), since one of its VPs (Lester) signed for the containers on the dock. He clearly knew what he was doing, too, since Bullock catches him trying to destroy the paper trail. I'm not sure where Buccapul is going with this development, but I'm glad that they've at least shown why Harvey would think Wayne Enterprises was involved.
Unfortunately, we don't have such clarity when it comes to the actual Icarus distribution-network. Batman hypothesizes that Sumo was just responsible for dumping Elena's car, but why then would he leave his phone in it? It's hard to argue that he was that incompetent. (Also, isn't he a bit of a heavy just to be responsible for dumping the car? He seemed to be specifically put at the port to take on Batman.) Moreover, if it wasn't Sumo's phone, but Jonny or the Squid's instead, how did it wind up in Elena's car? Did Falcone's men plant it there to send Batman the Squid's way? We got hints that someone was purposefully directing Batman their way, but it's still unclear how or who. Also, how are the Kings of the Sun connected to Jonny? Did he steal Icarus from them?
I'm hoping we get some sort of diagram next issue making it clear how the various gangs are related to one another, lest this story become (like this review threatened to be writing it) too unwieldy. But, for now, I'm OK with a moderate level of confusion if we get some sort of clarity (that word again) next issue.
*** (three of five stars)
Saturday, May 31, 2014
Detective Comics #31 (HERE BE SPOILERS!)
Manallato continues to make a believer of me. This issue is tightly scripted, well plotted, and beautifully drawn. What more could you want?
My challenge in reading this issue was keeping this story distinct from the larger one that Snyder and Tynion are telling in "Batman Eternal." For example, "the Rose" from last issue was revealed to be Carmine Falcone in "Batman Eternal" #2. (In fact, in my review of that issue, I originally mistakenly identified the events of issue #30 as happening in "Batman Eternal" #1.) By using Falcone as the main villain of this series as well as "Batman Eternal," Manallato help contribute to the sense that the plot unfolding in "Batman Eternal" spreads throughout Gotham. I'm fine with that, but, given how complicated "Batman Eternal" already is, I'm not sure it needs the help.
In terms of this series' plot, it's still a little unclear where we're going. I'm pretty sure that we're supposed to believe that the Roman set up the Squid, with Sumo intentionally misdirecting Batman his way. First, you've got the mysterious guy observing the fight and remarking to someone on the phone that Sumo "talked," something that he seemed to be expecting. Then, it seems like the other two mysterious guys place a defeated Sumo into the device in the shipping container to heal him after he took a dive in his battle with Batman; after all, he'd have to be defeated to have the opportunity to rat out the Squid. (If it's not Sumo in the container, I have no idea who else it would be.) It seems like Sumo might've been led to believe that, too, despite the two guys seemingly using Icarus to kill him, a loose end, instead.
But, either way, even if Sumo legitimately ratted out the Squid, I still have no idea what the Roman's or the Squid's plans are. Why kill Elena? Was it really just to prevent her and Bruce from developing the East End? It seems unlikely, given that we learned this issue that Elena's daughter is untraceable, making it clear that they were running from something. (Remember Elena talking about fresh starts last issue?) Why is the East End so key? I'm assuming that it has a link to Icarus, but Manallato hasn't made that link yet, as far as I can remember.
It's only two issues, so no need to present everything as a pretty package just yet. But, the lack of clarity on the Sumo issue hearkens to Hickman-esque plotting, where confusion is confused with intrigue. A little more clarity on the events that we witness -- so we know what we're actually witnessing -- would be great.
*** (three of five stars)
My challenge in reading this issue was keeping this story distinct from the larger one that Snyder and Tynion are telling in "Batman Eternal." For example, "the Rose" from last issue was revealed to be Carmine Falcone in "Batman Eternal" #2. (In fact, in my review of that issue, I originally mistakenly identified the events of issue #30 as happening in "Batman Eternal" #1.) By using Falcone as the main villain of this series as well as "Batman Eternal," Manallato help contribute to the sense that the plot unfolding in "Batman Eternal" spreads throughout Gotham. I'm fine with that, but, given how complicated "Batman Eternal" already is, I'm not sure it needs the help.
In terms of this series' plot, it's still a little unclear where we're going. I'm pretty sure that we're supposed to believe that the Roman set up the Squid, with Sumo intentionally misdirecting Batman his way. First, you've got the mysterious guy observing the fight and remarking to someone on the phone that Sumo "talked," something that he seemed to be expecting. Then, it seems like the other two mysterious guys place a defeated Sumo into the device in the shipping container to heal him after he took a dive in his battle with Batman; after all, he'd have to be defeated to have the opportunity to rat out the Squid. (If it's not Sumo in the container, I have no idea who else it would be.) It seems like Sumo might've been led to believe that, too, despite the two guys seemingly using Icarus to kill him, a loose end, instead.
But, either way, even if Sumo legitimately ratted out the Squid, I still have no idea what the Roman's or the Squid's plans are. Why kill Elena? Was it really just to prevent her and Bruce from developing the East End? It seems unlikely, given that we learned this issue that Elena's daughter is untraceable, making it clear that they were running from something. (Remember Elena talking about fresh starts last issue?) Why is the East End so key? I'm assuming that it has a link to Icarus, but Manallato hasn't made that link yet, as far as I can remember.
It's only two issues, so no need to present everything as a pretty package just yet. But, the lack of clarity on the Sumo issue hearkens to Hickman-esque plotting, where confusion is confused with intrigue. A little more clarity on the events that we witness -- so we know what we're actually witnessing -- would be great.
*** (three of five stars)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)